High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15964/2018disposed of

Hometrail Buildtech Pvt.Ltd,Bathinda v. The State Of Punjab And Another

2018-08-27The Taxing Officer,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma6 pages

%&' '()*)+,-

.'&/%)01)02&'(34&5&2 '&)&)+'/ 6'/*1* 3'7&%&' 1+8%9%+2%+&3'/ '*:+2'+&*

/'*'+&, #/*3;<1.%/==%/>%0?7'+)/24(%&'>)&3 #/1+''&=/%>%0?24(%&'%+2 #*1/4)7)+3%?24(%&'

/&3':'&)&)+'/ #/%+;%8 1:&%?220 ?1+8%9

3':'&)&)+'/3%* )0'2&3':/'*'+&:'&)&)+).:1=+)+=&3'

%**'**.'+&/2'/%+22'.%+2+&)('2%&'2 @++'A1/' !(00B$C>3'/'9B&3'%**'**)+=%1&3/)&B3%*0'4)'2&%A+&3'3'%0&3(%/' *'/4)('*:/4)2'29B&3':'&)&)+'/&)+2/:%&)'+&*)+&3'3*:)&%0 +*1::/& &3'%/=1.'+&*?/'0)%+('3%*9''+:0%('21:+% )4)*)+'+(3812=.'+& 1/&)+

&)&0'2%*D

D)+>3)(3)2'+&)(%0)**1'3%*9''+2'()2'2%+2&3)* 1/&3%* :)+'2&3%&&3'.'2)()+'*)+&3'3'%0&3(%/'*'/4)('*:/4)2'2&&3' )+2/:%&)'+&*)*+&&%A%90'%*&3'%.1+&(3%/='2(%++&9'9) 1/(%&'2 &(1001&%.1+& *%0' .'2)()+'*?'4'+) &3'%.1+&)**':%/%&'0B (3%/='2 /:3%/.%(B?0%9/%&/B*'/4)('*?).:0%+&**'/4)('*:/4)2'29B &3'2(&/*%*)&)*%(.:*)&'.'2)(%0*'/4)(':/4)2'2

+&3'&3'/3%+2?0'%/+'2(1+*'0 /&3'7&%&'>3)0'+& 2)*:1&)+=&3'812=.'+&/'

'//'2&&3)* 1/&)+ #$% &'*19.)&&'2&3%&&3'7&%&'3%*:/' '//'27:'()%05'%4'

'&)&)+%=%)+*&&3'% /'*%)29'

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

3%/;3%+2 1/&:%**'2)+D, & , -(

D? !$ -!3/$?%=%)+*&>3)(37:'()%05'%4''&)&)+ >%*2)*.)**'2'0'4%+&:%/%* /.812=.'+& 1/&)+ #$% &'%/''A&/%(&'29'0>./ F' 3%4' (+*)2'/'2 &3' /'0'4%+& *&%&1&/B :/4)*)+* &3'1+8%9%+2 %/B%+%7&%&1&'*?&3'

)3%/ )+%+(' (&? &3' &&%/ /%2'*3 (&? &3' 812=.'+& &3' 3%/;3%+2 %+2 00%3%9%2 )=3

1/&*?812=.'+&* &3'<'/%0% 1/&!()&'29B &3'/'*:+2'+&*$%/')+/'*:'(& 10%=/''.'+&>)&3&3'

:)+)+/'(/2'29B&3'3%/;3%+2 1/&%+2&3'

00%3%9%2 1/&%+2 )+2+/'%*+&/'(/2% (+&/%/B :)+)+ / & 302 &3%& &3' *1::0B

.'2)()+'*? 2/1=*? *&'+&*? ).:0%+&* '&( & % :%&)'+& 21/)+=%.'2)(%0:/('21/')+3'/*%+B'0'.'+& *%0'?

