High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21193/2016disposed of

Jagbir Singh v. Presiding Officer And Another

2023-08-29Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger12 pages

!"# &#'()($* + ,+

!-.(/ 0(*-1 ++++++ #"("($*#/ 2#/)3) /#)(&(*-

%%('#/4 *&3)"/(!5 /(.3*!5'367!.$3/ $3/"4

!*(8!"

!*& !*$"1#/

++++++ #)8$*&#*")

/#)#*"

)1$9 :!-(4

&;$'!"# %$/

/+ 0+0+ <1!/!.4

&;$'!"# %$/ 8#"("($*#/+

/+ 0!"()1 0(*-5!4

!/:!*!+

+ + + #"("($*#/

!-.(/ 0(*-1 %(5#& (*)"!*"

(;(5 /("

#"("($* 3*&#/

/"('5#) $*)"("3"($* *&(!4 )##9(*- =/("

*!"3/# '#/"($/!/( %$/ >3!)1(*- (683-*#&

=!/& &!"#& ++ ?

**#@3/# A4 8!))#& *&3)"/(!5 /(.3*!5'367!.$3/ $3/"4 !*(8!"

1#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& B"1# .#5$=B #@"#*"4 =1#/#.:

8#"("($*#/ .##* &#*(#& /#5(#% /#(*)"!"#6#*"

)#/;('# !*& %355 .!'9 =!-#) !55 '$*)#>3#*"(!5 .#*#%(") !*& .##* 1#5& #*"("5#& '$68#*)!"($* )+ ?4 4 8!(& /#)8$*&#*" #8!/"6#*"+

%3/"1#/ 8/!:#/ .##* 6!&# %$/ &(/#'"(*- /#)8$*&#*" #8!/"6#*"

/#(*)"!"# 8#"("($*#/$/96!* !*& .!'9 =!-#) #%%#'"

%/$6 + + , "(55 &!"# !55 '$*)#>3#*"(!5 .#*#%(")+

/(#%5:4 8#"("($*#/$/96!* /!()#& !* (*&3)"/(!5 &()83"#4 =1('1 =!) /#%#//#& .#5$= %$/ !&C3&('!"($*+

* '5!(6 8#"("($*4 8#"("($*#/$/96!* '5!(6#& 1# =!) !88$(*"#& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

3.5('

#!5"1 #8!/"6#*"4 !*(8!" $* 8$)"

!5('361$=9(&!/ $* + + !*& 1() =$/9 !*& '$*&3'"

1!& /#6!(*#& -$$& "1/$3-1$3"

&3/(*- "#*3/# 1() )#/;('# !*& "1#/# =!) *$ '$685!(*"

!-!(*)"

1(6+

1# '5!(6#& 1# =$/9#& 03.

(;()($*!5 *-(*##/4 3.5('

#!5"1 #8!/"6#*"

$+ 4 !*(8!"

%/$6 :#!/ :#!/ !*& !5)$ &3/(*- 8#/($& %/$6 :#!/ + + A4 1# =$/9#& 03.

(;()($*!5 *-(*##/4 3.5('

#!5"1 #8!/"6#*"

$+ 4 !*(8!"+

) 8#/ 8#"("($*#/=$/96!*4 $* + + 4 1# =!) "/!*)%#//#& 368

8#/!"$/4 1$=#;#/4 /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

&(& 8/$;(&# !*:

5$- .$$9 !*& !""#*&!*'# /#-()"#/ 1(6

=$/96!* %$/ 83/8$)# 6!/9(*- !""#*&!*'# !""#*&!*'# /#-()"#/ !*& 5$- 5$$9 %$/ 6!(*"#*!*'# &!(5:

/#'$/&+

=!) '5!(6#& =$/9#& %/$6

+ + + + A =("1$3"

!*:

./#!9 !*& 1# 1!& =$/9#& %$/ 6$/# "1!* A &!:) #;#/:

'!5#*&!/ :#!/+

) 8#/ 8#"("($*#/=$/96!*4 1# %(5#& A , .#%$/# "1() $3/"

)##9(*- /#-35!/(D!"($* 1() )#/;('#)4

=1('1 =!) &()8$)#& "1() $3/"

&(/#'"(*- /#)8$*&#*") "!9# &#'()($* $* /#8/#)#*"!"($* 8#"("($*#/=$/96!*4 1$=#;#/4 8#"("($*#/ =$/96!* '5!(6#& 1() '!)# %$/ /#-35!/(D!"($* )#/;('#) =!) '$*)(&#/#& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

!*& (*)"#!& )#/;('#) 8#"("($*#/ =$/96!* =#/# "#/6(*!"#& $* + + A =("1$3"

!*:

*$"('# /#>3(/#& 5!=4 =1#/#38$* %(5#& &#6!*& *$"('# 3*&#/

0#'"($*

*&3)"/(!5 ()83"#)

'"4 A

1#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& BA

'"B .#%$/# 7!.$3/

%%('#/4 !*(8!"4 =1#/#38$*

'$68/$6()# =!) #%%#'"#& .#"=##* 03.

