High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3944/2025dismissed

Baljit Singh v. Gurmit Singh

2025-08-12Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl17 pages

!"# $ %& ' )( *

+*(, $ %&

( + &*(."/ 01

* ( 0(" 4

,-*%

6*( '

9*%

9* ( 1 / & %(& ,-*%

6*( '

$* :4

;( *

*7,

" , *( < ,("

7( <& : = ,-(

<& ( : %( ,*,<

* )""% & >7 : / $*7 3& "

?"</ ( 0,7" 1 (% (

*(&(

*7, +*(, $ %&

( -

* %

/ 1"

$* :4

, "( *

(

*7,

(**" &* (1

*(&( (%* 1

4 6*

1*( +*(, $ %&

(**" *,

1( 6*

*7, .&

(% .

-(-(8/

-(1 &

-(-(8 ""%""8 -"8 (*

;( *

(" *-

> A7" $*-(,

(-(

(* 1

1(8&

( 3(7*

-.("

(""

*( (* ( (-(

*7,

(*, --"

("" ((=#*%,

$* :4

,((*

,-*% 1

--"

""%"/ (1

$* :4 (1

&( "( *

-(* --( 7<

,("

* *( "

"8 "8 -(

&* (1

,-*%

,-*% (

( .& ".

(1 7 *-&" (

&( (

.*" 7 ("1

-(( " (1

* ( 0(" 4

&"" %

6*( '

B6*

.""

6*( '

--"

44 / "".

"#$"

% %$$

This is an application under Section 151 CPC for revival of the revision petition which was disposed of vide order dated 14.05.2025.

For the reasons stated in the application which is supported by an affidavit, the application is allowed and the order dated 14.05.2025 is recalled and the main petition is ordered to be restored to its original number. $ %""$

This is a Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India for setting aside the impugned order dated 23.04.2025 (Annexure P+1) passed by the Executing Court and the impugned order dated 07.05.2025 (Annexure P+2) passed in the appeal.

Learned counsel for the petitioner, after arguing for some time and after seeing that this Court is not inclined to interfere in the matter, seeks permission of this Court to withdraw the present revision petition.

In view of the statement made by learned counsel for the petitioner, the present petition is dismissed as withdrawn. July 07, 2025"

@ $1("

71 (1

( ("1

( &1

6 .& (1

-*(- / &

"". "Present:

Mr.D.D.Bansal, Advocate for Mr.G.C.Dhuriwala, Advocate for the petitioner. *** The petitioner had earlier filed CR+2911+2025 in which on 07.07.2025, the following order was passed:+ &#$"

% %$$

1. This is an application under Section 151 CPC for revival of the revision petition which was disposed of vide order dated 14.05.2025.

2. For the reasons stated in the application which is supported by an affidavit, the application is allowed and the order dated 14.05.2025 is recalled and the main petition is ordered to be restored to its original number. $ %""$

1. This is a Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India for setting aside the impugned order dated 23.04.2025 (Annexure P+1) passed by the Executing Court and the impugned order dated 07.05.2025 (Annexure P2) passed in the appeal.

2. Learned counsel for the petitioner, after arguing for some time and after seeing that this Court is not inclined to interfere in the matter, seeks permission of this Court to withdraw the present revision petition.

3. In view of the statement made by learned counsel for the petitioner, the present petition is dismissed as withdrawn." '()( *+ $

%""$

' ( ,

-*( *

((/ " /

& &

% &(*%& 7& "

" &( 7".

.*"

* (/

(*,

7 !"#$%% &&'()*' +,-.'+!/0

!% !#!+ % (

6* !"# $ %&

(

1*( +*(, $ %&

( - .& ( - " , *( < ,("

, 7*" *- &* &(

-(*

.*"

(

//= /=

%(,

( 7" ,* /=

(1 7( $*7 % ((

-( 1(,

< ."% (- "

(

7 .

01 . &( .

