← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15972/2018disposed of

Kulwant Singh v. Punjab State Federation Of Cooperative Sugar Mills Limited

2018-07-05Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik3 pages

Sumit Gulati 2018.07.09 15:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

  

       

    

            

        !!  

 

   !

 



 

 

 

 !"

 "#$%&'()*&+($,-&.,&/%$&0(&$&$),*$1(2',2(%%&$31(4)* &+( ),-&$&'&$),)*,2$.&+(0(&$&$),(%+.--)'5+&$--'.,3()*./%$&$,&+( ,.&'%()*6.,2.6'-2$%(3&$,5&+(%(-0),2(,&-&)%(1(.-(+$-/$&++(12%(&$%.1 7(,(*$&-.1),5/$&+$,&(%(-&890(%.,,'6 

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

 )%2(%2.&(2@0.--(27"&+(.00(11.&('&+)%$&"7'&&+.&%(#$-$), 0(&$&$),  /.-  2$-6$--(2  #$2(  )%2(%  2.&(2  4  :,,(C'%(  =< +(%(.*&(%&+('5.%!$11-.00%).3+(2&+$- )'%&7"/.")**$1$,5

 )44)*4.,2&+(-.$2/%$&0(&$&$),$--&$110(,2$,52$-0)-.17(*)%( &+$- )'%&.,2$--&.&(2&)7(1$-&(2*)%  +)'5+,)&$3()*6)&$), /.-$--'(2$,&+(.*)%(-.$20(&$&$),"(&,)$,&(%$6-&."B)%2(%/.-5%.,&(2 7"&+$- )'%&-&."$,5&+()0(%.&$),)*)%2(%2.&(2@0.--(27"&+( .00(11.&('&+)%$&"&$-.1-)0(%&$,(,&&)6(,&$),+(%(&+.&*)%&+(%(.-),- 7(-&D,)/,&)&+('5.%!$11-&+(0%(-(,&%(-0),2(,&$(',E.7&.&( (2(%.&$),)* ))0(%.&$#('5.%!$11-&2+.-,)&7((,$601(.2(2.-. 0.%&"

=

,2)'7&(21"&+(0(&$&$),(%-&))2%(&$%(2),=> .,2&+( ./.%22.&(2@@0.--(27"&+(!.,.5$,5$%(3&)%+.-.1%(.2"7((, -(&.-$2(7"/.")*.33(0&.,3()*.00(.17"&+(.00(11.&('&+)%$&"#$2( )%2(%2.&(2@.,2*'%&+(%&+.&&+(%($-,)-&."5%.,&(2$,

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

= 6),&+-$-5)$,5&)(C0$%(,($&+(%.,".3&$),+.-7((,&.D(,,)%&+(7(,(*$&- +.#(7((,%(1(.-(2 &)&+(0(&$&$),(%.,2+(*((1- -.&$-*$(2$, .3.-(. 2$%(3&$),$-$--'(2&)&+(%(-0),2(,&&)3),-$2(%&+(31.$60'&*)%&+7"&+( 0(&$&$),(%$,+$-1(5.1,)&$3(.,2&)&.D(3),-3$)'-2(3$-$),/$&+$,-)6( -&$0'1.&(20(%$)2 

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

! 

"

'1.&$ #

+(&+(% (0)%&.71(  (-

+(&+(%0(.D$,5B (.-),(2  (-B)