(;()($*!5 *-(*##/ !*& !*& ("

=!) !-/##& =$35& "!9#* .!'9 $* &3":

%/$6 ,+ + A+

)3.6(""#& C$(*#& 1() &3":

$* &!"#4 1$=#;#/4 $* A+ + A4 /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

/#%3)#& "!9# $* &3":+

1#* !-!(* )#/;#& 5#-!5 *$"('# &!"#& ,++ A $* /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

!*& !5)$ %(5#& &#6!*& *$"('# &!"#& + + ?

.#%$/# 7!.$3/

%%('#/4 !*(8!"4 =1#/#38$*4 !-!(* '$68/$6()# =!) #%%#'"#& !*& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

!-/##& "!9# .!'9 $* &3":

!*& )(*'# "1#* 8#"("($*#/ =$/96!* =!) )#/;(*- 1() &3":

/#-35!/5:

=("1$3"

!*:

./#!94 1$=#;#/4 1# =!) .#(*- 8!(& =!-#) /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

)(*'#

35:4 ,+

* "1#)# '(/'36)"!*'#)4 )#/;#& 5#-!5 *$"('# &!"#& ++ ,4 =1#/#38$* 1# =!) !-!(* "#/6(*!"#& %/$6 )#/;('#) $* ++ , =("1$3"

!*:

/#!)$* !*& =("1$3"

!*:

)1$= '!3)# *$"('#4 '1!/-# )1##"4 *$"('# 8#/($& 8!:

!*& =("1$3"

'$*&3'"(*- !*:

#*>3(/:4 !''$/&(*-5:4 '5!(6#& 1() )#/;('#) 1!;# .##* "#/6(*!"#& ;($5!"($* 8/$;()($*) 0#'"($* ? A

'"+

# '5!(6#& /#(*)"!"#6#*"

)#/;('# %355 .!'9 =!-#)+ + 1# !%$/#)!(& '5!(6 =!) '$*"#)"#& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

$* -/$3*& =!) #685$:#& $* &!(5:

=!-#) $* 63)"#/ /$55 .!)() !5('361$=9(&!/ #%%#'"

%/$6 + + !*& =$/9#& 38"$ A+ + A+

=!) )"!"#&

1!& =$/9#& &(%%#/#*"

)3.

&(;()($*) &3/(*- 1() #685$:6#*"

!*& ("

=!) &3":

!5('361$=9(&!/ !))()"

=!"#/ 368

8#/!"$/ !*& '!//:

$3"

!*:

$"1#/ 6!*3!5 C$.

!))(-*#& 1(6 =!"#/ 368

8#/!"$/ 3*($/ *-(*##/ (*'53&(*- 6!(*"#*!*'# (*5#"4 '1!**#5) !*& %(5"#/ .#&) #"'+

#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

&#*(#& '5!(6 1# 1!& =$/9#& '$*"(*3$3)5:

%$/ A &!:) $/ 6$/# :#!/ &3/(*- 8#/($& + + + + A =("1$3"

./#!9+

#-!/&(*- '5!(6 /#-35!/(D!"($* )#/;('#)4 ("

=!) )"!"#& '!)# &(& %!55 3*&#/ )'1#6# /#-35!/(D!"($*4 1#*'#4 '!)# =!) '$*)(&#/#& %$/ /#-35!/(D!"($* !*& =!) /#C#'"#& 1# =!) )#/;('# )(*'#

? 38"$ + + 4 /#>3(/#& 3*&#/ 8$5(':

/#-35!/(D!"($*+

=!) %3/"1#/ )"!"#& 83/)3!*'# )#""5#6#*"

!//(;#& !"

.#"=##* !*& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

.#%$/# 7!.$3/

%%('#/4 !*(8!"4 =!) "!9#* .!'9 $* &3":

#%%#'"

%/$6 ,+ + A !5('361$=9(&!/ !*& "1#/#!%"#/4 1# 5#%"

C$.

