Sunil Kumar Arya v. Chief Administrator Haryana State Agriculture Marketing Board And ORS
!"#$%!&'(()'*" + '$,'"- #".+
/-#-#"/( /(*!* +#/0&#"#*-('-( '()'"' -'-/.(#1!$-!(/2'(3/-#".
'(0 2'"0#+','"'"0-+/(*
/*4"0/"-* 2 5 2 5 2 5 2 5
6 2
7
6 2
7
6 2
7
6 2
7
6 2
6 2
6 2
6 2
(/*/"- (/*/"- (/*/"- (/*/"- 2( '"' /"#(081'-/,#-+ 2( ()' 081'-/(-+/4/-#-#"/( 2( '0'&3'"- ,#8/0# 081'-/(-+/(/*4"0/"-* 9:9:9:
9:9:9:
9:9:9:
9:9:9:
+/#"*-'"-,(#-4/-#-#"#*0#(/1-/0'.'#"*--+/(0/( 0'-/0 ""/<!(/ 4'**/0=)(/*4"0/"- -+/ +#/0&#"#*-('-( '()'"' -'-/.(#1!$-!('$2'(3/-#".'(0 '"1+3!$' ,+/(/=) -+/ =/"/#- ,'#8/( #"-/(/*- " -+/ #"*-'$&/"-*'$$#".0!/'-/(;
> ># -+/0'-/#**!'"1/ 1&4$/-#"1/(-##1'-/-+/*+4#"?!/*-#"+'*=//"0/1$#"/0 +/4/-#-#"/(!(-+/(*//3*-+/*/--#".'*#0/-+/1'$1!$'-#" *+//- '- ""/<!(/ > #" -/(&* ,+#1+ -+/ 1"*/?!/"-#'$ 0/&'"0'*!&@A ;B5!4- +'*=//"('#*/0 +/4/-#-#"/(,'*'$$--/0*+4 C #"-+/('#"
2'(3/- '4$# #*-(#1- '"#4'-=),')'!1-#"1"0!1-/0"
C ('--'$1"*#0/('-#"@ B5 ,/"-)#8/ 4/(1/"- -+/ *'$/ 1"*#0/('-#" '&!"- # @ > AB5 ,'* 0/4*#-/0=)-+/4/-#-#"/('--+/-#&/'11/4-'"1/+#*=#0 '"0 -+/ ='$'"1/ *'$/ 1"*#0/('-#" @A D B5 ,'* - =/ 0/4*#-/0#"*#</?!'$+'$)/'($)#"*-'$&/"-*,#-+#"-/(/*-EF 4/( '""!& '* 4/( 1"0#-#" 1"-'#"/0 #" -+/ '$$-&/"- $/--/( 0'-/0 +/#(*-#"*-'$&/"-,'*-=/0/4*#-/0"( =/(/ > > +/4/-#-#"/(+'8#".-'3/"4**/**#"-+/ *#-/#"?!/*-#"1&4$/-/01"*-(!1-#"-+/(/!4"=)-+//"0
/1/&=/( '"0 " ;
> !("#*+/0 ' (/?!/*- - (/*4"0/"- 5 /1(/-'()2'(3/-&&#--// '4$# #*-(#1- '"#4'- ( #**!'"1/ -+/ 1/(-##1'-/ 1&4$/-#" +/ 1&4$/-#"1/(-##1'-/0'-/0;
> > #"(/*4/1--+/*+4#"
?!/*-#",'*0!$)#**!/0=)-+/1&4/-/"-'!-+(#-) +/#(*- #"*-'$&/"-,'*0/4*#-/0=)-+/4/-#-#"/(" >'$".,#-+ #"-/(/*- " '11!"- > 0')*6 0/$') -+'- +'0 11!((/0 ( 0/4*#--+/*'&/ > " #-* &//-#". +/$0 " ;
