High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4931/2012allowed

Rajesh Kumar v. Punjab Public Service Commission

2017-11-13Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan11 pages

!"##$%&%'(

)

!*#&+,-.!/ #"%"%'#/ 1#/&-&

-'*!2 -23%$4#/5%$#..%&&%'

!'6"+#/& #&7'6#'"&

/#&#'"(0 /4-8+6##7 !/.!/965$!"#/"+#7#"%"%'#/ /5%'%"5!&"+%99 -'*!2 :::

#"%"%'#/9;+%&5%&-!33<%.7!%/#69%&!==/%#5#6"+#!$"%' "+#%/&"/#&7'6#'"%#"+# -'*!2 -23%$4#/5%$#..%&&%' +#/#%'

!"#/"2#/##//#6!&"+#..%&&%' !'6"+#&#$'6/#&7'6#'"%#"+# #7!/".#'" -23%$/8& /!'$+9 -'*!2%'+!5%'=6#'%#6+%.

$'&%6#/!"%'/!77%'".#'"""+#7&"4-2%5%&%'!3'=%'##/ %5%3 !=!%'&""+#7&"/#&#/5#6/"+#7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/< /%#!$"&!/#"+!"65#/"%&#.#'" 0 ;!& %&&-#62<"+#..%&&%'%'5%"%'=!773%$!"%'&/.#3%=%23#$!'6%6!"#&/ /#$/-%".#'" " ) 7&"& 4-2 %5%&%'!3 '=%'##/&

%5%3?#$+!'%$!3?3#$"/%$!3 %'"+##7!/".#'" -23%$/8&

/!'$+9 -'*!2'"+#2/#!80-77&"&%'6%$!"#6%'"+#!65#/"%&#.#'"@ 7&"&;#/#4-2%5%&%'!3'=%'##/& %5%3 ;7&"&;#/#/#&#/5#6" 2#%33#6-7/."+#7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<+#$'6%"%'& #3%=%2%3%"<!&/#=!/6&#&&#'"%!3A-!3%%$!"%'&9!=##"$;#/#!3&%'6%$!"#6%' "+#!65#/"%&#.#'"+#7/&7#$"%5#$!'6%6!"#&;#/#7-""'"%$#%'"+# !65#/"%&#.#'"%"&#3"+!".#/#7&&#&&%'"+#7/#&$/%2#6#&&#'"%!3

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

$ %&'() *

$ -

* , *- .

, 1 - (

, ,

, + %&)&23

# #

, #+ *

567 8 9 0:;<- *

, = %&:>%:72&)52((?%2)5277&)$ - # + #

8@+

$ - 7

< :

- 5 < :

- !,

- 5 < :

* *#

) +

#"%"%'#/ 7&&#&&#6 "+# #&&#'"%!3 #6-$!"%'!3 A-!3%%$!"%'& 7/#&$/%2#6!'6!773%#6/"+#7&"4-2%5%&%'!3'=%'##/ %5%3 -'6#/ "+#/#&#/5#67+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<#!77#!/#6%'!&$/##'%'= "#&"$'6-$"#62<"+#..%&&%'!'6"+#/#&-3";+%$+;!&6#$3!/#6' @

#"%"%'#/%&&"!"#6"+!5#&#$-/#6 B.!/8&%'"+#&$/##'%'="#&" +#7/#$%&#=/%#5!'$#/!%&#62<"+#7#"%"%'#/%&"+!"%'&7%"# 2#%'= "+# &3# 5%&-!33< %.7!%/#6 $!'6%6!"#9 ;+ +!6 !77#!/#6 %' "+# &$/##'%'="#&"9+#;!&'"#5#'7#/.%""#6"7!/"%$%7!"#%'"+#'"#/5%#;+#36 '

