Harwinder Singh v. Ld Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab And Others



    


    !"

!# !

$!!

!
!# !



#%&'

*'+,-,(.



/

%01,.*'0 2,.34 ////// '&,&,(.'0

5'0-6- !99'%7- 6.:%;

(&4'0- //////

'-9(.*'.&-

 %01,.*'0 2,.34 ////// '&,&,(.'0

5'0-6- !99'%7- 6.:%;

(&4'0- //////

'-9(.*'.&-
 !  <"= 

2
 !

2 "

 

0'-'.&  0/ 26..> ?/ 2,.37% !*@(+%&'

9'&,&,(.'0/

0/ ,08%7:,& 2,.34 #,1%.% 2'.,(0 #!

6.:%;/ 0/

/?/ 246A7% !*@(+%&'

+%@'%&(00'-9(.*'.&

/ / !

2 "

  

 !=

/ 4,- -4%77 *,-9(-'

%)(0'8'.&,(.'* &1( ,/'/

 ;(&4 %0,-'

(6& -%8'+(88(.

(0*'0/

/ 0%>'0

),7'* !0&,+7'-




(.-&,&6&,(.

.*,% ,.&'0 %7,% ,--6%.+'

.%&60'

+'0&,(0%0, -'&&,.3 %-,*'

9%--'* !99'%7- 6.:%;

,.

-4(0& <,.%.+,%7
(88,--,(.'0</ /

0%>'0

),7'* !0&,+7'-




(.-&,&6&,(.

.*,% ,.&'0 %7,% ,--6%.+'

.%&60'

 

+'0&,(0%0, -'&&,.3 %-,*'

9%--'* !99'%7- 6.:%;

,.

-4(0& <,.%.+,%7
(88,--,(.'0</ / (0 ;0'@,&> )%+&- 4%@'

;''.

&%A'.

)0(8

"0,')7> (.

*'8,-'

240, (3,.*'0 2,.34 90'@,(6- =%8;%0*%0  '.'0%7 @,77%3'

"%-&,

(;,.* %3%0 2%8%.% #,-&0,+& %&,%7% 90(+''*,.31'0'

,.,&,%&'* ),77,.3 %)(0'-%,* @%+%.+> 14'0',.

%01,.*'0 2,.34 0'-9(.*'.& "%7:,.*'0 2,.34 0'-9(.*'.&

 601,.*'0 2,.34 0'-9(.*'.&  60*,%7 2,.34 1'0'

%7-( +%.*,*%&'-/

/ 4'

!--,-&%.&

.*

0%*' 2%8%.% 1'77 !--,-&%.& -&

0%*' 2%8%.% 0'+(88'.*'* +%.*,*%&60'

%01,.*'0 2,.34 %)(0'-%,* @%+%.+> 97%+'* ;')(0'

%&,%7% ,.

-4(0& <
(77'+&(0</

4'

/

 %99(,.&'* %01,.*'0 2,.34 =%8;%0*%0 @,77%3'

"%-&,

(;,.* %3%0/

/ ''7,.3 %330,'@'* %3%,.-& %)(0'-%,*
(77'+&(0<- /

 0'-9(.*'.& "%7:,.*'0 2,.34 1'77 0'-9(.*'.&

 601,.*'0 2,.34 90')'00'* &4',0 -'9%0%&'

%99'%7- ;')(0'

#,@,-,(.%7 4(1'@'0 ;(&4 %99'%7- +%8'

*,-8,--'* +(88(.

/ /

/

/ 2&,77 %330,'@'* 0'-9(.*'.& "%7:,.*'0 2,.34 1'77 0'-9(.*'.&

 601,.*'0 2,.34 90')'00'* &4',0 -'9%0%&'

0'@,-,(.

;')(0'

1'0'

%77(1'*



,8963.'*

14'0';> (0*'0- 9%--'* 1'77 #,@,-,(.%7 1'0'

-'& %-,*'

1%- 0'8%.*'* 1,&4 *,0'+&,(.

)0'-4 '@%76%&,(.

0'3%0*- 0'7'@%.& )%+&(0- ,.+76*,.3 '*6+%&,(. 7%.* 4(7*,.3 'B9'0,'.+'

+(886.,&> -699(0& '&+/ / .

%)(0'8'.&,(.'* +,0+68-&%.+'- 9'&,&,(.'04%@'

),7'* -'9%0%&'

+,@,7 -''A,.3 0'7,')- .(&,+'* 4'0',.%;(@'/ / '%0*/

'0' 1(67* 0'7'@%.& 'B&0%+& 0'7%&,@'

8'0,&- +%.*,*%&'- %- .(&,+'*
(77'+&(0C ,- 


 

      

       

    !3'

  *6+%&,(.

&4 "!

!

=%.* 4(7*,.3 ?%.%7 %07%

?%.%7

?%.%7

%07%

'+(88'.*%&,(.

!--,-&%.& -&  

0%*'

1'77 !--,-&%.& .*

0%*' 2%8%.%

'8%0A2(.

*'+'%-'* 7%8;%0*%0  

/ !

9'06-%7 %)(0'-%,* +4%0& 1(67* -4(1 0'-9(.*'.&-

%0'

>(6.3'0 %3'

8(0'

'*6+%&'* &4%.

