High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22126/2015dismissed

Hari Krishan v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-12-20The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 1

"# $%&

'()!*

+ ,') !-,./0

+1'-+ 3'4' 5+ +6+++(-' '7('

')8 % 5414.+0(,+0 -7 % 94 %+0 (( (,+ +0 +6++ :- % 5+4+/-%+;0'''+(,+++6+++( %'

14'-+(71 %+,-+(+0(,+0 -'7('

<<<<<< -7-+'7+6( - :;'4/'+ ')8 =: ,++6-+777+:0 ((, >4+'-;-+, -'7(' .+(( ?*(+( @ !A

"#B4

!&+(-+,'+'/;,+6-7'' 5, & - ;- + .7'+ +( +'7+,6 C+( ,>4'0 -+/+ +(

'. ,0 A0 ,( :- , .

? +( (,+ -+ - +,>4' 7,(;' >4+ - 776 - 7 1-+'+

!DEE @EA .#!8 ?&0 :-,- ,..,( /6 ,+ 4(5,?(+(!?

D@#B4 8A&+(:+( *(+(

D@*#B4 8"&'7, +(

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 2 7 '4+( :- - 4 '+ -:+ C-+0-'+(',-:+ F

C+(,4' -7'4/.'-+-7-+( 74,-+'( ?E@ '-+' >4+ ? .++' +( 1-+'+

!DEE @EA #?8 & ( ;'( '+ (( (+( A!

D@ - 4 '+ 3+;-:+C-+0-'$',-:+ -'+(+( :+'+,>4(/6-5+ +6++( ,+'(+(!?

D@+(

D@*''4(4(5,'?+( -C+(,>4',0 @D?0 :( /6 +:+( (+(

D@* - 74/, 747'0 +.60 - (7. +( 4G+ +( +' '(+ +( ..,+ ++ 4( - +6++ /+ 7. 4-6 ,0 D** -4;- - 7 (( ,-+; - +,>4' 7,(;'0 -: '. ,8'-+'-+(>4'-+(,-+;(-7,(;'/ -' 4/6 ;+ A?

D D@*0:--'4-+( '+6(-('7'''' -7'- "

D@@ -'+( 7 :+' ('7'( ( ( (+(

' 4;( -+ - 7''+,4++(7-6',+7'''' -+(>4' -+(,'4,(+.+( 4:+':--74'('(+( --',+ 4-0('7+4,. +:+(

D@*0 ,.7'+-+'/7+(-7+('+.'6;:--C+( ,>4', - 0-+,>4'7,(;'>4+-+( >4''+('+7'(: 5, & ,

,+0 % 94 %+0 +( ((+ (,+ +0 +6++0 +77+; - '7(85+ +6++ '4/.' -+ - , - 7 /; 7'''' - +( >4' ' (( .' +' - 7'''' - +( :+' +9 /6 ,(; +7+ G+.,-+

(+(

D@* +( - '+. :+'

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 3 -+((-/ ,+6(7+. '4/.'-+- +,4. - '+6 ('7'''' . - +( +4 - ,8'-+' :4( .76 -+ '4,- '+6 :+' 7+ +4 - 7 +' : 5,-7'''' -+('+('+90'+.'+(''(-5+ .+,4./+,'

4-0 - ,(' -+ - ,.7'+ - +( >4' :+' (46 (( 0 :+' .+( +++/ - 70 -:--+',-',-'+. ('4/'++- '+.0++,-+'/7+,(- +,-+.+H6 ,.7'+ -+'++(6/('/4'(-+(:'+'4 -+,.7'+ - +:+(( +( '

0AA0"D0@@E80 + +.4

0D 0@* E8 D"I -+,.7'++.4'+('('/4'( -+(:'

'4/.'-+-+.4:+'((-7 +' :0 -:0 - -+' -.' ,-' , - ,.7'+ :-,-''+++/ ('/4'. - 0''4/.(-+', -,;,'.(5, ?# & -, A+ 4 (+'7'''' -+('+('(46+9+(-/;+ - 5+7+6-,.7'+'+('(',-+;(:--(E7+6. ,.7'+J-7'7.'('.''+ "

-+-+(+(,4' -7+'+(74'(- ,('

77+60-.+''4'+4(-+77,+/6 5, & - ;- +.7'++(+'7+,6C+( ,>4'0 -+/++( '.,0 A# '-K-,

AL& ' ('74 - -+ - ,'6 +' ;+(' - ,'4,0 7+ +( +77,+/6 - , A -+' ', / '( /6 - L/ 547. 4

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 4

( - 7,7'+'4(:-+,,4.'+,'-+,>4'7,(;':4( /(.(-++7'(4(5, & -, A-+/ '7 4 /0 - 7B 4 -+' (',4''( (+ + - ,''+6 +'7,' -+ + + 7; 5, & , A0 -:0 -747' (,(;-.++-+(0- ,- ,,4(;7++;+7-' -H4(;.:4('4 ,)8 K2

! " # $ %$% # &

# " # " '( " #)

* "# " ' # & * & &&

"" +# ) # * " # ( #)