" %& $'"#'6#6 "+!" '3< /"+7!#6%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6 $!'6%6!"#&+!5#2##'$!33#6/"+#'"#/5%#;!=!%'&""+#";7&"&4-2 %5%&%'!3 '=%'##/ %5%3 /#&#/5#6 -'6#/ "+# 7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6 $!"#=/<

00 '"+#/#73<%3#6'2#+!3"+#/#&7'6#'"0..%&&%'9%" +!&2##'&"!"#6"+!"8##7%'=%'5%#;"+#3!/=#'-.2#/!773%$!"%'& /#$#%5#6%'/#&7'&#""+#!65#/"%&#.#'"!6#$%&%';!&"!8#'"$'6-$"! &$/##'%'="#&"$'&%&"%'=";7!/"&%# !/" % !'6 !/" %% $!//<%'=)

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

/"#$"%' %=+"&!'6 -33 !/"%$%7!"%' $"9@ +#/#%'!"#/"2# /##//#6!&"+#@$" ;!&2/-=+"%'"/$#.!8%'=/#&#/5!"%'!" 3#!&"E7&"&%'!335"#&"!23%&+.#'"&""+##>"#'"E#!$+/"+# 7#/&'&&-#/%'=/. % 3%'6'#&&/3;5%&%' %% +#!/%'=%.7!%/.#'"

!'6 %%% F$."%5#6%&!2%3%"</$#/#2/!37!3&<+!7"#/1"+#@ $" 6#!3& ;%"+ "+# #.73<.#'"7#/&'& ;%"+ 6%&!2%3%"%#& #3#5!'"

&#$"%'&"+#&!%6+!7"#/!/#!&-'6#/(0 B

# $#% % &'!'

(

) % )* #) $ )%# % & '

%"(+

%C2

# 4

4+ *

567 8 9 0:;<-

#1 0*-

#4 +

,# % )*"

# $#% %C&#

# *

# +

, C -*

# * #4

#$ 7

, ,

# + D

4*#

4 #4 # *

4 / # *

, -"!"

++ .$

# (

!")) #)&") C6

# # #

# 4 #

4 # * +

# * *#

# *

#4 # #*#

#$ 7

, , #

* #4 #*

, +

A +# $" %& ! &$%!3 3#=%&3!"%' #'!$"#6 / "+# 2#'#%" #/&'&;%"+%&!2%3%"%#&G !&6#%'#6-'6#/"+#@$" !'6%"&

0C0 7/5%&%'& .-&" 2# %'"#/7/#"#6 %' /6#/ " -3%33 %"& 2*#$"%5#& +# 3!'=-!=#"+#&"!"-"/<7/5%&%';+%$+%&$3#!/!'6-'!.2%=--&/#3#$"& $3#!/3<"+#%'"#'"%'"+#3#=%&3!"-/#"/#&#/5#%'#5#/<#&"!23%&+.#'" -'6#/"+#77/7/%!"#5"'"3#&&"+!'E"+#5!$!'$%#&/"+# 7#/&'&/$3!&&7#/&'&;%"+6%&!2%3%"%#&;+%$+E#!$+&+!332# /#&#/5#6 / 7#/&'& &-#/%'= /. 23%'6'#&& / 3; 5%&%'9 +#!/%'= %.7!%/.#'" !'6 3$."%5# 6%&!2%3%"< / $#/#2/!3 7!3&< %' "+# 7&"& %6#'"%%#6/#!$+6%&!2%3%"</##/#'$#%'"+%&/#=!/6.!<2#.!6#""+# 6#$%&%'"+#'H23#4-7/#.#-/"%' #

# "

# '

) -% "

# "+ )"

+ "

# '

)%/ 01 2 / 03 '-/"+#/!'$#"+#.!'6!"#4#$"%'& !'6"+#@ $""+#5" -'*!29#7!/".#'"4$%!34#$-/%"<!'6#5#37.#'" .#'+%36/#'+!&%&&-#6%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @)

