← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21300/2016disposed of

Jagjeet Singh v. Subordinate Services Selection Board Punjab And Others

2019-09-05Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

    



!

    "

 #

$$ %"&"&  '()*

+, -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/ 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

67 '()* -18.

3 -$ +.

./ """$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

766 '()*  ,$

/ 91:

/

./ """$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5

 ;"

;66 '()*  +

5 ).

./ """$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5



%"

6 '()* 4<$

/ -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

;%7 '()* -

5 -$ +.

1/

"""$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5

 6"

)6&& $ =

%7 '()*  3$

/ -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 7"

7%6 '()* 5 """$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5



&"

6;66'()* -$43$ """$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

;7 6'()* 1/3$

/  -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

7;&6'()* ./ , 9.1/

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

;76'()*

5 -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./ """5

 "

&;6'()* -18..

$

-$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5



;

;"

 6'()*

:

5 """$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 %"

6'()*

:

5

./ """$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

  "

&77'()* $/3 $/ -$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 6"

%& '()* /2

>

./ """$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5

 7"

%&'()* -18.

3  , """$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5



% &"

;66'()* 1/

:

-$ +.

"""$$ / 0"

-  # 1 ,

./

"""5

 "

67 '()* -

5 91:

/ """$$ / 0"

-12/ $

 -/3$ -4$

/

./

"""5

  )? @> )"

-

 

  



      





  !"## $ !%"#&  #!'

( )

  * )  

 





+!,&" + #!&

( -     





  !%#& !&%% .%% &/% /,"#  #!'



  !.&'# !.&#" !#''

$ !# !

 #!%

1 *  

 





+! &.,+ #!%

 * )  

 





  "./&  #!'

$

  %#.% $ ,.!#  #!%

  

 





+ /#&+ #!'

( * -     





+ " "%+ #!'

 (    3 *      





+ /"#+ #!, (  * )    





+ . %+ #!%

5     6  71



 67 - 7 6 71

7 5 * :       +;6

*7 -7) (    *  * )       "

 

+ &/%+ #!'



    .



+! &.,+ #!%

*  *    5   

    .



+ /#&+ #!'

 

  A

"

9

8    # 

  8    8<   17)

 )) =7 

  

   2   

 8  )

  !"##  #!'  8< 

      )  )      8 7    

 8    8  

   

97     

 

   7       



 )  

 

+7)+

>< ?

  

77  

)  % !! #!/ @7 +!

:  7    +;6

        ;

    8

  3  

7   

  

   8 



  /

 7+ 

  

       

   

    







          

    

  



!"

# $% 

 

  & %  #

    

  $    " 

   

   



'    (

 ) *+,*-.-    

 *+,*-.-) 

  (

 "  

    

  

     &

%  #

 

  $ )  )'



    /0  #/ 

      $     

 ( 

    1

  

 (    

  

   

 ( 

 ) 

 

# 

 

)( 1  .+234    5

&",6$ # $% 7  

  #) 

 

 &



$ "

 ) ...*-.*



   

 ...*-.*) 



 (

  

7  

   &

 

   )  )'

    /0 

 ( 

    1

  

 (     

  

   

 ( 

 ) 

 

# 

 

)( 1  .+234    5

&",6$ # $ 8      



 "

  

)     

"

 9

        

   (



 



      1  

  

"

  8     



 

 

 %  #

  

 ($  

  #1

 

 (7  

 ( 

 

 ( &  

 ($    

               1   1    

 



'    (



  

      (  

    

 )(     1     

8      )

 9

   )

  )

 : %  ) 

 1      

 (

 )

) ) 

 ;)

1  # $< 

= 

)( 

  >  

   

    7   

    &   

   

 

  ?)( (            =   / 7 7 1

7



   )    

.+23

  # 5

&",6$

   

 

    

  (

)'

)   

    

 (  "

  

)  

 # $@# $



)     ()  #$< 

&

 

)( (



  "    #      =   / 7 7 1

7 $    

 %     4        )

  

    

8       

/0#/ 

  $  7    

 ( 9    9  

  



7  **  1#A 

  



7  ** 1 



 5

&"

,2$    

)'

)   

 

 

 (  "

  

)  

# $@ # $



)     ()  # $< 



 

)( (



     B"

    =  #           =      /   7   7   1

7 $

 

  

   )



( 8      )    )

  

          

 

 8       )'

    ) 

 

   

 (  "

  

)



# $@# $



)     ()  # $ 8       )

 )  ) )



 

)( (   







 

& # $ 7 

  



 :

 

(   

 )      

C 





 

( 

 7 

 

(  

       > 

  

 (  #1

  7 

   & $  %    #

     

 ($  

%   4   



 

   & 

 " 

   ?

