M/S Malhotra Land Developers And Colonisers Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!" "#$%$&' () *
!"# $ %&'($ $ )
$
!"# $ %&'($
('# '
* + ,-
. + /#-
. 0
-
)- +,) 0 1
.223 (
1 0- . + . 4
56652652
8 92:; 4 1
8
1 . ,
. 1 ' 1 , , .
8 ,(
.0266<( ,
1 . 5=55266>
. +. 0 $1+ 11 0 ', , . +.
( 6:6>2663+ +. . . . .
. +81 1
1
0 , . - 5::> 7
? . @;
5:6=2663 , 1 +, 0 + )
1
626A2663 .
/ ,. ,
- +. 22552663 .
. . ,
, &+, . - 0 + 6=522663
+/ 8
1 . ,
. .11 . 25522663' $. +
0 + ,
6=63266= + 0 -
536A266=- 0. .
256A266=
..
, - - 4 .1 536A266=+ +, 0
5=6A266=- . + 0 ,8
1 . ,
. .
, ..
0
536A266=- 1++ + 2B6A266= 1 ,
1 . + .
, 1 . .. .
!
1 !
(
1 . 5=6A265=+ 0 $ , . , . .+ -
1
2:6A266=+ / ,1 . ,$. + -, +. 1 '
- + + 1 1
. 4 0 2>C
1
' . 81
. BB72; . + 9 2>C1 6A6=266A .
1 1
. , , 1 536A266=-
. << .
0-+.
1 $.
81
. , 536A266=. ' + + . '+
- / . , ,$
.
, 81 536A266=
0 1/ , - 1
1 - 0-
, ( 1 1
0 '+
-
.
0 )
+ ..04 $401 .
0
. << . + . , 0 0 . ,
56652652
+
0
. << . ++ ,
1
1 . 1 . 5=6A266=
.1 . + - .
0+0D95:<262652-+.+ + .
. ..
0 . 0, ,1 0 ,+ 1 ' . , . .
0
2A65265<- 1+ . ' D!2=<2<265<
.0. . . - 81 +, 1 $
. 0 / ,
, &
0+ 0+ + , 1 ' . .
1
5:55265> 1
1 ./+ . . 81 , . . 01 % $ 1
. /
, 0 , ' 6362265>- . . + . $. + . 1 . . 0 1 / 0 ( . 0 0 " . + 0 6=522663
6=63266=-1. . 4 .
1, , 0 ,
0 - )
+
+ 0 . . . +1 . % $ 1
. + 0 0
.. . - 1,
636=2653
/ + 0 ..
0 .1
" # .
8 ,.
+ , , 0. , .
1 % $ 1 ( ./,
+ 0 .
. .
. 0 + - $. - , 536A266=- 0 . .
256A266=- 04 . + , . ( , . 5=6A266= +
,0 $
.
. .
, + .1 0+ , # - . 1 + 0 0 0 0
. -+.
- 1 . , - + ..
0 0 1 + . , 1 ..
.+ +(
, + ./ , 01
566C1 1
266=
+
1
+ - , - 2>C 1 # - .0 ,
.
1 , 0 ,. + % $ 1 , +..0./ + , 0 )
+ . + . +. $ , 1
+ + 4
+1 0 , 1 ,
% $ 1 - + , , 0
" . 0 1,
( 8 .
. 1 0 + .00 . .
0 .
. .1, + 0 .. . 0
.
.1
0 1
, -
1
.
. 5=6A266= + .. + ,
1
$.
.
. . 4 . + - 1 , ,1 + . .. .
1 99 . % $ 1 . .
0 0
. D
. 1 , '. ,0
+ 81 .
8 95 (
.0266<
+. 1 , , . , . +. .
8 92( . 0 / ,. 81
1 .0 ' $1+ 11 1 , +
. , . . ,
. 5<, . - 1 , E
. 1 1 , $1+ 11 8 . + 9
0
! " # $
"
! % # & ' "%" ()
* +, -
. # / %"
0 % ,
/ % % , / 1 # %"
2"*33 2"
*44"43
"
..
! % # & ' "%" ()
* +, - . # / %"
5
% / "
%
% / 1 # %"
2"33 "
2"
4"43
6
6:6>2663 ( + . . 6:6<2663
+ . ( ' .
8 9B
01 06:6>2663 $1+ 11
1 - . . . ,
(
.0266<
. , . . -1+. 8 .
,2 / 774"8 5 5 $ "
9 52
/ 774: 5
1 " ,"
,"
%5 ; , 5 / 774". 5! ! % '/, ,
,+, &# 5'/77<, ,"8 , ,5 5 35"
"
5 / 774 5 5 -# , -# 5 , ,= 5 5 >"6
6=63266=- 0 +,
+8 . , +
. BB72; . -, 81 1 . 8. . <2 -. +.
8 . + 9 ?