'"+#&-2*#$"D/#&#/5!"%'5!$!'$%#&%'6%/#$"/#$/-%".#'"/"+# 7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#67#/&'&%'"+#4"!"#G3!-&#&99@9C!'6)"+# %'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @);-362#/#3#5!'"""+#%&&-#!"+!'6!'6/#!6 !&33;&(0 B9

44 . # #

$ '

@ 9 (

# *# @ 8

/ E2E+

) *

0&=:

> ,

567 8 9 0:;<- "

-2 4

A *

48;"* * ,

, 4 *

, #

, , #

* # " #

# 2 #

# # + *

* ,

* 4

+ *

+A +#%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @) $3#!/3<&7#33 -""+!""+#/#%&!/#&#/5!"%'""+##>"#'"E5!$!'$%#&%'6%/#$" /#$/-%".#'"3!&&099!'61&#/5%$#/7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6 7#/&'& +#2/#!80-7"+#E/#&#/5!"%'%&E#!$+/$!'6%6!"#&9 ;+!/#&-#/%'=/.23%'6'#&&/3;5%&%'9+#!/%'=%.7!%/.#'"!'6 3$."%5#6%&!2%3%"</$#/#2/!37!3&< +#&#5#/<%'&"/-$"%'&/#3#$"! $'&$%-&6#$%&%'"+!""+#E/#&#/5!"%'+!&"2#%.73#.#'"#62<.#!'& !

7%'"/&"#/!'65!$!'$%#&!33%'=!" &"#/9 !'6)2# /#&#/5#6 D

! " # #$ % &'G

-/"+#/./#9/#&#/5!"%'.!6#/"+#$!"#=/%#&+!'6%$!77#67#/&'&%' "+#"+/##$!"#=/%#&%&%'"#/$+!'=#!23#'3<%"+#$!'6%6!"#2#3'=%'=" '#$!"#=/<%&'"!5!%3!23#/%"+#'!"-/#5!$!'$<%'!'%$#%&&-$+

0B0 "+!"!=%5#'$!"#=/<7#/&'$!''"2##.73<#6 +#%&&-!'$#"+#%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @)

!'6"+#$'"#'"&"+#/#!/#'"6%&7-"#62<"+#/#&7'6#'"' %#"+# #7!/".#'" -23%$ /8& /!'$+9 -'*!2 5#' "+# "+%/6 /#&7'6#'"%#"+##7!/".#'"4$%!3 4#$-/%"<!'6#5#37.#'" .#'!'6+%36/#' 4$%!34#$-/%"</!'$+ 94"!"# -'*!2!6.%"&" "+#&!.#";-362#!77&%"#""!8#'"#"+!"#5#'%'"+#!65#/"%&#.#'" 2#!/%'= ' ''#>-/# 0 "+# %'&"/-$"%'& 6!"#6 @) %'6 !

.#'"%'%'3!-&#B * 6#%'%'=$!"#=/%#&!'67!/"%$-3!/3<"+#7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<'"+#/;/6&9"+#%/&"/#&7'6#'"%#"+# -'*!2

-23%$4#/5%$#..%&&%';!&!;!/#"+#%&&-!'$#"+#%'&"/-$"%'& 6!"#6 @) +#/#;-362#'6%&7-"#"+!""+#%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @)

%&&-#62<"+#77/7/%!"#4"!"#5"!'6%'-/"+#/!'$# "+#.!'6!"#$'"!%'#6%'4#$"%'& !'6"+#@$";-36+36"+# %#36%' & !/!& /#$/-%".#'" !=!%'&" "+#"; 7&"& 4-2 %5%&%'!3 '=%'##/ %5%3 /#&#/5#6/7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<<!773<%'= "+#E/#&#/5!"%'#'5%&!=#6-'6#/"+#@$"!'6%'"#/.&"+# %.73#.#'"!"%'&-$+7#/$#'"!=#/#&#/5!"%'!=!%'&"!

