High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18023/2017dismissed

M/S Krishna Agro Foods And ANR. v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And ORS.

2017-11-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath7 pages

!!!!!

"#$$%&'&() "#$$%&'&() "#$$%&'&() "#$$%&'&()*$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$- .

!!!!!

!!!!! /0'1-&'2(" 3-4'"(4"(#2$- $#&#&($-' 5' 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-' $'9(4$(#' !!!!!

!!!!!

!!!!! /0'5&*$; 3-4'"(4"(#2$- $#&#&($-' 5' 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-' $'9(4$(#' !!!!!

!!!!!

!!!!! /) /) /) /)< :/ 11/

< :/ 11/

!!!!!

!!!!! -$'$(#) /-1&(3"=. 4*%"#$. -#2$9$#&#&($-' /-5&(4 2"-48"7. 4*%"#$. -#2$-$'9(4$(#'>&(

? /-&#$($2-". 4*%"#$. -#2$-$'9(4$(#'>&(

? !!!!!

!!!!!

!!!!! 11/

. 11/

. 2&' -4$- '2"== 4&'9'$ #8 9$#&#&(' ,$"-&(3

#&#=$4"'@/0'

@/0'

@/0'1-&'2(" 3-4'"(4"(#2$- 1-&'2(" 3-4'"(4"(#2$- 1-&'2(" 3-4'"(4"(#2$- 1-&'2(" 3-4'"(4"(#2$-5' 6(7", #"#$ 8$- -9-"#&( :&+&#$4 "(4 #2$-' 6(7", #"#$ 8$- -9-"#&( :&+&#$4 "(4 #2$-' 6(7", #"#$ 8$- -9-"#&( :&+&#$4 "(4 #2$-' 6(7", #"#$ 8$- -9-"#&( :&+&#$4 "(4 #2$-'AAAA B- '2-# C#2$ '# 9$#&#&(<D"(4

#&#=$4"'@/0'

@/0'

@/0'5&*$; 5&*$; 5&*$; 5&*$; 3-4'"(4

3-4'"(4

3-4'"(4 "(#2$- "(#2$- "(#2$- "(#2$-5'6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-' 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-' 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-' 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-'AAAAB-'2-#

C#2$ (4 9$#&#&(<D "' #2$ &''6$ &(*=*$4 &( ,#2 #2$ 9$#&#&(' &' %++( 8$*$-.-#2$'";$%(*$(&$(%$#2$"%#'"-$,$&(3$E#-"%#$4-+#2$ '#9$#&#&( 2$9"-#($-'2&9&-+/0'"-=$$(&%$/&=='2"4#89"-#($-'. ("+$=F."=7$$#&(32"(4"*&(4$-&(322$&-+,#"&($4="(-+#2$ #"#$ "(;"#&"="&=-"71"6-8&$"=7$$#&(32>9"-#($-#2$&-+? +-#3"3$4 #2$ ="(4 +$"'6-&(3

;"("= G +"-=" %+9-&'$4 &( ;2$8"# ;2"#(&

0GH.;2"'-"

00I+&(> H?.>?. +&(>? +&( >? '&#6"#$4 "# "&=,-"2 "4. 5&=="3$ 6+#& 1"="(. &'#-&%#

"#2&(4"B2$-$&("#$--$$--$4#"'C#2$9-9$-#F&(J6$'#&(<D"''$%6-&#F- #2$3-"(#'"&4="(2$-$8$-$#8-&%$+&=='&(#2$9-9$-#F&(J6$'#&(. ("+$=F. /0' "-=$$( &%$ /&==' "(4 /0' +"(9-$$# &%$ /&==' /0' "-=$$(&%$/&=='+"4$"4$"6=#&(-$9"F+$(#="(2$#"#$ "(; "#&"=" &(&#&"#$4 -$%*$-F 9-%$$4&(3' 6(4$- #2$ $%6-&#&K"#&( "(4 $%('#-6%#&( &("(%&"= ''$#' "(4 (-%$+$(# $%6-&#F (#$-$'#

%#.

,F 96##&(3 #2$ 9-9$-#F &( J6$'#&( # '"=$ 2$ ,"(; &''6$4 "6%#&((#&%$&(*&#&(3,&4'$#&#&($- 9"-#&%&9"#$4&(#2$"6%#&(&( 2&'&(4&*&46"=%"9"%&#F"(496-%2"'$4#2$9-9$-#F&(J6$'#&(-"'6+ . .