> > -+/ 2'(3/- &&#--// '4$# #*-(#1- '"#4'- 1"*#0/(/0 -+/ './"0' '* (/.'(0*,'#8/(#"-/(/*-"-+/(/&'#"#".#"*-'$&/"-*-=/4'#0 =)-+/4/-#-#"/("'11!"-+#*+'8#".1&4$/-/01"*-(!1-#" "-+/*+4,#-+#"-+/*-#4!$'-/0-#&/('&/'"0-.#8/=/"/#- -+/ #"*-(!1-#"* #**!/0 =) -+/ '()'"' -'-/ .(#1!$-!('$ 2'(3/-#".'(0G(*+(-6-+/'(06H#"*!1+(/.'(0 4) -+/4(1//0#".*0'-/0;
> >4$'1/0"(/1(0'"0'44/"0/0 '*""/<!(/ ,!$0*+,-+'-'(/*$!-#",'*4'**/0=)-+/ 2'(3/-&&#--//-.#8/-+/=/"/#-,'#8/(#"-/(/*-"
> (/&'#"#".#"*-'$&/"-*-=/4'#0=)-+/4/-#-#"/('"0-*/"0 -+/ 1'*/ ( #"'$ '44(8'$ - -+/ '(0 /'0?!'(-/(* '- '"1+3!$'
#0/1&&!"#1'-#"0'-/0 > -+/&'--/(,'* (&'$$) (,'(0/0 =) -+/ 2'(3/- &&#--// '4$# #*-(#1- '"#4'---+/+#/0&#"#*-('-(-+/'(0(.('"-=/"/#- ,'#8/(#"-/(/*-"-+/='$'"1/#"*-'$&/"-*=)*4/1##1'$$) *-'-#".-+'-'-/(#**!'"1/'$$-&/"-$/--/(0'-/0 -+/ '$$--//B4(/*/"- 4/-#-#"/( +'0 1&4$/-/0 -+/ 1"*-(!1-#" -+/(/!4"'"0+'0'44$#/0(1&4$/-#"1/(-##1'-/"; > '"0-+/*'&/*-0#**!/0";
> > -,'*!(-+/(*-'-/0-+'- -+/'$$--//+'04'#0-+/#(*-#"*-'$&/"-'$".,#-+#"-/(/*-" > 44'(/"-$) -+/#**!/,#-+(/.'(0-.('"-=/"/#- ,'#8/(#"-/(/*-"-+/='$'"1/#"*-'$&/"-*--+/4/-#-#"/( (/&'#"/04/"0#".,#-+-+/'(08/('1"*#0/('=$/$/".-+ -#&/ $/'0/01'*/-+/4/-#-#"/(#*-+'-+/+'0(/4/'-/0$) '44('1+/0 -+/ 2'(3/- &&#--// '4$# ( 0/4*#- -+/ #"*-'$&/"-*# 4(#"1#4'$'&!"- =!--+/*'&/,'*(/!*/0" -+/4(/-/<--+'-'#"'$0/1#*#",#-+(/.'(0-,'#8/(#"-/(/*- +'0"-)/-=//"-'3/"
"0/(*!1+1#(1!&*-'"1/* -+/4/-#-#"/( +'0 /8/" .- ' $/.'$ "-#1/ 0'-/0 C A */(8/0 !4"
(/*4"0/"-* '"0>=),')(/.#*-/(/04*-1'$$#".!4" -+/&-.('"-=/"/#-,'#8/(#"-/(/*-'*'$*-'11/4--+/ #"*-'$&/"-*-+'-+'0=/1&/0!/#"-+/#"-/((/."!&=!-$#&#-/0 - -+/ 4(#"1#4'$ '&!"- * " 4*#-#8/ (/*4"*/ ,'* (-+1&#". -+/4/-#-#"/(#$/0'1&4$'#"-=/(/-+/ #*-(#1- "*!&/( #*4!-/* /0(/**'$ (!& '"#4'- !"0/( -+/
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
