Dilbagh Singh v. State Of Punjab And Other
!"
!"
#
$$$$ #"
!""# #" $ % % & !
! *(')+
, -'. !
" & #012
&/ & 453 & !
3
453
'( *(') & " &
453 & " &" 3!
3 453 &
, 63 3 3
!
! "!
" & - 7
& 8 '( '( '9):
(4 '99;
!
" +1%. '9;<
"" "%+#02.
1! " %
;(3 & "% %%%%%
453
7 &/ -
& 1= > :5*9'95; &" 3"
& &/ "
& 3 " &
('
('
'9)5
3" ,
3
& & && 31 <( ''
'955 & 1=
> )'954 "/ &/
3
& !
3" 94(-'5(( &"&
"
<( ''
*('5 ?
?
> :';'959 &"& (< (* '995 '995
&& &/
3
& !
$
3" &/ "
"
3"
*5 (* *(': *5 (* *(';
& , (*3 &" *5 (* *(';
3
& ,
& "" 3 &
'@ 3
'( *(')& &
3" &" !
A! 3 " !
"%%% "%%%
"%
453 ;(3
" "%
63
& "%%%
"%3
7 !
*(')
!
3
& 3 & *(')& & "
&" & ! 45;(3 !
&& 3
, A 3
"
&" 3
?
"
'( *(')"
!
3
& 3 *(')" 3 '9;< &"!
"" '9;< "% "%%% '9;< & !
*(')& " && & "
, 3 " 3 "/ 1%%%-& " 33
B "
!
3 3 !
& 3 " &" A! "%%% "
"% "%%%
45 & 453 % 3
& *(') " !
3
& 3 ;(3 %!
" !
"&
7
A &" 1
- = *(') "%%% "% " !
C = !
'9;<
&"!
"% " !
" 1%1 %%% 3 3 " &
'9;< C = *(')"
'9;<
%
C % " & " "
!
D!
" &"
!
% " !
, 3
*(')3 3 >& ! & ! & "
& 3 & *(')3
"%%%
"%
! 6 "1& " ?
> 5:*((9 " *) (* *('* &'(')*'+,- .'./01'(2'3''340.&/(- *('*+*. E4:9" "3 " &"
"
!
" " 3 3 ! '<
F'< B A" " 31 +. '99; ," !
, A B !
3 #!
A / "" , G > :
! "
/ "" !
& " , " ! A!
, % > 4
3 " " "A
&"A 3 3
"
"3 > H& !
> 4 "
" " H
& & "
& " *((( *((< & "&/ 3
7 H
& " 3 " "
" &
&
'9 (9 *((< &/ 503.('(2 63-.(75.603- 8/(/ 6--7/4 03+2 03
$'34#.&/(/10(/#.&/+/'(3/4 639+/749/8'-(69&.
63 &0+4639 .&'. .&/ -'64 63-.(75.603- 5'330. &':/ '32 (/.(0-*/5.6://11/5.;7.)7-.;/*(0-*/5.6:/+2'**+6/4% & "
3 " "
E > 4& " A
I 1 "1 & " 1= > ;5;;'99' " '( (9 '99< 7()'6+ 639&,-
.'./0173<'; " " 3 3 3 ! 5 9
F5 H! " % !
""
% #!
"" ') '95: &
" &"!
"
!
"
" /
> 3 6 '
'
'99'
+
, -).
" /&
"
%"
" & " &"
& " /& J 3*( '99' &" "" " ! 3" " /
" % " H
& " /&
'
:
'99(
&
"" J 3*( '99' !
" 6
& 3 3 "!
&& " /
!
& " &
=
!
"" & " &" 3
%&
"" /&3 !
"
& " !
3 &"3 "
"
% & E
"
,K K !
%
3 3 "
&
" /
3
3"
I 7 /
! & " & "
!
*(')"
!
3 "
& 3 *5 (* *(';
'( *(') 3 " "" "" 3
J !
'9;< 3
&
"
% '9;<
"% '9;< !
"
, -:& 3 % '9;< 3"!
'9;< &
3 '9); ! - "
> ;:5<G?
(9 '* );
7
+1-%.
!
+1-%. '9;< 3
#!
! >" >
#
'*<G1 G <(9G; *< (4 '9;< +"3 " .& !
"-% %
3
!
>
>
& "
+.
+. "
"
A"
D,
L"
D, " "
'
G "
1 )4M *4 M 63 "
8 1&/ =
!
&
"
3
3
" &
*
8 1&/ = !
&
"
--- '((M ---
3 3 & / &
& = 1 1 (9 '* );
3
1
!
&& 1%
7 '9;< &
'9)9&
"% !
(;
''
'954
"% 7 '9;<
!
" "/ "%
"
"%%%
3 ""
3" &"
!
, "%%% " 8 !
3" " &!
" 3 "%
" &" " %%% "!
'9;< "" 3 "%%%&
'9;<
3 "" 3" "3
"%%%
% "
"
" '9;< 3&"
"%%% "% 3 *(') &"
&
/
! & 3" !
"%%% "%
% " & " " &
!
" & !!
" H K
1% & " 1! > <;(4*((9 /3/('+ '3'9/(#..'('35&'+'+ '3-.&'3,- "'>)6/:6'340.&/(- " '4 (4 *((9 F<'
"
"" 3
B " " =/
*' " *((*
" / " &3 ! " "
H 1 & &
"" &"
"
& !!
3
!
!
" 1 ,- 09634/( 039'N+*((:.* 11*9)O & &
, "!
" "
" 3 3 ! I
! 6 " 1 & " 1=
> '4*55*((; " ':
'* *((; &'(');6('34'30.&/( ,- .'./01'(2'3' #!
, "!
" "
!
& " ! ! " " &" " "& " "
!
" 3!
" ! 5 9
F5
" /
& !
3
&3
1 J -
, < " 3
"& !
! " '; " + "
!
.
#!
, "!
" "
!
3& " ! ! " I % " 3 *(') '9;< !
&" 1%"" '9;< 1%%% &"" 3 " & H '9;<
& !!
*(') "
!
3
'9;<
! & !
"
"%%% "3 "
& 3 *(') 3
, 3
3&& & "
3
, 3 &" && "3
& 3
&"& , &
"3
*5 (* *('; ! ,
"
1
, !
3 " "!
33 , 3 1 , & "!
3
3 *(') "3 ! & " H 2
1% &
&""" "!
3"
1% .'./0173<';'34.&/(-,- '16? '-6&#
% $$ "!
3"!
"
/
! &
!
'*
&" - F% &" &!
"!
3 & 3
!
/ 3
3
,"
6 3 " !
& 3 3
& & & "!
3
& & +. "!
3
1-%%% 1-% +#K1K #KK .
+. "!
3
& &
3 "!
3
+. "!
3
& ,"
3
,"
!
3 "!
3
+!. "!
3 " &
& 3
A "
"" 3 !
!
3
A &/
+!.% 3 " & 1!
" "
"!
3
& A 3" , &&
A
K "!
I
! & !
!
"!
3&"
3 , & 3 "
" A 3
" 3 "!
& & "
"3
7 & & !
% & '
(&
'
(&