0&(2&'("+$2$,"(;&''6$4#2$'"=$%$-#&&%"#$&("*6- 9$#&#&($- (

. 82&%2 8"' 46=F -$3&'#$-$4 &(#2$ &%$ 6, $3&'#-"-. "+96-" 26=. &'#-&%# "#2&(4" ( G

#$- #2$ &''6"(%$'"=$%$-#&&%"#$.#2$,"(;"='8-#$"=$##$-4"#$4 I

# #2$$2'&=4"-."+96-"26=.&'#-&%# "#2&(4"#-$+*$#2$,"(;=&$(&( #2$ -$*$(6$ -$%-4 "(4 &# &' "==$3$4 #2"# #2$ ,"(; =&$( 8"' "%%-4&(3=F -$+*$4-+#2$-$*$(6$-$%-4&(-$'9$%##2$9-9$-#F&(J6$'#&("(4 #26'&#8"'-$$-+"==$(%6+,-"(%$'

&(%$#2$9$#&#&($-'8$-$#'$#69"-&%$'2$==$-&(#2$9-9$-#F &(J6$'#&(6(4$-#2$("+$"(4'#F=$/0'1-&'2(" 3-4'.&#2"4 "99=&$4-"($8$=$%#-&%&#F%(($%#&(#-$'9(4$(#G,F4$9'&#&(3 #2$-$J6&'&#$"+6(#0$$*&4$"99=&%"#&(4"#$4G

9"-#-+#2&'.&# "=' "99=&$4 - '"=$' #"E "(4 #2$- -$J6&-$4 9$-+&''&(' 8&#2 4&$-$(# '#"#6#-F "6#2-&#&$' =&;$ 6(7", ==6#&( (#-= "-4 "(4 /"-;$# ++&##$$. 2"3#" 2"&$#%$'9(4$(#G'$(#"=$##$-4"#$4 IG

##2$9$#&#&($-''#"#&(3#2"#-"($8$=$%#-&%&#F%(($%#&(#2$F2"4#9"F .

.G 0("%%6(##2$46$'#8"-4'/0'"-=$$(&%$/&=='2$ 9$#&#&($-'4&'96#$4#2$4$+"(4"(4'$-*$4"=$3"=(#&%$4"#$4 H

,6# ($&#2$-#2$$=$%#-&%&#F%(($%#&(8"'-$=$"'$4(-"(F-$9=F8"'3&*$(,F -$'9(4$(#G"(42$(%$.#2$9-$'$(#9$#&#&(2"',$$(&=$4&(-4$-# %2"==$(3$#2$=$##$-4"#$4 IG

# &' 9$-#&($(# # +$(#&( #2"# *&4$ #2$ &+963($4 -4$-0=$##$- 4"#$4 IG

. #2$ 9$#&#&($-' 8$-$ &(#&+"#$4 ,F -$'9(4$(# G #2"# @82$-$F62"*$"99=&$4#2$:%(($%#&(&(#2$("+$/0'1-&'2("

3- 4'. "# #2"# 9-$+&'$' /0' "-=$$( &%$ /&==' *&4$ 0% 0

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

I 2&''6,+&''&(.2$2"'-$=&$469("4$%&'&(#2$69-$+$6-#&(#2$ %"'$@9$%&"=&%$-.++$-%$.-#2"'#$-(=$%#-&%&#F @9$%&"=&%$-.++$-%$.-#2"'#$-(=$%#-&%&#F @9$%&"=&%$-.++$-%$.-#2"'#$-(=$%#-&%&#F @9$%&"=&%$-.++$-%$.-#2"'#$-(=$%#-&%&#F+9"(F +9"(F +9"(F +9"(F -&''" >? "(4 "(#2$- -&''" >? "(4 "(#2$- -&''" >? "(4 "(#2$- -&''" >? "(4 "(#2$- 5' /0' /0' /0' /0' "326("#2 "9$- /&==' -&*"#$ "326("#2 "9$- /&==' -&*"#$ "326("#2 "9$- /&==' -&*"#$ "326("#2 "9$- /&==' -&*"#$ :&+&#$4"(4"(#2$-A :&+&#$4"(4"(#2$-A :&+&#$4"(4"(#2$-A :&+&#$4"(4"(#2$-A

> ?I ( #2$ #2$- 2"(4. =$"-($4 %6('$= - #2$ -$'9(4$(#' 2"' '6,+&##$4#2"##2$9$#&#&($-'"-$=&",=$#9"F9-$*&6'46$'/0'"-=$$( &%$/&=='$*$(&#2$F"-$"';&(3-"($8%(($%#&(&(#2$9-$+&'$' /0'"-=$$(&%$/&=='(#2&'-$3"-4.2$2"'-$$--$4#="6'$

#2$ 6(7", #"#$ =$%#-&%&#F $36="#-F ++&''&( >=$%#-&%&#F 699=F 4$ "(4 $="#$4 /"##$-'? $36="#&('.