1() $=* %/## =(554 1#*'#4 *$ *$"('# =!) *#'#))!/:

$/ '$68#*)!"($*)!5!/:

=!) /#>3(/#& 8!(& 8#"("($*#/=$/96!*+ "

=!) )3.6(""#& /#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

;($5!"#& 8/$;()($*) '$*"!(*#& 0#'"($* ? A

'"+

''$/&(*-5:4 8/!:#/ %$/ &()6())!5 '5!(6 8#"("($* =!) 6!&#+

A+

* .!)() 85#!&(*-) 8!/"(#)4 ())3#) =#/# %/!6#& !*& 8!/"(#) 5#& "1#(/ /#)8#'"(;# #;(&#*'#+

%"#/ '$*)(&#/(*- '!)# /#)8#'"(;# 8!/"(#) =#55 #;(&#*'#6!"#/(!5 85!'#& $* /#'$/&4 .#5$= /#"3/*#&

%$55$=(*- %(*&(*-)

" #$%&'" ( )

+,- .

"/0/1

" #$%& '" ( )

* +,-

2 $*)(&#/(*- !%$/#6#*"($*#&4 .#5$=

!*)=#/#& /#%#/#*'# %!;$3/ =1#/#.:

(*)"#!& 8!))(*- !* !=!/& /#(*)"!"#6#*"

)#/;('# %355 .!'9 =!-#) !*& '$*"(*3(":

)#/;('#4 =!) 1#5& #*"("5#& 8!(& )36 '$68#*)!"($* )+ ?4 +

+ * !%$/#6#*"($*#& '(/'36)"!*'#)4 !88/$!'1#& "1() $3/"

%(5(*- (*)"!*"

=/("

8#"("($*+

+ 7#!/*#& '$3*)#5 %$/ )3.6(") .#5$= #//#& 5!= -/!*"(*- /#(*)"!"#6#*"

'$*"(*3(":

)#/;('# !*& .!'9 =!-#) &#)8("# !*)=#/(*- /#%#/#*'# 1() %!;$3/+

)3.6(""#& .#5$= !'"#& !/.("/!/(5:

&#*:(*- /#5(#% !*& -/!*"#&

6#!-/# '$68#*)!"($* )+ ?4 $*5:+ "

)3.6(""#& '$*'#&#&5:4 !%$/#)!(&

=!/& &!"#& ++ ?

.##* (683-*#& /#)8$*&#*" #8!/"6#*"4 "1#/#%$/#4 -/!*"#& /#5(#% /#(*)"!"#6#*"

!*& !55 '$*)#>3#*"(!5 .#*#%(")+ ,+

* $"1#/ 1!*&4 5#!/*#& 0"!"# '$3*)#5 $88$)#& 8/!:#/ $* -/$3*& !88/$8/(!"# /#5(#% !5/#!&:

.##* -/!*"#& /#5(#% /#(*)"!"#6#*"

%355 .!'9 =!-#) !*& '$*"(*3(":

)#/;('# !3"$6!"('+

)3.6(""#& (683-*#& !=!/& C3)"(%(#& !*& !&#>3!"# '$68#*)!"($* !5/#!&:

.##* -/!*"#&4 "1#/#%$/#4 (683-*#&

=!/& &$#) '!55 %$/ !*:

(*"#/%#/#*'#+

''$/&(*-5:4 8/!:#/ %$/ &()6())!5 (*)"!*"

=/("

8#"("($* .##* 6!&#+

+ 1!;# 1#!/& 5#!/*#& '$3*)#5) %$/ 8!/"(#) !*& 1!;# !5)$

8#/3)#& 8!8#/ .$$9 "1#(/ !.5# !))()"!*'#+ + $*'#&#&5:4 )#/;('#) 8#"("($*#/$/96!* 1!;# .##* 1#5& "#/6(*!"#& ;($5!"($* 8/$;()($*) 0#'"($* ? *&3)"/(!5 ()83"#)

'"4 A

1#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& BA

'"B+

1# /#)8$*&#*"!*!-#6#*"

5!(& !*:

'1!55#*-# (683-*#& !=!/& 1#/#(* =1#/#.:

'$68#*)!"($* =!) !=!/&#& 8#"("($*#/$/96!*+

+ 1# 5!"#)"

5#-!5 "/#*& !=!/& '$68#*)!"($* 85!'# /#(*)"!"#6#*"+

* '!)# 3(.045(6' ) (77$$84

8#@ $3/"

1#5& =1#* "#/6(*!"($* )#"

!)(&# .#'!3)# ;($5!"($* 0#'"($* ? A

'"4 ("

*#'#))!/:

/#5(#% /#(*)"!"#6#*"

-(;#* 6!""#/ /(-1"+

* 9 4( ( :' );(77 ,4 ("

=!) (*"#/ !5(!