.1(3 0'** *'&* 1& &3')+=/'2)'+&* % D*%0'D 3'

:>'/&).:*'*%0'*&%AG6 0>* /. +&/B 5)*& 7(3'2)0'6%+2/&)(0'

! $

+*&)&1&)+? &3' 0%&&'/ %**)=+)+= &3' *&%&1* % 2''.'2*%0'&&/%+*%(&)+*>3'/'+'/&3'&3'/ '0'.'+& *%0')*.)**)+=?91&>3'/'&3''0'.'+&

*%0')*%0&='&3'/.)**)+=%+2&3'&/%+*%(&)+2'*+&

%00>)&3)+%+B &3'(0%1*'* /&)(0'

! $

&3' +*&)&1&)+ +2)%? % 7&%&' *3%00 +& 9'

'.:>'/'2 & 0'4B 4%01' %22'2 &%A + *1(3 % &/%+*%(&)+ / &3' :1/:*' %&&/%(&)+= 6 ? % &/%+*%(&)+/%:%/&&3'/' ?>3)(3)*'**'+&)%00B% *'/4)('>102 3%4'&E1%0) B%*%*%0'>)&3)+&3'

.'%+)+= 7%0'* 2*(&? /&3'2'

)+)&)+ *%0' 3' )(&)+ %2''.'2*%0'%::0)'*+0B& *1(3*)&1%&)+*%*>102 %00>)&3)+&3'*19(0%1*'*

/&)(0'

! $ &3' +*&)&1&)+ +2)%>3)(3 :'/.)&*'4'/%+(' &3'*'/4)(''0'.'+& /.&3'*%0'

'0'.'+&%+2'.:>'/*&3'7&%&'&&%A&3''0'.'+&

*%0' :'/1*%0 /&)(0'

! $ &3'

+*&)&1&)+ +2)%2'*+&'+%90'1*&/'(/2%+ :)+)+&3%&)&(4'/**'/4)('*:/4)2'29B3*:)&%0* '

/'*1(3%&/%+*%(&)+)*:1&&&%A?>3'&3'/1+2'/ &3' %/B%+%/1+8%96 (&?)&>1023%4'& *%&)* B&3'2.)+%+&+%&1/'&'*&9B/'

'/'+('&&3'

*19*&%+(' &3' (+&/%(& (+&/%(& / .'2)(%0 &/'%&.'+& +'('**%/)0B)+404'*.'2)()+'*?*1::0B

*1/=)(%0)&'.*?*&'+&*?).:0%+&*?4%04'*?>)&31&>3)(3

%.'2)(%0:/('21/'/.'2)(%0&/'%&.'+&(%++&9' (.:0'&'2 3'*1::0B &3'*'%/&)(0'*%*3'029B&3'

00%3%9%2%+2&3'3%/;3%+2 1/&*%/')+&'=/%0 &%+2'**'+&)%0 /&3'&/'%&.'+&

'/'2&:%&)'+&* %+2'4'+) +'.%B(%&'=/)H'&3'*'%*)+()2'+&%0& &3'%(&1%0.'2)(%0:/('21/'?+'(%++&91&)=+/' &3%&%.'2)(%0:/('21/'(%++&9'(.:0'&'2>)&31& *1::0B .'2)()+'*?2/1=*?*&'+&*?).:0%+&*?&3'/'9B 0'%2)+=&%*)+=10%/(+(01*)+&3%&&3'7&%&')*+& '.:>'/'21+2'/%+B:/4)*)+ &3' +*&)&1&)+ .1(30'**&3'2'

)+)&)+ =2*?*%0'/2'%0'/?& *'4'/'&3'(+&/%(&%+2(+*&/1'&3'*1::0B 2/1=*?

.'2)()+'*?*&'+&*?).:0%+&*'&(%*%*'4'/%90':%/&

&3'(+&/%(&%+2?&3'/'

/'?'A)=)90'&6 ?%*%*%0' 3'*)&1%&)+>10294)1*0B9'2)

'/'+&) &3'*'

%/&)(0'*%/'*1::0)'2 /.&3':3%/.%(B %3*:)&%0 2''.)+= )(&)+?.1*& 9' /%&)+%0 %+2 +&

%/()(%0 3' 2.)+%+& :1/:*' % 3*:)&%0 )* & :/4)2' .'2)(%0 &/'%&.'+& %+2 ) 21/)+= %.'2)(%0 :/('21/')&)*/'E1)/'2&:/4)2'.'2)()+'*?*&'+&*? ).:0%+&*'&(?)&(%++&9B%2''.)+= )(&)+9'3'02& 9'%F*%0'I:%&)'+&.%B3%4'%(3)('%*&&3' E1%0)&B ).:0%+&G*&'+& 91& '4'+ &3%& (3)(' )* (+ )+'2&&3'*1)&%9)0)&B %*&'+&'&( 3' %(&&3%&% 3*:)&%0.%B(3%/='.+'B /)+2)4)21%0*&'+&*'&(?

