← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17825/2017dismissed

Diamond Avenue Green Field Karan Vihar Society Th Its Residents v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-11-20Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages





      

 !" #

$ %&'

(")*+,- #. #

(,/  0.    /.  1((  23(  4)5.  &(63(  (/.

,*(

 2*0* 4(" 06(-%3*

*7/* 

 !"#$ %&'()$ % *+&

)(( # !"#$ %&'()$ )(

# ,,,

*+ & ./)(.

"37

& 43*307(.4 . 06(-.

"34(

& *38( (*3(./)(.

"*7/* %9

& (,/4:3./)(.

"*7/ !

;;;;;

)(

#-%

<(,/0. /.1((23(4)5.

30:340=3-4:3-:4)(=>20.3(*7"/3 7* 0-)*?:()(,:3"8:"+< @ 



 

                      

     ! "    #  

 $% 

  " 

&  &      $



%

   $%   

# 

 

  $ &&



  % 

 '   $ $%&  %   

  &       (

    

)    % 

 

        *+$      %        

   , & .  (/  )0*  7*:  3  7< 4)5*0-,/3(3)5(",/8(*(77/-53 &0)7(  7(  ,*(    3  5(  ###  (3<<(8  "

*7/ !<(4:3(/3*-3((64:3838* "(/-(:13(*(*

A> B$A<

'(/ A> .83)38(**/ 7*-5*7/ !(*( 8"5  *7/ !

:(5)()3/073((""7(=:(/7(="3*/* "3(,/0(/3)*-5*(:(*,(*)(/0*5 "),-)=*(/))/08(/,((3*3(7"*(/. )0*3.,()35(/ *)= "-)=* 37.-:(*)( 8=.(77()3/3(03*(:833*/*"3((-5 ,:*7(((77)(*.-0"((  "3(77)(3(* -(C/(*C0 <9

8(*(*(:0/3(((77)("/,()("3 (/-(:=3(*(0,-*(",/8(*(*,/.83 8(*"0/3(*7/ !8(*38"9&((*"(/ 13(*(

A> B$A<

'(/9&((*13(*(

A> .83)33 3(*((/5)*0)/330*  ")8(*,(/(//(/

#

##A//  AD" ##9$0* 8,2*0*4(" 06(-%3'.83-583/*7*:"

3(",/87.3"8:/)*8**0/+<   

       

.

             

  

  

    



  

   

 !"   #$   % 

   & 

       

  



  

'

 (  )*&+&+**,       -

   

         

         

      

    

     

  '

          

  

         



  

        

 .  (    /  0     

 1 

       

 '

     .   (           

  

  1

  2 &

 

            

   

 

   

    

   

   1

 

 '

    .   (            

           "

     .

  (



  

        . (

   



     

   &2  

     .    '

    .   (        

       

                 

   



    

    &     3      3

      &

/



"

  .

 (



      

       '

    .   (           

       3

    4 (



2-5  



 

     "

 

  .

   (

        

      

  & 

     '

     

   

 

       

       

  .   (                  

  

  

 



  .     

     

       

 

&6  

        



  

      



      

 



! "     

  # $    

"      " %  "   &

 " 

   '

  "

  

   #

   #   $  (

"  #  "    

  "   ")    * *    $  

    +,-    !./  ! .!. 0

 *  

01, )   

 * *  "  2

 - 3 4, 



  

 

"#   



  5 )  "    

           

       

    *  *   

            !  

"  "   6 

""

    &   

            &  & 

 *  !.1 , ) / ,   5 )  "  "  "   

  (  "

   )&*   .0  ! !. .     "    

& 

    1!.

2

   - 3!4    )&  )            5  ) 

    #"

 

 

    * *  &  

" 6  

  -& 7 "  $"

    

&     * *   &

    

     

 

 "    " 

     8  (  

     "

"       *  -&   8   

  $"

2

 - 34   *  #   

 !

0 $

* 5   

 5 )  "                      3 

  "

"  & 

 "       

0

     &      

   &  # &   9 * "  

"  

 # !...

  

   

 #   "  &  

: 

"     

  #5 )   

" 

 #   

5        5 )  "  #    & " " 

 !

0  &    " 

3  #   "   "

& !!1!. +    &#"  ;

<+& 7 0  2 &)830

 1  +***1         

 &#   

   





   



    

  



  &7   

 9  2 &)+, ):  )+, ++   & 7 

      & ;& 7    



 

   



   &7   

            

 &$        &                &8

  



     2 &)830       

  

        . (      ++&*:&+*)< 

        &=    1      



&7     &8                 

  

 



  



   ! 

