High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17510/2017disposed of

Rajender Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-16Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

! "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&() "#$ $%&'&()* * * *

",$(-$./01"."(-#2$.' $#&#&($.' 3' 4#"#$ ".5"(""(-#2$.' $'6(-$(#'

)78 4/4/ )78 4/4/ )78 4/4/ )78 4/4/

.$'$(#) '1.&#""96":;-<%"#$;

.#2$6$#&#&($.' .4"0."=2 20(#";;".5"(" .42"#&";-<%"#$;

..$'6(-$(#>

/4/ ; /4/ ; /4/ ; /4/ ; 2$ 6$#&#&($.'; .$'&-$(#' 3&::"9$ $$1?"; $2'&: "(- &'#.&%#".&-"="-;2"<$6."5$- .#2$&''0"(%$ "@.&#&(#2$("#0.$ %$.#&.".& .A0"'2&(9#2$ $1."(-01 (-$.'#"(-&(9B C$(#$.$- &(#=$#@$$(.$'6(-$(#'>(

*.&(#2$":#$.("#&<$ .$#0.(&(9#2$:"(-&(A0$'#&(##2$."1"(%2"5"#;$$1?"$2'&:"(- &'#.&%#".&-"="- $'6(-$(#D! (=.&$ ;.$'6(-$(#D&'#2$@($. :"(-1$"'0.&(9D> ?"(":+1".:" "%.$ ?"(":+1".:"!'&#0"#$-&(#2$.$<$(0$$'#"#$ 3&::"9$$$1?";$2'&:"(-&'#.&%#".&-"="-#:$"'$-0##2$'"&-:"(- ##2$$6".#1$(# $%2(&%":-0%"#&(;".5"(" .$'6(-$(#!( EE

"##2$(1&(":."#$ F6$."%.$6$."((01 ."6$.&- >> 5$".''#".#&(9 .1EE

#+E

.#2$60=:&%60.6'$;("1$:5;

$'#"=:&'21$(# $@<$.(1$(#:5#$%2(&%::$9$"#$$1?"#&' "<$..$- &( #2$ 6$#&#&( #2"# .$'6(-$(# 2"' #2092 %16:$#$- #2$ =0&:-&(9 :5#$%2(&% ::$9$ &( #2$ 1&--:$

* =0# #2$ %0.'$' @$.$(#'#".#$-$<$(&(#2$'$''&(

+2$5."#2$.%"1$#?(@ #2"#.$'6(-$(#&$#2$$6".#1$(# $%2(&%":-0%"#&(;".5"(" 2"- 2"(-$- <$. #2$ $(#&.$ =0&:-&(9 #2$ <$.(1$(# :5#$%2(&% ::$9$;$$1?"#.$'6(-$(#>=5@"5 -"#$-

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

&%&":'"(-2$:-1$$#&(9'@&#2#2$$60#511&''&($. (#2$.$6:5 &:$-=5.$'6(-$(#>;&#&'"<$..$-#2"#&#&'" 0=:&%4$%#.(#$.6.&'$0(-$.#2$ &(&'#.5 &%.;41"::"(- $-&01 (#$.6.&'$';<$.(1$(# (-&";@2&%2&'$(9"9$-&(6.1#&(9;"&-&(9

> "(- '#$.&(9 #2$ 9.@#2 &%.; 41":: "(- $-&01 (#$.6.&'$' "(- ":' $(9"9$- &( &16".#&(9 #$%2(&%": #."&(&(9' .1 &#' #$%2(&%": '$.<&%$ %$(#.$' 2$ #$%2(&%": '$.<&%$ %$(#.$'

$.' #$'#&(9 "%&:&#&$' # #2$ &(-0'#.5#2.092#2$&.8"%%.$-&#$-:"=."#.&$'6:"%$-&(#2$%$(#.$' 2$ @"'$(#$.$-&(#=$#@$$(#2$$%2(&%":-0%"#&($6".#1$(#; <$.(1$(# ".5"(" &$ .$'6(-$(# "(- "#&(": 41":: (-0'#.&$'.6."#&(B4C .'$##&(906 "%&:&#&$'#&16".##."&(&(9( &(-0'#.5 -.&<$( -$1"(- .&$(#$- #$%2(&%": #."&(&(9' # #2$ =$($ &%&".&$' =$'&-$'

$.&(9 #."&(&(9 &( &6:1" %0.'$' &( #2$ 6.$1&'$' # &' ":' "<$..$-#2"#"

#$.#2$ @"'$(#$.$-;.$'6(-$(#>2"'$'#"=:&'2$- #."&(&(9"(-'$.<&%$%$(#.$&(#2$6.$1&'$'@2$.$#2$6:5#$%2(&%-&6:1" %0.'$'"'@$::"'#2$.#."&(&(9''2"::=$6.<&-$-##2$'#0-$(#' ".$"&(%(<$(#&(":#$%24?&::6.9."1'2$-&6:1""(-#."&(&(9 &' '6$%& &%"::5 -$'&9($- @&#2 "( "&1 # "%&:&#"#$ $16:51$(# # #2$ '#0-$(#'=$:(9&(9##2$:%":".$""

#$.%16:$#&( #2$#."&(&(9#&' ":' "<$..$- #2"# .$'6(-$(# > 2"' "9.$$- # #"?$ 06 6:5#$%2(&% -&6:1"%0.'$'#6.<&-$#$%2(&%":#."&(&(9##2$'#0-$(#'"(-"##": (01=$.