>3'&3'/%*:%/& %:%(;%='/*':%/%&'0B)*'+&)/'0B )//'0'4%+&(+&/%(& .'2)(%0*'/4)('(%++&9'

*%)2&9'%(+&/%(& /*%0' %*&'+&?/4%04'/

.'2)()+'*&9'1*'2)+%.'2)(%0G*1/=)(%0:/('21/' 3' '**'+&)%0 '0'.'+& *1(3 % (+&/%(& )* &3'

:/('21/' ;+'' /':0%('.'+&? 3): /':0%('.'+&?

%+=):0%*&B?>3)(3%*%+)+&/)+*)(%+2)+&'=/%0:%/& )+404'*:0%()+=%+).:0%+&>3'&3'/)+&3';+''?3):

/%3'%/&'&( 3'+0B(3)('%4%)0%90'&&3':%&)'+& )*&3'+%&1/' &3').:0%+&?+%.'0B?)&*E1%0)&B91& *1(3%:/('21/')*%2.)&&'20B?%.'2)(%0:/('21/' %+2%*'/4)('&3%&(%++&9'(.:0'&'2>)&31&%+ ).:0%+&G2/1=*%+2.'2)()+'*%*%+)+&'=/%0:%/& :/('21/':/)4%&'3*:)&%02'*+&:/4)2'.'2)(%0 *'/4)('* / /'' 3' %(&&3%&)&(3%/='*.+'B? / 2/1=*? .'2)()+'* '&( (%++& /%)*' %+ )+ '/'+('

)+&'+&&*'00=2*)+&3'*3%:' .'2)()+'*?*&'+&*?

).:0%+&*'&('%/'?&3'/'

/'?)+(.:0'&'%=/''.'+& >)&3 &3' :)+)+ /'(/2'2 9B &3' 3%/;3%+2 )=3

1/& )+

!*1:/%$ %+2 &3'

00%3%9%2 1/&)+

+%/=1.'+&&3%&&3'2'

)+)&)+ F*%0'I1+2'/ &3' )3%/ %+2 &3' &&%/ /%2'*3 (&*? )* '+&)/'0B 2)

'/'+&?.1*&%0* %)0:'/1*%0 &3'2'

)+)&)+

*%0')+&3')3%/%+2&3'&&%//%2'*37&%&1&'*/'4'%0* &3%& &3)* %/=1.'+& 3%* %::%/'+&0B 9''+ /%)*'2 9B 2)*/'=%/2)+=&3'2'

)+)&)+ *%0')+&3'*'*&%&1&'* >3)(3%/''**'+&)%00B)2'+&)(%0&&3'2'

)+)&)+ *%0'

&3':/'*'+&*&%&1&' '&3'/'

/'?3%4'+3'*)&%&)+)+302)+=&3%& .'2)(%0:/('21/'*G*'/4)('*

'/'29B&3':'&)&)+'/* %/'%*'/4)(' 3'*1::0B 2/1=*?.'2)()+'*?).:0%+&?

*&'+&*? 4%04'* %+2 &3'/ ).:0%+&* %/' )+&'=/%0 & % .'2)(%0*'/4)('*G:/('21/'*%+2(%++&9'*'4'/'2& )+ '/%*%0'%*2'

)+'21+2'/&3'1+8%9/&3' %/B%+% (&%+2&3'/'

/'?%/'+&'A)=)90'&4%01'%22'2&%AI 3' (+&'+&)+* /%)*'2 9B 0'%/+'2 (1+*'0 / &3' 7&%&'

/'=%/2)+=812=.'+& <'/%0% 1/&)*&&%00B.)*(+(')4'2 /&3'

/'%*+&3%&)+ #$% &'0)4)*)+

'+(3 812=.'+& 1/& 3%2 %0/'%2B9''+(+*)2'/'2 '4'+&3'

% /'*%)2812=.'+& +&3'>/)&:'&)&)+?+1.9'/ &3'/0'=%0)**1'*3%4'%0* 9''+/%)*'2*&3'(0%)..%2'9B&3':'&)&)+'/)**E1%/'0B(4'/'29B&3' 812=.'+& 1/&?>'+''2+&&=)+&&3'&3'/)**1'* 3'*%.' %/'0'

&:'+&9'(+*)2'/'2)+%+B%::/:/)%&'(%*' 3'>/)&:'&)&)+*&%+2*%00>'2 ! 5$

!# 5$

3'&3'/*:'%;)+=G/'%*+'2, '*G 3'&3'//':/&%90', '*G