2 ( @@ * , 5 / 774 , ? "@ 774 , ,0 , 2 8 !:"
! % # & "%"
* , 5/ 774
, ? "@ 774 2 *,
$
' , !5 - &) 0 . >-. @ *33<"
* ' ,?A: ? 8 5 5 ."6 '
536A266=
256A266= + 0 ' 1 1.
+
536A266=
1 . +1 256A266=
. 1 1
. 5=6A266=+ - +
1
. 536A266= +
, . '1,
2B6A266=1/ , , . 2 ,
,, 81
. BB . , . + 1 " -+
081
. 1 . + , + 1.
0 .
9 *" 2 @@ / 774 !:"! %# &
%"% , 8 B, !" ! 52 / ,, :
5 , $
' , !5 - &) 0 . >-. @ *33<"
* ' ,?A: ? 8 5 5 ."6 '+
B
256A266= 0+ +
9 @" ? "C:DC:*33< 4*:<DDD DC# -# *"3C"*33D,5 "6 ' 1 0 , . 1 +. . 4 .+
.
+ , . ,, .. , 1
.. $
,
. - + .. 1
+ ++ 0 ,
1 -
0 +
0 0
0 - +.
1 . , -. 0 0 .+ , , 0 1 , .+ 8 ( + 1
. 0+ + . + , 0 +. + 9 D"
5E ? "*D * *3 , 8 B, 8 *C"3"*3 ( 58 +,# "8 B,8 7""*34 (0 = 5 !:F - %"A 8 B,8 $ . , 5, 25 ,5 (0 , 5 !:"
F - %" ,5 " . , = 0%#
5 "6 C"
. 8 B, 8 ( 5 8 +, # 5 C"3 "*3<" 5>5 2 :@@ / 774, 5 ,
!:"F
- %"
, ," > 2 :@@ / 774 7"3D"*33D 2 *"3C"*33D *@"3C"*33D". ? " ? ? "D:D:3 48*:<7 37"37"*33D , 2 " -2 5 *"3C"*33D 5 D"3C"*33D"? 5 D"3C"*33D 2 *"3C"*33D
, ,
: 5D"3C"*33D" 5 2 7"37"*33D"
>*<"3<"*33C 5 2 : @@ * / 774 3C"3D"*33C 57"37"*33D"
. , ,, 2 :@@ * / 774 5 2
*@"3C"*33D" ,
2 2 :@@ * / 774 3C"D"*33C 7"37"*33D " 5
!:"F- %" > !:" ! % # & %",5
- "6 $401 + . <<
. -+. 1,0
0 0 )
1
. <B. BB72;-<<
<B . . +
!
222222
* .(0 5
2 2 5 2,5 5 5 , 5 "6
""
# $ "
( 0 5,5 A 0G 5 5 5 5"
( 0 5 5 5 , = 5H
* 5 ,55 5 5 55 5 5 , ,"
5 5
. 5 , 5 5 5 5 ,,5( 0 @"
@ . 5 73C
I 73C "
"
"
(0 55,55 25 5 5
2 5 ,5 5 5 5, 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 $ 5 , 5 $ , , , "6
. 0 . . 8 . +
. BB72; .
. . . 0 , ,
/ , . ./ ./ + , . . 1 0 # - 1
+ . , 0
. -+.
- . , . 0 .. + +, , 0
. 1 + 0 0 +- + 1+ 01
08 . , + 0 ' 1
. . 0+
+ 0 , + , # -+ . . 0 , 0 0 1 .% $ 1 -+. 1 . .1 . + 1 , + . + .
1
'+ . 01 . + , D!2=<2<265< ..0 . )
1 ? . 1 0.1 + % $ 7;
. 1 0 ,
@' 1,
+ . .
0. 8 . 0+ )
. . , 0 .1 01- .11 ,,
0 1 % $ 1
.
0 . 1 . .
0 .. +
+ . , . 1 % $ 1 - . / , .11
1 E
.
% $ 1
?A
,50 , 8 & +, # **""*33< 5 ,55 3D"*"*33<" *4J -# /"4*"43 /"
"
< +#) /"
"4
,5 "3"*33DD4J -# /"@4C"43 3<"3D"*33D" 5:
" 2 , ,2 :@@ / 774 ,58 B,! 5 <"3C"*33D, 5 -# D"3C"*33D"' 5 !:"F- %" 5 , 5 !:"F- ",
52 :@@ / 774 " ' = "1 , 5 ,
!:"F- %"6
0 ' . .
. . 0+ .1 . .
, 0 566C $
. .
0
, 0 1' + . + 0 . 4 .8. ..0
,.1 .'
. 5=6A266=+ 0 .
.
+ , 536A266= D. .
+ + '1,
1
4
9 . ,
. 0. . 0 01
1 ,
+ , 1
536A266= + 7 $ )
$ ;
%&)$ 22>265:7
('# '
;
%&)$