High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17818/2017dismissed

Innovative Techno Park Private Limited v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2018-01-30Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan34 pages

# $%& ' ()"

%(* +,%

-. / ' 0,%

' '' /

! " #

$ % ! " &

' !"

$ ( !" " ' !

!" )*

-. / '

& +,+*-+,. / )- ,0+1-+,2 / ), & # & / & / & 3 /4/$ " 54$"6

*!* - ), & 7 8 8 ! # & $ ! )- 4/ ( )9 $ ' ! #:

&! )* ! '&! )1 4/ $ " 54$"6 9

$ ! ; & 8 <1"" ,'% , ' .,+ )== ""

!>4$"?

=@!>" ?= "

?)")$?

=) ?) .-+=$4"

?)"!4 4"!='?4 ) ?) .9+ =$"")$=" ) ?) .*+4 4") ?)A= ="

=!?

=" ?4== ?7)?)8?

=")"

4= .1+$=7=)=")$B

# &

& & &

: $

# /

C # # #

&8.++ / / 4 D

! # ! / &8<.++ / / 4 B 4$" #

*)*

9- ** #

& / # D % ; ,E-* $ & 4/ " "

! ,021 -* %/

" 4 & $ "

! ,0.9! '

# &8<.++

/ / 4 B & #

4$" / D ! # !

# # $ *

# & .9 F 29 21!$ '&

& $ ), / ,.+*-+,+ 15*6 %/

" 4 & $ "

!,0.95 / < ,0.9"

*2* 5& &G 6! ! !

! / ! / / ! !& 3 !

3 3 /

/ 9-!**21 / &8<.++

/ / 4 B 1

,-+--+,, ,+7 ,0.9"

$ ! #:

& H& & / & : $ 5 6

< : $B

# I % !:$ % !

;

% 8 <A=J)7? "

?)"(?4 = ?>=

% :$) ?)"

?>= /

: & # &

& "=# && /

&& / ? % # & /

: $ ' =& &!

!# !$ && !

! &

*3* #

/ # " # / &

5 6

& & # / ,+ H &

! F**:,E

:$ !&: ? 9+++ & & : % = ! % !7/ !

/ & ! & # ,1+

# / & #G % : $

# : $ % & (

'& $ '&

" / 3

9--0E2+*C

-2-1+ ( & : $ ( ! / 90.1+ C "

H / 3

H / &-920 5 6 (=7 " 4""(?4 = ?>= # / &&#!# /33# &

& &

? ' =& &!

!7 '!$ && &&/ /& &# ) H&(

! # ! ;

*1* # !

: # & #

/ 4(

% :$? /# & %

/ '& ) F &&&/ ?'")"

?): ")"'= =) ?7 =:$) ?)

?>=

: $ % # / & / #

# / J& # / & '& $ " : $ % / # % '&

/ / :$ % / & # /

/ ! #

/ # & &

"A= )'"")'= =)

:$ % / & # # /

3 / # / # #

: $ % "&

/ / # /

& & :$ % C

# :$

* * &/

& '& 7 !

/ '" / / & B

# /

: .5"6 ( +.+2-+,,! $ # : &! 5$

6 / & 4 /%

8 <J C &

& &

$ / # # & #/ H & % / &

& # '

& & &

! 4/ ! :$ ! # G ! && &! #/ &!

& # H !

& B 5(6 4 ! / +.+0-+,,! $

& 4 &

$ 56 #

/ +.+2-+,,

** 56

! / +,+.-+,-! &

/ &

# /

# /%

,0.9 "

3& 2 ?+0,,-+,-! '&F 4/ HF -+9,"$7 $ # / ! #! 9-!**21

&<.++ / / 4 B

# -1+E-+,+D " # -0+E-+,9#

E & !

&/ ! & +0+,-+,* / "4$" "= ? 4$"#

! 8 </% && & K )?"8,8-++,G-2+02 +*,+-++,! &

# # ! </% B # #! <

)*2! 89-8 C && & B!#

& / &

*4* )#!

/ / 4$" '& 4/ = ! #& /! / / & / 8 , ? -

:$ 9= & *? ' G " ! && G & 1? 4

&G & 21L / & / #

/ & /% #& 8 ,

G/ & /

/ / ),1/ 9 7 &G &/

& M-1L H

-1L / & 1+L / -1L / #1+L21L

21LB E5"6

!/ +*+.-+,1!&

+0+,-+,*

8 <

! " #&& # , ? -

:$ 9= & *? ' G " ! && G & 1? 4

* "* " 5 = ? )"8, 54(68-+,*GEE0 " 4$"

& # &

& /

& # & & /

5 G 6 '&B 5(6

= ? ! / +0+.-+,1! +0+,-+,*<

/ '&B 0 !

,-+9-+,1 &4 : $ 56

! / -*+9-+,1 # ! '&

# ! !

4 ! ! '&

;

#! ! #

,+5"6 ( 5" H G,E6 5 H/ ,9+2-+,16! C $'

& / & < & 4

/ &

G& # B 5(6

!/ -.+E-+,1!& # 8 <

,9+2-+,1 / /%

* J C / /% / H -.8$5 6

" 4 & $ !,0.1 /% & / & #

/ & # G

& / &

6B 56

!/ ,*+0-+,1! C ! !'&F )* ! !