#."&($$'; ( 6&:# ="'&'; 2"<$ ":.$"-5 =$$( #."&($- #&:: >>

+ &( -&

$.$(# #."&(&(9 %0.'$' $9 160#$. ".-@".$; 8; ;"::5@:$%#.&%":"(-"'2&($'&9($#%&(#.-0%$-&( #2$ %$(#.$ '&(%$ %11$(%$1$(# "%#&<&#&$' .1 090'#;

"(- " (01=$.

'#0-$(#' @$.$ "%&:&#"#$- . $16:51$(# &( -&

$.$(# &(-0'#.&$' "

#$. '0%%$''

0: %16:$#&( #2$&. #."&(&(9 6.9."1 # &'

0.#2$."<$..$-#2"#.$'6(-$(#>2"' &:$-"66:&%"#&(##2$::(-&" 0(%&: . $%2(&%": -0%"#&( B . '2.# G7C (

+ #2.$$ -&6:1" %0.'$' &$ $%2"(&%":; :$%#.&%": "(- &<&: (9&($$.&(9

D "(-<&-$#2$&.$1"&:-"#$-

+;#2$5%(<$5$-&(6.&(%&6:$"66.<": '0=,$%##%16:&"(%$ .1":&#&$'#&' 0.#2$."<$..$-#2"#.$'6(-$(# >2"'":.$"-5&(<$'#$-%..$' .06$$'&(#2$6.,$%# (#2$.$6:5 &:$-=5.$'6(-$(#' ;&#&'"<$..$-#2"# #2$%('#.0%#&( =0&:-&(9 #2$'"&-<$.(1$(#:5#$%2(&%#2.092 #2$ 0=:&% .?' 0&:-&(9' "-'!; $6".#1$(# ".5"(" @"' %16:$#$-(> *

*#@"'":''0=1&##$-#2"##2$.$@"'"-$%:&(&(9 #.$(-'&("-1&''&(&(6:5#$%2(&%' #2$4#"#$-0.&(9"%"-$1&%'$''&(

* "(- "=0# > H '$"#' @$.$ 0(- <"%"(# &( <$.(1$(# :5#$%2(&%' "(- H '$"#' &( 6.&<"#$ 6:5#$%2(&%' #2$ 4#"#$ ( #2$ 1$"(#&1$; " 6.6'": . '$##&(9 06 4 $%2(:95 $(#.$ "# ".&-"="- @"' '$(# # #2$ 46$%&": 4$%.$#".5 $<$:61$(# 11&''&($.; &(&'#.5 &%.;41":: $-&01(#$.6.&'$' 4 !; <# (-&" <&-$ :$##$. 4F4F

FD>D -"#$-

.1 #2$.&(%&6":4$%.$#".5#<$.(1$(#".5"(";(-0'#.&$'11$.%$ "(- :$%#.(&%' ( .1"#&( $%2(:95 $6".#1$(#' ::@$- =5 $1 > >F$< "#$- +>

* 2$ 6.6'": . 6$(&(9 $%2(:95 $(#.$ "# ".&-"="- @"' %('&-$.$- ( D

* =5 #2$ 4$%.$#".5; 4 ; <$.(1$(# (-&" 2$ $6".#1$(# .$":&I$- #2"# #2$.$&'"($$-#6.<&-$'?&::="'$-#."&(&(9##2$50#2 #2$4#"#$ #2$&.=$##$.$16:5"=&:&#5&(&(-0'#.5"(-60=:&%'$%#.2$-$6".#1$(# #?#2$&(&#&"#&<$"(-"66."%2$-#2$ &(&'#.5 4 ;<$.(1$(# (-&"#'$#06$%2(:95$(#.$"#".&-"="- .6.<&-&(9'#"#$ #2$ ".# '?&:: #."&(&(9 # #2$ 50#2 ".5"(" "#&(": 41":: (-0'#.&$' .6."#&( 4!0(-$.#2$ 4 ;<$.(1$(# (-&""9.$$-#'$# 06$%2(:95$(#.$&(#2$($@:5%('#.0%#$-=0&:-&(9 <$.(1$(#

:5#$%2(&%$$1?";".&-"="-&(%::"=."#&(@&#2#2$<$.(1$(# ".5"(" $%2(&%": -0%"#&( $6".#1$(#; ".5"("! 2$ 1"%2&($.5; '#"

"(- #2$. .$A0&'&#$ "%&:&#&$' "(- ":: 1<$"=:$ "''$#' . #2$ #$%2(:95 %$(#.$ @$.$ # =$ ".."(9$- =5 4 # 1"?$ #2$ %$(#.$

0(%#&(": ( <&$@ #2$.$ ; #2$ @"' $(#$.$- &(# =$#@$$( #2$ $%2(&%": -0%"#&( $6".#1$(#; ".5"(" "(- #2$ "#&(": 41":: (-0'#.&$'.6."#&(8#-(

