Sri Kant v. State Of Haryana & ORS

   
    

     
    

     
    

     
    

  











 

   

 



 !"

 



 !"

 



 !"

 



 !"

#$%&'()'*#$&((&'&+

,($($',# ,#)-) (&(,&#.&'&&'/(*,#) 

,)0'/,'()
1 2

 1 
 

  


1 2

 1 
 

  


1 2

 1 
 

  


1 2

 1 
 

  

 #,),'( #,),'( #,),'( #,),'( 1# 1&'$&4,#4&!/56&(,#(*,0,($($',# 1# $//*&#(*&'7&#$&! ,0-(./56&(,,',#&+!

&#.&'& 1# &8/$)*1&'6*&'/&!/56&(,##,)0'/,'( 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

9:9:9:

9:9:9:

 

  

!  

  

!  

  

!  

  

! ')(&'(7#$(0,($($'$)/$#,6(,/&8&$')((*,#/,#/&(,/    0&)),/  ;.  (*,  <,6-($5,  $6,#!  1-'$6$0&+ 
-'6$+!

*$7&'$!'',<-#, !/,6+$'$'8(*,0#&.,#(*,0,($($',## $'(,#,)('(*,/,+&.,/0&.4,'()(*&(7,#,4&/,(*$4$'+$,- 7#=),<,6-(,/ 
&),(*,0,($($',#$)(*&(*,$)&6'(#&6(#&'/$' (*,  .,&#)  2>!  &  '-4;,#    /,5,+04,'(  7#=)  7,#, ,<,6-(,/;.*$4  (*&);,,' &5,##,/(*&()-6*7#=)7,#, ,<,6-(,/  -0'  7#=  #/,#)  *&5$'8  ;,,'  $))-,/  ;.  1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$++7$'8/-,0#6,))  *,7#=)$'?-,)($'

7,#,  6&##$,/  -(  '  (*,  ;&)$)    0#,)6#$;,/  #&(,)   (,# 640+,($'(*,7#=)!(*,)&4,*&/;,,'/-+.5,#$$,/&'/ $')0,6(,/  ;.  (*,  6'6,#',/  $6$&+)  &'/  7,#,  -'/  (  ;,

 )&($)&6(#.&'/(,6*'$6&++.)-'/ '&4-'() "+&=*)*&/ ;,64,/-,((*,0,($($',#  *,#,?-$)$(,0&.4,'(7&)'( #,+,&),/  *,1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$ '@  ,5,'

0&)),/ &#,)+-($'6&++$'8-0'(*, $#,6(#! ,5,+04,'( #;&'6&+ /$,)!&#.&'&()&'6($'&)0,6$&+&4-'(# /$);-#),4,'(    /-,)  (  (*,  6'(#&6(#  ;.  6$($'8  (*, &/5,#), $'&'6$&+*,&+(*(*,
-'6$+ )-4) >!@!">A27&)0&$/ '  >    &'/  (*,#,&(,#  0&.4,'(    ) "!"!@A2  7&) #,+,&),/  $'  1&#6*!  >  &'/  0&.4,'(    ) "!!B>A2  7&) #,+,&),/$'0#$+!> 8&$')()-6*;&6=/#0/,+&.,/#,+,&), /-,)$'#,+&($'(7#=)640+,(,/&'/,<,6-(,/$'(*,.,&#) 2>(*&((*,6+&$4#$'(,#,)(*&/;,,'#&$),/&'/(*,)&4, *&)  ;,,'  /,6+$',/  5$/,  $40-8',/  #/,#  /&(,/   !

