High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5076/2012allowed

K.C. Sareen & ANR. v. Punjab National Bank & ORS.

2015-11-20Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron9 pages

"#$%&$

$ '$(

()*+,%&$

$ /0-$"($1.21$ /$$)( $-0 01.21$&-$ /$#($2'$01.21$&$-.

"(+.-#3&&(,$+

$ '$(

()*+,%&$

$ /$ "/+,1#$.214& /$')5&51.21$&-$ /$#($2'$01.21$&$-.

&$.$&++.-$0.44$- 6 !

.!8 !

91$3.+:(+4 . & -$ 6 !

4$ --. +$, 4& & $-. ; , & 5$ <= ($( +.3.&5$ <<!$&(.$#>

@$.4& # 9A BA.B . 9A B & $2 $$(- 1 <==1 &

-$4$2.*5&+$.#-+(.3 ! <<< &*(&$.$21&-$4$$2.4&&4 (2+5..34$.&-(&0C0+$0 #$2D$0-$ <8AB&-$#+0.. < <88 1&$$1 8 <<<1$.$.0+$24-. 3&-$&-$+.--+3&)(.30 2.. ! <<<&.--+4.0.*5&($

!33$2.3&)(.30&($1-$--+ 4$ +.*5 & -$ *$&D*+ #(-$0 ($ &. --+ 4$ ++4. 2. 00 $.$ .. >

-. $0+ --+ >

8 +. C"#$ ' # 1 1 &.3$&%&$D14&4*$2.(.$ E23&$.+$.(+$&-$.&233 &$(3&&$$.&14$&-&1& &1&0$+$$..*+&&& -$( *5. $*+ .(* &$$1 & --++ :(.&&$3+2+.3&0 & 0-(3. )(.30 . $.$ & 3& ($ .&--+++4.$.3+5F 1 &$$1 & -$ (*0. $-$ $ $0$2&-$4$$.

1*( &-$4$(.+.5*,@43.$+.* ($+$$5:((&$0&-$ (*0. $-$ $ -50 & *,@43 . &$ :(+*42$1&$-$-$ . -$ 4$ $).

. < >

$-2+5 33$2.3&&$-.;,1&-$+. &-$4$-

++51&4$-4*3&$.*5&+$.#3+ &1*(&-$&$$(3&0.0&4$-1 &++3&2$# A BA*BAB&,3 3(+1 <><#&$4&++3&($5-$21&0$4 -+.*$&2&$0& (+&($ &$+2-$2&,3 3(+1 <>< # A BA*BAB$.(.$ E

$&*0-+500333.$$ $$00-+50 A B ,30-5; AB &++0-+5$*03.*50333G$ A*B &++0-+5$(&0-+505-$ @ AB 4&1$50&*1.)(..+21 $ & (-.. -50 $ & 0-(.. 4& & $.$1$4&1$&*12.*5$0+($ 2+230$+($-(.G HH HHF &.&$-.;,&4$0 &:(+&-$&($*+1&5&2*:(. *5323&0*.(*14&&++5.$$0&. $(0$-&:(+/.I+1&$@(. 4& & -$ & $-. $+. (- )(.30 D*+ #(-$0 ($ $-$. # , . %&$ ' /&00. *.(+ &0A

9B #87 & &$ &.1 6 !8 !

9 -$$$. *5 &$ @(.1 4& 4 :(. *5 +$. #-+ (.31 *( 2.*5&($2.)(.30..

!42$1($&$ --+1&D*+#(-$0($-.$.$:(+

> $ & ($1 +$. (+ $ & -$AB $3(. & & )(.30 $$$. *5 & $-. /&00. *.(+

&0D A(-$B --+*+ & & -$ 0(& &$2&-$ 4$ .0. 4&(&+.3 5.-$0+:($51*(+5&*)(.30&$0+ ($ &.)(.30&*.53$(.4&2$1 & -$ $ +. 43 $ & -$. &5 4$ ,- ( $2$.*5&$-.&0+2&)(.30 /&00. *.(+ &0D A(-$B $ ( 4&$ & $0+ -$.3 4$ . & 0-+5$ $ $+.(&0-+54&+4$,34&&0-+5$1*( ($0+-$.3.$(.$#><= $.

