High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22737/2014disposed of

Vijay Garg v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2015-08-14Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal9 pages

! "#$ %!&' (#$ ")

"#* + ,-%.%/

'0' 1%!%.% %% 2% 3

'4 '

33 4'!&%4%4'5%.6%72'3-02/5 8

336!23 4' 8

333-02/5 '302642 3/'8 ' ( + % :2&%:!34 +'

+%5%1 /%%7%:40.2&% %:%.% %: !'4 + %-,5% :1 2&%73 +'

;%1% % 2+ ;,5% :2&%': !'4

<<<< 34 ';'%7!&%=0%'3% 2'>%'2 ?>'. &'!+ @% 2'''026.31%!%.% % '4&!36% 2'!3

+A' 2 &%2 2%B C @2 0/%

34 3%'%''0/3% 22& /'4 '

#% '43'%!73%3%/'62&46% 2'6. 3

%50 % %&54% .

34 %/'3'6 % !34&.!%520 234' '!3 -%6?&' &: #D#$ !03 ';' % !0 2 ! 3 %50 ' &3%/2 %/2. ?&''!535 3/0 23%336% 2'2 ! 5 3?&'4&.

@%'.:34 ';'%72& /3 '4 ' '4 % >/ / '&%5 / 5 3% #"" &' %

0%.

30/3'3/3.206!03%3'7'5% % %67 74'05'

34 E'/3'% 5.%!!&2 %''05 /3'%/% '%7!0 22 34 E'/% &6!. '3%3

'23!'6% 2'%0 !%.3/34&'% 3%3 '4&3!3%2 6 !?2 '.:3 ' !?2 1& 2.: 3 4 ' 5. %!!&2 %' 3 ' 60 260.3

E'420&'

32.:30/3 60 22 ': 3 4 3%' 6 60. / 3' 420&' ! 7 .%'

3 % /% &: 3!: ' 60'. '53 / ' 73&3 7 7 ! %

420&' %0' 6% 2' ! 2% 5%2 !/ =0:3!73&3%'20 236% %5 F .%1%/ 0? 3';.E: F54% 0 104 % 3';.E % 2 F 2'

2 % 5053';.E:%3?'. &B C! ))A>:

DGA>%

"GA>'4&.

7!35%'3!'3 6% 2'A420&'

3' /% &/%2 /34& /!3'3 6% 2'

3/% &' '4&!33420&''20 2 3 6% %5' F 2' 2 0% 4505 73';.E: F54% 0 03 &% 3';.E% 2F .%1%/%''&3';.E:%3 !

"""A>: #")"A>% #$D*A>:'4&.

7!35%' 3336% 2'A420&'

$ ''2 !534%.':34 E'/% &7%' 3%3336% 2'2 ! 25 3?&'4&.

7%': 37:%'& 226!0'3%3' 2!! & 3=0%. 3&54' !3&'4 /420&'!3!'3% 23 336% 2'A420&': %5.:67 36% 2' .%1%/0?

3';.% .%1%/%''&3';.H67 36% 2'54%0 104 % 3';. % 2 54% 0 03 & % 3';. % 67 3 6% 2' 2' 2 % 505 3';. % 2 2'

2 % 505 3';.

& 22 3% ' 5 2!! & 72' 36% %5'% 3 /5 * 3 4 ' % %! 30/3 E' /% & ' %. '53 / ' '2!!&0 63%3/% & 3%7%' ?4''26!0''3%/% & 3!'3 /3%702'; % . '3%34 3%2!7.%'6 60. /34 E' 420&'730% ./% &2'40%'3=0%.4&3! 3 4 3%' 6 2% / '5% 420&' 5. ! 3

'4 60!%0'35% 0!%&0'% 2420&'!3. .%'

7%' &542 2 ' &3' 2 ' 0 %.

' 2!!&0 6 3% ! 3 7%' 2!! & 3 =0%.67 3&'4 /420&'!3!'36% 2'% 23 336% 2':34 7023%0 %.4%2%50&33/3 4&!3336% 2'A420&'73 3&023%/3!' 36% 2'A420&'%%50&374& 3!''4 %

0 &'% ?&'4&.!%&3.% 34 3%'!23?&'4&.!3.% "##>#

%0'

G'4&!'36% 2%6! .2'.A67.A7 .6 / 4% 73&37% ''420&'6'2 31%!%.% %3%'/ '6% 2%6'%442!53?&'55'' % 232'' % 26 /4% ''0%2 31%!%.% %%%'=02/ 3%6'%442 3'%55'% 2& 2 3!'0&0! %&3 420& &02 / 3';.A1&&3 ' 4'&62 3 '065 / % %44&% ! /'% ! %6': 3 %44&% 50' '065 3 ?

