High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17712/2017disposed of

Comptroller And Auditor General Of India And ORS v. Central Administrator Tribunal And ANR

2018-01-11Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri,Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar2 pages

Mamta 2018.01.18 14:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

!"# $ #%&'&() * +,"--#

./&" #(#!- $ (/&!

!(/ "0#'#"&"&(#'

1#'.'

#("!- /+&(&'"!"&1#

&2.(!-3 0!(/&4!0 #',(/#("'

#'#("

!5#'0 &""!-3 /1%!"# $ "0# ,#"&"&(#'

!# !--7#/3 !'

,!8#/ $ ,8 $ /# ./4+#("

/!"#/ : :

"!;#( ( #%/ '.25#%"

" !-- 5.'"

#<%#,"&(' !"# !$

0# ,#'#("

,#"&"&( 0!'

2##( $&-#/ .(/# "&%-#

= !(/

$ "0# ('"&"."&( $ (/&!

$ &''.!(%# $ !

7&"

&( "0# (!".# $ %#"&!&3 +!(/!+.'

!(8 "0# '.&"!2-# 7&"

$ >.!'0&(4 "0# &+,.4(#/ 5./4+#("

/!"#/ =:

((#.<# = 3 ,!''#/ #("!- /+&(&'"!"&1#

&2.(!-3 0!(/&4!0 #(%03 0!(/&4!0

$"# !4.&(4 !"

-#(4"0 !(/ $&(/&(4 "0!"

"0# ."

7!'

&(%-&(#/ " &("#$## 7&"0 "0# &+,.4(#/ /#3 -#!(#/ %.('#- $ "0# ,#"&"&(#'

'"!"#'

"0!"

"0# %-!&+ $ "0# #',(/#("?7;+!( 7.-/ 2# !%%++/!"#/ !'

7!'

/(# &( "0# %!'# $ "0# '&+&-!-8 '&".!"#/ ,#'('

Mamta 2018.01.18 14:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document

0# '#-#%"&( ,%#''

&(&"&!"#/ "0# ,#"&"&(#'

,.'.!("

" "0# !/1#"&'#+#("

" #4.-!&@# "0# '#1&%#'

$ !-- "0'# &(%.+2#("'

70 0!/ 2##( &( '#1&%# !'

%!'.!- -!2.#'

'&(%# ** .,7!/'

7!'

#''#("&!--8 %(%#''&(!- ,%#''

&("#(/#/ " 2#(#$&"

!-- 70 0!/ '#1#/ "0# ,#"&"&(#'

$ 1!&.'

,#&/'

0##$#3 "0# !4.+#("

"0!"

"0# #',(/#("

/&/ ("

,!"&%&,!"# 7.-/ 2# !

$!&-&(4 (#

&(%# "0# %.('#- $ "0# ,#"&"&(#'

0!'

+!/# !

'"!"#+#("

" !%%++/!"# "0# #',(/#("

&( '#1&%# ( '&+&-! "#+'

7!'

/(# " "0# "0# #+,-8##'

70 $!%#/ "0# '#-#%"&( ,%#''3 7# /##+ &"

!,,,&!"# " /&','# $ "0# ,#"&"&( !'

,#''#/

0# (#%#''!8 #-&#$ $ #4.-!&@!"&( !(/ !""#(/&(4 %('#>.#("&!- 2#(#$&"'

2# #-#!'#/ " "0# #',(/#("?7;+!( 7&"0&( !

,#&/ $ $. 7##;'

$+ "0# /!"# $ #%#&,"

$ %#"&$&#/ %,8 $ "0&'

/# %

* &!&'!

($'($) *$!+"#,-)$!#$.

/$- ($'($) )$*)'!01$ /$-