M/S Om Sai Filing Station v. Union Of India & ORS.
!"#
$ %&'
(!)*+&(,# -"# .
&/* 01( 21(()3(-*) (4(
5*6*
!7(%3*
*87*
!"#$ %&'()$ )(
#*%&+,$
*+ & 9*3(,3(-17)(43 & 9&(-7)(- !38
& 16:
1(3-7)(- !*87*
;
& *3*3:(8-7)(- !*87* <
&
(=>123--(,((- !31(
?????
)(
#*%- 3 8@ 0 1( 2 1( 3(* (88()37 3* 6 ! *92 4 ! )( ! A6(*32 ! 3 7 7(7 ;
;
#$B6 @"#'-743)33 ( 6(*38(7 3077(7"#
"
"##;$B6 @ '3(*>)()7
& 9*3(,3(-(716*(***7>,& 9 &(-7)(-8*238*6>0*3(86*6()( (7*0 **67 >, 3 7( 8( $! *3 C8(D'!(0!( 608(5(2()3(-3* (7 *) (7(>(7- *6(7 3 (( 234(,- 3 3!
*(&((2-7( 8(77(7 <
"
"##"
$B6 @ '*623
!0(&((2-((234(, 63,!7($!*3C D'
3 =))-7 &((20 !3 0(73(&((23(3 *4(**8)7(7!63)0077!32(!
! *2 68 ! 3 608 !(6 ! 3 8( 7 (!077(7;
"##;$B6 @"'
4-7 7(7"E "
"##;$B6 @;'-3 =))!073( &((2- 3(34(*(2(8!**3(;##0*>60 3( ##0*(7-3!-)0077!(B(!3)7 423!()3(34(*(((>,! 6083), (73)(884!()2()68>076@(((>,! 37*(78 4-30(0-383(7(* *6>07 ( (88)( ! (4(72 ! 3 ( 6 (*3843)34(*60(,-4(73(2!6706*-(7 3877(7"#
"
"##;$B6 @ '
!63*6>0*3(38-())7230* (7)7*!3F!-4(*A6778*((06!
* ##()*4(7**!*)6,78*(7>(
!0( 3))778(0*-**)
!0(378(0*- - 1&7(-*) (7(>(7- 8(0!& (4(-*) 4 (7 6, (2 8(0- (7(>(7 (7 86, 00**- (7(>(73(7>>(7-B)8
!0
!63 *6>0* 3( 3 3(7 > B)3(2 ! )*87)* >438((73 432(7)08()!
)(0*(7)7*!3868*!2(!
436
.
238((,*(2-3!-38)(> 0(7(>!(,7(,>(23
!03 134 )(6*)4(*76,87 886,!3(24(*23 8 38(>,(92)*7(38**! 3 6*3(7)()737(*38!3832673( 37(*380(766*7!(87!3,(*-36*-*6>0* 3(436(,!(6!38-37(*383(*>)()7 !()-383(*>0(7*6!!4236**>43 8((73
!)67)(68& *3*3:(8-(7)6* 8*237( 8(-3*63(*7(! 3(2-)(768& :(8876)3!!)*87)* >4 3 (7 3 8( & :(8 3(* 876)7 83)8* ! 3 )*87)* 0( 3( 7 7(7
"
"## - 3(7 4 3 7( 8( F7 - 62(*( !!)2(72)08()!)()7*! **6()!
3)*!37(7 "
"## (736*+@ C
!""# $%& '()*+ ,- '' ,./01*+2 &1&0+3* "24/45 6
7 #771+0117087 7998% '1*6116*008 :6 ! ; ('
' '4<=
'
' 21100%16 -/ '
' '>4$+6900 2* ' 2 '( '/ ? '' 6 7 7 7<@ :7 2*7>4 $+69007+83'036116*0086 @''''-;'(''''
'
''>4$+6900 2* A <( '
6,-6 ,
-';' :';'6 B -'' -';' ' -;' ( ''76<@ :>4$+6900 2* (' ' 4'' '. (44'' ' *06086*008 -' '
'C ;'- '(4 '.' '*094
';(''''- +$4 ' (4C'
'' ';('90046 'C 4 -' ;'- '(4 '
'4(( '-;'';('6<'' ';- D '-;'(4 -'
(' ' (' ( -' ' ('' '.6 E ' 'F'' ' 'F' (4(' 'C ''' '(' '('6 C E @='( '(
# 6G 86*6()3(!07-370()((7 (6*3!()*47(760(,77(7
#- )087 43 3 A60/)7* ! 3 >, 0(92 67(92!78*23(06431( !)*6)!