I B&( '2-# C#2$ 699=F 4$

I<D82&%2-$"4"'6(4$-) @

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

"-4

"-45'/0'"(6+"(&%$/&=='2"("6-&"(4#2$-'A /0'"(6+"(&%$/&=='2"("6-&"(4#2$-'A /0'"(6+"(&%$/&=='2"("6-&"(4#2$-'A /0'"(6+"(&%$/&=='2"("6-&"(4#2$-'A

G IG # %"(*"'' #2"# 82$-$ #2$ '#"#6#-F -6=$' - #$-+' "(4 %(4&#&(' '699=F.82&%2"-$'#"#6#-F&(%2"-"%#$-."6#2-&K$#2$'699=&$-$=$%#-&%&#F #4$+"(4-+#2$96-%2"'$-"9-9$-#F%="&+&(3-$%(($%#&(--$'2 %(($%#&($=$%#-&%&#F.#2$"--$"-'46$,F#2$9-$*&6'8($-%%69&$-&( -$3"-4#'699=F$=$%#-&%&#F#'6%29-$+&'$'.#2$'699=&$-%"(-$%*$-#2$ "--$"-'-+#2$96-%2"'$- 2"*$ 2$"-4 ,#2 #2$ =$"-($4 %6('$= - #2$ 9"-#&$' "(4 9$-6'$4#2$-$%-4 2$ 82=$ %"'$ #2$ 9$#&#&($-'. &( -4$- # %2"==$(3$ #2$ &+963($4-4$-0=$##$-4"#$4 IG

> (($E6-$?.&'#2"##2$9$#&#&($-' 2"*$"99=&$4-"($8%(($%#&(&(#$-+'$%#&(I #2$=$%#-&%&#F

%#.

B-'2-#C#2$ %#<D&'$(#&-$-$=&"(%$&'(#2$4$%&'&(#2$ 69-$+$6-#-$(4$-$4&(#2$%"'$/0' /0' /0' /0'"326("#2"9$-/&=='-&*"#$ "326("#2"9$-/&=='-&*"#$ "326("#2"9$-/&=='-&*"#$ "326("#2"9$-/&=='-&*"#$ :&+&#$4 "(4 "(#2$- :&+&#$4 "(4 "(#2$- :&+&#$4 "(4 "(#2$- :&+&#$4 "(4 "(#2$- >69-"?

>69-"?

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

H B-'2-#C#2$699=F4$

ID&(82&%2&#&'9-*&4$4#2"#@#2$'$-*&%$ %(($%#&(-+#2$("+$"9$-'(##2$("+$"(#2$-%('6+$-'2"== (# ,$ #-"('$--$4 6(=$'' #2$ "--$"- %2"-3$' 9$(4&(3 "3"&('# #2$ 9-$*&6' %%69&$-"-$%=$"-$4A#8"'"-36$4,$-$#2$69-$+$6-##2"##2$-$&' (9-&*&#F%(#-"%#,$#8$$(#2$96-%2"'$-"(4-9"F&(3#2$46$' #2$ 9-$*&6' 8($-0%('6+$- ( #2&' ,"%;3-6(4. #2$ 69-$+$ 6-# 2$=4#2"#'&(%$#2$-$8"'(-$J6$'#-#-"('$-#2$%(($%#&(-+#2$ 9-$*&6'8($-##2$96-%2"'$-"(4&#8"'"-$J6$'#-"-$'2%(($%#&(. #2$-$-$.#2$"99$"=&=$4,F#2$8"'4&'+&''$4

6# #2$ 4$%&'&(. &( #2$ %"'$ /0'

/0'

/0' "326("#2 "9$- /&==' "326("#2 "9$- /&==' "326("#2 "9$- /&==' "326("#2 "9$- /&==' -&*"#$:&+&#$4"(4"(#2$- -&*"#$:&+&#$4"(4"(#2$- -&*"#$:&+&#$4"(4"(#2$- -&*"#$:&+&#$4"(4"(#2$->69-"?

>69-"?