1#5& "1$)# '!)#) =1#/# =$/96!* 1!& =$/9#& $* &!(5:

=!-# .!)() !*& =$/9#& 6#/#5:

%$/ 8#/($& A &!:) $/ :#!/) !*& =1#/# "#/6(*!"($* 1!& "!9#* 85!'# 6!*:

:#!/) !-$4 /#'#*"

"/#*& =!) -/!*"

'$68#*)!"($* 5(#3 /#(*)"!"#6#*"+

* ( ( < '!)#

)38/!4 $*B.5#

8#@ $3/"

/#("#/!"#& "/#*& /#%#//(*- ;!/($3) C3&-6#*") !*& (*"#/ !5(!

1#5& 3*&#/ (

( $1 = * ;>#'

=*2)?@ 7

B C (

(* 5 3 ! 7 '"50 C) 7 & DE(3 7

D . E D 1

57C ( 5E 0 4 5E * @ (" 5 0. 1

@ C =

" F=* * 5

= . E F!

:'C ( (77

BBBB$ # >) G# 7

! HHHH HHHHH HHHHH

( $&1

7 @

G > C (

@ = ( ( 7 :

'(77 ###

)

! G + "

=$/"1=1(5# /#%#/ &#'()($* $*B.5#

8#@ $3/"

3(.04 3 A

0 AE =1#/#(*4

8#@ $3/"

'5#!/5:

1#5& =1#* "1#/# ;($5!"($* 0#'"($* ? A

'"4 /#(*)"!"#6#*"

%355 .!'9 =!-#) !3"$6!"('4 =$/96!* )1$35& -(;#* 6$*#"!/:

'$68#*)!"($* =1('1 =(55 6##"

#*&) C3)"('#+

1# $*B.5# 038/#6# $3/"

$.)#/;#& 3*&#/ B

( $1 = * 7

! "

( $1 = *

(

'(:( D= ',)>(77 )@

2 + 1# $*B.5#

8#@ $3/"

85#"1$/!

'!)#) &(/#'"#& '$68#*)!"($* 5(#3 /#(*)"!"#6#*"+

#%#/#*'# '!* 6!&# 5

= . E F!

:'8) (77$#$ (" . 1 @ :'8)$(77#$ F=* * :'8)>(77, A+ 1# 8#/3)!5 !.$;# C3&-6#*") 6!9#) ("

'5#!/ *#= #)"!.5()1#& "/#*& -/!*"

'$68#*)!"($* 5(#3 /#(*)"!"#6#*"+

?+ * 8/#)#*"

'!)#4 )#/;('#) =#/# "#/6(*!"#& !.$3"

:#!/) !-$4 =1('1 1!;# .##* 1#5& .#5$=

;($5!"($* 8/$;()($*) 0#'"($* ? A

'"+

$*'#&#&5:4 /#)8$*&#*"!*!-#6#*"

5!(& !*:

'1!55#*-# (683-*#& !=!/& 1#/#(* =1#/#.:

'$68#*)!"($* =!) !=!/&#& 8#"("($*#/=$/96!*+ 1#/#%$/#4 ;(#= 5#-!5 8$)("($* (*&('!"#& !.$;#4 '$*)(&#/ $/&#/ /#(*)"!"#6#*"

6!:

8!))#& "1() '!)#+

$=#;#/4 '$68#*)!"($* !=!/&#& .#5$= 5$=#/ )(&#+

''$/&(*-5:4 '$*)(&#/(*- "$"!5(":

'(/'36)"!*'#)4 6:

'$*)(&#/#& ;(#=4 (*"#/#)"

C3)"('# =$35& 6#"

(% '$68#*)!"($* !=!/&#& 8#"("($*#/

.#5$= #*1!*'#& %/$6 )+ ?4 )+ 4? 4 +

#)8$*&#*"#8!/"6#*"

&(/#'"#& 8!:

#*1!*'#& !6$3*"

!%"#/ !&C3)"(*- )36 '$68#*)!"($* )+ ?4 4 !5/#!&:

!=!/&#& .#5$= =("1(* 8#/($& "1/## 6$*"1) %/$6 &!"# /#'#(8"

'#/"(%(#& '$8:

"1() $/&#/+

* '!)#4 *$*8!:6#*"

!6$3*"

=("1(* )"(835!"#& 8#/($&4 )1!55 #*"("5#& '5!(6 )(685# (*"#/#)"

/!"#

8#/ !**36 "(55 )3'1 "(6# 8!:6#*"

6!&#+

+ 1# (*)"!*"

=/("

8#"("($* &()8$)#& !%$/#)"!"#& "#/6)+ ,+

8#*&(*- !885('!"($* )4 (% !*:4 )1!55 )"!*& '5$)#&+

+ ,+

)C9) 1#"1#/ )8#!9(*-/#!)$*#&

$ 1#"1#/ /#8$/"!.5# #)