7%'"/&"#/ !&7#/$3!-&#@"+#%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @) "+#%/&"

7&"-""+#";/#&#/5#67&"&4-2%5%&%'!3'=%'##/ %5%3 /"+# 7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<-=+""+!5#2##'.!6#!5!%3!23#"! $!'6%6!"#&-#/%'=/.23%'6'#&&/3;5%&%'%#5%&-!33<%.7!%/#6 +#!&&#/"%'"+#7#"%"%'#/"+!"+#;!&"+#&3#5%&-!33< %.7!%/#6$!'6%6!"#9;++!6!77#!/#6%'"+#&$/##'%'=7/$#&&+!&='# -'/#2-""#6 '2#+!3"+#..%&&%'!&"!'6+!&2##'"!8#'"+!""+#/#

00 ;!&'5!$!'$</#&#/5#6&7#$%%$!33</"+#23%'6/5%&-!33<%.7!%/#6 $!'6%6!"#& ' "+#/ ;/6& "+# ..%&&%' +!& 7/$##6#6 " +36 ! &$/##'%'="#&"7#/"!%'%'=""+#E/#&#/5!"%' 7/5%6#6/7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6 ;%"+-" 8##7%'= %' .%'6 "+# 2%-/$!"%' !.'=&" "+# E /#&#/5!"%' %# E #!$+ / 23%'6?3; 5%&%'9 +#!/%'= %.7!%/#6 !'6 3$."%5#6%&!2%3%"<?$#/#2/!37!3&< +#..%&&%'+!&7/$##6#62< $.73#"#3<6%&$!/6%'="+#6#$%&%'"!8#'2<"+#4"!"#5""+!"5!$!'$%#& !33%'=!" %'"&9 !'6)%'!

7%'"/&"#/;#/#/#&#/5#6/"+# "+/##$!"#=/%#&%#23%'6/3;5%&%'9+#!/%'=%.7!%/#6!'63$."%5# 6%&!2%3%"</$#/#2/!37!3&<%'"+#&!.#/6#/+#&"!'6"!8#''2#+!3 "+#..%&&%'"+!""+#/#;!&'5!$!'$<&7#$%%$!33</#&#/5#6/"+# 23%'6/5%&-!33<%.7!%/#6$!'6%6!"#9%&%33-'6#6+#!33!$<%'"+#&"!'6 "!8#''2#+!3"+#..%&&%'&"!'6&#>7&#6%'!&.-$+!&"+#/#;#/# '5!$!'$%#&/#&#/5#6&7#$%%$!33<#5#'/"+#/"+7!#6%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6 $!'6%6!"#&F%.%"%'=$'&%6#/!"%'/!77%'".#'"!=!%'&""+#7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<'"+#2!&%&.!/8&2"!%'#6%'"+#&$/##'%'="#&" !'6"+#/#2<$'%'%'=$'&%6#/!"%'"'3</"+7!#6%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6 $!'6%6!"#&9$!''"+36=64-$+9$-/&#!$"%'/-'&$-'"#/""+# 6#$%&%' "+# 4"!"# 5" $'"!%'#6 %' %'&"/-$"%'& 6!"#6 @)

'"+#/#73<%3#6'2#+!3"+#..%&&%'9%"+!&2##' &"!"#6"+!""+#%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @);#/#%&&-#62<"+#5"

-'*!2 #7!/".#'"4$%!34#$-/%"< !'6"+#2%-/$!"%'"+#5!$!'$%#& E/#!$+$!"#=/<7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!'6%6!"#&;!&"2# 6'#!""+#3#5#3"+#5"9;+%$+%&"+#/#A-%&%"%'%'=!'6!77%'"%'= !-"+/%"<4-$+&"!'$#"!8#'2<"+#7/#.%#//#$/-%".#'"!=#'$<"+#4"!"#

