← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25696/2013disposed of

Sukhwinder Singh & ORS v. Panjabi University Patiala & ANR

2024-04-22Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!"#$!% &'# (&")*+*',*"* *#*"-!%*' ./01 .

23451678751. 9:;<=> ?@ABCDEBFGHGCIJ11K./K1.1/ LMNOPGIEBQLGIRO<;QH KKK4BAGAGCIBQH SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@<[IQ KKK\BH]CIEBIAH 23451^6_151. 9:;<=> ?BW4@QN@HOLGIRO KKK4BAGAGCIBQ SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@<[IQ KKK\BH]CIEBIAH 2345178 651. 9:;<=> `MQEBB]LGIRO KKK4BAGAGCIBQ SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@<[IQ KKK\BH]CIEBIAH 234566_51. /:;<=> a@RHGQLGIRO KKK4BAGAGCIBQ SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@<[IQ KKK\BH]CIEBIAH 234587^^51. /:;<=> b@QEBB]LGIROLGEOM@IE;AOBQH KKK4BAGAGCIBQH SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@ KKK\BH]CIEBIA 2345 .7/.51. /:;<=> =@I]QBBAc@MQ KKK4BAGAGCIBQ SBQHMH 4MIT@UGVIGWBQHGAXY4@AG@Z@<[IQ KKK\BH]CIEBIAH

!"#$ %&'($ )&'*+,-.

/01012345647892 :::#4;1;19245 <45=>= #>2?@A1B21C45=1;DE#@;1@F@,/25 :::G4=H92342;= !"#$& &('$ )&I*+,-.

6@2;9=868@5J@ :::#4;1;19245 <45=>= #>2?@A1B21C45=1;DE#@;1@F@,+;845= :::G4=H92342;=  KL  MNOPQKRSTUVWQLLMLTXLKY ZZZZZ #54=42;[ -5:\@]?9;612]8E/3C9^@;4_95-5:`>2@Fa@b@5E/3C9^@;4 _95;84H4;1;19245=12!"#$ %c&d$ )&'@23!"#$dd($ )&I -5:G:`@5;174D@@23-=:G:/7@27=8@E/3C9^@;4= _95;84H4;1;19245=12!"#$& &('$ )&I -5:/21F-48;@@23-5:681C@Je@2=@FE/3C9^@;4= _95;84H4;1;19245=12!"#$&)%I)$ )&I -5:<1?@D#@F@23-5:/=81=8`>J@5E/3C9^@;4= _95;8454J@1212]H4;1;19245= -5:f:6:e@;;8E/3C9^@;4_95;8454=H92342;= ZZZZZ LLMLTXLKYRSR

KLP &:

g84=4 ^@=4= 12C9FC4 =1J1F@5 1==>4= @23 ;8454_954E @54 A412] 31=H9=43 9_;9]4;845AD;81=^9JJ92?>3]J42;:

:

g84 H4;1;19245= A412] @]]514C43 @]@12=;

;84 95345 3@;43 &':&&: )&'E 8@C4 _1F43 ;84 H54=42;

H4;1;192= _95 h>@=812] ;84 =@J4E b8454AD ;84 B21C45=1;D 8@= 54F14C43;84J_59J=45C1^4:

':

i4@5243 ^9>2=4F =>AJ1;

;8@;

;84 H4;1;19245= 8@C4 A442 b95712] @= i4^;>545= *29b 54$34=1]2@;43 @= /==1=;@2;

#59_4==95=.

^92;5@^;j@389^ A@=1= =12^4 31__4542;

D4@5= A4;b442 ))d ;9 )&& @23 ^92;12>12] ;8454>H92E b454 A412]

!"#$%& &"

'( )(*+,-(.

'/ !010+,) !(& "2 (1*+"/((!3 4%0-% 0!

60"+,&0"5 "2 &%( *)(-(.(5& !(& '/ 7"58'+( &%( 9#*)(1( :"#)& 05  ;< = = >?; @ A > B<CDE FGHHIJK 9::GLGM NM O5 &%( -"5&),)/3 +(,)5(.

-"#5!(+ 2") &%( )(!*"5.(5&PQ506()!0&/ -"5&(5.!

&%,& !05-( QR:

60.( -"11#50-,&0"5 .,&(.

GIMHSMGHK 3 %,!

1,.( &%( T#,+020-,&0"5 "2 UVWX8 1,5.,&")/ 2") Y!!0!&,5& Z)"2(!!")!

[,5,$(1(5& ,5.

:"1*#&() 9-0(5-(3 &%( *(&0&0"5()!

4()( )(+0(6(.

,!

&%(/ .0.

5"& 2#+20+ &%( !,0.

)(T#0)(1(5&M SM \5 )('#&&,+ &"

&%( ,2")(!,0.3 +(,)5(.

-"#5!(+ !#'10&&(.

&%,& &%( *(&0&0"5()!

