← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25576/2013allowed

Jagdish Singh Rana v. Financial Commissioner Cum Principal Sec & ORS

2015-04-30Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages

ARCHANA ARORA 2015.05.13 10:42 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

    

 !" #"$%&%'()*%+



 ,#%&-.%',- '

 "!%!%'"*& /"*&0& -"%' '$% +11%&&%'"*2$012*%'$%) +."$*"! *3 '# !-"*&  "&)'#"'!& 4( 564.46  

   



  



   





    

!!!!

"

# 



 

$

%  &'( ) *

+ $    )

, # &'( '

 $ 

() 1%! 7 + 8* +9 

(  %  "- .

*-"

(   $

  ** *-"

0' "/  (  *-"* "34 %$

' (   % ''

    ' 

5 $   '' '   $

   (   % 6'

   &'  

  &'(  .

"* *--3

  &'(

 0 $ %  

         

     

   !"     " 

                               #"      "    "   

    $%   "            

      

                   &    

 '(()* +

   

    ,-      

 "      "      .'(()*

+

  /              

     

  

   0         

            

              1 

   

    

  &     

.'(()* +

                    "



              

"     2         "       



  " "

    /

    

      3

     $  (  %

 '



 $'(  

5 %'

 $   ( "-   %$

5'

7  (

  % (  



  **8  6

        (

(  & % 

2- 4      /"

 "     4456+ 44    #(7+   (7+  8)/ 9  :  -

   2    

        5     (!(7+ 2 

  

  # 2    "

      " 

   

     



"     "

    6         +  

 6  +             (()*      

   0      3 9 %   



( 7 5' :  5'  '$ $

%

0 

   *- ";;-

  

:

0

  **  6



 (  0 $ % 2,        (4 /  4

  5 .

(()* +

3 9 '( 0  6'



(   ' /          (4# 4   ;        

    (!(7  6+       

 .

'(()* +

/      

       

     ; 2        

  <   "  

        

       

5      3 < $

(   &'(  %  % (  ".

*-"- "*4

< (( '(  ( 

   %  $

 =

:'

 

   7 >'

  >( (

  7 

  % '    0        .

"* *--3





 '

    $ (    

  

$' '      '

6'

 % 

% 6'

  $ % $'(   0   (

:

6'

 */ *-""

"?4

'( '  =

:'

 

   7 >'

  *-"* ( @( A  6'

  '

   "- .

*-"

"/4  % ' % (   % ''

 

 ' '$ &'(  .

"* *--3 % 

( $

% 

 :'

:

(' 

 0  0' 1  (' 6'

(   &'(   B

 ('  "

0  ' 2  

     

  2       $         

  

      2

      

        

                 21="2 %

     

  >      --  6 

   8          

  "

        

 "

       3  ' '$  % (  '  (

  '

 '

   %  $

:

>'(



  



    '$ @( A *-"* "34  %  

:' %    $

6'

 %  0(   ' %   ' 

(

&'  %   ' 

'

 ";/.

 

 '

    $B

(  0 2'4

   '$  %  ( (    B% $'  

$( ' 

'

C            %   %  B   ((   

 6'

  

6'

  0( %   %

  % ' $

  (  ' (  '

    (

0 

   6'

 0 ' /      

 



=   +=    "         0

  !((44? @ %% 6

;66  6 "      

 "

6 :

6 '/;/ "        "

     2          0

  

  "A* '  0

  >7' 3 A* %  " 

                   &    

 '(()* +

 

 

   ,-           

  "    

   "   

 .'(()* +

/     

   

      

   0     

             

     

           &   

 .'(()* +

 

      " 

     

"     B  "  

    

    "  "

       /

      

     3 2     

;

  "   

     "

 6  :

  '  /;/    ,

"      

  

 2@ %:

0

 

            

    

               CCCCCC3  >  

       /

;  :

6/9:" 0

 

!(44!              

"  @ %% >    0

  !(44!0

  @ 2 % 6 ;  "  "

6:

6  ' /  ;  /     2  0



 !((44?

"   61="1 %    

  /              "     

   " "

6:

6 ' /;/ "

;  /                     "    52   

 

             

"   " +

   0

 @ %:

6 ;-   !((44?

 0

" 



              

  6:

'/;  /   " 

 

      >      "  

     6  :



< 6  ' /  ;  /     

   %A*2

 6:

6  '/;/); /  -  

 3 @( A *-"* "34    % : :

'

5    '

$ ' '   ' <

'

 *

: :

' ' 

 ::

 % %  &'(  :'  $ 

(  B(  



B $ '(

 ('  B (' 

6' (  $

:

:' %$

:

:'  

(   7 

% 

 '   

  $

 5'  

9

('

  

   $

 :'

(    

  % 6'

     %

%

5   6'

 %    $'  :  ' %  (  ( (      >'

7 $'  

  (  ' %

( $ 

$ '  ' % B

(



 

(



$ $

( ( 

(  "   $'



  '(

5 % %  $ $ '( "- .

*-"

"/4 (  *-"* "34  $

6'

%  (

%

8469 )*%+

  *$- '