- C*(8 ( &

*(/ "( *

("8

*7,

(% (

!$#%%%! &&'()*' !,-.'1/0

%11 !#!+ 9*%,

* "(

( - +*(, $ %& %

(" %(

(-(* &( 7".

"8.

Suit of the plaintiff stands decreed against the defendant that the plaintiff is owner in possession of the land measuring 1 kanal 2 marlas under Red line bearing khasra No.53 Khewat No.951, Khatauni No.2 alongwith two rooms and semi constructed house on the said land. Parties are left to bear their own costs. Separate decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File

be consigned to the record room.

Announced:

Sd/+ Sub Judge 2nd Class 28.9.1992 Chandigarh."

-(* 71 .*"

((

-(%(-&

( --( &(*%& &

7(*%&

%% (

% -.( ( 8

1*( 01 .& --(

+#2%% &&'()*' +,-.'21/0

%11 !#!+ % (

6* +*(, $ %&

1*( $& # $ %& .& ( - " , *( < 4 ,("

* "

" , *( <

,("

,-(

<& (

1 +#2%%2 &&'()*' ",-.'2/0

!% !#!+ $* -

$& # $ %& .& ( -1 71

" , *( < 4 ,("

.""

+*(, $ %& 1 #$!## &&'()*' ",-.'2/0

!% !#!+

( . , &

%( &( "* (/ %1 -

-" &( $& # $ %& (%(

* "

$& # .&

1*(

, -(8

-(-(8 (%(

%( $& # $ %&

(-(* &( 7".

"Civil Suit No.160 of 15.6.1996 Decided on 31.8.2001 Sohanjit Singh s/o Sh. Gurcharan Singh, resident of House No.1915, Phase V, Mohali, Tehsil Kharar, District Ropar (Punjab).

....Plaintiff

Versus

- )./ (/

1 ""$2 2.

Gurmit Singh s/o Sandhu Singh, resident of Village Dhanas, UT, Chandigarh.

...Defendants Suit for possession on the basis of title under Article 65 of Limitation Act "Bara" land measuring 0+17 Marlas, bearing in Khasra No.53(1+2), Khewat No.9, Khatauni No.9, Н.В. No.15, situated at under Red Line at Village Dhanas, UT, Chandigarh on the basis of sale deed dated 15.6.1993 against the defendant No.1.

AND In alternative suit for the recovery of Rs. 1,36,000/+ with interest @ 12% per annum from 15.6.1993 till filing this suit against the defendant No.2.

-( %

6-(

, -(*

.*"

$& # $ %&

", -

(% (

@ 1 #"!#1 0--"

* (

(( *" '

6-(

1 #"#"!#$ &&'()*' !,-.'$+/0

!% !#!+

--"

* (

(( *" '

1 " ("

) 1#!!#!+ &&'()*' !-.'"%/0

%11 !#!+ 0--"

0 ( 9*%/ & %(&

%(* ",

&* 44 1 --"

* (

(( *" '

*-&" --"

--( (, 7( ( ,-*%

6 %#!##" &&'()*' #-.'"1/0

!% !#!+

* "(

@ 6* +*(, $ %&

1*( $& # $ %&

.""

4 6* !"# $ %&

(

1*( +*(, $ %&

.""

.( ""%"/

*""

-" (* &

(-(*

,-*% ((/

(-(* &( 7".

" ( ) to the effect that the ) " 3"%% registered on 15.06.1993 bearing Register No. 518, Book No. 1 Volume No. 89, Page No. 42 executed by defendant no. 1 in favour of defendant no. 2 and )

4 !"%%" registered on 27.08.1991 bearing Register No.1053, Book No. 1 Volume No. 83 ))*'

*) (( ( +

(( " and the correspondents entries in the + and

%"%% by the Hon'ble Court of Shri Gulab Singh, Sub Judge, 1st Class, Chandigarh in Civil Suit No. 247 dated 28.09.1992 titled as

Gurmit Singh V/s. Baljit Singh as unlawful, null and void being collusive and illegal, void, ab+initio,

) 5

)( (

5 () (( ) *)* . And further for permanent injunction for restraining the defendants from alienating the said property by way of sale, mortgage, gift or transfer in any manner whatsoever to anybody else on the basis of ownership.""