-&')=/"-#1/0-+'-'"'44/'$4(//((/0=)-+/ (/*4"0/"-5'(0'.'#"*--+/(0/(0'-/0A A4'**/0=) -+/ #*-(#1-(!& '"#4'-,'*'$$,/0=)-+/ -'-/"*!&/(
#*4!-/* /0(/**'$ &&#**#" '()'"' 8#0/ (0/( 0'-/0 '"0'8#/,,'*-'3/"-+'--+/1&4$'#"-#-*/$,'*"- &'#"-'#"'=$/'*-+/4/-#-#"/(,'*"-'1"*!&/( /-#-#"/(-+/(/'-/(4(//((/0'"'44/'$!"0/( /1-#"
-+/ !"K'= .(#1!$-!('$ (0!1/ 2'(3/-* 1- CD '"0 !"0/(-+/ !"K'=.(#1!$-!('$ (0!1/2'(3/-*1-G/"/('$!$/* CD'44$#1'=$/-'()'"'H'.'#"*--+/1+'(.#".#"-/(/*-" -+/='$'"1/*'$/51"*#0/('-#"-+/*+4 !1+'44/'$*-'"0* 0/'$-,#-+8#0/#&4!."/0(0/(0'-/0 4'**/0=)-+/ 0&#"#*-('-( '(0 /-#-#"/( +'* =//" 0#(/1-/0 - 4') #"-/(/*- E F 4/( '""!& " -+/ ='$'"1/ #"*-'$&/"-* "
!(-+/('"1/*!1+(0/(0'-/0 4'**/0=)-+/+#/
0&#"#*-('-(5(/*4"0/"- 2'(3/- &&#--// '4$#
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
4/(!*'$ $'!*/ -+/ 1"*$#0'-/0 #"*-(!1-#"* (/54(0!1/0+/(/#"'=8/ ,!$0&'3/#-1$/'(-+'-#- #*#"-+/"'-!(/.('"-1"1/**#"-'"'$$--//,'#8/( #"-/(/*-"-+/!-*-'"0#".#"*-'$&/"-*4(8#0/0+/1&4$/-/* -+/1"*-(!1-#"'*4/('44(8/04$'"'"0'$**+#-*+#*=!*#"/** -*!1+4(/&#*/*,#-+#"'*4/1##14/(#0-,)/'(*(&-+/ 0'-/'$$-&/"- "*!1+/8/"-!'$#-) #"-/(/*-#*1+'(./'=$/"$) !4--+/0'-/#**!/-+/1&4$/-#"1/(-##1'-/ "-+/4(/*/"-1'*/ -+/0'-/'$$-&/"--+/*+4 #"?!/*-#"#"'8!(-+/4/-#-#"/(#* +/4/-#-#"/( 1&4$/-/0 -+/ 1"*-(!1-#" #" /1/&=/( #-*/$ '"0 -+/(/'-/(-+/1&4/-/"-'!-+(#-)!"0/(-+/2'(3/-&&#--// /8/"#**!/0-+/1&4$/-#"1/(-##1'-/";
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
-+/1'*/4!-(-+"=/+'$-+/(/*4"0/"-5'(0-+'--+/ 4/-#-#"/(,'*"-/$#.#=$/(-+/.('"-1"1/**#"/"8#*'./0 !"0/($'!*/-+/1"*$#0'-/0#"*-(!1-#"* /,!$0+'8/ "+/*#-'-#"#"+$0#".-+'--+/'1-#"-+/(/*4"0/"-5'(0 +'*=//"!"K!*-'"0'(=#-('() /,!$0'$*=/#"1$#"/0-'11/4--+/1"-/"-#" ('#*/0"=/+'$-+/4/-#-#"/(-+'-+/,'*(/'0)'"0,#$$#".- 0/4*#--+/4(#"1#4'$'&!"--+/#"*-'$&/"-*0!/#"(/$'-#"- -+/*+4#"?!/*-#"