# # $ %$*%" # " ' # " , " * ' -&./# $%* & #

* ./ ./ - " #0 #) # $%" # " ' 1

#& # " "" #

# " # ( " * 1 #

* &(# * 1(#

* ("#

* ( * 1

-+ 2 2 "# $% " # " ' # "#

# -#0#"3 # $%# * & #

4 " )

*"#$ &% " "# " #0 # " # " ,

* #

###& " # " '# * ) # '

" #0 # "

, *" "

( # '

" # # * ) 53 " #

$ # %

" #0 #) #"3 & # 4 " )" " (#

# " ' * 6 &6 " "# "

#0 # " # " , 7 # * #

# '

$ % " # "

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 5

, ( # #0 # $% 3 3 " #

# - * ) #

) # '

$ % & & " ##

& ) "# " ) #

( # # #0

#) # $%" # " ' - # $%" # " ' *

"# $% "# $ %$*% 8 - " 1) # " , #

# $% * &) " 0 9 :#&*

1) # " # " , ( ) # $% " # " '(# * 1 # $% , - "# $% )"

" #)

#* # " # 1 #

" " *" # " ' # "#( #)" #0 ) & ##

- " * #" *# *+# #

"" # $%" # " ' ) & # " # 0 ) " ##

#) " #0 #

#) ) " "# " # " '( (

3* # ## #)

& 0 ) " " 1)

#) " " #

" # #0 ; * :0-B7' +:.+(-+ '+(H4(;. ,+/ 4-'4..+G( -'+9 ,+6-7,7'+((: /6-'4,-)8 #+& + -' ,+'' :- - +,>4' 7,'' -+( / +(/4-+:+(-+'/+4,(4(5,

-, @D?0-(+ ,..,. -,

A !

?0 - ' +7' 7,(;' +( - '+.:,40-:0:--(-+-,.7'+

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 6 -+'/(.(4(-7'' -, -' ,+'' :- - +:+( 4( 5,

- ,

@D?-+'/+4,(7,..,. -,

A0-7'' -, A:4(-+/+; +77,++(-7,(;':,4'7, -' ,+''0+' 0-, @D?-+'/7+( #/& -:(KL4'(/:/--,;,' 5,

& -, A'/+(+'./+'./:-,- .+'-+'9+7'; -+,>4'7,(;'/-- ,;,' .4' / 4 ( %+; -/60 -+ - 7''''-+(/+9/4-,.7'+:+',(0 - :4( / +7' 5.+60 ,.7'+ -+' / +,,7(/4-7''''-+'/+90-:4(/ +7' $"# ' '$%" 4) % #,& ' + +' - +'7, ,.7'+ - +( +,>4( ' ,,(0-L/547.4 (+-+',+;,+6 /'( -+ - B7'' 7+( - .+ 7+ 5,

& - , A (' ,4( + (7' ,.7'+4 -+'>4(/7('-+- ,.7'++.4:+'((:-,--+'/B7+(

' .+ -+ - +.4 ' .+( +++/ - +(::-,-:4(/+(',-+; -/;+.+9 -7+6.+(-+'4,-+7',+/7+G( -( +4.+9;-7+6. - ;5,' # &0A # &0A? -, @D?+(,.7+;-.:-- 7++.++7'' 5,'* +(@! -, A0 -L/7B4-+',+ (-+-6,'>4,

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 7 87+6. ,.7'+'.+9-7+6. ' +'75,A? -, @D?

-L/547. 4-+' 4-,+ (-+,-7+6. ,.7'+ -+' / (E(( 4( 5, A # &0 - +,>4; +4-6,+/7+G( 87+6.+'-+.4-+' .+47+((4-+(:L' 4'++,,7 ,+ 6 4-0-7B4-+'/'(-+ ++(:-+' (+ , -;-,.7'+0-,+,+.-+- :+'7+(-+.4 #(& -+(;-7'5, & -, A0- L/ 547. 4 -+' ,+ ( -+ ,+'0 - 7+6.-+'/.+(/4(7'(0+/67+6+.4 +;:-''4/'''+( (7'( .+H6 -(;' 6+'.0,.7'+4(-,

A -+' / 7+( - +(:' +' - (+ ,+ +( +,>4' 4( 5, ? - ,

@D?

