M/S Vinay Auto Pvt Ltd v. Nabh Parkash & ANR
!
" # $!
"!
!
"
#$ "
"! %
&'()* % #"
#
&&'(&&
) #
* " + + ,&, - .# &/ ! *# % # - &/ + #" + +
#
+ 01 +
+
# !
+ # 0 +" - + !
''2(/ 1
1 &&'&
3#
4 0 3#
&5&6 - .# ,/
+
! 1"1
" +
& 1 & # " !
+ 01 "
## #
1 "
# $#
" #
1 "
1#"
+ - / 2 % !
# + #
+
+ 01 + 1
"! + # 10
1
&67
*# #
8, 9 * +
1
+ #
1 + # + 01 , 7 1 #
+ 01 +
: ; 6,&5 ! 1"1
1
+ #!
# %
01 + 1 &&'& 1"1 +
"
# !
+ 01 +
# #
! *# % #
# #! + 0
&, !
"! *# % # "!
# +
&67
*# #
8, %
+
3#!
<
1
< 6 % 1"1 ! #
2 + + + - / :
"
1
! 1"1
" + #
#
0
+
1 0 ! *# % #
&5&&6 - .# ,/ ' % 3# +
+
= + 01 * $#
# - / + #
#
# 1 # $ * >(+,-'
-.+/ 0 ('1(.( 2(23 +'-45)25'3
('632-.+ 7('8 (.8 (.72/3'9% :
&* ;: % 4 ? #1 ) # # 1
1! + !
"
# #" 1
1 !
# 7#
1 + # 1
+
#
+ + 01
1 &, !
0 ! "
1
#! ! +" +
#
+ + %
. # > * #
#
# 1!
"
1
1 ! +
# "
# 0 +" + # !
+ 4
" "
#
! 0
+ ! +!
,
# 1
1! + !
"
# #" 1
1 !
# )
1 1
6 * + # # !
1 ) # ! +
1
&67 #" 1! # +
1 # # 1
! % +
# +" + + 01
1 &, !
0 ! "
1
#! ! +"
# ! #
+ % ) # "# + ! +" + 1 1 ! %
4 " ) # @ # ) " " 1
#1
#
! " + 4 #
+ 4 " ) # +
+ # " +
1 0 +" 1
$#"1
# # ! 4 " ) # + # " +
1 0 +" # +
' A +
1 1
1 #
1 !1 "
;
# + # +
#1 * # + "
! +
1 1 1 886 B#! 5 88' + "" ! +" #
+
6( ! = 1
A
"! # !1 # 1 + . +0 1 !
+
1 + !
C 8D #1E 5 % + B(+,-'
-.+/<= - / + ! 4 ? #1 ) > .4/('+3 ??-43'
@ .' 0 /(.6('
/32219% &A* +
# 0 +"
( + + % " # # >6 A 0
B"
"
# 0 1 +
# 4 " ) # " "
6 1 % + "" ! +" 85 ""1
#
# ! 1 ! # 1 ' 856 # &6 ! 0 * # #
$#
1 !
+ # 1
* #
( -# ; / #
1 $# 3# A
"! # !1 1 + ' +0
1 !
" +
1 !
8 #1E 8 %
- / + "
+ > 3.-7'
5B3'-.23.83.2 3)3+'(B/ &'(??-4*% /7B() 0 (.27=/ "5C('
3() @ '=9% A + 4 ? #1 ) 1 0 +" 01 "" !
+" +
,( + 01 %
" # >' * + !
! ! ) # ! +!
# 1
1
1 !
# "
# !
#
1
# # 1! - F + ) @ G F! = !H F 7 1 ) ) B H
G ; @ I#1 J1H !
1 % # H 1 G ; @ =# 71 % " * #H B # 1 # !
1 H K 1 # ! G
0 I#1 G
0 =" !
$# G / * $#"1 # !
# - @ B/
B"
" 4! "
## 0
+
+ > * #
#
# 1!
"
1
1 ! +
# "
# 0 +" + # !
+
" "
#
!
0
+ ! +!
+" # 1
1! + !
' "
# #" 1
1 !
# )
1 1
, * + # # !
1 ) # ! +
1
&67 #" 1!
# +
1 # # 1
! % +
# + + 01
1 &, !
0 ! "
1
#! ! +"
# !
#
+ % ) # "# + ! +" + 1 1 !E 5 *
" + 01 + "" ! +" # &6 ! 0 ! + 0 !