4& # > & 4$5 $&* 1 <8 $ (& 21&0-+5$4$-*+.1&$$1&0-+5$& *$3&+50.$-*+$-50*,@4314&$& -$ 1 & $0+ -$.3 &2 * . 0-+ 02. *5 & $-. ; , . & , & -$2 & &$3 3&-$*$&$0+($&(1&-$4(+. * +. ++ * $ & . *5 & , 3 & -$ I$. (+ $ & -$AB + $+. (- 4 2&)(.30&($$.$.

! +.C&34',&$5)+'$30I.%&$D ...

=.6 <<>

7+.C&&.$ +' 00$1 /(-+ $-$1 I(.& % &$D ...

=-$$0&)(.30D*+#(-$0($$-$.

3.$#3&' $$$5&.3$&%&$A

!B # 977 & &$ &.1 +$. (+ $ & $-. ; , $+.(-&)(.30D*+#(-$0($$-$. &&.) &($) &,$ ' #(-$. 3$1 ()$ +$5 $. A <<8B #8 9G .%&$'-+#3&A

>B #

G+.2#3&' .%&$A

!B=#7>7.& &$'# )&A

7B #9 >

$+51 4 4++ .( *( & &++3 & +3+5 +(AB# A BA*B&, 3(+1 <><&. -$2 -$&* 0-+50 -$1 4& $ & * 2.*5$0+($2+230$+($-(.#(& -$2 --+*+ & 0 --0 0-+5 & -$14&&*2.1*--.*5,30-5 $0-+501&$+&-32$.&$*5-$#+0 $&#$2 3(+&,# A BA*BAB--+*+ 0-+51 4& . &2 0@.(. (*:( & --0$2. #++($&$12&.

-$2--+*+1&*$ $- 330 -$ 2. *5 $0+ ($ $ 2+230$+($-(.&-$4$$.*5$0+ ($&54$2.*5&$+($4++--+*5& ($42$1&D*+#(-$0($:(.&-$ :(.1&-$*.*2.*5$0+($ $ 0(& + 0$+ ($-(. &$$1 4 .

-$2# A BA*BAB$&$($*+$(4$$.$ 2--+*+&&-$ 03&0$&+0$3$.343$&-$. & -$ 4$ ( $21 ( & & )(.30 $$$. *5 & +$. (+ $ & $-. $ ++ & 1 4&$*5 & :(+ $0+ 4 . &$ & *5 & 0-+5$ H- & &$D A(-$B & &$D A(-$B1 & 0-+5 $. & 3 (-$( & . -3 & )(.30 :(+ & ($ $$$. &&.) &($) &,$D A(-$B &+. & 3$ *,@43 (0&($&&+.

&&3$*,@43$:($.* .$.&&*&+.&++43 E< &$.@.@$(+*+..4$3$.3$ *, 43 & & * .$0. 4 3$2&$3$0+0.(4++3.3&04 +(.3(+5&.+2$3)(.30..

#$0+--+8= <=!$+&+.&&-$( &**+-$2&5.0.&.*0.*5&0F &-$1&$.$.0+4-.++5 &*)(.30&$0+($ &(.$.$ &*,,..4*5(*:($.$&D*+#(-$0($1 (&$.$.0+@$++-($-&-$4(+.* +.&+$5$&-$.1&54$,-($2( $.$.0+-.&*$.$214&& $.$&*. &)(.30D*+#(-$0($-+#3&D A(-$B4.$.3$.$-.*5&($$-$.-+ #3&' .%&$

A B#I <7&.1-+

#3&42.$(.$#9

1*($:(+1 & 4 $. & D*+ #(-$0 ($ . & . *4 -$.3 . *5 & .-$0 + . *5 & &$. -$&($&+.&++43 E> JJ -$(1 4&& (+0+5 $(+. :(+ &-$$.4&*&$*5&.-$0+1 -$&-.$.$05$ &&$&.1 K & 0-+5 $ -(*+ $2 3 2+2. $0+ .$+2*5&$+($1&3:(+ --+ (*:(+51 & .-$0 5 0$ * (. (+ 4& $ &23 ,- &0 ( $21 & +4 *+3-$2.*,-(. * $.