>69-"?&'(# "99=&%",=$,$%"6'$ &#2"' ,$$( 2$=4 ,F #2$ 69-$+$ 6-# &( #2$ %"'$ /0' "(6+"( &%$ /&==' /0' "(6+"( &%$ /&==' /0' "(6+"( &%$ /&==' /0' "(6+"( &%$ /&==' 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"? 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"? 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"? 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"? #2"# & #2$ '#"#6#-F -6=$' - #$-+' "(4 %(4&#&(' #2$ '699=F. 82&%2 "-$ '#"#6#-F &( %2"-"%#$-. "6#2-&K$ #2$ '699=&$-$=$%#-&%&#F#4$+"(4-+#2$96-%2"'$-"9-9$-#F.%="&+&(3 $&#2$- -$%(($%#&( - -$'2 %(($%#&(. #2$ "--$"-' 46$ ,F #2$ 9-$*&6' 8($-0%%69&$-&(-$3"-4#'699=F$=$%#-&%&#F#'6%29-$+&'$'#2$(#2$ '699=&$-%"(-$%*$-#2$"--$"-'-+#2$96-%2"'$- ( #2$ 9-$'$(# %"'$. #2$ 9$#&#&($-' 2"*$ #2632 %="&+$4 #2"# #2$F2"*$"99=&$4-"($8%(($%#&(,6##2$($8%(($%#&(&'"99=&$4( #2$=49-$+&'$'&$#2$9-$+&'$'/0'"-=$$(&%$/&=='(#2&'-$3"-4. #2$'#"#6#-F="6'$

#2$699=F4$

I&''J6"-$=F"99=&%",=$"' &#&'9-*&4$4#2$-$&(#2"#@#2$4&'#-&,6#&(=&%$('$$+"F-$6'$#3&*$2&+ '699=F "# "(F #2$- 9-$+&'$' 6(#&= 2$ 9"F' #2$ "+6(# 46$ "(4 "=' +"F -$6'$#%(($%#'6%29-$+&'$'$&#2$-(-$J6$'#-+$E&'#&(3%('6+$-- ("99=&%"#&(-($8%(($%#&(,F"(F9$-'(#&=="==46$'"-$%=$"-$4A 26'.#2$-$&'"*"'#4&$-$(%$,$#8$$(#2$9-*&'&('#2$699=F4$

I"(4#2$699=F4$

I,$%"6'$&($36="#&( #2$699=F 4$

I#2$-$&'('6%2%(4&#&(-$6'&(3#3&*$'699=F"#"(F#2$- 9-$+&'$'$*$("($8%(($%#&(6(#&="(46(=$''46$'#2$=4%(($%#&( "-$9"&40%=$"-$4,F#2$96-%2"'$- 2&'6-#&(H

#&#=$4"'@/0' "7"7 0' "7"7 0' "7"7 0' "7"7

==F'

==F'5'6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-'A 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-'A 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-'A 6(7",#"#$8$--9-"#&(:&+&#$4"(4#2$-'A4$%&4$4(

2"' "=-$"4F 4&'%6''$4 #2$ 4$%&'&(' #2$ 69-$+$ 6-# -$(4$-$4&(#2$%"'$@/0''2"/"-,=$' @/0''2"/"-,=$' @/0''2"/"-,=$' @/0''2"/"-,=$'5' &2"-#"#$=$%#-&%&#F "-4A

&2"-#"#$=$%#-&%&#F "-4A

&2"-#"#$=$%#-&%&#F "-4A G > ? HI . @/0' "-"+6(# =F+$-' -&*"#$ :#4 /0' "-"+6(# =F+$-' -&*"#$ :#4 /0' "-"+6(# =F+$-' -&*"#$ :#4 /0' "-"+6(# =F+$-' -&*"#$ :#4 5' ";'2&( ";'2&( ";'2&( ";'2&( "-F"(" &7=&5&#-"(&3"+:&+&#$4 "-F"(" &7=&5&#-"(&3"+:&+&#$4 "-F"(" &7=&5&#-"(&3"+:&+&#$4 "-F"(" &7=&5&#-"(&3"+:&+&#$4A

G> ?:H"(4/0'"(6+"( /0'"(6+"( /0'"(6+"( /0'"(6+"( &%$ /&==' 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"?

&%$ /&==' 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"?

&%$ /&==' 2"("6-& "(4 #2$-' >69-"? "(4 2$=4 #2"# #2$ '#"#6#-F -6=$' 86=49-$*"&=-#2$96-9'$$=$%#-&%&#F%(($%#&("#$-#2$46$'#2$ $"-=&$-%('6+$-&'%=$"-$4 26'&(*&$8#2$"-$'"&44&'%6''&(.4(#&(4"(F+$-&# &(#2$9-$'$(#9$#&#&('"(42$(%$#2$'"+$"-$2$-$,F4&'+&''$4 92#%9F#2&'-4$-,$9="%$4(#2$&=$%(($%#$4 %"'$ > 11/

> 11/

? *$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$- *$+,$-

2$#2$-'9$";&(30-$"'($4 $'0 2$#2$--$9-#",=$ $'0