.(  



   

  &8&6 = >& 

   

 

 

 1  

5  )   

"    "     

       

       5 )  

     &   9 "#

 

 

        

 

  $"



 - 3

  "       "       #  

    "    "   

      "

&     &

        &    . 9 

    

 #       5 

          (   



  

   &  ! .!.  

  ,     +,-  &      * * 

   

#  & #   & "   

     "  "   

 # " 

 "  %

) ""      

"   

   5 )   >   5 

  #         

     ,  %  &      ,    %  -  !. .  2     <!. .  -?4   "  @    ( #  ,  %

    "  !. .- "  & $ "



* ")  "  

 ;





   

   !

 "#$$ 



%& '(%)%* +(  )) ()*%&(

( %),,*%-.(   % *( #%

'( *

((/(%'  '( *('

.(

/ (*. '

( , ((%'

*   , ). %

* '( '  * (%*'* (, * %'&%(-

%*'( *

('-%- '( 

") '.". +.%) '

))-( 0  - *. 

  '( *

(  (/(%'    

,*( .

'

& * '( /%*1  2(

'( *

((/(%'

  (  )%*  3- %' ' .( %* * %)( )4

( %)(

5/  % *( 6  ' "+ * - *(,, * %

* "&. ( , ((%'

*(% ,% (',,*%,*( &% '(+( (

/ (*.  (%    ,    %&, '

(%'8% (  (%  (

, * %'8'

(( (%'  + %  &.    )%*   (%  %'(

(  (

(/(%'"  +    (&( .  )% '  (%    - 9(%

"

)*-%%

%*&)  :*'*."( &. '( *('

%''.

;

( %)-(, &,%*(' "

  < %' % *&(( *   / (  * ' 

((%'

)*%&*%(-(&   

((%'

 %&,''/  %)  *

& '(  %*  (%*( *  %) , * %'

 %'/'/     (

"   *

'  %( *  7+*  

 .  (  %( *  %*  .  (

,%   

((%'

*  , *(''/  (%  '-*%'& '(  ,% (%'"

 ( *' %) %%/' ")%*

('+)  )

((%'

* %&,''/-%(%'%) &'*/ (  =

/ (*.  '(( (%- *).( '( '(

%) , * %'" % (.%*'

%(%'+ %'-%7

(

;

* (%'  %)  (  5/  % *(  %'  (  

 %)  , 

1

'( *

(  > *  (

/ (*.    '.  % (  %' 

'( '( "'%)) '%( (%(  )) (  , ( ,"

9 ,(%'( , ((%'

+  * * - .,% ( ?

'( *

(

((%'

* - ( *% / ,% (  '%( '( *('

 9 ,('( )%%+'/

<@ 

((%'

'(.,* %'

* ' ( '



((%'

%&,''/-%(%'%) &'*/ ( 

((%'

7'/+*('( '( * %)   %*,

- 

((%'

 +(   

 %) 

  '( *  ( ( ( &.

* *

%@&%(  ,*%

'/  .  (  % *(  '  C

 '( *

(DA -

((%'

.)''.%*, .

.  , * %'

"

&'%*  '8%*  %,,*

 

(%'

 %)  % (.  

, ((%'

 )'/  '  (   ( /%*.  &.  

'(  (%  (

& * * (*.%) (  ((  / *-

 ( %*(.

%' *'

"+ %"%' ( )(%'* /*'// '

'

'

%) ( , ((%'

*"&.,*%-  (  /' '/ % '

(%( -(& E(

%@&%( , ((%'

'(( .( 5/  % *(

 , ( , )%* ( )4

( )%* ' ('/(

&  )%* ',,*%,*(  '  , **% ( *+( '

( *

.

F 3E0*",(((-5" 0-)*?:( )(,-/-(/07-"3*)3"3*0 234 ' 563 7

8 9:9(6 '3  :

2349-// # .0 3(7((:(73*9(/A"3*(/60/:,(/30*+< - ."   $ %$   /0 121 "     

  $    3  "   

     4 /%$  %    

  "   %/    

% 

             %



  $%    3    

 

% 



     

    "  " "  % $%% " 35

6 

% 



  6

%

%          "    $         $   & $%$    %



 $%/

       

 

% %                    7    $     / , 0       &    "

   

 

 * * 

 

 

     

      

,  % +    

    



  $    $   

   !!/3!!

)  ,

  , &    &            #" - #"

"  $ % *+&

)(( #   )(

# %&;<$  %&;<$

 =4 - 3= 6 6 9> 3? 5@

* 9@

6 6 

> 34

* 9@