%01,.*'0 2,.34/

4%& %9%0& %77 +%.*,*%&'- %0'

4%@,.3 7%.*4(7*,.3/

.

&4,- +%-' %7&4(634 1%- %99(,.&'* =%8;%0*%0 1%- )60&4'0 %)),08'* #,@,-,(.%7 4(1'@'0 -'& %-,*'

(0*'0- 9%--'* #,@,-,(.%7



(;-'0@,.3 
   

               

          



  !   

 "

    #  "                  "  

    

                           

             

       



     $   

          

     "  %               "      !      " " 

                                "

     " & '  ()   ( *++  ,*         "                              "           



     

"  " -    )#   "

                "  

          "           %    %  " &       $             



   

     

 

.

 #     

                            

    /012022    "

 ,&, 

 202020 " &    , "      

 & 

  ,      

        %       "           "



  

 "

       $ 

 

     # 

      3

/ !

9'06-%7 %;(@'

'B&0%+&'* ),.*,.30'&60.'* 1(67* -4(1 (.'

)%+&(0- 1',34'* 8,.* 14,7'

0'8%.*,.3 )0'-4 +(.-,*'0%&,(. ,- ,- -&%&'* ,.@(7@'* +0,8,.%7 +%-'/

4'

-%,* )%+& 0'3%0*- ,.@(7@'8'.& +0,8,.%7 +%-'

4%- .(& ;''.

*'.,'* 9'&,&,(.'0 4(1'@'0 ,- -&%&'* 1%- %00%>'* %.

%++6-'* +%-'



 //

 0'3,-&'0'* 2'+&,(.-   

  
%& (7,+'

2&%&,(.

,&> 2%8%.% 4(1'@'0 +%.+'77%&,(.

0'9(0& 1%- -6;8,&&'* -%,*   4%- ;''.

%++'9&'* +(.+'0.'*
(60&

 /

& ,- )60&4'0 .(&,+'* ,- ,.@(7@'* %.(&4'0 +%-'





 0'3,-&'0'* 2'+&,(.-     

  
%& (7,+'

2&%&,(.

,&> 2%8%.% -&%&'* 4,8 9%0%  9'&,&,(. 4(1'@'0 )%&'

&4'0'() 4%- .(& ;''.

*,-+7(-'*/



/ "'

8%> &4,-
(60&
      

     4$567, (8 4'7* '.*'%@(60 0'@'.6'

%6&4(0,&,'- ,- %99(,.& ,.*,@,*6%76.,89'%+4%;7'

,.&'30,&> +4%0%+&'0 0(7'

=%8;%0*%0 *'8%.*- &06-& 0'-9'+& +0'*,;,7,&> 1,&4,.

+(886.,&>/

4%& %9%0& 14,7'

%99(,.&,.3 =%8;%0*%0 3(& -1%>'* )%+& ,- -(.

*'+'%-'* =%8;%0*%0 %.* &4'0')(0' 4'

4%- A.(17'*3'

=%8;%0*%0, 1(0A/

.

8> +(.-,*'0'* @,'1 %)(0'-%,* )%+& '--'.+' %8(6.&- 3,@,.3 90')'0'.+'

4'0'*,&%0> +7%,8 (&4'01,-'

4%- ;''.

4'7* ())'.*,.3 !0&,+7'


(.-&,&6&,(.

.*,%C #,@,-,(.

"'.+4 &4,-
(60&     

     51, 9::/

/  %8 %7-( @,'1 '*6+%&,(.%7 E6%7,),+%&,(.

,- 0'7'@%.& +(.-,*'0%&,(.

%99(,.&8'.& =%8;%0*%0 -%8'

1(67* +7'%07> )%77 +(.-,*'0%&,(.

%-9'+& <%;,7,&>< +%.*,*%&' '-9'+,%77> &%A,.3 ,.&( +(.-,*'0%&,(.

.%&60'

*6&,'- 9'0)(08'* =%8;%0*%0/

/
(.-,*'0,.3 &(&%7,&> +,0+68-&%.+'-  %8 @,'1 0'7'@%.& 8'0,&- *'8'0,&- +%.*,*%&'- 0'E6,0'

0'7((A -( ;'-& -6,&%;7'

+%.*,*%&'

%99(,.&'* =%8;%0*%0C %)&'0 +(.-,*'0,.3 %77 0'7'@%.& )%+&(0- .(&,+'* 4'0',.%;(@'

%7-( +(.&%,.'*

67'

=%.*

'@'.6'

67'-/ / .

@,'1 %;(@'  ),.* .( 8'0,& ;(&4 -%8'

%0'

%++(0*,.37> *,-8,--'*/



/ (1'@'0 +(.-,*'0,.3 )%+& 90(+''*,.3- %0'

9'.*,.3 -,.+'

   *''8 %990(90,%&'

*,0'+& ),.%7 *'+,-,(.

&%A'.

%&,%7% 1,&4,.

9'0,(* -,B 8(.&4- )0(8 &(*%>/

4(&(+(9> &4,- 97%+'* (.

+(..'+&'* +%-'

),7'/ '.*,.3 %997,+%&,(.

- ,) %.> -4%77 %7-( -&%.* +7(-'*/

!

2 "

  

# 

/

-:A- 4'&4'0 -9'%A,.30'%-(.'*  $'-



( 4'&4'0 0'9(0&%;7'

 $'- 

(