"-'3#".*!1+8#/, ,/'(/#"$!/"1/0=) -+/'1--+'-"-+#".+'*=//"4$'1/0"(/1(0-*+,-+'--+/ (/*4"0/"-5'(0'-'")4#"--#&/('#*/0'0/&'"0"-+/ 4/-#-#"/((0/4*#--+/4(#"1#4'$'&!"-#"*-'$&/"-* -+/1"-('() -+/4/-#-#"/(+'0.-*/(8/0!4"-+/(/*4"0/"-*
'$/.'$"-#1/0'-/0C A('11/4-'"1/-+/#"*-'$&/"-* 0!/'"0$#&#-/0--+/4(#"1#4'$'&!"- +/'1-!&-+/1$'#& -+/4/-#-#"/((/.'(0#".,'#8/(#"-/(/*-"-+/!-*-'"0#". #"*-'$&/"-*+'8#".(/&'#"/04/"0#".(&(/-+'"'0/1'0/+'* ."/!"1"-(8/(-/0 /'0#"/**'"0,#$$#"."/**"-+/4'(- -+/ 4/-#-#"/( - 0/4*#- -+/ 4(#"1#4'$ '&!"- #"*-'$&/"-* ,!$0=/(/$/1-/0(&+#*1"0!1-,+/(/=)'-/(4'**#".-+/ (0/(0'-/0A A4'**/0=)-+/ #*-(#1-"*!&/( #*4!-/* /0(/**'$(!& '"#4'- -+/!-*-'"0#". 4(#"1#4'$'&!"- @D > B5,'*0/4*#-/0" ;
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
1'$1!$'-#".#"-/(/*-!4- '(/*/-'*#0/ "*4#-/+'8#".*+/$0#"'8!(-+/4/-#-#"/( ,/ '(/-+/1"*#0/(/08#/,-+'-/8/"#-+/1"1/**#"B#"1/"-#8/ ,'* 4/(&#--/0 - -+/ '$$--// +/ ,'* *-#$$ $#'=$/ - 4') -+/ (/&'#"#". #"*-'$&/"-* # -+/ 4(#"1#4'$ '&!"- '* 4/( -+/ *-#4!$'-/0-#&/('&/1"-'#"/0#"-+/'$$-&/"-$/--/( "!( 8#/, -+/ /"0* K!*-#1/ ,!$0 =/ &/- !4" -+/ 4/-#-#"/( 0/4*#-#". #"-/(/*- E ;F 4/( '""!& (& -+/ 0'-/ -+/ (/*4/1-#8/B*!11/**#8/ #"*-'$&/"- =/1'&/ 0!/ -#$$ -+/ 0'-/ 0/4*#--+//"-#(/!-*-'"0#".'&!"-&'0/=)-+/4/-#-#"/( # ;
(0/(/0'11(0#".$) /*4"0/"-5'(0,!$0 ",*/(8/!4"-+/4/-#-#"/(,#-+#"'4/(#0!(,//3*(& -+/ 0'-/ (/1/#4- ' 1/(-##/0 14) -+#* (0/( ' (/*+ 1'$1!$'-#" *+//- #" -/(&* -+/ 0#(/1-#"* 1"-'#"/0 +/(/#"'=8/ +/ 4/-#-#"/( #" -!(" ,!$0 =/ =$#.'-/0 - 0/4*#- -+/ '&!"- '* 4/( (/8#*/0 1'$1!$'-#" *+//- ,#-+#" ' 4/(#0!(,//3*-+/(/'-/( /-#-#"0#*4*/0#"-+/'(/*'#0-/(&* G
7 H G
7 H G
7 H G
7 H G
H G
H G
H G
H
2
2
2
2
-/
-/
-/
-/ +/-+/((//((/0-/4(-/(LG /*B H +/-+/((//((/0-/4(-/(LG /*B H +/-+/((//((/0-/4(-/(LG /*B H +/-+/((//((/0-/4(-/(LG /*B H