)(     D

 1  )     



 5

&"3E= 

7 

   

(  

 )

 

   

  



7  **     

 )   1  





 5

&",2< 

/ 

        7         

      7



  )     

 

              

          

 

      1 # 5$ 7 

  

  

   

 &

B# $

)  

  ) ) 

    



   

( 

    

  

      

        (

)  

 



  

)

   (@



( ) 

 

    

   



   7 

        = 

(  

  )   



!"



( 8      

 

8         /     

   

     

 ( 4 '

   

 &'

)    (  :    

 ( 9   

 (  

 

 (  " 

  

)  

# $ 

  

)     )   )        

 

    

  "

  

)   

# $



)  )   ) 

 % 

       

"

   )   

   

      

     

(    /0  

 (  

  

  

     /0     

     

   

 

 7    **       1     

8      ) 

 )'

 

 (      

 (    

               7   /0  

 (  

%

        /0 

 (     

/    

   

  



 **   7  /0 

 (    



'   

 (   

 ( %

    



 )



 

  8      

 

&'

) ) 

  #5$% 

     

  



 )

( ) 

  

 

    )  

            

 )( 7 

    



           #5 $% 

     



   

   

  

)   )     

 )(    

(

     

 



  (

()   )





(         )



 %    

(

 

 )   )

( :

 

  ) 

  







  

 5 

 



     

 ( %  

 ) 

   )      

    

    

)(  ;) 7

1 %

 

3,# $

'  



!"

#$!%&'

! 

()

*)&)+) , *- ') .

 

 1 

 

 ) 

)(  (

     )   )

8        

 



   

 ')  # 



 )   

  )      

  4 $   

 

   

 5

  

      

         )   

       

  

 

  "    ) 

    



( ') )   8        )  

  ) 

 )



 

   '))   

8       

 8       (  ) 

( 

)   9    %

  

 8                  )  



    8       )

  9

(    



:      

 )

 

(  ( 

8   8      

    (  

  



( )

 

     

 )    )'

                    8         

        8      7  

(       

  (

 

 

  

()   

    )

 

 

# 

   



) $) )





 

     

 

  

)    )   ) 



   





 

   (

   )

 



   

         )  



 ) 5

  8     # 

  

 

$ 

    8       

  (   

  8       ( )



   

  

:          )  

   ) 5

 )





(

 

        

 

  

  8       

 

#    

      )  

$ 



 8         B0)    ) 

  )  



 % ) 

  

( (

  

  ? # $% 

  



7

 

(

   )( (



  

)(                8        



 

) )

 



  



 

)( ;) 1   )

 

   ()'

  (    ) 

;) 1      



)   ) 5

    )

  

  

 



 (

       )   

 

(

    :    

)





     

 

 #)$%    



  "

  )



 

 

 

8      )

 

 

   

) 

     

  



    

   

    

         



   

8      

 )  

 

    

    ( 

    

     )     (     )  

 )( ) 8   8          

 )

    

%   

  

 )   ( 

   

    

      

)( ;)  51     /  , 0.* 10,2

3 4

!"

"

"  )( 1   5+) )+

 67,  !

#  #$B

 (   



 )

)(   &1&  

:

        7 

 

 (#

 



 *#$ 7  , 1$  

  

 )   8  



'  



     )'

       

 (     

      

      #          

   /0 7   

 ( 

  

 

       

 " 

   

)



 

$

    <   8

   7  =7

  :

   <   8   8<  *   <  8<  *   71 8  



   



     8 9  ,

    )  7  8 )  7   < 8 8

  ) 7

< 7  < A       ) 

7<     7     

    8<        8 9  ,1 

7  



     

2 





8<  <      )  

 '

 

  *

  %"&"& "%

   B  C

 (  8 C