& 2 !
1 0 +" 1
$#
1 !
# #
* #
+
,(
+ 01 - ,/ 1
A
"! # !1 1 + ' +0 1 !
" +
1 !
8 #1E
$#"1 - / + # 3#!
+ !
#1 ) > ! = /5'5C()9% A & *
% + + + 1
! +" 0
# " ! #
#
1 #
1 + &67
*
+" # 1
1 !
1! 1! 4 +
+ 1 # ! # #
>
1
"
E 1 # !
+ # 1 + "!
"
#
"
1 *
"
1 #
3# 1
1 + " "
1 !
+
" % "
" # >&2 * 1
$#"1 !
"
# +" + 1
# " 1
!
A 1! +
"#(1 + 01 1 "!
( 1
( ! +!
K # #
4 +
1
1
! +" + 0 + 1
# " #
# 1!
&67
*# #
0
# # 1
+ 01 # "
1 !
+
+ 1
# &,
!
"
#
# * + + 1
#
" #
!1
1
! 1 ! 3# # &67
*# #
1 +!
1"1 1
1 ! ! !
" 1 1
# + 01 + + 0 ! +" " 0 "# K -
I0 F1
-&'/ , )) / %# +
1 "# K "
# ! +" + 0 # # # "
" " # + 01 "
1 !
! )
1#
1 " 1 + #
1 !
!
1
1
! * # # "
"
1
" " + # ! # &6 A + # 0 % 1!
+ 1
! +" + 0
#
" " # + # #
1
"
K + " # + 0 ! +" $# 1 + % 1! # $# + "# K # 1
! #
+ 01 1 * #
#1 1 + 0 # 1 # 1 + "!
"
#
"
1 * # 1 # # !
.
+ " #
&' !
"
# #
A
+ + 0 " ! +"
5
1
0 1 ! "
=
# + 0
6 ! 1
+ 0 " 6 ! # ! 1
#1 + ! & && %
1 +
1 "
" B#
0
1 1
! # 1
"! 7 +
+
+ # 1 ! "
#
1 * " -#/ +
+
=@ ) # "
& @0
+ 01 + !
+ 0
1! &, ! 0
" +
+ #
2 0 %
# + & 1 " +
&D #1 1
$#"1 +
) *% 1
. %
1 %
6(-# 7
% # !/ E 7 1
+ 01 + 0
1 ! 1 6,&5 &&'& + 01 "
##
+
" 1#" +
! " " 3# #1 #1
+ 01 & = + 1 3##1
! + 01 + # $#"1 ! ) $#"1
# ; % 2(23 7?
('1(.( 0= 5'E332 (.8 (.72/3'% 834-838 7.
; + + + 01 #1 #1
6(
1 !
%
8
+ >'
+ !
@ = &2&& #0 "
4!
2&&2 1 !
#
"
$#"1 # ' #! + 01
1 &, ! ! + 0
" 1 6 L ! +
# 1 + #
# ! +
+ #
1 +
@ # ) # 4 0
1 + # $#
# 1
1 &6 ! "
!
+ # $# +
#
&6( "
6( ! 0
+ 0
1 6 ! + 1
% . ) 4! F 1
# ! J ;1 -&/ 6 )) ,& " &6(
! + F 7 1 ) J )B -&/ 8 )) 262
& ! #1
6( + " ! :"
$ 1 ) G J
1 " &2 -/ ) '8
+ +
+ +
"
+
5 1 #
6( + " ! "1 4 # %
@ J !1 1 &5 -5/ )) 5
!
6( " * IJ G J 0 ! F
!
0 G && -,/ )% ,6
, ! 1 # + + &6( #
1
6D +
+ "
"!
E #
# + # +
1 !
1 + 01
#
6(
1 ! I
+
= + 01 + 0
' !
1
#1
2(
#E 2 4
" " !
#1
" + 01
"
# & !
+
+ # 1 ! + " 1 #1 #1
0
1 !
+ 1"1 +
1 2 0 , ) 3#! 1#" + 1
. + 01 #1 #1
= )(6/= #
# !
6 % 1"1 1
1 # 0
#
+ 01 () = ,2&8&285 *7) M: ,2& M 0 4!#
##"1 +
. +0 1
!
7 " +
1 # !
'D #1
#
! !1 ' -=B7=38 7?
"!
"
-/
! 8-=B7=38
"! &"! *
(1 %
A 0 "( M(=
A M(=