High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22151/2015allowed

Satpal Thakran v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-08-06Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

!"#"$% !"#"$% !"#"$% !"#"$% &

& ' '

' '

( )* +, $ ""$ , -# ,.

$ $/* ,# #($/ $#

0%120 0%120 0%120 0%120330 330 330 330

, # $% 0,3/ 4/5!

,* ( ""$ , 0, 6, 7*0*6$ 44 ,.

$ 4

,, #($/ $# 8 0, 5 $* ,/9 :4/5!

,, #($/ $;

3304 3304 3304 3304 *"# ( ""$ "# /", ! / < "$# * ,/ , / /

( ## / 7. , #($/ $ 6$/ , !"$ ;; * ,"="$ ) ,! /6, / 4 >?;@ ,#*,A* ,1B $/$"! / /'

4"##6 /"$ (6,#6 $! * "=(6<$ /,/ ,/ /

4$* <,6$/ 7 "$< ")) < ) $/9"*6:6,"#/"!"$ * ( ""$ , 9 )) < /). ) ! / # * (, #"/ $ * !" . !

)) / 0 .

" )/ ,/ $ #"/ $ )

, !" .4 !, 4 6,< $ @ , #*, A* !" .1B * "#,"! <"#, , ",=# $/ !" " #4 6,< $ 5"/ *"# ,/ , / / ((,5 / * $ 9). !$#"6 /#!" .* # "// !"#"$9 #!* )) $< /7.* = =7 ,# !" . 7. 9 . $ (( ) ") /7 , * <"#, !" " #4 9* 5"/ *"# ,/ , / / C ;4 # #"/ * ,/ , * "#,"! <"#, ",=# $/!" " #* ,/ ,/ / C ;9 #!* )) $< /

7.9 . '&C> ;9*"!*9 ))9 / $/* = ,9 , = $/ /7 !+ * <"#, !" " #49* < "$ ))9 /*

(( )5"/ "#,/ ,/ / C ;

* # "/,/ ,9 #!* )) $< /7. * !" . 7. 9 . ';

9*"!* 9 ))9 / $

* $,

6, (( )7 ,"$<2''?

< "$#* / !"#"$ / /

9 # 9"*/, 9$ $ ;

=5 $

((,(,"

(()"!

"$ * 5" 9 (()"!

"$ 9 )# /"#="## / * ,

,#= = =7 ,# * !" . ") / !=() "$6$/ , !"$ ;; * ,7 , * 67"5"#"$ )0 46,< $$* <,6$/ * * !" ."#$(,5"/"$<7 #"! = $"" # 9 , $/ ) !,"!".* 046,< $D, #($/ $5"/ *"#"=(6<$ /,/ ,/ /

"##6 / /", !"$ * "#,"! <"#, , ",=# $/ !" " # $/ )# !$#"6 / $ "$/ ( $/ $ "$ ,"= !==" * 5 ,$= $

"! ,#D

"!"

)# ,,6$$"$<*

",# * !" .$* <,6$/* $6, * !" . * / ), /. $/ / "$ * .

))9"$< * "=(6<$ /,/ ,/ /

4* 5 ,$= $/="$"#, ,* + $ * !* ,< $/, E6", / )), #"/ $# )!+40 .

" )/ ,/ $/ (#" &4

* /="$"#, !!6$ ,$ /!6$# ) ,* ( ""$ ,* #5 * = $). ,<6 /* , #($/ $ * # , $#<, ## / *"# (9 ,# =6!* ) ## F! / / *"# :6,"#/"!"$"$( ##"$<* "=(6<$ /,/ ,7.9*"!** * /"##6 //", !"$# * "#,"! <"#, , ",=# $/ !" " # $/ (("$ / $ "$ ,"= !==" 5 ,$= $

"! ,#D

"!"

)# $/ 6,* ,"##6 / /", !"$

(("$/="$"#, ,,6$*

",# * !" . $ * * , * $/4 ) ,$ / !6$# ) , * , #($/ $# * #67=" /* * "=(6<$ /,/ ,"#9 ))"$ !!,/ $! 9"*) 97 !

6# , #($/ $* /* :6,"#/"!"$(, 5 $* (67)"!$6"# $! "#

; #67=" /* * = =7 ,# * !" .9 , $7 "$<(,5"/ /9 ,

$/ ) !,"!". 7 !

6# * "$ ,$ ) 7"!+ ,"$<4 * , , 4 * "=(6<$ / ,/ , * # 7 $ ( ## / "# )# #67=" / * 5 $ $ &

4 * "#,"! <"#, ",=# $/!" " #*"=# ) * (("$ /* *#")/ ,

$ /="$"#, $/ * # "/ ,/ , * # $ 7 $ !* )) $< / 7. * ( ""$ , * 5 * ,/ ) ,$ / !6$# ) , * ( ," # $/ ( ,6# / * , !,/ $,/ , ((, !"

,<6= $#, "# /7.) ,$ /!6$# )

,* ( ""$ ,4"96)/7 , ) 5 $, ,* (,5"#"$# !"$ ;; * ,49*"!*, / #6$/ ,% G ;; $/""$ ) ,/ , , , =5 ) $6"# $! H I * $ 5 , "#,"! 0 , 67 /"5"#"$ ) 0 , $. * , F !6"5 0 #( !"

)). =(9 , / "$*"#7 * ) 7.* 5 ,$= $4$ , ! "5"$< * , (, ()"!