*)(70(93(23;##0*-43)3*3A60
/
!623(7(*38 3)*!37(7
# (736*+@ C' ; '/ :7<( 7>$+69701 '136016*010 @='( '(
#
$%&'(2*+,- 6 -/ '
' '$+6900 2* ' H ' <( 6@ ' 2 '( @'' '' '' 6 7 #771+0117087 2 1998%'1*6116*008 '-;'-='( '''(
' 'F'(4'C'- ('/
;- D '-;'( '';'''(4 6 *6
'C ' '4
'@D ((';('4C' '' 90046 E''F''C '(' '(' '-;'('-'(44 '
' ' '''6 C E , :4'
' ;'' ' ! ; (' ' '4<= '
' 21100%1 "(/-;'6
0
!63*6>0*3(3(!3 77*8743)3)**(738((93(!0708627 7)*
& 16 :
1(3- (7 )6* 8*2 3 *6>0*3(3)78(2(,)*87)*7(7
#*4(2/0**2(7-3!-!(6)(>!67433
!63*6>0*3(38(3(**6>073 67(92(7-3!-!4(!3*(0-
)67>**67
3*!()3(*>77>,& :(8(*3(*!*6>02 3 67(92- 06)3 ** 7* *8)!, 2(72 83)8, 34* !63*6>0*3(3*()006)()7!0 3&*,! 60%(6((*7(7
#**673 )$&9' / F/ F-&60>(!(!30(7/ 8( ( 67(*38*,2)*7!!,(*-**) 84*3*(03(*>*7 (7!)*!3 ))7 08(, 3)*!37(7
#(7 36*+@ 6@21+011717*0032
!;'4' @''4 ! '
' ';'4-'&*010 ' '(C
7 @ :7<@ : 4-6 -='(/2';'
'''
';;'4' ';' '' 6 4 '(' ' ' ';;
1
'4'';' '' -'''.4' -'' '(' 9 '.2 I '' '4'';'''';' 4-''1$6116*0034 -'4''/2 B' ''' ; ; '' ''4' - ;'-'' ';'4' '' '- ' 3 ''' '4' '(' ';; ' 4' (7' ( '( '4'(4 -''4'
'; ' 44''- '< '''(;'
6G E ::
#''(' '!;6 '6*90$&9%+G !63*6>0*3()(*3*6*)72( 3!-3
4673(3=6*7)->6,3(7! )*
3(3(73(7)6*!38(*(7(88(*7 38(8>9
(72!37(7 "
"## (73*8* 7(7
#-(0!343(83(7>0(7*6!! !!(6!(*36**/0*67*(72>438( (7 3 - *67 8(**2 ! 3 08627 7 3 (63*(330!(!!(*-8()6(,3(2)**367> *27>(23
(*42*6)3!()-*,3 86>)((2-06)3**38-3(*6!!7 36*2!3!6 *(*!3**()007*-43)3*A67!7(,@@7(, ()* *!3(868*-3(7*04(***67(*34(* @(((>,!3!63)(*7*
3((*0(,-3!()0(*3(3 )67 *30(**62
!!(6!38 (3- 3*6(8!0-087)(683 =))! 3(2(9()->64673(!63*(737)*!3 * 3(*(*>(88*7>,& 3(3(762387), !348-)(0(73(*>()A67
*6(,-(0!343(3086277!4( !
)(>(>67*,38>64!3 (**(!07 3!-3*(0*3>,*@(*7 :8243)*!37(7
#- B()7(>432(73(!37(*38*@(@*3 843)$&9' -(0!343(38*4 8)(>7*8*7!3!420(+@ ('
42 3 ()A6* ! )( 0 (7- 3 8->,=237( 8(-*3(*6>0 (3A6*7)60*38(!3868* !0(92386088((G >'
, (92 A6* 7)60*- 3 8( *3( !63 *6>0 3 *(0 3 !343 (7 3 3(!*3(87683(88)((7 )(*!(,)(!)(*3(>()938(! )**,(**38(73(!**63
436(,!63**!08!(>,434 49*3(!G )'
)8!3
>,3 -38(
*3(8()30(!(!37(*38>!3 (7 ! )* (7 3 (7 ! )* ! 3 8(*3(7)730(30*>=)(7 8(20()0(G 7'
3 8 *3( (* * 3
((7, >(7!0378(0*7)(7(>G '
! )08 ! 3 !0(*- 3 (7 ! )**3()*730(8(20()(,(7(9( 7)**(!37(*384!3 7(7
#43(87!(303
33(!07>*(*-348*(7* 7*8*7!
-2*1 )(
# -3 %&+,$ 5 5 46 -7 89 -4
:
;
5 5
-<
;