$2 :(+51 & $ 32 & .$+.(-1$&--++$+5231*( $ 4& $*+ 4++ &(3& H- , & -$ & $.$ .$3 $0 * (..&$-.&*$.$21$& $ & & $+$ .&$3 4 ( & $0+ -$.3.2+51&--++$4++4&&$ $3&.5*,43&$-.$&-$.&4 $2&--++*0.+*+-5$&-$. $4&&&5(+.2+&$2&$-.& 3&($1($24100.3$2$$$1++43*, 43 +1 4&( .

2$3 ++ (& $+2 - . .$:(+51&$.$&3&($$ .$. -50 *, 43 +*+ * . &$*5 .F &34DA(-$B12&&($ 4.$3 (+7!& ()*2+#$2 (+1'+(0 $1 --+*+ $5 $ .$3 & )(.30 D*+ #(-$0($-+#3&DA(-$B1&&+(..(.$ (+7!& (+$$$.*5&-$.+4& &(-.($3&-.5&$0+-$.3& .)(0&++4$(&-$.0-+.*0.

= $.3 & $(0 & 4++ 0, & 0-+5$ +*+0,&-50&*,43+5&4.-$2. &43$*5&0-+5$&-$1& (.5 & -$ 4 ( 5 & $-.&$$1&$.$-.*5&(&$3$3 +2&,..($&-$..$0

(+ 7! & (+ . $. 4& & -$-+ +4 (0$.*5&D*+#(-$0($F &&.$ +DA(-$B1&2&&+.(.$ E.(.&34DA(-$B1&& 0-+5+03$$$++43$ 4&$ 0-+5(-..(.-+$5.$ 0-+.*5&0-+5$(&1H$& .-$0+ :($5 -$.31 & 0-+5 &++ * +. $$$ +$51 *( 1 4&$ 0-+5 (-.. (&2+20$0+&& 0-+5$1 & 0-+5$ * ..+. 4& & +*+5 -50$$$+$5&-$-+C4$,-5D1 (&4.&&0-+5$F &$ 2 & & ($ $5 + $-$%&$'+$)5+

A BI A %B 1&&+. &++43 E= )$.3$.$3(+4(+.&4& 0-+5H$..-$0+:($51&& +.3$(+++$5&&2$*-+.(.$ (- 2 4&$ & & ($. -(&0 $-$0.1 -$ -$2 +( AB (*@$3(+ A B

3(+ > 1 & 4(+. * +. (++ +$5 & $+ *&.&$3(+&(-H$(& 0-+5 4 )(. I,41 $0+ 1 4&& 2$. *5 3(+ > 1 & -$.3 &2 * $0. &&2&:(+++*+01&&0(*$. .(5.($3&-$.&*42$10-+5 & * ++5 2. . & 2 . *5 & &3&$($1&(&0-+505*$.$2

< 2.&&0$+-$0&$(3& 3(+> . > 1 &$$1 & 24 , *5 & +$. #3+ (.3 . ($$05+3+$054$$3$$*5&($F &&.) &($) &,$D A(-$B1 & D*+ #(-$0 ($ & . & :( *, 43 4(+. * .$. +5&$-.&2,*545.-+$5-$.3 .&4(.*((*++4.&0-+54 (+4(++5-$2.$0.&$33&.(&H1& .( *0 $+2 & -$ 4 (. +. *, 43$&$&&&.2+2.&0+$0.&..*+. &0+$0$.$3&$2(2.$$ )+43&*2$(.$#

$.4&9> 24 & *21 4 . & & -$ 4$ -$0. 4$, ( ,*5& $-.++5 *.(-&$$+&$0+&2&* .&(1&-$$+.43$0&..0+ ++ & . &$ $0 & & -$ & $-.$.$.-5&$$$*,434&-$. &$0& :(+51*&&4$-$.-. A/

! A I B '0+