2#+20++(.

&%( T#,+020-,&0"5!

"2 QR:

") Y\:XW ,!

,."*&(.

'/ &%( Q506()!0&/3 ,!

)(T#0)(.3 ,& &%( &01( "2 &%(0) 050&0,+ ,**"05&1(5& 4%0-% 4,!

05&(5.(.

2") &(,-%05$ #5.()$),.#,&( -+,!!(!3 2") 4%0-% 5(0&%() VWX 5") Z%M]M T#,+020-,&0"5 4,!

.((1(.

)(T#0)(.3 2") 4%0-% %( *+,-(.

)(+0,5-( "5 &%( ^#.$1(5& "2 &%0!

:"#)& 05 _ ` @ A <?

?=`  = ? a ?D  

:bZPLcLLPKLLd3 .(-0.(."5H MHKMGHKNM dM 7(,).+(,)5(.-"#5!(+"5(0&%()!0.(M IM Y 4")&%4%0+( )(2()(5-( -,5 '( 1,.( &" eCf? g<  

@ A > B <CD  E :bZPIccGPGHHN3 .(-0.(.

"5 KKMHNMGHHS3 4%()(05 &%0!

:"#)& %,.3 ,!

)($,).!

)(*+,-05$ *,)&P&01( (1*+"/((!

40&% !010+,) !(& "2 (1*+"/((!

"'!()6(.

&%,&3 hX%( 20)!& 0!!#( 056"+6(.

&%0!

-,!( 0!

4%(&%() ") 5"& &%( *(&0&0"5() !%"#+.

'( ,++"4(.

&"

-"5&05#( ,!

i(-&#)()!

FR#(!& j,-#+&/J "5 *,)& &01( ',!0!M k((*05$ 105.

&%( ").() '/ &%( 9#*)(1( :"#)& 7,)$#)*),&,* 905$%l !

-,!( F2#++/ (m&),-&(.

,'"6(J3 -"5!0.() 0& ^#!& ,5.

,**)"*)0,&( &"

,++"4 &%( )(!*"5.(5&!

&"

.0!*(5!( 40&% &%( !()60-(!

"2 &%( *(&0&0"5()!

-,!( &%(0) !()60-(!

,)( 5"

+"5$() )(T#0)(.M \& 40++3 %"4(6()3 5"& '( "*(5(.

&"

&%( )(!*"5.(5&!

&"

!#'!&0&#&( *(&0&0"5()!

40&% "&%()!

2") &%( !,1( *#)*"!( 2") 4%0-% &%( *(&0&0"5()!

%,6(n%,.

'((5 (5$,$(.M Y!

, 1,&&() "2 -+,)020-,&0"53 0& 1,/ '( !&,&(.

&%,& &%( 5"1(5-+,&#)(

!"

#$% &'(&#)#'#%& *!'+, (% )--%+%./0# )0 !#$%- *!-,& %01/1%2%0# !"

%23+!4%%& /& / 2/##%- !"

#%23!-/-4 /--/01%2%0# 5/, $!67 &#!381/37 6'--%0#8,'#47 3/-#8#)2%7 6!0#-/6#'/+7 #%23!-/-4 %#69 &!

/& #!

-%3+/6% #$% 3%#)#)!0%-& *!'+, 0!# (% 3%-2)&&)(+%:

;0 6/&% #$% -%&3!0,%0#& ,%&)-%, #!

#/<% *!-<7 )0 #$% &/2% "/&$)!0 /& )# )&=*/& (%)01 #/<%0 "-!2 #$% 3%#)#)!0%-&7 )# *!'+, (% )23%-/#).% "!- #$% -%&3!0,%0#& #!

/++!* #$% 3%#)#)!0%-& #!

6!0#)0'% )0 #$%)- 3-%&%0# /&&)102%0#&> !- #!

-% )0,'6# #$%2 )0 6/&% #$%)- &%-.)6%& $/.% /+-%/,4 (%%0 ,)&3%0&%, *)#$:

?$)& ,)-%6#)!0 *)++7 $!*%.%-7 (% &'(@%6# #!

!0% !.%-8-),)01 6!0,)#)!07 0/2%+47 #$/# )# *!'+, (% !3%0%, #!

#$% -%&3!0,%0#& #!

$!+, / -%1'+/- 3-!6%&& !"

&%+%6#)!0 (4 )0.)#)01 /33+)6/#)!0& "-!2 /++ %+)1)(+% 6/0,),/#%& ):%:

(4 "!++!*)01 #$% &/2% 3-!6%,'-% *$)6$ #$% A,'6/#)!0 B%3/-#2%0#7 C'0@/(7 "!++!*& *$)+% 2/<)01 /33!)0#2%0#& /1/)0&# #$% 3!&#& !"

D%6#'-%-& )0 E!.%-02%0# 6!++%1%&:

F0, )0 6/&% &'6$ / 3-!6%&& !"

