Karam Chand Sharma v. State Of Punjab & ORS






 
   















!"#  #$%&%'(   )  

  

   

  
 (*+ , -
  -  -

 



!  

  !   "

#  

  -  - .

    $  % & ' (    )* )+ ,)
-.


0 1        "!     "   & 2  $

     &          & $     ,* )- *0 4$

     "   &        

14!& /    &4 1      !& 

5  ! &     & $ &  $ !   

61$    

 

   "  &  7     2 

 &  ' !    "!

,    2  !      /       

-)
) ,)
-1 4 !4#      "     2   &  &        .

80 1 &&1 $ ! 1(  




  


 
 
 
 
 



 

 
 
 
 

 



 &4         "   &      ! !  )*
, ,)
-$ !&!  &   -)
) ,)
-.

80     !       !4    #     

 " 2  & &      !  !' ! 91& &/!      ! !   )*
, ,)
-  14 !&! 1$
   

  

 

           

! "#$%&'(

 *$$+,$#",-#.#/012"



$3",#4$1#/5%6.6703376$89 1804$,//"6,8012"

,"1+* *"1%6:",* 0 & 7",6/6+"#61  ,$:",%61:  *1,",604 ,$401$,"#61 "%46886 7$##*$ $4 $,8/#*$#"#$4468861"1%

68#,6+#5,"

- 6, "4%6,$+#$%#,$/$,#,%$,%"#$%' ')'

$",61:

1%8# 

)( )'

'  );;)

%"#$% ')'

,$8#,61:3,.6861 ;+1#"61$%61,%$, %"#$%  ;)'

)  6880$%  .6%$  1%8# 

)( )'

'



(  ;  %"#$%  );)'

)  "1%  #*68  4468861<8 7$##$, 



%"#$%) ' )'

)1#*$ 2$+#  +6#$%  "

.$  "1%  #  8"-  #*"#  ,%$,8  /  #*$ .$,14$1#%"#$% ;')'

)"1%' ')'

",$ $61:

6437$4$1#$% -/6=61:#*$*1,",604/#*$ $4 $,8 ,$#6,$%/,4#*$20%6+6"786%$,84$#*$,.$,14$1# 2 "83$,#*$+7",6/6+"#616880$%.6%$ $4

)(

'

 )!%"#$% )'

) >$.$,#*$,$",$+"8$8>*$,$#*$ $4 $,8*".$ ,$#6,$%/,430 76+8$+#,01%$,#"?61:880+*"8",%8 7$+#,6+6#-  ",%  @1>    $#+A  ,3,"#61 "#61"76B$%  "1?8  8$46:.$,14$1#  ,:"168"#61

76+8$+#,01%$,#"?61:8 *$,$/,$#*$$=3,$8861 <.$,14$1#2 <1$$%8+7",6/6+"#61##*$$//$+#>*$#*$, #*$  8$,.6+$  ,$1%$,$%  -  #*$  $4 $,8  61  80+*  76?$ ,:"16B"#618  /"778  >6#*61  #*$  %$/616#61  /  #*$ <:.$,14$1#2 < #68#*$,$/,$,$C0$8#$% #?61%7- +7",6/- "8# >*$#*$,#*$ $=3,$8861 <:.$,14$1#2 <61+70%$8#*$ 8$,.6+$,$1%$,$%6184$",%7$+#,6+6#-",%@1> $#+A,3,"#61 "#61"76B$%"1?8$46.#

,:"16B"#61 0 76+$+#, 1%$,#"?61:8$#+8#*"##*$ +7"64 /

$4 $,8 +461:

/,4 #*$8$ ",%8 ,3,"#618 "1?8 ,:"16B"#618 +"1

$ +186%$,$% D0,8/"6#*/077- %   $:68#,",E 9  !&! 1   

:

)
:01! &&1 $ ;F

 5  5 F D  

55 

    @ 

    A 

$:68#,", 012"

#"#$1804$, 6830#$8 $%,$88"74468861 7#  '$+#,*"1%6:",*

$4 

)( )'

' 

 ;(

"#$%*"1%6:",*& '

)'

0 2$+#& 6,+07",,$:",%61:*1,",6043"-"

7$##*$

$4 $,8/ 68#,6+#1804$,5,04"1%012"

#"#$ 1804$, 6830#$8 $%,$88"74468861 *68 *"8 ,$/$,$1+$ # -0, 7$##$,   012"

)'

!  %"#$%  '( ))'

  1 #*$"

.$80 2$+# *$"/,$8"6%4"##$,*"8 $$1#"?$103>6#*#*$ 561"1+$  $3",#4$1# "1%  #*$  561"1+$  $3",#4$1#  *"8 "%.68$%#*"##*$  

 




*



 

 


 

! 
" 

#  $ 
 

#
 % 

 
 

 
 


    



 






 
 
 

 







  >*6+*  >07%  ,$:07"#$ #*$6,,$401$,"#61 *687$##$,*"8 $$16880$%1#*$ "868/"%.6+$ ,$+$6.$%  /,4  561"1+$  $3",#4$1#  .6%$  #*$6,  7$##$, 

)'' (F

)'%"#$%'

'

)'

%  61#$+,$#",-5%03376$8E

 11 1 $/   
+)))7  "! "  &  2   $            &

 &4 1      &  !& & $1 &< !     &4   % &' (   !   !&      ,* )- *0

6!    1/ =

& !&! 

:

)
:0 4 #   1&

(1 1    % &' (>

! & $ $

 % &' (5  &&41' ( $  4 & ! ' ( $  .

!<  6 ?

( $0 !
@:).    % &A  !0 ( $   % &' (5 1     

   % & ' (   = 4 !=  !         !

!/  4'

&
" 



(

)

*
 *
+
,
! 
- 

*
.//.
)($
0" 1
233
  $    & $ $   &A ' (1&& $1      ;

&!  B  !      !  ,  .0      &!

 !  6!< !!   11  &A ' ( & 4   & ! 1  ! && 4 & #      9  !  $     /        &&1 $


 

 



 

 
*
- 4 
)







 
 4
 *



 





 

 
)



 
 
 
 

5 

 

 

 
*
- 4 
)







 
 
 
 



 
 

 


 
 * 





# 
 

  
 

 
 
 



:

 



 
 
 
 



 



# 
0" 
6071

60811

 
 





 
 
*







 





 



  


 
  
 

  

  

 
$
*

0" 
21

5   



 
 4
 *







 








 
 
  
&  

&





 

 4
 *

" 
8091

 
* - 4 
)

 
  
&

&


 


 
 
 



 4
 *

 



5   
& 


&







  
 
& 

 


&
0 *&
+

# 
!

.3/1

91! !&   ;: 


 
 

 ! 
- 
*
- 4 
)


  

 



 
 4
 *





  


 
)






  

 
 
 



 

 4
 *





" 
7
01
071
01

 !
!
)

;

  
 


 
 
  
"


<


!  





 

 4
 *

 
   
 


 
 


&

+   

" 
701

 
!
!
)

6  % &' (  $ &    &#   4' &
" 



)

*
 *
+&
 
0 1
!&    ( $         &  4  1      1& !   &$!&! 

:

)
:0 4#      "     2   &  &          !  !' !

!!  $&4 &&1

6$   

,* )- *0

"!  &    !&             / $       1&   $        "!     "   & 2  $&4 1     /! 4

% &  1     !! !4 

" 

     -  -    


  C( $7 

D  C& %