*#&'":'"<$..$-#2"##2$'"&- %$(#.$@0:-.0(>6:5#$%2(&%-&6:1"%0.'$'&(#2$-&'%&6:&($' &<&:; $%2"(&%":"(-:$%#.&%":(9&($$.&(9@&#2#2$&(#"?$ * '#0-$(#'&( $"%2 -&'%&6:&($ "(- @0:- ":' 6.<&-$ 66.#0(&#5 . #2$ .$'&-$(#' ."1"(%2"5"#;$$1?"2$4@0:-&(%:0-$($(1&($$ 4#"#$ <$.(1$(# $%2(&%": -0%"#&( -$6".#1$(#! &( #2$ "("9&(9 11&##$$F".- <$.(.' ! #2$ $%2(:95 $(#.$ "# ".&-"="- "(- @0:- .$'$.<$ '$"#' 6$. %0.'$ . #2$ @".-' ."1 "(%2"5"#;$$1?" ."-1&''&(#<".&0''?&::"(--&6:1"%0.'$'"' 6$. #2$ 6:&%5 #2$ <$.(1$(# ".5"(" -"#$- >

D "' #2$ ."1"(%2"5"#;$$1?"2"-9&<$(:"(-((1&(":#$.1' 0.&(9#2$%0.'$ 2$".&(9;:$".($-%0('$:"66$".&(9 #2$ 4#"#$ ".5"("; ( &('#.0%#&(' .1 ",$'2 99".@":; &(# &.$%#.;$%2&(%":-0%"#&(".5"(";"(%2?0:";6.$'$(#&(0.#;1"-$ "'#"#$1$(##2"#.$'6(-$(#@0:-1"?$"::$

.#'#&(#.-0%$1.$ -&'%&6:&($' .#$%2(&%":$-0%"#&(&(#2$%1&(95$".''#2"##2$ "%&:&#5 "%%.$-&#$- =5 #2$ <$.(1$(# (-&" &( %::"=."#&( @&#2 #2$ $6".#1$(# $%2(&%":-0%"#&(;".5"("%0:-=$60##0'$ 6:5#$%2(&%%0.'$'=$'&-$'0'&(9&#=5#2$4"'#2$60.6'$&':0-

* "(-%:$".##."&(#2$50#20(-$.#2$<$."::6.9."11$ G4?&::(-&"7

.#2$60.6'$ 9$($."#&(9$16:51$(# 2$ 0.#; "

#$. 6$.0'&(9 #2$ "<"&:"=:$ .$%.- "(- 2$".&(9 :$".($-%0('$: .#2$6".#&$';&''"#&'

&$-#2"##2$:"(-&(A0$'#&(;9&<$( =5.$'6(-$(#D#.$'6(-$(#;"#"(1&(":."#$ F6$."%.$ 6$."((01;2"'=$$(60##0'$ .#2$60.6'$ #$%2(&%":$-0%"#&("' #2.$$-&'%&6:&($' &<&:; $%2"(&%":"(-:$%#.&%":(9&($$.&(9@&#2#2$ &(#"?$ * '#0-$(#'$"%2".$":.$"-5#2$.$"(-#2$--&#&(":&.$%#.; $%2(&%": -0%"#&(; ".5"(" 2"' "''0.$-#2$ 0.# #2"# $".($'#$

.#' @0:-=$1"-$=5#2$-$6".#1$(##&(#.-0%$1.$#$%2(&%":%0.'$'&(

0#0.$=5#"?&(9"66.<": .1#2$'#2"##2$-0=#"(-'0'6&%&( &(#2$1&(- #2$.$'&-$(#' #2$<&::"9$1"5(#6$.'&'# 20';&(<&$@#2$.$ ;-(# &(-"(5.$"'(#&(#$.

$.$&( #2&'6$#&#&(=0#=$ .$6".#&(9 .#2$60.6'$ ?$$6&(9"($5$(#2$ "''0."(%$ 9&<$( # #2$ 0.# =5 #2$ $6".#1$(# #2$ $%2(&%": -0%"#&(;".5"(";.$'6(-$(#&'-&.$%#$-#'0=1&#"'#"#0'.$6.# # #2$ 0.# @&#2&( " 6$.&- ($ 5$". .1 #2$ -"#$ .$%$&6# %$.#& &$-%65 #2&'.-$."=0##2$$

.#'2"<&(9=$$(1"-$=5&# 60.6'$ &(#.-0%&(9 1.$ -&'%&6:&($' #$%2(&%": $-0%"#&( "# #2$ <$.(1$(#:5#$%2(&%$(#.$"#$$1?";".&-"="- &'6'$- /4/ !

/4/ !

/4/ ! * * * *

+ 2$#2$.'6$"?&(9F.$"'($- )

$'F 2$#2$.$6.#"=:$ )

$'F