D*(&( -(* ("1 -(

-" /

(-(*

-( ,-*% ((/ .*"

& "( 7*

*/ -"

(

1( 6*

8( *(&(

8( 6* +*(, $ %&

1*( $& # $ %&

*(&( -(* ,-*% ((/

--(

*/ 7& +*(, $ %& $& # $ %& --( &8

-( .(

6 !#+!#! &&'()*' ,-.'$!/0

!% !#!+

*" :&

(""

" ".

(% (

"8 7

" 1"

* 1"

8( 4

( ( ""

6 !"#!#" &&'()*' %,-.'"/0

!% !#!+ 7#

/ .(

-(* 71 .*"

(**"

.8 ,-(

B6* &.1(

6 ##+!#% &&'()*' 1,-.'#/0

!% !#!+ "

9*%

9(1/ & %(& 1 --"

("" 4 = "". 7" 7(< -

"< (,

-*/

.& "". 7 (1

"...So, at this stage by no stretch of imagination, it can be assumed that the decree under execution was obtained by the DH by playing fraud upon the JD no. 1 or that the same was obtained by him in collusion with JD no. 2 Gurmit Singh. Hence, in view of the above discussion no ground is made out to recall the orders dated 20.07.2018/8.8.2018. Therefore, the present application dated 27.08.2018, filed by applicant+ defendant no. 1 under Section 151 CPC for recalling the orders dated 20.07.2018/8.8.2018 is hereby dismissed. 8.

Having said so, it is needless to say that any observations made hereby above would have no effect on the final outcome of the present case.

Pronounced in Open Court 10.05.2019 Sd/+Meenakshi Gupta, PCS Civil Judge (Junior Division), Chandigarh. UID No. PB0369"

6 !#1!#!+ &&'()*' ,-.'!2/0

!% !#!+ 0--"

8 6*

.& ( -

071 "

.( <

(

61 #"#+!#!+ &&'()*' !,-.'!/0

!% !#!+ 0--"

61 #"#"!#!+ /

&"" %

%(*

.( & (*/

.&(.

(-(*

("( -( &

(-(* &( 7".

"Civil Revision Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India for setting aside the impugned order dt. 23.4.2025 (Annexure P+1) passed by the Executing Court and the Impugned order dated 07.05.2025 (Annexure P+2) passed in appeal, which are hit by act of fraud and also the decrees obtained by Gurmit Singh has expired after 12 years of its date of grant i.e. 28.9.1992, in the interest of justice. It is further prayed that during the pendency of this revision petition, the operation of Impugned Order dt. 23.4.2025 (P+1) may kindly be stayed, in the interest of justice. of justice." &.1(

- &( *(&( ,1

--"

( ,( &

("" ("

--"

&"" % 7( &

-(* .*"

-""8 7 (1 1"

.( 6*

4 @

$* 7( :4

8( " D(

-*(- / ("

-" *-

8( 4/ ("1 -(

(-(*

,-*% ((/

-( .&&/

7 (1

& "( 7*

/ "

- &"" %

.""

7 (1 --"

(

1("

< ."% &* --"

("" %=(1.

7(( ",

-*(- / ((

, $

0 -(1

, (1.

*(/ (, / /

71/

7 (1

" --"

( &(

"8 6*

1*( $& # $ %& "

.""

( .(

-""8 ,

*(&( 7 (1

(* ( (-(

&* --"

(""

"("8

--"

(""

7& 7(( ",

,("

% (

4 6*

1*( +*(, $ %&/ (

* -(-(8

" 1"*7"

(

.""

*7 C*

@ 6* +*(, $ %&

1*( $& # $ %& &1

* &"" %

,"8

( ( ""

" ".