'',<-#,  ,&#',/  6-'),+  #,0#,),'($'8  #,)0'/,'(    C 1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$)-8*((D-)($.(*,/,'$&+$'(,#,)( '  (*,  8#-'/  (*&(  (*,  0,($($',#  *&/  ,&#+$,#  $+,/ 
$5$+  #$( ,($($'  B      #&$)$'8  &  /,4&'/  #  #,+,&),    (*, 0&.4,'()&'/7*$6**&/;,,'/$)0),/' $'(,#4)   8#&'($'8  +$;,#(.  (  (*,  0,($($',#  (  $+,  &  /,(&$+,/ #,0#,),'(&($'  ;,#,  (*,  ,0-(. 
44$))$',#!  *$7&'$!  -;

$5$)$'&+  $6,#  E
$5$+F!  1-'$6$0&+ 
44$((,,!  *$7&'$  &'/

<,6-($5, $6,#!1-'$6$0&+
44$((,,! *$7&'$! $)(#$6( *$7&'$ 7$(*$'&0,#$/(77,,=)#4(*,/&(,0&))$'8(*,#/,# &'//$#,6($')7,#,$))-,/(*&($'6&),)-6*#,0#,),'(&($'$) 4&/,!(*,)&4,7-+/;,/,6$/,/7$(*$'&0,#$/(74'(*) (  $)  6'(,'/,/  (*&(  0,($($',#  (*,#,&(,#  *&/  4&/,  &

#,0#,),'(&($'/&(,/ !'',<-#, !&'/$'7*$6*(*, 6+&$47&)'+.7$(*#,8&#/(0#$'6$0&+-()(&'/$'8&4-'( ) "+&=*)&'/'(?-&$'(,#,)( 66#/$'8+.!$($)-#8,/(*&((*, 0,($($',#6&''('7&8$(&(,(*,4&((,#7$(*#,8&#/($'(,#,)( '&66-'((*,/,+&.,/#,+,&),/-,)  *&(&0&#(!7*$+, ),,=$'8/$)4$))&+(*,7#$(0,($($'!$(*&);,,'&#8-,/(*&((*, $8*
-#($',<,#6$),$()7#$(D-#$)/$6($'-'/,##($6+,> (*,
')($(-($''/$&7-+/'($))-,/$#,6($')(,'#6,& 6$5$++$&;$+$(.&#$)$'8-(;#,&6*6'(#&6((0&.&'&4-'( 4',./-,((*,6+&$4&'( ($)6'(,'/,/(*&((*,6+&$4#&$),/ $' (*, 0,($($'  $) & 0-#,  4',.  6+&$4 7*$6*  -8*( '( ( ;, ,'(,#(&$',/  &5$'8  *,&#/  +,&#',/  6-'),+  #  (*,  0&#($,)  &'/ *&5$'8  0,#-),/  (*,  0+,&/$'8)  '  #,6#/!  (*$) 
-#(  $)    (*, 6')$/,#,/  5$,7  (*&(  (*,  $40-8',/  #/,#  /&(,/   !

'',<-#, !6&''()-)(&$'&'/(*,0,($($',#$),'($(+,/( 8#&'($'(,#,)('(*,/,+&.,/#,+,&),0&.4,'()$'+$,- 7#=)(*&(7,#,,<,6-(,/;.*$4 '(*,7#$((,')(&(,4,'((*&(*&);,,'$+,/';,*&+ #,)0'/,'( A <,6-($5, $6,#!1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$!

&'&((,40(*&);,,'4&/,($40#,))-0'(*$)
-#((*&((*,#, &#,/$)0-(,/?-,)($')&6($'5+5,/ (*&);,,'&5,##,/(*&( (*,  0,($($',#  *&)  '(  &((&6*,/  &'.  /6-4,'(  7$(*  #,8&#/  ( &++(4,'(7#=&)*&);,,'&++,8,/ *,/,(&$+)(*,7#=) &++((,/*&5,&+)'(;,,'4,'($',/ (*&)&+);,,'&5,##,/ (*&((*,#,$)'4&(,#$&+0+&6,/'#,6#/()-;)(&'($&(,(*&((*, 7#=  7*$6*  $)  )(&(,/  (  *&5,  ;,,'  /',  7&)  )&'6($',/