&%+%6#)!0 )& $%+,7 )# *!'+, (% !3%0%, #!

#$% -%&3!0,%0#& #!

2/<% /33!)0#2%0#& #$%-% "-!2 (/&%, !0 #$% 2%-)# !"

6/0,),/#% *$!

$/, 3/-#)6)3/#%, )0 #$% &/), 3-!6%&& !"

&%+%6#)!0:?$%)0&#/0#/--/01%2%0#$/&#$%/33-!./+!"#$%-)./+3/-#)%&:G H:

I!0J(+% #$% K'3-%2% L!'-# )0 M  NOP Q R S TUM M VWMM 5XYXX9 Z[ KLL [ Y7 *$)+% -%+4)01 !0  UO P P VMU 5&'3-/9 /0, \ ]^ Q R V _  ` 5ZaH[9 KLL b7 $/, !(&%-.%, /0, $%+, #$/#7 cF 3%-'&/+ !"

#$% /,.%-#)&%2%0# ,/#%, X 8d8XYZd )&&'%, (4 #$% C-)06)3/+7 E!.%-02%0# e/2+/ f/@/ E)-+& C!&# E-/,'/#% F'#!0!2!'& L!++%1%7 E*/+)!-7 *$)6$ )& /# F00%g'-% C8X !"

#$% /33%/+ 3/3%-(!!< /0, #$% /,.%-#)&%2%0# ,/#%, X8h8XYZd )&&'%, (4 #$% C-)06)3/+7 KiK E!.%-02%0# i!,%+ K6)%06% L!++%1%7 E*/+)!-7 i:C:7 *$)6$ )& /# F00%g'-% C8b !"

#$% /33%/+ 3/3%-(!!<7 *!'+, &$!* #$/# #$% /33!)0#2%0#& *%-% #!

(% 2/,% /"#%- #$% 6/0,),/#%& $/, 1!0% #$-!'1$ ,'% &%+%6#)!0 3-!6%,'-%:

?$!'1$ K$-) j/#/-/@7 +%/-0%, FKE $/& &#-%0'!'&+4 '-1%, #$/# #$% /33!)0#2%0#& !"

#$% /33%++/0#& *%-% /& 1'%&# +%6#'-%-& /0, 0!# /& /, $!6 %23+!4%%&7 "-!2 #$% 0/#'-% !"

#$% /,.%-#)&%2%0#&7 )# 6!'+, 6+%/-+4 (% &%%0 #$/# #$%

!""#$$!%&'

(#)# !""*+%&#, *% !, -*.

/!'+'0 1& +'

!

'#&&$#, ")+%.+"$# *2 $!( &-!& !% !, -*.

#3"$*4## .!%%*& /# )#"$!.#, /4 !%*&-#) !, -*.

#3"$*4## !%, -# .!% /# )#"$!.#, *%$4 /4 !%*&-#) .!%,+,!&# (-* +'

)#56$!)$4 !""*+%&#, /4 2*$$*(+%5 !

)#56$!)")*.#,6)#")#'.)+/#,78 :-+'

;*6)& +% < = >'6")!?

@ ,+)#.&#, .*%'+,#)!&+*% *2 &-# "#&+&+*%#) 2*) )#56$!)+'!&+*%@ /!'#, *% &-# 2!.& &-!& '+%.# -# 26$2+$$#, &-# A6!$+2+.!&+*%'

!& &-# &+3# *2 -+'

+%+&+!$ !""*+%&3#%& +% B99C@ &-# '6/'#A6#%& !3#%,3#%& &-#)#*2 +% &-# 4#!)B99D@(*6$,%*&.*3#+%-+'(!40 BE0 F% !

.636$!&+G# .*%'+,#)!&+*% *2 &-# 2!.&'

!%, .+).63'&!%.#'

*2 &-# .!'#@ +% $+5-& *2 &-# !2*)#H)#2#))#, I6,5#3#%&'@ "#&+&+*%#)'

!)# #%&+&$#, &* .*%&+%6# *% &-# "*'&'

&+$$ '6.- &+3# &-# '!3# !)# 2+$$#, /4 (!4 *2 !

)#56$!) ")*.#''

*2 )#.)6+&3#%&@J KLMNOPJ .*%&+%5#%&*%&-#+)(*)Q!%,.*%,6.& )#3!+%+%5'!&+'2!.&*)40 BB0 :-#")#'#%&"#&+&+*%''&!%,,+'"*'#,*2@!..*),+%5$40 BR0 S"-*&*.*"4*2&-+'*),#)/#"$!.#,*%&-#2+$#'*2.*%%#.&#,.!'#'0

TTUTVWTXY ZVW[\ ] ]  ^0_!3)!

`-#&-#)'"#!Q+%5a)#!'*%#, b c#'ad* `-#&-#))#"*)&!/$# b c#'ad*