( "( (% (

7 ""%"/

*""

(8 &1 "(

, (, 1"

3&(

*& (="(

1*( 0 ""8/

* +*(, $ %& %

(

-(*

6*( ' .*"

-""8 ((

* .&

* & --( &(*%& &

* (

%% 0# '"

$ %&

$& # $ %& .& -*(& (, +*(, $ %&

* +*(, $ %&

( 1

6*( '4 -% @ E "&*%&

6 -( 7* --"

* (

(( *" '

--"

&((,

3&* 1

$& # $ %& .&

*7 C* (% (

1*(

*7 C*

1*(

, -(8

(

.& ( - &1

&* --(

&- (%&

" .& ( - " , *( < ,("

&* ",

,("

*& .(

* ( 7(% -(( " --"

(""

--"

( ,( &

7(( ",

,("

(%&"8

1 (1(/

--"

%(* / 1"

* ( 0(" 4

> A7" $*-(,

$*-( (" *-

"( *

*(&(

,-""8 (

7( > A7" $*-(, *(/

*( ,- --"

* ( $

/ ' ,,"8 ( 3(7*

.( (""

%(*

(%( #*(

* ",

, 7* ",

-"8 (* .& 3(7*

/ . ",

.( ",

.( ,-

#*(

*( &,

&--

(1""

,(8" .&

( ( (1

9 '(< & ""* .&

,(8"

( (

*( &* .

-( .(

1*(

. ",

0( 7* , & -(

*( ,- %1 -8 (-( -(-(

$*7

-( '" /

(1 #*(

,-""8 ( (*,

,-""8 ( -"/ .&" &8 .( -( &( .

((/ ""

C*(

*( ,- "

(

, ",

-( /

-" .&

(((""8

"-- - 5,,"8

"( 7*

*( ,- --"

("" .(

%(* (*/

""8

%(* &(

-.( (1.

.& 3(7*

7 (1 > A7" $*-(,

*( ,- , < .

7* (*

*7 C* "8 .&

,(%

-*(- .*" 7

(1 "

--"/

--"/ "8

"(8

(,*" .*" 7

(

*(&( 7 (1 >%& .&"

%( "7(8

*( ,- 1"

"%"

(,8

1"7" &, 7*

(,8

7 (1 , 8

- .& ( - "

", ",

-*7" , 8 &(

*( ,- --(& (7*

(7*

.( ("(

< ."%/ 7* , * (*

*(&(

*( ,-

% .&

.( 7

*( ,-

< ."% 7* (*

-"8 ",

"8 (

&. &%& %( (*

(*, > A7" $*-(, "". --"

,-*%

(7* ( ,(

7 ( & 3(7* ( ( ( 7" --(*

--"" &(

*( ,-

""%

71 7( > A7" $*-(,

&( &(

* (% (

(

&( 7 1"

-(, 7" &

,(%

-(8

.""

(% (

*7 "

&%&"%&

7&"

(* > F7" $*-(,

& ) 6 7 )8 (-(

%/ 7 (1 >%&

/ (- &/

-.(

*-( * ( 0(" 4

* (( .&

(7*

( *(

(( :(

6( &

-.(/

*( --"

*( ( (7*

*7(

7 (1

*(8 , , .& ( - $

'(*(

* .

,7 >%& *(A

-.( * ( 0(" 4 7*

, ,/ ,* 7 (,,7(

*(8 , ,

(( - %"8 6- >%& *(A

#*(

*-( * ( 0(" 4 -.( (( * ( &

0("

7 <- ,*,

*( .&"

, &" *

#* (,

-*( * -""*

-*7"

* (7*

*7( >%&

7 (1 -.( * ( 0(" 4 ,8 7 * ( 7*

*7# &%& %( #*"

-" ?-

(*, &

,-*% ,-*%

(( &

.&" 6(

-.(

* ( 0(" 4

( %"8/ ,-*%

( *-&" (1

7 ,("

0""

- "" *

--"

&""

71 !#$!#!+

Pawan 34'54'*6,'-78&.9*'-6/&': '69/ 34'54'**',/*5-;<' '69/