Surjit Singh And Others v. Commissioner, Ambala Division And Others




  
    

 !"#$%

&#'( )*+*(%,-$%

.*/. +0& 10( 

 ( (*( 22(( -23&&( -23&&& 10( 

(4 (



  


   

( )5

& 6&/& -1'&-#04 ( 5 2&/5&6& -1'&-#0'&&7(4 (

7 

   8 &9 04 (&(1 (#&+00&//*5&/&-0( && +&0-('23&& 0& 1 1(4*2&(* +20& %% &'(( 04((((

. '0&2 & '0&:&(&1&(( +( ;*&0(&1& 1-04 (- '*1 +0.&4& '0#&2

& '0&:&-#1&/ 4 * 1.' !7#0 * /&3<&+ 22  =& 1(  8 +*& 9  '-  , -  &(  &44'&3    0  .&  # &:& &-(6 +1'&& #00& 1 1(4* 0 (*7'*274 >&(1(2((13:0'-23&&111&1

?

$% -&+& (>0'00:0&#1&44&3#022(( - 23&&( -23&& 044&*0: &:+& 1&17  2(&:3*1024*+ 111&1$!

%@ $% 0(&:0&(3

&'&1>0*&((+  +& :&( & 10&44&0&(3 (1# 0& + $@

% $%

0&++14 (&3#0(* A$B . '.&4& '0#0&2 & '0&:&0&(/ 10& 1(>0 04 (-0 (#0&2 & '0&:&(3 +61&#3:

& & '0>0(0*(3& 1((4  @ 0&&:(#(4 ( 



  $ ( '&& A!B 0&0&1& 1'* (#04&(& 1+ 0*+0 0'1 A"B
&44&(0&#0&2 & '0&:&(*''1( 1(4(((( + 04 (#20(*& 11* +04 ':#0&44&- >*1- &>&:- 10&44& #*'**( 04 (C4((((

  0  1'(  #  0  &44&  0*(  1((    3  4'1  11 &''1 +:

0(&22- '&

60#&'0&#0& (#* 10&(1 &2 & '0&:&-04 (&&3 '24 (&0&2 & '0&:&#0(((3* 1(*##1*   #(4(((( 3:04 ( 
>*130*( 0 ( #/*('& 1;*:1'0&44& (3#022(( - 23&&( -14(&(*2# ( $%-%%%D74&' 0*# '&23&&>0  2 0 0'(0&640&2*     && &(1& 
'&(04 (#&(&3(00 -0&2* (14(1& +>0 ((0&3&(1 #&* #0&2 & '0&:& >-#0&44& (3#22(( - 23&&( (*''1& 1&013> (#0& 1 1(4*- 014(1&2* 0&(3#* 1102 A@B 0&#7(&1&2* ( :#0'4:&$% -

&2:-*40&( +0'* 
'4 022(( -23&& ( -(1'11'10&44& 01&#E1  -$@

% $%

& 1D & :'&(3#!%

$%


0 #01'( +( &+& (04 (& 1#0:>& &&#*021:-0:(0&3 &314(*('0&+(#0(&( # &37$% & 1F0&#7$% ?

&(&0(&2&# ( $%-%%%D74&'->0  2 0#201&



  ! #4&(( +#013:022(( -23&&( -23&& 

0 #  714(-0' ( +(4 ((0&3&3: (6&'& #0&17 2(&:

11&''1 +:

=&'4:#0(13+ 1&(& 1'* (#0 4 (1* +0'*(#1&:-* 10(+ &*(#0 '0 .'&:& 1 4&:2 #*(*&'0&+(

       !

 *+*(%,-$%





























!