← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9264/2011allowed

M/S Harisar Rice Mills v. Pb. State Power Corpn. Ltd.

2017-02-03Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages





     

 ! "##$ %&'

(!)*+ ,-(."/0 "#1 &2*  (*(  )  &*0  3(45(  4  (60  7(8  (**(0 

4(5(60*)9-64((

 7*-*

-:(,3( 5;(960 (((%4*

*;6* 

 !"#$ %&'()$ )(

#*%&+,$

*+ &

-6(036)(54 &* 3(<*406)(0 !4;

& *4<4(-64(.06)(0 !*;6* #%

=====

)(

#*%- 4; )&*(886!4!68*66 ,.4>(*;-3???(64 -?! 6**( !()*$@-* A (6 A'

&

-  6(0  (6  3  -*  (***6  ,. &* 3(<*40;*84;*-,?*4(4;?**!4 ;  5  *;)62)4)<6   

"""0  #1

""

0 

""

""/0

""/(61 #"

""/,.(-*(8)*!4*;6A (60*;)(.&,&*83C-(6$&&3'(6!-64 ?  (*  D EF  4   ; 5(* !(,,8(*6    )  (  ) $@- A#'6(6#"

"" 054,.(86(,?(.4? 8(684- 4(*!2  5(*!-6(6*-(.

""G0  (  *-;;?(.  6?(6  !  * "0  # 0 

2A    ())-  !



4(-8!4())-!?)?,#

B?,0 "" 5(* (*6 4 (!?6 6?(6 5(* (**(6 ,! 4>( ??0  54)4  4(6  -;46  4  *(?  4 ?(  5(*  (<    4 ?,-6*?(054)44(66-)64;6!4(-8!?# #"

"""

## ##

""

!-4*-,?*4(4()!4*;6A,(6 (6 4>( ??* )*()544;** ! 3) !6()).)0# #"$!*4D# #")F'054)4 5(*!)(4(?(*45)! ""/)(?!) !

-0 ""/(64(!,.!)(05(*@66!(;6 !  *@  ?4*  *  ;  !)(*  6(6  B

""/0 

""  (6 #B

"#"04(;;)(,.!46)(*8(6*4?)-6 ;(#G

"#"

  !-4  *-,?*  4(    5  !  4  (!?6 !)(04;**!# #")5-6(;;.(6(*;*-,A*) $'!3) !# #")0C-64;*5;054)4* (*;6-)64AA,5*;)!46!)?*04(86 6?(6)(,.)!6(;6!*@?4*+A  

   

         

           

   

               

    ! "#



    #                                   

.

$      

  

%

       

   

    

   

& $   

%      

    #  '             

( )

     

  

          #  

  

     %  % #    *  

+ ,        



  ,  



       %  # 

    #  +  



      ,    

  -.

  /

 

   

  !"#



  



%#   



     *      

  

  #





 $



        *  

   

 



   .

  +              

               

           

   ,

 ,   



     #+ #  

  

      #      !

"#

 

  

  .

     *   

 #    #  '     



           #

  *  



       ,   

    %        

           #       

       !

"#

 

  

                      

  

    

      *  

! "#

     

  

 

 

   

   



  

 %  

 + #

  *    (    

     

     *  

 .,   2 

  34              

       

        

    ,   

    *    

  34

 

   

          

 4

/

4*!()4(*,)*66,.4>(??(6 4 ?,-6*?(   *-;;  ! 4* )0 4 4(* 6 -;  4 :-68?66,.4H,3-;?-" 0-'1

 23 #4  5 363  & '$"*  )  7  '  7.   )6  4(  4 (!?6;**4(6,-;46(604-*0-8*4*-4( 4  (86  6?(6  )(  ,  .  )!6    (  ;6  !  *@  ?4* ;)6846(!)4)<8

& *4<4(-64(.0(6)-* !*;6* (6 *-,?*4(4(!?6(8-?,4(!!4)*-? 5(*(*64,!4>(??4 ?,-6*?(0 4!0)(,;?6(*4*(66?(6!4!*? 45; &04;**!# #")5-6(;;.

(64*;**!(*846?(6)!8;6!*@ ?4* 46*!4>(??(6 ?,-6*?((04-*0 (,,-;46(6*-*(6 4(4(64(6)-*!4;(*(6(;;(*6 4;(;,<

4;**!*-,A*)$'!3) !# #")(6 (*5(*4!)(*0!6(,04(,6*;-6 ,-6  ,.  & 4(-64(.0  4-*0  !  (  *  (6  ;-;**0  4 (;;)(,.!46)*A(A*4?5(*!)#G

"#"

&

-6(0(63-*06-84)-*! 4(804(*6(54(!4*-4!)(6(6

""1**-6,.4 -:(,3()). 8-(.??** )64( *-)4.;!)(**04;6!(*846?(6* )!6*@?4*0 0 $8'054)4(6*(*-6+A



D5#

        

              6          7 .

 2  8 002       

       

      

     

 ,  

 

!



           +



  # #    

9        %   9  +



        9   2#

#

 

   %  :      

 

   #            

   #    %   

 9   )  

#         

                       

  #  

       #        

         #       #

  

 # 

       

 *( 2,*;     <   

    

   

       

#   

     

  6   ( 



 

 

  

7

         #  

   6    ( 



9  

 #  < ,    

 

  

 4 )(,,64(4;(.(**(846*!4 >(??(6 ?,-6*?(4(6(*64(!?6;

?.504)!& 4(-64(.!(*846?(6* 54.?*))6 !()05(*(<-;

*4*,()<6;!4 ?(04 ?,-6*?(6-)64;6!4(-8!())-!? #"

"""## ##

""

:-@(;*!4;**!*-,A*)$'!3)

!# #")(6(*5(*4!)(*;?-8(6,.4 -:(, 3()). 8-(.??**0@()6(,06?(6)(, .)!6;6!*@?4*04-*0?.5046*( *-*((,  (6  (,    ,  ?6!6 *-(.0  4  6?(6  !  4 )).(6*)!6*@?4*;)6846(!)4)<8

4(*,*(6,.& 6(4(4(?-6?(6 4(*((6.,6;*6(64;*6!-6!4 @)**(?- !  ?(<8  *-)4  66-)0  4  )).  (6  5-6 (*4(?-54?40!(854)45(*( 4(! I;(-?

))68.045;*(56

96-:.*7   )(

# -;

3< %&+,$ < < 31 -= 2> -3

?

3>

< < 

-9

?

3>