# )* +0+,-+,* / "4$" 5$6 )*F !/ --+0-+,1! ! 8 < && & ! : 4 !

/% & / & #

/ & # G

& / &

/ &

(

/ "! 4$" "8,54(68 -+,*GEE0 +0+,-+,* #!

, ? -

:$ 9 = & * ?

' G " ! && G & 1 ? 4

! '& / C

* !* 5=6 ( -0,+-+,1! C )*F !

# & # 4$"; +0+,-+,* & & 4

$ 576 )*!/ +*,,-+,1! 8 <D /% / !

# & ) 'G

G-+,1G90-+ --+0-+,1" & & & & 4 & '8-*0-G$5(6G-+,*,1E2 -++,-+,* /$ #: &!/ &

4$" "8,54(68 -+,*GEE0 / # 4/ ( B ,, ( +1+,-+,. $ 4/ ( ! C 4

& G #&

/ 4 # # ; ;

" # / -2+,-+,. C $ ' ! #: &! & & ; / H ;/ C

* )* ,- ( +9+9-+,. C ! !'&! )?G &H

! !'&/ ,++9-+,. 8 <J C / H 4 & )'8-*0-8>=568-+,,G.111 +.+0-+,,

/% & / & ( 8"$$"' 5" & ! / "

& / ! #

& / & #

/ &

J / & 7"#

& / # &$ 5

6 ,9

-,+9-+,. )?G &

# / / 9++*-+,.#

8 8 <J

/ / !

! '&! ,,+*-+,. !'& /% & (?A8")$(

:$ 56 # G &&5 G =6 &

# 4 & / &

& / B ,*

/& & #

$ 4/ ( !!/ & +,+*-+,. !

; C && 4 I

$ ;I ? ;#

* 2* % & # #

48-+9, C / / 4 3 # & / 9 $ & 4/" "

!,021& & G 3 # C 821 / / 3

#! !

# ,021 "

! # & G

& / #

4 ,1 ?9++1-+,.

& / #

# / & ,0+1-+,2 ,.

# 8

"#$ "% & #$ '!( # "#!)"

'* )' +

" $ % &

" #

* 3*

" (

)

"# )'!

"#"))'+')'!

"#"%

#,$'!(

#"#!)"

'* )' $(- *+ "

# ( + + "

' , "

# ) , "

# +

,& - .

0 .

1 # " 2 0

3 $445

"#.( )"/

"# "# $' "% #* # "#!)"

'* )' $'

" # !

(

( ( (( ( 7 #

& ( ((

, " # "

" " 80 9

(# !

# 2 " .# 1 0 0

5: "

" "

" #

* 1* + (#

;

"#0( &&

"#%")&')1 $$ "#'!( #*!/' ,) #!"))'%$ !/')'"%(2

< -

= -

: -

: ( #

# + "

$ 3

(# 7

# ' #

# +

8 +

"#"

' , "

7 " !

# , "

# #

" #"

( +

5 '6 7 "#* !

"#$)'8 )'*!" '% %

'* 9!/' &&

++++++++ (

) ' 0( '% # !

"#$7 8 /

7 '

+ ++++++++ + ?

#@ #

# # ' #)

#) #) + ?

#@ #

(

# # ' ' :' )"&")!

"# "% !/' $ !' ;/ / 1 9 ' "<')'*;

#,$7+

" # # #

# #" # #

" # # # >

" #

# +

* *

" #

4444 7 <<B

" 4444

7 +

" # $

(

# @ ,2

& <.++ / / 4 B

#& / #

&8<.++ / / 4 B ,E D # #

&/ &8< /

/ 4 B ,0 "# !

,-+--+,, 8 / I % ! :$ % !

;

3 ;

<# &

& " # && /

&&/ B

% &

* 4* :$ %

# H& #

!# !

# / % -+

% #/ /& % # /

&<.++ / / 4 B

& H& & & / &

I;# / / -, 1 ,0.9"

C $ 8 &&

/ / 5-65 6 # /% #

/ . C / & /

# 81#

$ 4 2 # / #

# / *5,6 H

# $

& / / &

*!"* E #

9!.2 /

! $

% -- -.56 ,0.1 C

/ / $ / $ *0 #

/ # / &

& / &

! ! / / &D # ,E-* ,021"

-9

! #& 4&

,0.9 "

,0.1 / /

& & / / # #

# 7

& / & ! ! $ & 4

# &<-++8

B! $ # /

* &<.++ / / 4 B -* " ! &

C #

# &8I ;

&< / / 4 B -1

/ 4 & < / / 4 B &I ; # #

&I ;! & % & /

-. D # # / &< / / 4 B!#

# =

.1+ # #I;=8.1+ #

! ! I; -2

5,0.06,.-*! # / /%

# !

" 5"/ #6"

!,01.

8 <3 )%!

# #&

*!!*

/ ! /%

/ & ! /

/ "

& /

& <B "

& & <B </ & /& / &

& /% B

! <B < / & ! /%

/ & ! &!

