High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8934/2011allowed

P.S. Sawhney v. Cat, Chd And ORS

2018-12-14Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu4 pages

!"

# %

$&'(

$ %)$ & "$ , -

!"# $"%&' !"# "( &")'&"('

$

-$ $.

/ "$" $0"+ "0$ 0+($1'%

$$ - 2

$"%&'*

$%!

"(($ +( 3 $-&#" ( )"- $"& ( $-$ 4

"

+ (($ +( *+ " ( !

$5 )"

$#+"$ #--

$ 3+$$ "6

$ )"- $

&"

$#-$

*#

4' 8!

-

)"$ $1"-$% + 6

$! 4

--

6

$&/

""$4 &%&&4

"- % $$ )" $# $-$ ! *# "

$"

# 9 )"- !

&$-$ 4

" $#$-$% $$ 2 )" - $ $-$ "

#

4"$

" $#-$

+& *

4

(-&# $ #% !"

"/-&($" +$ #$ * $ +"

+ )" "($

""

$# '+"$ #" (- "- &# + 9:-$

+(%

$$ 2 )"-

& --& )"$

"

4 $$""--&

&*#"- %$ 8

" 1"-

&';9 ;8!

)" - $ " --$

-$ )" -

-$-$&#$ $%$1" $ -$

-& 4%$

4" -&

$ $

" --&

& + $ " $& '(

$ %)$ &'1 9)"-+$- "'

4 % -# 5+

$% ($ $" --$""

+$ $!

"$!

4" (($ +( "$4 $

4

"$$ 2 )"*5 $

*#&$ +

& $"<

)$$ $#1" 4$"1

""- ! *$$*#& (

$(

" $&'(

$ %)$ &'1 9=$ +

& --$

4 $ <

)$$ $#1" 4$"1 " " - $" % "&& 4"$$

"-$ "%4 "$+4"""$4 $(4

"- )"- $" * +--& "&

!

" +( $& +- *# " -$( +$

4 " +$

$#-$

8!

$# $"

#

> &

!

" +( * $& +- *# " -$( & 4!

""$ & "$4 ,$! -$+*#&$ +

&--$

$<

)$$ $#1" 4$""%4 "$+4"" $#$-$ 9 )"$

$ $ "+( & )"6

$"

$& +- " ( !!

)"&

!

" +( "+&"%*

>!

""(($ +( "$4

)"- 1 *%1$-&#*#

4$-$ " $#$-$3

&$-&# 2 )" - $" 4 % >-& "" $#+& *

+ 4

"

(

"($-$

"#$ )"6

$ ! * 3!%$1!

"+/

$ "

$-&#

&*# "

( 2 1 " (-+4 $$ 2 !$

-+

"( +

-

9:-$

+(! -

8

+$

$ -

1 " $-$ ( *# " - $

2 4

" $# $-$ 9 "+& "% *

$*#"

#

$ 4"-$ - %)"- ! /$4

$ 3" --$

"-$( "+ (-&&

4 1"+& $4

" ()" (

*$(

+*$

=$ +

&--$

$<

)$$ $#1" 4$"1

" " - $ " "&& 4 " $# $-$ 3!%$1" "($

""- $" "&& 4"

& $$ 2 '&&"$$ -

*#"

# +$

4" $#-$

$( ( ("%($4

"$$ 2 " "-

&$-&#" $#$-$1 ! "" $#$-$

& >-& $#8

"!

" "

$# '+"$ # ! * )"

$# '+"$ #" &$#(+- (

! $ "-& &$ +

& $<

)$$ $#1 " 4$"1""- "+&"%"&& 4"$$$ $

*#")$ &

';9 :3 ;1

$ 1

&&#(

%)"+$ &!# (+&"$&

" 4

"-$

#$ &1 !

&& $% #-+$-

"-

( "- "

*& 41 " "

"4

#$ 43" $&

&' 1!"

"! )" - !

&

"#$ ;)"&$ )$ &" "($

($

% ! "-+& $ " 3*

&( --$

-$ (# / !"

#4$ # &! )" - &# (- +- " - $

&

-$-$ "&&4(

+8

&&!""- &# (+ ((

+$!

""&&4(

+0-

% !" - "($1" (

"&*

-$-$ '$

4&#1"!$ -

&&! "$$-

*#"

# "$$ $ $*#" &$ )$ &

';9 ;$

)"(+ &$#+ $("-

"-

$$*$ + "

(!

"

-$ +$!/ $(# & 4!

"

$ ?@-$

+()"

7+

91: ,5 % "$( A+4 3$

$

4" "+ %

A+4 ""$ -/

4:$ B : ""$,-$*& B :