;+(;-(7'0-+'/,+ ( - H4(;. -+ - -;- ,.7'+ :0 - .6'-4(-+/(7'(:--C+(,>4' , - +'46 - 4 :- '7, .+H6 +(-(;'0.+;-/60 :+'(7'( +6 --.(':-'7,.+H6 -(;'0- -;-,.7'+: :0/4'4(5,A? -, @D?:4(/-,'>4, #& ';+('-.( +9;7'''' -+(0-7B 4-+(,+ (-+(+:; >4'7E..+(4. :4( .+ -+ 7-6',+ 7'''' -+' / +9 - +:

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 8 :-;+('; +(-+',+;+/+( -(-+,-7''''-+'/+94(5, -, @D?0-+(''-5++(-,+/ +6(';+7';

# & -,.74;-;+77( 6+'/:-(+ +:+(+(,..,. -, A0+6.( '4/'';'/B,4((:-,-.+'-++ B,4(; -. (0- 78>4' ;+77( " 6+' ' -0-7'' 5, &,+/9( #;& -L/4-+' 4-,+ (-+ -+,>4' +(-+(+/,-+;(+(-+,>4':+'47-(0 :-,- .+' - 7,(; '( ,,4((0 - 4./+ 7, 5, & -, A,+/9+' (''++(./+(,+.' #-& 7++AA*0-L/547.4-+'.+(,+-+- 7' 5, & - , A ' .+ / 9( /6 - / ,+' +(:' :- : ' ,((+-. ''4+, ,+4(5,? - , @D?

6 '4/'>4 74,-+'0 -( -:'0 ,+9 -7'' 5, & - , @ -4'0-+;74'(-7+(;' /--7+'+(-+; B+.(-,'0:-+-'+,,4(-+-.+ + -+( ' '>4+6 ,( /6 - 7,7' +( (: /6 - L/ 547.4

$ %+(- 0- 7,+.;+7' +,>4'7,(;'0(''('.''+ - :;+'')8

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 9 +& -4;--7-+',((-+-'+,4+7-6',+ 7'''' -+(>4'0-:0-'+(+. ' +/ : - 7+ K

L .+( /6 - L/ 7B 4

:--L/4-+' ,+;,+6-(-+-:(7''''4'(-,

@D?-+'-'+..+;+'-+ 7-6',+7''''4'( 5, ? # & - , A0 -+ ' :- - 5+ . +,>4' - +( +( (+:' ..+(4. +9; 7'''' :-,- - 7' ,+' ' /6 ,(;

+7+ G+.,-+

(+(

D@* 5,0 - 7+,-+.+ :+' (+: 7 - ( ('7'''' 7+''(/6-'40- 07-6',+7'''' -+( '+('+9+(,-7'''''+90-'+/'4 '; - +( - 5+ -+ 0 - +(:+'-7'''' -+(0-'+'7+''0 +('4,-7'''' '7+''4' -/ +( /-+ -: 5+ 5,7''''-+'/+9 /6,(; +7+ G+.,-+

(+(

D@*0- 7+ - 7 -+ - ' 7-6',+ 7'''' - +( ' -4'0 -/6 H,( + + 7'''' -+' / +(/6-.0'6+'+'7+''+(+'+: ' + ,'>4, - 0 - ''+' ,+.; +7' +,>4'7,(;';'

/& ' + +' +'7, ,.7'+ ' ,,(0 ' '7, , '+( -'7('-+-,.7'++.4:+'(46 (( +( :+' .+( +++/ -+(:',4(;

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 10 -7 ('4/'++-'+.0+ ,-+' /.+(- +,-+4 +,.7'++.4

0AA0"D0@@E80++.4 '

0D 0@* E8 .+H6 -,.7'+-+'/('/4'( -' +,''4 , '-: -+ - ,.7'+ :+' (46 ((0 +( - 7-+'-.' ,-',-'+.0:-,-- ' + /6 , , ' '0 - ',( ,;,6 7',/(5, & , A+';'+(-4'0 +' -,;,'7',/(5, & , A ' 4 (0 - (.( , +7'; 7(( 4( 5, & - , A ,+ / 9( 5, -,;,'.(5, & - , A ' 4 ( +' 7'''' - +( '+(' +9+(-,.7'+'+('(46((0- 0 (,+++';+('+7' +,>4'7,(;',+/ .

+(-,+'+-+( 4-0% 94%+0 ,- +,'7+((- :'+.-+'-.6,((-+-5++,>4(-+( - 74/, 747' 4G+ +( '(+ +( ..,+5, A0-:+ -+(>4''6.4,-''+ +,-- 74/, 747' +( + ,'- 7+; +' 7 -+64 7+ -+,'((-'7+ +;4.+'(/6-'7('+( :+,.7+;.:--'+.+'-''+.7+ +, /97.

CWP No. 22126 of 2015 11

' + '>4 - +/ (',4'' +( : +: '4..+G( 7++8AA

$ %( '7, ,+6 + -+; ,(( -+ - ,+' + -+(0 - 7-6',+ 7'''' - +( >4' -+; / +90 - /;+ 7+6. ,.7'+ '+(' (',-+;( +( +' ,'(; -+ - +( >4' ' 6 .4,- ''+ +,- - 74/, 747'0 : -+ -'+ -( -+ - '+ ,+'0 - 5+ -+' 46 (',-+;('/;+>4+/--,;,',,4;5, ? # & - , A , +( /; '0 - 7' 7 .' ('.''+ -7'+,,(;6('.''(

- : 7 -+' / ('.''(0 + 7(; +77,+'0 :4( +,,(;6 '+( ('7'( . ('0 +60 +''+(+,+( # 351 & 5 #

CC&

!-,./0

+( Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No