High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18881/2021allowed

Rohit Kapoor v. Central Board Of Secondary Education And Others

2021-11-12Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal9 pages

!

"

#$ !%&!

'$ ()'##')

!

" !

$%& '''''

#')* ( " )*++ ,- &.&$ /

/

/

- "/

/ - /

0 3 1

/

&

( )*++ ,-/"

2

# 4)

"1- - ")* ,- 5

6 -

" "7&.$8 ( )*

&.

.9 &.$8 ! ,

)$

: 2-1 )-) ; ! ,

)&< "-)*+

# 4) &.$9

)*+ ,- /

- )*++ &.&.

,-= - "1 )*++ ,-/ 2- -2 / 2

# $

,-/"

2-2-

2

/

2 1

+ / 2

$% & 2

-/ )* ,-/

1> ( / -)*+ (2 1

"

)*++ ,- ( /1 -

( ! ,

)$?4 / / /

)* ,- - # + :

1 ;#+:< ( 2

1 /

: - -2 / ! -

- /

,- - 1

)* ,- - / /

1> ( /

@

+-2

# 4)A

1

2-

"-)*+ 2 2 6 -

"" 1 )-)(

/ (

# 4) / 2 2A /

2

# $ ( / 1 2-

2

# 4)

+

(

/-

2 ! /

1

/ 1 (

/ - 2

/ -

1- /A 2

C

!" #

:

$%& 2- 1 ,- )5/ $99B; 7 &.$4<;

)5/< ! ,

)$?$ 0

1> 3 -

1> ? 2 ? 6

- + (

- &;,</1

C

1> C E @;2< - )*+ ? ,- 2

1> !

1> 2 2

/ / ! ,

)$?&/6 -

"" ( /

"

- )*+ = $.

$;<;< / ? ,- -C

1> C/ "

)*++ ,- ( 1 /

= /1 -

- ! ,

?4

)*

,- -#+: (

:

( )*

,- - 6 -

" "

"-)*+

# 4) 2 / ")*++ ,- ( -

""

1> 2 ( F 2 /

/

1 -

&;, < D $

1 11 -

1 F

2 / ) -./! 01

2 CC-

-./!3 ;< !

"1-CC/ - ;< 2

1

1 2

1 +H ;< F1 F F1

,--"1- - H ;<

F

1 -;--- -,--< - 2 # - !4 !"%!" 2 /

H ; <

< 5 1 ?(

1 2 + 1

F

/

/H 2< - ;< 1 F1 F F1

,-H '<= -

1 2 - 2 2 /

G

1 1 ! $88D 2 - -2

2 $@;$< ( +6( := +5G# (: = !#G:

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 ''<#2 - "1 $@;&< ( +6( := +5G# (:

= !#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 '';2< 1 -2 ;< &

/ G2 ;F :

= < ! $99B

1

-

/ ! 4;&< ( +6( := +5G# (: = !#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9

'';< J

2

, 1 2

- 1-

- 2 - 1

/

- 1 /

1

1 - / - )- - 2

2

-

2

-

4;@<(+6(:=+5G#(:=!#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 ';<;<= ! 2) ;<; < ;< &- + ,

1 ( +6( := +5G# (: = !#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9

2 11/ "

1 12

- -

/

;< & -

;< -

$&;$<;< ( +6( := +5G# (: = !#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 ;<( 2) ; < ;< & 1

-

;<2) ;$< 2

-2

2

, ))

- - /

- -2

2

-2 ,

)

)

2 2) ;< ;< &

/

21

-2

1

21 F -

2

-2 , 21 $&;&<(+6( := +5G# (: = !#G :

5:I G!(+:#!( &..9 ';

<# / -1

2A

1

1

$4;$< ( +6( := +5G# (: = !#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 !

2

) ;<

2 2 / /- , -

;2< 2A

1

2 2 / /- , / )

2 F

-2 -- - $4;&<(+6(:=+5G#(:=!#G :

5:IG!(+:#!( &..9 17 -"- "$ ;< ! /2

1 /

1 2 2

1 2 ? (

6

- 2 - KK 2 ;<

1 2-

;2< CL1,-C / ,- 1 / -"

- H F ,-C- ,- 2

1 ?+

1 2 ?

1 2

F

1 ,- 2 2 KK ?

1 2 M

! D $;<;</ 1

1> 2 2

1> 2 "

- $.

, ;< - + 1

1> 2 - $$

+ / 2

/-2

$ %& - / "- )*+ - 2

# 4)

/ "

- +

-/ > 1 2

$%&

) -

"

-

( 1 -

2

+/ "/ - 1 -

1 - 1 ( /

+

# 4/

2

/

2

"

1 $%&

2

- / -"

+

$!2

/

F /

/ -

-

2 (A1- F

$&

=

/ /

! ,

)D/

2

2

1 2 1 F $%&)

/

" -

A1- ?

0#')2 !%&! *

% & $ '

(

) % & * $&+

)