!%&.%'!3'%2420&% /73'4% ?>!%&.%'

/36 /1%'% 2 .3%!&% 36% 26/'2 31% 5 ' 2!0'/'% % 2 2/'36% 3 1% ! %.% % ! 3 ' % 0 %' %6 2!! & %' 4% 3 /36 /1%'% 23%44&% E'6% 37 '! 3/'26% 2'%%6';3%44%!324%5 &%' !% .&3% / 3?>!%&.4& %0'$%'F ?2 @& &'E 3'4 & & ' @>#& &'

%0''$% 2$ #%2%'0 2(> I

' (

)

! $ (

! *!

(

* * !

# + ,

! " -.&

0 $# (

! ! #

" ' "

! *

'75 2%:3' 2'40/% &%60 3!?% !3 !3!'36% 2'

'%/23%3 '4&!3336% 2'3%2 6 !?2% 23%2'43'%5 3

7%'5%; /35%%50&33/34&! """A>:

#")"A>% #$D*A>:'4&.

)

'.'2!!&0 % 34 3'/0 2% 3 4 E' '% & 35'! 60/3 3' 420&' 0 %.!%607.%'

3'%25'' 37%'3 %4%.3 /%.

''05 /7%'% /%.:73&3774' .'377%'

: 3 4 50' 3% ;

7 %60 3 '%5 3%' 6 3' 60' ''!3..%'

1& 2.: 3' & %44%' 6 !%&0%. && 3' 4&% 37 '%5 'A%!!2%' 4.!26. 3 '4 '

3%' 35'! %

?0 > F ?&02 / ?&' ' ! + 1 6% 2'! @>#& '' 3 1% ! %.% % ! 3 .% "##># +'

%7%: % 2 40. 2&% %:%44% / 63%!!'4 #& !523%3''3 ' '4&!3420&'!23

13& !523%3 &02 /!3

E'336% 2'3%'6 !?2%' !&2

?0 >

37 '%5 '%'3% %' 4 &%0'

#$: . 3 5 505 4& ' !?2 % 3 5%?505 4& '

37 34 E'&%'3%3

E'4&'% 3/33% 3''24& ! 223 4&3%2 6 !?2 6.3!''4 '4 3!''4 %% .54 3

2 '4 !5 ' / ' 3 3 420&' 3 1% ! %.% %%3'%24&' 37' #"

7%' 3 & 22 3% 3 =0%. ! 3 &'4 / 420&'!53!'36% 2'% 23336% 2'% !%&3 '%5% 23%3

7%'/%.% 22'3 '.&3%/ /% 3/3%!333420&'2'43'%5 ## 3 =0' %' 3 =0%. ! 3 420&' &%

6 25 26.30%%' 3!' '% &% 23% %7 4 0 2 &

G ! 3 '0 ! 2% 3% ' ! 3 %03' & & 2 2&2 3 ' 3 / 2&% 3% 3 %03'3%!?23 '4&!% .3420&'37' 3% %&&2% &73%7 %/% '%7%.'4 3%03' ' 3 ''0 ! 3. 3 ; &''%. '4& ! % . 420&' 733!3

E'!% .34%.

1& 2.:45%>!%&%%''2!!&0%&&43% 34 %&0%.6'3%3=0%.!3&'4 /6% 2' !3!'3420&'% 2333420&''3'%5% 23% 2'4 3 '%5 3

2 '4 ' &3%/ / 3/3 %' ! 3 3 3420&'

'75 2%:34 3%'6 2% / '5%420&'!%0'34%'!%603..%' 3%'6 40&3%' /A2% / 3

E'420&' '4&!33 36% 2'!%60!0.%'

7%' '0652 63%! ! 3 4 3% 3 3%' 6 &54% /%603'%5!3%'3.%'

4%2.%';23

% 2 &0 ' %44% / 63%! ! 3 4 %' 73. 3 3 4 60/3333420&'!3

%%50&3 3/34&%30/33623%3=0%.3!7%'3'%5%'3 &'4 / 6% 2' ! 3 !' 3 6% 2' 73&3 7 50&3 &3%4 34 7%' &5422% % .4%&0%5% 0!%&0 420&E'420&'