/ ! ! B ? $ # <& / / # !

& /% ! / B "

# $

% & N 5,0126 -0,O

/ </ & # I; # & # H #

B "

% ' ( ) N 5,E0+6 ,* ( , 0O

< B & / # /

<% B

# / <" & /

& / # & / / 5# / / #

6 /

# " / / ! & # C

! #

& ! / & I% ; / H & C

*!)*

? & C B D & "

/ B <B

! # & # H#

D / H <

/ B #

C / / & /

/ / "

# & / A& "

# / /%

6B -E

# I; ! !/ H#

&<.++ / / 4 B

! ! / / 8

/ / /#

/ / &

/ & / -0 =

& # /

! # !# /

/ &

/ & &

# #

& /# /

*!2*

# / #

& ; % # & ; #

/ / 9+ / / I; H#

! ? /

;

& ! & !

# ! & /

7 ! ! # 4 ! / "

& !

/ ; /

# &< / / B # / / #

& " # $ ' ! # :

& -++. # "4$"

*!3*

# & 4$" -++. 9-

& & & 5?656 &

8*1 ! #

& / / # # # # 4$"

& /

/ # #

4$"

& C

4$"

% ;

! !

/ 4$" /

3& # /

/ / 4$" /

# # / 4$"

8,* # &

8*1 # #

& 5?6 56

8*1

& #

#& # / 99 & /

/ 4$" / -+++ &

9-**!'& 9-** <.++

/ 8 / B &

*!1* # '&

# C & & B '& / ! /!

G ? 9- ** & / & !

/ #& 8 < %' ' ='( J

#& &/

8 "6' ?& ' $ ! ( / 4 & ' P (6) ' G G?&3P

= (=4= ? #& / / & /

, ? ! -

$ 9= & *?

' G" G && G & 1? ,+L / & / / #

6B 9*

& 9-9*#

/ /

* 91

# ! ( $ ! ! / )-8 !4/ ( $ ! &

8. "

" )- ;

& )- / -2+0-+,. C "! 4$"!

"!4$"!/ ,9,--+,. 9-**# -+,+-+++ / # /

D &/ /

"!4$"! )- / / 4$" +*,+-++, 4$" 9- **! '& ,000 -+++ ! # !

4$"/ && & # H -* ,0.9"

9. " ,0,--+,2 # / > &! # !!$ # &! ! / ), 9

8,, # G +0+,-+,* / 4$" &

8,, 8 <,,

+0+,-+,* / 4$" # /

/ #

*!*

0 : ,+ /

/ C # 4$" # /

/ 4$" 4/ " "

# " "

B / #

#/ # # # & =

/ / &

/ &8<.++ / / 4

4$" & & 9-!**21! '&! #

<.++ / / 4 B

& +0+,-+,* / "!4$"! #

/ /4$"# /

/ *

! # ! / +*+.-+,1 &

# & #

= ? / +0+.-+,1 +0+,-+,* <

/ '&B

#! ! 4$""# # ! # /

/ --+0-+,1 ; C

*!4*

/ & 4

</ ! / "! 4$"! )"8,54(68-+,*GEE0 +0+,-+,* #! B 92 " % & / & # / & # /

# / +*,,-+,1,++9-+,. / )*8 !'&

+*,,-+,1 & & 4! &

4$" +0+,-+,*/ # 4/ ( 9E 7 # ! ; #

& 4$"! #

# # ! & / '

/#& /

/ ,E -* $ & 4/" "

!,021#

8 = '!

"# 0' 6

# 0

" 8 "

# C 2

- !

# "

+ + !

" + !

*)"*

"#6:(";')!"1 >') '$7

" ( #

$ 8 &

# # #

" #

'D (#

<) #

)

) #

=) #

;) (#

" $0 8 &

# # #

" 0

(

C - . " #

' , #

> # >

# # &

- ,

E +

" #

) , #

# "

" " # )

*) * , #

) "

, # #

) < *" 0

- 9#

@ 90

#! # !

C 4$"

&# ,E<) & "

# ' B5

6 ,021 "

& ' ,E

/ ' "

# &

& 4$" H #

,E # ,E

/ # ,E & ,021"

,0.9"

,021"

#! ! ,E

*)!* *+ -* ,021 "

# & D & H ' ,E # ,0.9"

-* ,0.9"

# -* ,0.9"

8 <!2) & "

# ' C # / & !

& H # "

/ & B

& "

# # ' C # / &

# ' # / & # '

*))* &

*- ( && ! # /

& # #

& # H& / # & / / ! # / /

& D H # & *9 " & & /

& !#

# & & <.++ / / 4 B D # / & ;

# & / & #

/ D #

# / & 4$" / &

!# # /

& # /

*)2* ** D # 4$" /1++E 9-**'&#

999 / & # # && / !#

8 & / / *2++ 5/ 0*L6 9- ** 21

# /

# & *1

& !

& # & &

/ &

/ $ # & /

/ *. # ! #

# # *2 ! #'

-. & ' )"

# '' & G Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No