 (,6*'$6&++.&'/&'.&00#5&+#640+,($'6,#($$6&(,*&/;,,' $))-,/  > 1# &8/$)*  1&'6*&'/&!  /56&(,  &00,&#$'8  # #,)0'/,'(  !  *7,5,#!  6&'/$/+.  &/4$()  (*&(  (*,  7#=)  $' ?-,)($'  *&/  ;,,'  ,<,6-(,/  &'/  640+,(,/  ;.  (*,  0,($($',# *,#,$'

 ,*&)&+) &/4$((,/(*&((*,0&.4,'()$'+$,-(*, 7#=),<,6-(,/6-+/'(;,4&/,((*,0,($($',#'&66-'( (*,  0#,6&#$-)  $'&'6$&+  *,&+(*    (*,  1-'$6$0&+ 
-'6$+   , -#(*,#/,)'(/$)0-(,(*&((*,1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+*&/6&++,/ -0'(*, $#,6(#!#;&'6&+ /$,)!&#.&'&#)&'6($' 4',.  )  &)  (  4&=,  8/  (*,  0&.4,'()  &)  (*, 0,($($',#A6'(#&6(# *&/ ;,,'

#,0,&(,/+.

),'/$'8 #,0#,),'(&($')A'($6,)##,+,&),(*,&4-'(/-,  5,'(*, 0#$'6$0&+&4-'((*&(7&)/-,((*,0,($($',#!*&5$'8;,,'0&$/! &+;,$(;,+&(,/+.!$)&4&((,##,6#/  *,;D,6($'&'//,,'6,)-8*((;,(&=,'-0$'(*, 7#$((,')(&(,4,'(7$(*#,8&#/(/$)0-(,/&6()/,)'(,5,'$'/ &4,'($'$'(*,$40-8',/#/,#/&(,/ !'',<-#,  *$)
-#(7-+/*&5,'*,)$(&($'$';),#5$'8(*&((*,7#$((,' )(&(,4,'(*&);,,'$+,/D-)(#(*,)&=,00)$'8(*,6+&$4 *,#,&#,'/$)0-(,/?-,)($')&6($'5+5,/$'(*,$')(&'( 0,($($'

@ *$) 
-#(  $'/)  (*&(  (*,  &6($'    (*,  #,)0'/,'(2 &-(*#$($,)$'*&5$'8#,+,&),/0&.4,'()(*,0,($($',#$'(*, .,&#)  2>  $'  #,+&($'  (  7#=)  (*&(  7,#,  ,<,6-(,/  &'/ 640+,(,/$'(*,.,&#2>$)0&(,'(+.-'D-)(&'/-'&$# "

'1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.5 *,(&(, 1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.5 *,(&(, 1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.5 *,(&(, 1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.5 *,(&(,

#$))&

#$))&

#$))&

#$))& &'/(*,#)!">-0#,4,
-#(B &'/(*,#)!">-0#,4,
-#(B &'/(*,#)!">-0#,4,
-#(B &'/(*,#)!">-0#,4,
-#(B!&5$,77&) (&=,'(*&($8*
-#()-'/,##($6+,>(*,
')($(-($' '/$&7-+/'(,'#6,&6$5$++$&;$+$(.&#$)$'8-(&;#,&6* 6'(#&6(&)$(7-+/&4-'((;,&0-#,4',.6+&$4 *,0,<
-#(  $' / 
#0#&($'    '/$&  &'/  &'(*,#   5   1A)  ,$+ / 
#0#&($'    '/$&  &'/  &'(*,#   5   1A)  ,$+ / 
#0#&($'    '/$&  &'/  &'(*,#   5   1A)  ,$+ / 
#0#&($'    '/$&  &'/  &'(*,#   5   1A)  ,$+ $4$(,/&'/(*,#)E@FB

 $4$(,/&'/(*,#)E@FB

 $4$(,/&'/(*,#)E@FB

 $4$(,/&'/(*,#)E@FB

*&/'($6,/(*,D-/84,'( #,'/,#,/$' 1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.

1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.

1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'.