0 $!''3<2#"#/.#6!&-'/"-'!"#2%-/$!"%'"+#5!$!'$%#&E/ #!$+ $!"#=/< 7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6 7#/&'& !" "+# +!'6& "+# 4"!"#?77%'"%'=-"+/%"<;!&7&&%23#'3<%"+#..%&&%'+!6.!6# &7#$%%$/#$..#'6!"%'&/!77%'".#'"%'/#&7#$"#!$+$!"#=/< "+#$'"/!/<9"+#..%&&%'+!&3%.%"#6"+#7!/"%$%7!"%'$!'6%6!"#&!" "+#&"!=#'"#/5%#;/"+#7+<&%$!33<+!'6%$!77#6$!"#=/<'3<'"+# 2!&%& .!/8& 2"!%'#6 %' ! &$/##'%'= "#&" !'6 %' 6#/=!"%' " "+# %'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 ) +#..%&&%'+!&!-3"#6%'

"!8%'= "+# E /#&#/5!"%' / 7+<&%$!33< +!'6%$!77#6 7#/&'& !& '# $.7&%"#-'%"!'6"+#/#2<%''"+!5%'=.!6#/#$..#'6!"%'&&#7!/!"#3< ";!/6&E/#&#/5!"%'7/5%6#6/23%'6?3;5%&%'9+#!/%'=%.7!%/#6!'6 3$."%5#6%&!2%3%"<?$#/#2/!37!3&<#!$++#/#&7'6#'"' 6#7!/".#'"

+!&$.7-'6#6"+#.%&"!8#2<!$$#7"%'="+#/#$..#'6!"%'&.!6#2< "+#..%&&%'23%'63<+#/#+!&2##'!$.73#"#3!$8$/6%'!"%' 2#";##' "+# /#A-%&%"%'%'= 4"!"# 5" 6#7!/".#'" !'6 "+# 4"!"#

#$/-%".#'"=#'$< &+/"/#73<2<;!<!%6!5%""+#+%#'=%'##/9 -'*!2

/!'$+'2#+!3&#$'6/#&7'6#'"+!&2##'73!$#6' /#$/6/!"+#/&"/!'=#&"!'6+!&2##'"!8#'!'6""+#33;%'=##$"(0 D +

# #

, , *

!)&*

#*# 77!5A

#&7'6#'"' 6#7!/".#'"+!&"+-&5%/"-!33<;!&+#6%"&+!'6 "+#.!""#/ +%&-/";-36+!5#'+#&%"!"%'%'+36%'="+!""+# 7/#&#'"$!&#/#3#$"&!$.73#"#3!$8;%33'"+#7!/""+#/#&7'6#'"

00 !-"+/%"%#&%'$!//<%'=/"+"+#.!'6!"#"+#@$"5#'"+#6#$%&%' "+#4"!"#5"$'"!%'#6%'%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @)

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

;-362#!=!%'&"!5!$!'$<"+!".!<+!5#!/%&#'&-2&#A-#'"""+#%&&-!'$# "+#!65#/"%&#.#'"!"''#>-/# 0/2<$/#!"%'=!&-7#/'-.#/!/<7&" '"+##5#'"-!3%"<"+#7#"%"%'#/2#%'=-'6&-%"!23#/2#%'=!77%'"#6 ""+#7&"9&-$+!77%'".#'";-362#";!/6&$'&-.%'=!/&"#/7%'" %6#'"%%#62<"+#4"!"#5"!=!%'&""+#5%&-!33<%.7!%/#6$!"#=/<!&7#/ 6#$%&%'$'"!%'#6%'%'&"/-$"%'&6!"#6 @) 4-$+#>#/$%&#2#$.73#"#6;%"+%'!7#/%6";.'"+&/. "+#6!"#/#$#%7"!$#/"%%#6$7<"+%&/6#/

#"%"%'%&!33;#6%'"+#!/#&!%6"#/.& ( ) *+**,-*.

3-$8< +#"+#/&7#!8%'=?/#!&'#6( #&? +#"+#/ #7/"!23#( #&?