Ashwani Gupta And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

(1)










 

  


  



 !"!#$
% &  "'( #!
)*

+
 ',"





-



 ,.

#
+
 ',"

   /$

 01
/ 
 -
  -
 
/-








 01
/ 

 -
- 2
2 /
3 /   
   

 


  
 

   -
 
/-

4


   !     "#
$%
"$$&'( )*+  ,& -  .

     *%/&  '        0*%/&  0+ "&
$%
"$$1'( )"+  ,2 *%/&!"*
$3
"$$#'( )3+!      ,"&'"+  456   7  -.

  8  6 "$*3' 0"$*30+ 9  6 "#
*$
"$*2'( )/+  8  5 8    !! 5:;
"**1"$*& 06< 6=  
,  = 0

(2)

"
> 8 !   

8689  ,1)-.

  *%/&""
$/
"$$&8 !   6 "&
$%
"$$1  '(   )"+       ,  2     *%/&  
7 ,/*%/&!  !

  89 8 !    6! "*
$3
"$$#'( )3+ 8  
7 

    5   8    5:  ;
*2&*2    "$$2  !  !   3*
*$
"$*3'( )#+

      "#
$%
"$$&  '(   )*+      "&
$%
"$$1 '( )"+
   3*
*$
"$*3'( )#+

 

 08,

65 8  ,-'5+ ;
%%/*"$*&!   6 $*
$1
"$*# '( )%+!8 !     6 !!   8     !6 .

9 

.

  
 >66 6   !

 5 .

  .

  ,"&'"+ "$*38  5:;
"**1"$*& 06< 6 = 
,  = 0! 8!   6 9  6"#
*$
"$*2'( )/+  8,"&'"+"$*3!
 3

5       8

(3)

 6 5   !     ,"&'"+"$*3     

  6  6 8 8   !               .

    !   "*
$3
"$$#'( )3+88 !,"&'"+ "$*3
>  .   *%/& !  
5     8   86      "#
$%
"$$&  '(   )*+      "&
$%
"$$1 '( )"+  !"*
$3
"$$#'( )3+ 

 8  
 &
?     86 

8 ,"&'"+"$*3!! 

 8   .

 

  *%/&  8  

  6   
> !   86 !.

  *%/& !  
>          

    9  6      08  ,

6  5    #5, 67*8#
) ',!

.
3"
/ #'

,7 7
#5
 ',""$"$'> +,5*&/2
7 8         ! 88 ! - .

   5  @8  A   B 6      $#
$/
"$"*! 8     .

 !  ;
*"&#)&%"*
$3
"$$#
>  

(4)

8 !6 ! 6  6!  6 8!-5 8  6
?

6 ! 
"1"&&/$3/C)6 
"%*2%2/%C)      8   8             6    8 8  6
, 6 6   

  


***#&321%C)'    

 + 6 ! 8!-56   !!  8  8  6
 1

   .

   "18 8    3"  2 ! *" 6 8   " "&6A

8)  @ 

,4

8) 12,5? @,      ,1) !   3$6! 8    *"  6  !                

 8 
 ,6  6  8        !    -  .

   5       

      8        ;
*"&#    *"&%   "*
$3
"$$#6  .

,"&'"+"$*3 ! 


 2
5  86    ,*%*%/&8 B   D    E6   ;   !           6  .

  

(5)

,"&'"+"$*3 8 68 

08,

65  323'1+9  6  
  



    '

+! 8 ! ! 6  6   .

  ,"&'"+"$*3

  86   !    6 
 #
:         86   6  8         !    

  ! 9  6  8  08,

65 
  



    '

+
 %
7   888


;  , &2*%/&!  "#
$%
"$$&"&
$%
"$$1      ! "*
$3
"$$#
     .

 ! ,"&'"+"$*3
  "&&"&19  6 
  



    '

+!  ,     .

!! 8

 6 68
7      

F6  886     
 7       8             !  ,
   8  ;
*"&#"*
$3
"$$# 79 ;
*"&%

(6)

  "*
$3
"$$#              !     8 

      F6 886    
 /
   6  6   8

    6 !
"1"&&/$3/C)6  
"%*2%2/%C)  8 8    6  8 8  6
, 6  6      


***#&321%C)'

    + 6 ! 8! -56  !!   8 8  6
 8    6 6  !  6 6   8 8  6
*$
"$39  6 
  



    '

+ !!0 0 8  "$2 !6  88  8 8

5
>    6  8 68   6  8  6     
 6 8 ""& 9  6!0 0 , "&'"+"$*3  !6 !0  0 ! 8   ,"&'"+
> 8  .

 !  6  6 

(7)

   !-.

 5! 8  8  6!' +
 **
, 9  6  8  5 5:;
"**1 "$*& 06< 6= 
,  = 0  ! 8 8      6     9  6

08,

65  
  



    '

+ ! 8  

8 ,"&'"+ "$*3!!   8    .

  *%/&   8     6  


> !   86 ! .

  *%/&!  
>6 8 8   86 !    .

 88   ,"&'"+"$*3
*"
7  .

   "18

   3"  2 ! *" 68   "

 "&6A

8)  @

,4

8) 12,5? @,     ,1)  !   3$6! 8  *"6!  6  8  ! 

 
 *3
>6  8  

(8)

    ,  *%      *%/&      6   6  6 8B D  E6  ; !    
7 08,

65   323'1+9  6
  



    '

+       !  !              6      6        .

      ,"&'"+"$*3  8  86 .

 8  , "&'"+"$*3
*&
,!  8   

5:;
*2&*2"$$2   6  !   6 8  5 3*
*$
"$*3'( )#+ ,-'5+;
%%/*"$*&      8  6   8    08  ,

6  5         $*
$1
"$*# '( )%+  68     !

8  8   08 ,

65 
  



    '

+!

 31/323'/+ 8.   8  6 8

   8  68   , "&'"+"$*38   686   ! 8   6   !    8  ;
*"&#*"&%"*
$3
"$$#6 

(9)

6        8      !    -  .

  5  8 , !!
 *1
>!8! 6   !  6  6
 9  -
 
/-:

 
9- 2
2 /
3 /:

  % &   '

',
"* ;!#<=, "#5$ "= '

',
*,

>7$ "=