Hargobind Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others




        





 ! "# $%&

 "%&%'&( $%&  





 

   

 

) *+) , ,,  -  *+) , ++  

 !

" ##

$#%& '(#

 " "#

$&

 & *# "  #$##& '(# + ,,,, ,,  -.

-

$ $ # .

&



# /#$

)(# 01 234 

565+35-7&

9#

(/ (& 0$#) )

;$ -:68<4=  

# /#$

)(# 01 27>4 

565635-7&

?

3

) )#( (# # '@ *# 

)(#

565+35-7& #(/

@#

886?7 #(& #

# 'AA#  $A& #* B#A#& "* & $# "#*#& )#AA

( 66& -5+& -5?& -5:& -56

--5

# # 0"$#A4 



@ .$

*(

'

#$ )#' +

.# @

;# 

A(




&

A#

$#@

#( #

@ ##<

7 # A &

A(

@

 )(# ;.$ '.

@ "


@

($@

# *#&

'@ 

 @ + 



"

.$

*(

( 66& -5+& -5?& -5:& -56

--5&

$A

(

# #<

$#)&

# '@ 

)(#

?

01 27>4 #(/

@#

886?7 #(&



A(

 ,),,,       +  ,+      , 8

A#

(A

 ( & @  

)(# # A#A /#$

 #

( 

'

C$# 2

A %.

9#

(/ 0C@ #4 A& -6?7 0$#) )

;$ A -6?74 $#' )AA. $

882 #2

(# #(/

'# # &  A

@

(A#20#4 2( 0-4

85&

' .$)

$#)
.'& (

 (#&  9#

(/ C@@ .# (

# '@&

'

A A -6?7  .$

A(

)#AA #A @ $#)

'

$)& (

#(/

#$ A##A # 

# #& (A

#

' @#

A(> '# )A#. > '#





  



    

 



    

  

       

+  )$ @

A#

(A

& AA

 #@ #



# 2 +

'@ # 

) *( & (# ( $)& 

*

A#($

 $ # C@ #

# #( 9#

(/& $#A# 

A@ (& 35-7 0$#) )

D( 35-7E4 ?

A#

(A

#

 -

@&

 A & "


*( +

'

 $

@ .

C@@ C$#@#$

C$) "& *#&  @  $A

-35-355?& 5-5?355?

/A & A 

5:57355?& 535+355?&   '

A 

-+--355?

. 

 #A ( " *( $

( )#' +

"


*( +

'

*# '@  #A A( & 3557& .$($ .# #A 1

$

*( ' )(# -63+

338355+& 

'@ *#& #@  

C@@(

/A & '@ *#& #@


# @  

A #A @ + -+5?355?& -?--355?& 



"


*( +

$#)&

# '@ 

)(#

#(/




 

A(

#4 G # A & @

(

)(# # 

# '@& #  C@ # 2 +&

A(

'H

A# $#@

#( #

@ ## #(( #(

A )

"# A#

# #& @  ()(#AA

A#

$#@

#(

@ "

.$

*( + # 'AA#  $A& #* B#A#& "* & $# "#*#&

$A

(

# # : 9#

# (A @ ( .#



# '@

($#

A(

#& *( ( 

A(

&  ) # (

#
 )$ @& (

 # 

A(

# '@& ($

(

882 #

A(#A '/("'0%123  &24" (5! 4!" !2 $'6%&23 6"%#4!4%&!(5""4 $4&, (24%& %123 (2%17 6

/ A#.

.$($ /

)@A#

#A #.

$ C& .$$& @ @ 

  

'@

'# 2

'

' .$)

$#)& A#1

A&  # #& ('A

(



  

 !"#$%#

&"!%%'
"(  

! "#        

$% % &'()*&)

&'()+  

         

  

  ,    

 

  -        

.

/   .  

. - 0   .0    

   

-5 ) #. #' )@A#

/ A#.

