Kuldeep Singh v. Punjab School Education Board
!"#
!"#
!"#
!"#
$%& &'()(*+
$%& &'()(*+
$%& &'()(*+
$%& &'()(*+
,-./&&0(*12 &%(%(*&3 4) -*5$6'2./-'$%(* $3/ &)0*/&*% "+ "+ "+ "+7 8" 7 8" 7 8" 7 8",," ,," ,," ,," 3&)&*%+ "3,2.9$:/;'$%&:
3%2&0&%(%(*&3 ,,": ,,": ,,": ,,": 2&0&%(%(*&32$)03$<&/ 3$=3(%(*%2&*$%-3& '&3%(3$3(
3>-$)2(*1%2&3/&3/$%&/ ?
@=2('22$)$..&1&/.<6&&*0$))&/* %2& 6$)() $* &*>-(3< /$%&/ @
@ 6< =2('2 3&'AA&*/$%(*) 2$;& 6&&* A$/& 3 '$*'&..(*1 %2& 3&)-.% &C$A(*$%(* $..&1&/ % 2$;& 6&&*%$9&*6<2(A 2&0&%(%(*&3()$*&A0.<&& $*9&2$/$..&1&/.< $00&$3&/(* &C$A(*$%(*'*/-'%&/6<%2&-*5$6'2./-'$%(*
$3/*&$5(*/&3$.(*12)* "$12$3(*123&)(/&*% 4(..$1&:
2-%%$:&2)(.$*/ ()%3('%8-/2($*$A$/&$'A0.$(*%$1$(*)%%2&0&%(%(*&3 %2$% $* (A0)%&3 2$/ %$9&* %2& &C$A(*$%(* %2& 0&%(%(*&3 $) 2& =$) 03&)&*%(*%2&6$*9*%2&/$%& &C$A(*$%(**>-(3<=$)2&./*%2&)$(/ 'A0.$(*%2&3&)-.% %2&0&%(%(*&3=$)'$*'&..&/;(/&(A0-1*&/3/&3 /$%&/ ?
@&2$/ (.&/DEE
?=2('2=$)=(%2/3$=* 6<2(A*@ E
?(*=2('2%2& ..=(*13/&3=$)0$))&/+
F %&3 $31-(*1 3 )A& %(A&: '-*)&. 3 %2&0&%(%(*&3)-6A(%)%2$%(*0-3)-$*'& %2& &*>-(3< 03'&&/(*1): %2& $3/ 2$) %$9&*$/&'()(*=2('2=(..6&3&>-(3&/% 6&'2$..&*1&/''3/(*1.<:2&03$<)%2$% %2& =3(% 0&%(%(* A$< 6& /()A())&/ $) =(%2/3$=*=(%2.(6&3%<% (.& 3&)2*&* %2&)$A&'$-)& $'%(* 3/&3&/$''3/(*1.<G 2&3&$ %&3:%2&0&%(%(*&3 (.&/$*%2&3
? =2('2=$)$.)=(%2/3$=**
(*=2('2%2& ..=(*13/&3=$) 0$))&/+ F8&$3*&/ '-*)&. 3 %2& 0&%(%(*&3 2$) )-6A(%%&/ %2$% %2() 0&%(%(* 2$) 6&'A& 3&/-*/$*%$%%2())%$1&:$)%2&&*>-(3<3&03% /$%&/
@ 2$) 6&&* $''&0%&/ $*/ %2& 3&)-.% %2& 0&%(%(*&3 2$) 6&&* '$*'&..&/ 3&1$3/(*12() &C$A(*$%(* *)&>-&*%.<: .&$3*&/ '-*)&. 3 %2& 0&%(%(*&3 03$<) 3 =(%2/3$=$. %2& 0&%(%(*(*3/&3%$;$(.2()%2&33&A&/<% '2$..&*1&%2&'$*'&..$%(*3/&3
()A())&/$)=(%2/3$=* 8(6&3%<13$*%&/G
&)0(%& %2& $ 3&)$(/ %= 3/&3): %2& 0&%(%(*&3 2$) (.&/ %2() 0&%(%(*%'2$..&*1&%2&3/&3 '$*'&..$%(* 2()3&)-.%
@ 2$;&2&$3/.&$3*&/'-*)&. 3%2&0&%(%(*&3$*/0&3-)&/%2& $;$(.$6.&3&'3/ 2&3&)-.% %2&0&%(%(*&3=$)'$*'&..&/6&'$-)& %2&'$)& " A0&3)*$%(*# 2& 0&%(%(*&3 2$) $(.&/ % (*/ $-.% =(%2 %2& &*>-(3< 3&03% =2('2 2$) 6&&* $''&0%&/ 6< %2& 2$(3A$* %2& 3&)0*/&*% $3/"3&;&3:%2&0&%(%(*&32$/=(%2/3$=*
?%$;$(.2()%2&33&A&/<%'2$..&*1&%2&'$*'&..$%(*3/&3& '$**% $;$(. =3(% 0&%(%(* $1$(* % '2$..&*1& %2& '$*'&..$%(* 3/&3 /$%&/
?
@:%2&3& 3&:%2&0&%(%(*&32$)$00$3&*%.<A()-)&/%2&03'&)) .$= 6&)(/&)%2& $'%%2$%%2&3&()*A&3(%(*2()0&%(%(*(*;(&= %2& (*/(*1
$'%3&'3/&/(*%2&&*>-(3<$1$(*)%2(A
()A())&/ ,,"# ,,"# ,,"# ,,"#
2&%2&3)0&$9(*1H3&$)*&/
&)H 2&%2&33&03%$6.&
&)H