1A) -#4&*
')(#-6($'
40&'. E)-0#&F&'/*&/ ;),#5,/(*&(#($6+,(*,
')($(-($''/$&*&)#,6,$5,/& +$;,#&+  $'(,#0#,(&($'  5,#  (*,  .,&#)   '  &00#0#$&(,  4&((,#) 7*,#,'/$)0-(,/?-,)($'&6($)$'5+5,/!(*,$8*
-#( 4&.8#&'()-6*#,+$,((*,7#$(0,($($',#7*$6**,7-+/;, ,'($(+,/($'+&7&)7,++&)$',?-$(.

 '  '(,#'&($'&+$4$(,/&'/&'(*,# 5   <0#(  '(,#'&($'&+$4$(,/&'/&'(*,# 5   <0#(  '(,#'&($'&+$4$(,/&'/&'(*,# 5   <0#(  '(,#'&($'&+$4$(,/&'/&'(*,# 5   <0#(
#,/$(-&#&'(,,
#0#&($''/$&$4$(,/&'/(*,#)!EFB
#,/$(-&#&'(,,
#0#&($''/$&$4$(,/&'/(*,#)!EFB
#,/$(-&#&'(,,
#0#&($''/$&$4$(,/&'/(*,#)!EFB
#,/$(-&#&'(,,
#0#&($''/$&$4$(,/&'/(*,#)!EFB 

B 

B 

B 

B!$(7&)*,+/(*&('6,(*,(&(,#&'$')(#-4,'(&+$(. (*,(&(,$)&0&#(.(&6'(#&6(!$(*&)&';+$8&($'$'+&7(&6( &$#+.!D-)(+.&'/#,&)'&;+.7*$6*$)(*,#,?-$#,4,'(#($6+, (*,
')($(-($''/$&  /5,#($'8  (  (*,  &6()    (*,  0#,),'(  6&),!  (*, 0,($($',#$'(*,6&0&6$(.

&6'(#&6(#*&/,<,6-(,/(*,7#=) &++((,/(*$4;.(*,1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$$'(*,.,&#) 2>&'/0&.4,'()$'+$,-(*,#,*&5,;,,'#,+,&),/(*$4 '+.$'(*,.,&#)2>   5,')-6*0&.4,'()7,#,#,+,&),/ &(,#  #,0,&(,/  #-'/)    +$($8&($'  &'/  (*,  0,($($',#3)  *&'/) *&5$'8;,,'#6,/($+,&'-4;,#7#$(0,($($')&'/7*,#,$' /$#,6($')  *&/  ;,,'  $))-,/  (  (*,  #,)0'/,'(2-(*#$($,)  ( ,<&4$',(*,6+&$4&'/((&=,&/,6$)$'(*,#,-0'  (&(-(#.

> &-(*#$($,)6&''(;,0,#4$((,/(/,(&$'(*,0&.4,'(#7*$6* (*,0,($($',#7&),'($(+,/(-0'640+,($'(*,7#=  5,'

(*-8*(*,#,+$,)-8*(#$'(*,$')(&'(7#$(0,($($'4&.;, ),,'&)&4',.6+&$4&'/#7*$6*&6$5$+#,4,/.4&.&+);, &5&$+&;+,.,((*,0,<
-#($''-4,#-)6&),)*&)*,+/(*&(&' &+(,#'&(,#,4,/.7-+/'(;,&'&;)+-(,;&#&'/$'&00#0#$&(, 6&),)  0,($($')  6&'  ;,  ,'(,#(&$',/  -'/,#  #($6+,  >    (*,
')($(-($''/$&  ,,#,'6,$'(*$)#,8&#/4&.;,4&/,( (*,  /,6$)$'    (*,  0,< 
-#(  $' &'D&'&  1  $8  E1) F   5 &'D&'&  1  $8  E1) F   5 &'D&'&  1  $8  E1) F   5 &'D&'&  1  $8  E1) F   5 $'/-)(&' ,(#+,-4
#0#&($'(/ !EF@

 $'/-)(&' ,(#+,-4
#0#&($'(/ !EF@

 $'/-)(&' ,(#+,-4
#0#&($'(/ !EF@

 $'/-)(&' ,(#+,-4
#0#&($'(/ !