#))@#'& ' ) #@ @ 2( 0-4 (A# 0#4& 0##4

04&

' .$) (@

$#)&

 #

'@ #@ #)

)@ /  & (

#)#(& '2#2'& /  &

 @# ( $@

#'

'& #& 

.'&  (' #'&  .#%

' @ 

(A

(

 (@ 

1(A

 @#A .#% @ #'

#  

'@

' (@ ))('& >  A#(& ) # &

'& AA (/#A
  !$(  )$    *&+  -*+       

 

    

 



   

  



      -*+   

  

   

      

       

  

8


*+   

  

          

%"23 " 5!%&!2%9 5!!4:& $3 " 4&512 "23 !'904!!4%&!5$$" !! $9; 23 / 5"& $(%'&! /1%"23 6 2424%& "!4!" < (2 $.5&$.23 !'904!!4%&! 5$$" !! $9;23 / 5"& $,252 (%'&! /4!5(( 62 $

--

' )  (

#)#(

 #

'@ '2#2'



/ &

#A

$&  #%  $

(A#

#

'& 

 # # 

$#)&

'

(@ ))

'

( (@ 1(A  /A 2(@ A#(& ) # &

'

 #

'@&

 # #AA '#&

( & (#@ A#($

)

'# # 2 .$ ## 

# .

& (2 + -3

@# # $A

 #%  )#(@ ' A @ 01 2->74 

  

'@

+

$)& .$ .#%

@&

'

@#% #

A(#A

'  #)

(  /A& ))( 2(@ A#(& ) # &

#(/

#$ # $

#@  A'#( -7  @#A #A .$ "


*( +

'

 $ .

C@@



C$#@#$

C$) "& *#&  @  $A

-35-355?& 5-5?355? $@& #( '#A

A  '2#2' +& A#($

( 

A(

$ $ # (2 +&

 #(/ '( '#

-8
.'& ( # (#& #.#

#.# $) / # .$$ #

@

35-7 -+

$ $& A#

# (A #  ( @ @ 

#

$ C& A#

CAA( (#@

(A

( #.#

-- #  (A

## # $ -5-3

-5-7& -G04&

*

@  

EA C *+,#%- %

.!"-$  /+,#%0($( .12( 3$"% %4 (5 6!6 
 7

## .$)& #

$#)&

@ . $ C

( CAA(

# #.#

--

  

 

    

  

  1% 



      

          

    $% 2

     

  

 

   

 

       

      

            

                        





% #)& 11 )&1)&1#)&"

     

 

         

     

#)& %     




     

    1  

  

  

         

% &'!" &1&#1#)&   

% &'!"     *+

  & 

 .   #"1  3           

 

         



     )&1)&1#)&" % #)&  

1

 /        

   

      

% #)& 1/  

      

          



     

        . &&

% &'!" )&1)&1#)&"

  

% #)&        

81 /

 

 

  

    4 *+ /                       

 

, 5         $% , , % #)&              .   && 

   %  &'!"

       



 6                .   #"*&+ 

   %  #)&              

   % &'!"1

-? C/A &

@# # @ ' (#

$ C&  (#AA .$



 ( # .

 @ (#@

#

53-335-7&

$ C& .$)

$#) .$ #'

## # $

' ( @#

EA C& A#

.$ #.#

(#@

(A

  

#((

 (

( & > @

7


 (@

#

$ C&    #.#

( 
/

  

   

   

  

 7 8//

$% % &'!"    1 



)#1):1#)&"1 ;          

-G  /A& .$ #A A#

#'

## # $ #.#

#

@ C/A & #.#

@#

CAA(

#( )(# @#

$@ @

--

#.#

(

.$ @$ )@ # 

#&

@

$& 

)$.$



(2 +& ) CAA(  #

# #'#A#A (@

A#

2A -:

#(( A  =,,  -> 

=++>  

 $A$

3 23 "!6 5?4&:@" 5!%& $ 

!@%

3 23 "" 6%"259/ 

!@%