"! , , * , "$ ,= "$ $/ $ +"$< #6!* 5"/ $! H"

$.I #* *"$+# "4!$#"/ ,# I * $. 6$) 6) 7#,6!"$ , $6"# $! #*6)/ 7 , =5 / ,=

$. (67)"! () ! , ,= $. 9 .4 ,"5 ,,!* $$ )9*"!*"#,= .7 ) 6)).6# /7.* (67)"!J, H7I * * !$/6! $. , / , !!6( "$4 , * + ("$< $.

C </#,= ,!* $/"# 4"#"$:6,"6# * * )*,(*.#"!

)!= , !==6$".4 $/* "$!$# E6 $! #6!* , / , !!6( "$ #*6)/ 7 (,*"7" /,, <6) /,#6!*</# ,= ,!* $/"# #*6)/7 , =5 /, * + ("$<* , , <6) /J, H!I * * !$#,6!"$ $.76")/"$<4 ,4* /"#(# ) $.#67# $! 4 "#)"+ ).!!

#"$!$ "<6, "$, F()#"$4 #*6)/ 7 (, 5 $ / , #(( /J, H/I * $.76")/"$<4 $,#,6!6, 4,

$., "#"$#6!* !$/""$* " "# )"+ ).

)) $/ * , 7. !

6# "$:6,. ( ,#$# )"5"$< , !

,,."$< $76#"$ ##"$* $ "<*76,*/, ( ##"$< 7.4 $/ * "$ !$# E6 $! * , =5 )4, ( ",,#6((, #6!* 76")/"$<4 $ , #,6!6, 4 , * , =5 ) , #6((, #6!* , 4 "# $ ! ## ,.J, H I * $. $+4 9 )) , F!

! $ $. #6!* 9 . , (67)"! () ! #*6)/ 7 $! / "$ #6!* $$ , # (, 5 $ / $< , ,"#"$< * (67)"!J,

I * $./ $< ,6# $"= )#*6)/7 / #,. /4 !$ "$ / , * ,9"# /"#(# / 4 #6!* 0 = . = + !$/""$ ) ,/ , , E6","$< * ( ,#$ !

6#"$< #6!* 7#,6!"$,$6"# $! 4,!

,,."$<$#6!* , / , !!6( "$4 , + ("$< $. #6!* </# = ,!* $/"# 4 9$"$<4 (## ##"$< , !$,))"$< #6!* 76")/"$<4 $4 #,6!6, 4 #67# $! 4 $+4 9 )) , F!

"$4 , 9$"$< , (## ##"$< #6!*

$"= ),, 49"*"$ "= 7 "F /"$ * ,/ , H"I , =5 #6!* 7#,6!"$ , $6"# $! J, H""I / #"# ,= !

,,."$< $4 , , =5 , , <6) "$ #6!* $$ , # = . 7 /", ! /4 #6!*, / ,!!6( "$4, , =5 #6!* </# = ,!* $/"# 4,, <6) + ("$< * , "$ #6!* $$ , #= .7 /", ! /J, H"""I (, 5 $ #( * !$#,6!"$ #6!* 76")/"$<4 , ) ,* /"#(# ) #6!* #67# $! J,

& H"5I , =5 4 , ( ", , #6((, #6!*76")/"$<4 $,#,6!6, 4 , , =5 , #6((, #6!* , #J, H5I $! #6!* $+4 9 )) , F!

"$J, H5"I / #,.4 !$ "$ , /"#(# #6!* / $< ,6# $"= ) "$ * = $$ , (,5"/ / "$ * # "/,/ ,J ,4"

* 7: !##/4 (( ,7 , *"=# ) ,#= * ,F !6"5 0 #67,/"$ *"= "= $/() ! 7

"F /7.* ,/ ,4 $/#*9!

6# 4"$* $$ ,* , "$

,(,5"/ /49*.* ,/ , #*6)/$7 = / 7#)6 HI ,/ ,/6).= / 7. 0 6$/ ,*"## !"$#* ))7 !

)) /"$E6 #"$ "$ $."5")6, F() $ "$ K(67)"!() ! K"$!)6/ # )# (,( ,. 7 )$<"$< * 4 !

=("$< <,6$/# $/ <,6$/# ) 6$!!6(" / # $"

,.,, !, "5 (6,(# #L ( ,6# ) *

, # "/ (,5"#"$ #*9 * $ "* , , #($/ $* /* :6,"#/"!"$ $ , "$* !=() "$!$#"/ , * <," 5 $! # , "# / * , "$ $, * * / * (9 , ( ## * "=(6<$ /

? ,/ ,9*"!*"# F!)6#"5 )."$* /= "$ 6*,"" #(, #!,"7 /6$/ , * ( , "5 !" " #! ,$ / !6$# ) , * , #($/ $# !6)/ $ , "# $. $"$< 6) ,<6= $!$ # F! ( ,, ,,"$<* #67# E6 $,/ , ( ## /7.* "#,"! <"#, ",=# $/!" " #/ /&

7. 9*"!* $:"5"$<) 4 *#")/ ,46,< $9 (("$ / #/="$"#, , #, < ,/#* (("$= $ /="$"#, ,"#!$! ,$ /4* ( ""$ ,= . ")*"#, = /."$ !!,/ $! 9"*) 976"$#

, #* "=(6<$ / ,/ , $/ #67# E6 $ $"! , !$! ,$ /4 * # , ( $). ")) < ) $/9"*6:6,"#/"!"$ $! 4* (, # $( ""$"#* , 7. ))9 /

$/* "=(6<$ /,/ , $/$"! , * , 7.E6 #* / H330I H330I H330I H330I

& ' '

' '

' ' * * ,#( +"$<D, #$ / %

#D * * , (,

7) %