High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18017/2017dismissed

Aman Kaushik v. Union Of India And ORS

2020-12-11Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia9 pages

! "# $%&

"%'%( $%&

& )*

+++*

! "

# !

$ ##"

! ' ()

! "

! ' *

++,%$-,.,/0, 1 "

((+,((- . / # ! ' * 0 1 2# # & #

# & 3 !

! ' 0 1 5 # 2 0 !#3 3

3$ !.#3 6 .#3 &!

# !! ! & # 0 1 !

! 7! #3 8179 3

$ ! 8 :

3 0 &

39 ;

$ :09< .#3

" # ! ! ' ( #"

!/ & !

# 33

! (* =- (=>+8? @(9

7 ! & # !#3 "

3 ! ! >A =B (=>) 8? @>9 "

# &

3*(C!!

& ! & @

" &3' ( ! 3 !

# "

! "A & "(17 " ( " :

0 &

3 $ 8 :09

7 ! #)= >> (=>+8? @*9"

# &17.#3)"

# 15)( & #

17"

! /

" D'EF1.7%'1%

%'72'7%1 72.$'6 1.F7G 8 %12% %.72

%12%'07'7 %12%9 2 6.26F7%'(=>='02'02'702 7$22%'9

# /

& " ! !

' 2

378'279!!&3 6.

!! &3 6.

F27,27

. " &"

00# !!! "

3 6 . 8 ! "

0#9 # (==B

& ? /

3 ! '27,F27,27!

/ ,.

'27,F27,27

&/ !

# !

! '27,F27,27 !!

! " &3 6. # "

!& !

# .

/ & ! !&6.# #@"

!& ! &&3 6.

H???

????

I0# &! J 2# #82## 97! #387!

J2, 7!

,7" 3 0# 1 2# #,1 7! #3,1 0 3 2# #,1!

!7! #3,17! #3 #

K ! &

#! 3&! & L > 7!

# ! ,

? ! # M L ( .! , K N

3 "& #!

7! 13E

3# 81E9 3(=>* =( =B (=>+8? @-9 7!

0# 1E &!

"! & 3&3 . ! # . ! >4 =( (=>-8?@(,>9 ! "! !! ! " !

M %!! ! "

" >+ =( (=>- ! >4 =( (=>-8? @A9 & $" !! @& #

" # # # ( :09 ' 4 & ! !#3 & 6 .#3 " "# 3&# - " & ! &! ' ) 0 !, !. !

"& # $" & 3 # 3&

&3 " # 3- "(=>+ >*A= " ! !! "

3!() >*>== "

" ' 4 3 # !!3"! "& &

" # / /

> .

0# &! 2# #7! #3 ! & !

17 "

7 . ! #. " 1" @ "

7 !@. !

" " . ! #.

& :09"( A ! (!

' 4 !#3 7 ! ! & " # "

' .#3 & ! !!

0 "

# !

& "

6 7

0 > 2 6 )+ B- >A == 4* B- (

0 7 & ' %5.

)= =B >A == *A =B 15 )

# "

** =( =A == 4( =( 17 *

& .

(A >A >- == *4 >A 17

$@6 () +B >4 == )A +B 15

$@ 6 >+ >* =- == () >* 17 &

! & " ! 7 K # & !! # 3 " & ' ) 7 " ! " & # " & # :09 .#3 # & ! " 7 & !@. !

" " "

" "

3 ! & 7! 1E "

' * # "4* B- "() >*

' 7 "

! 3 @

3& # ! ( :09"

& & "

! ' 4 # !!3 &

! "

! & ! # ! &!

"&!

# :09 ! !

# "# 3&! # ! (= ! & "

"& # "3

. @ # # ! #

! & ! 8?@(,)9"

! " &&3" # ! /

& 3

# /

3! !!K !

"& ! !

# 3& " & " 3!- # () >* " "

3 !

1 & !!

!! " &!

I!" 3! # "

7 ! . ! #. "!

7 & @ & &3 !!! ! !

! "

" # " & 3 >+ >* ! # & &3 !

# !! $ ! "" " " &3 3!- (= ! !

!! !& & # :09!#3 ? ! # (= !#3 ! &

! &"" # " ! " #

& ! "

! 3" & "

""(=

#? ! " " 3"

# " 3 !#3 ?! @60#

0# 7 !" 3! 7 ?. +'! /,

2- "!3! %0# "!024",%2!550!!0% 2- "! 6+7 & # ! ! & # & @ D>4

!! # " 3 3

& !

3& F!, 7

# 3

! 3! 3 # &! F!,

# "3&K!

! 3& " 3&!

3! '27

" 3 #

! #

3 # " !

3 ! " & ! ! ! " 3 & ! " 3 3 #

& 8'/.0%$ " ,/+0%9-

,%2- "3!+2,2 '%:,; 2- "!1< + & @ D>> 3 "

@ 3 &! ! ! !

" #

# # "

7 ! 3

& # 8 1. % 5 F %

8(==49)..+>AL

.72 3O !

% 8(==>9+..)A= &

! !. 6 0"

8>BBB94..>A= 7 !

!! !!3 #&

&33 !#3 3

$ ! "

3& 7 3 # # !#3 "

! & ? 7 !& ! !!!&3

# ' *" # "

3 :09!#3!& !! !!

!! 7 3# ' 4 "

&! ! ! # ! @

# " &3

++* :

#, G,' : & G,'