7%' 60 22% % .!3420&'!3

7%' 260 60 260.% .!3420&'! 3

2 '4 ! 3 30/3 3% 3 =0%. ! 3 &'4 / 420&'!3!'36% 2'% 23336% 2'7%'3'%5:3 &02 3% &3' 60. 3 420&' ! 3 !' 3 6% 2' %

2'% 2%6.37%' % '7 #$ ' 3 4 3%2 6 2% / 73 3

2 '4 E' 420&'%3'.%'0 %.% 27306 /&5422' % .5%

73%'6.%76.& %&:%44%'3%3%%' !3'4 7%''53 /' !7%;!3%%' ' 4''6. 3 '0//'2 6. + ,5% : 3 % 2 1 0 ' %44% / 63%!!3

3%'%

?2 3&'4 &73&334 22 %

?34

'% ''!%22''267 34%' 3&0'!73&33 4 3%2&54% 2' /.%60363%0% 2%02!3 !!&'!3

'% &: 6. % >5% 2%2 #G "#

"#$: 3 &54% 2 %60 3 2!! : &%'0% % 2 ?5. 2/%. %02 ! 3

'4 E'!!&'

'%23%33%26 3=060' ''! 3%' ".%'% 23%3'7%'3'!'!!&%&54% /%2 /3 5'& 20& ! 3 !!&%' ! % . &54% .

!03 '%2 3% 3' % '733

3%26 ! 2.3 2!3.%

"##># 60 3% 3 7 '%!! 73&3 3%2 &5 ' & 4: "# 7%' ?5.402: 2!! % 24%%H3%3.%.% '723'43 H 3%345''5%2357.6!0!2% 23%73%3%2 6 2 3 7%' %! &%0' / 35 % ! 56%%''5 =0'23

2'53 /%603'

2 '4 6. % >5% 2%2 "#

"#$ '%2 3% 3!!&'702'56%% 72%.'% 2702;53 4 % 2'.3 /0 3%44% .7%'%5 /67 3 4%'

6. % >5% 2%2 ") "

"#$ ?4''2 '%'!%& 3%60%5 23%3%02!3'%!!3%2 &3% /2 %!35 / 34 %/23%30/33

%/2 &54 '% 35 !0. ! 3 % % 2 2&% ! 3 '34' 3 &'' 73! 7%' %60 #* %&' . * %&' 3%2 6 560'2 &%2 04 3

2 '4 &% 3 6%% & 20'

3 7 '% !03 >5%' /%2 / '5% /% &'

3&'4 &;%'/3.%&5 0'0 %!3

E'>5%2%2 "$

"#$ 7%'2 23%% .4%.5 ' 3%26 5%234 34 '%23%3702& 0 7% 2%&3!0 23%3

E'4&'!%023' &54'

,6% &555 ' %/2. 5%2 6. 3

2 '4 7 %' !2 %'2 % /% & 3% 3 3%2 &2% .45 %'&35!53&54% .

#* .% >5%2%2 "D

"#$34 %/23%3

'4 3%2 %''02 35 560'5 ! 3 2!! & %' 67 3&'4 /420&'!3!'36% 2'% 233 36% 2'%'34 3%225% 223!'36% 2'% 3

3 3 6% 2'

%/2 3% 3 7%' 2!! & 4%&;%/ /67 3420&'25% 22% 23420&''0442?&4 3%3'0442420&'75?4 ' 7%' 7%/23%3 &3% /'75%2 . &%'34!'!3

%3 &'!'%?&3=0% 2@> & '73%5%%!2 #G 3%44%3%6 & '2%62!! &'67 3 4 3 3% 2 % 2 3

2 '4 % 2 ' !!&' 3 3 2 '0//' 3% 3 4 E' 2/ % /%2 / 3 %02% 23& 20&!3

E'?&0!!&'7%' -0'!2 '37 3 &''%. 4''6%''''3'%5 3'74

+:3&55&%% '3467 34%' ' % 3''0'%'2 3'4

7'3&%!.3%7 2 ?4''% .! %7' 3%/2%%/5 '67 3 4%' /%2 / 3 560'5 ! 3 2!! & &' 67 3 420&'25% 226.34 % 23420&''0442356.3

2 '4 ' 4''6 3' 7 4 %2-02&% '0&3 2!! &'

50' %24 %444% 4&2 /' '4& 3!

06'% ' 5'% .45%>!%& 3&&05'% &':374 '2'4'2!'06-& 3%66'%