EF@

  *,  ;&)$)  #  /,'$&+    $'(,#,)(  &)  0-(  #(*  $'  (*, $40-8',/#/,#$ , (*&((*,0,($($',#*&/'(6+&$4,/$'(,#,)($' (*,  #,0#,),'(&($'  /&(,/   !  '',<-#,  !  &'/ 6'),?-,'(+.!  *,  6&''(  '7  &8$(&(,  )-6*  6+&$4  $)  '(  7,++2 -'/,/ '(*$)#,8&#/!$(4&.;,'($6,/(*&((*,#,0#,),'(&($' /&(,/   !  '',<-#,  !  *&/  ;,,'  )-;4$((,/   ;.  (*, 0,($($',#  $'  (,#4)    +$;,#(.  8#&'(,/  ;.  (*,  7#$( 
-#(  '  7*$+,/$)0)$'8
$5$+#$( ,($($' B *,#,)0'/,'(2&-(*#$($,)*&5,640+,(,+.

>!

'',<-#, >!),#5,/-0'(*,4&'/$'7*$6*&)0,6$$66+&$4# &7&#/    $'(,#,)(  G  H  0,#  &''-4  '  &66-'(    /,+&.,/ #,+,&),0&.4,'(*&/;,,'#&$),/ -6*+,8&+'($6,*&5$'8'( ;,,'#,)0'/,/(!0,($($',#$+,/
$5$+#$( ,($($' B@> >&'/7*$6*7&)/$)0),/5$/,#/,#/&(,/@  >&( '',<-#, 6&++$'8-0'(*,#,)0'/,'(2&-(*#$($,)((&=,& /,6$)$'  '  (*,  +,8&+  '($6,  /&(,/   "

>   ,)0'/,'(2

 &-(*#$($,)*&5$'8)&(5,#(*,4&((,#!&6'(,40('($6,/&(,/  7&)),#5,/&'/(*,#,&(,#

 7&) $+,/$'(*$)
-#( (7&)&(,#$))-&'6,'($6,$'(*,6'(,40( 0,($($'(*&((*,$40-8',/#/,#/&(,/ !'',<-#, !

6&4,(;,0&)),/&'/#,)-+(&'(+.!(*,6'(,40(0,($($'7&) /$)0),/'"

 &('',<-#, ";-(8#&'($'8+$;,#(.( (*,0,($($',#(*&($*,7&))($++&88#$,5,/$'&'.4&'',#!*,4&. &5&$+&00#0#$&(,#,4,/.

 ($)$'(,#4))-6*+$;,#(.*&5$'8 ;,,'8#&'(,/;.(*,
'(,40(
-#((*&((*,$')(&'(7#$(0,($($' *&/;,,'$+,/ 
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

 /56&(,  (*&(  (*,#,  $)  &'  &6-(,  -'/ 6#-'6*7$(*(*,1-'$6$0&+
-'6$+! *$7&'$&'/(;&+&'6,-( ,?-$($,)!(*,0,($($',#$)*,+/,'($(+,/($'(,#,)( G H0,# &''-4(;,6&+6-+&(,/'(*,0#$'6$0&+&4-'((*&(&+#,&/.*&/ ;,,'#,+,&),/&'/(;,6&+6-+&(,/5,#&0,#$/$5,.

@ > *,  #,?-$)$(,  $'(,#,)(  &4-'(  ;,!  &66#/$'8+.! 6&+6-+&(,/&'/;,0&$/((*,0,($($',#7$(*$'&0,#$/(7 4'(*)#4(*,/&(,#,6,$0(&6,#($$,/60.(*$)#/,#  #$(0,($($'$)&++7,/$'(*,&#,)&$/(,#4) E 

  

F E 

  

F E 

  

F E 

  

F  !"

 !"

 !"

 !"

         

 

 

 

1 1 1 1

(,

(,

(,

(, *,(*,#)0,&=$'8A#,&)',/

,)A *,(*,#,0#(&;+,

,)A