Kulwinder Singh v. Indian Red Cross Society & ORS




   
 

!"##$%&%'() *  +,-.%'/#01%'23 #"%"%'#0 5#0&,&
'/%!' #/0&&1$%#"6!'/"3#0& #&7'/#'"&
 


     

0#&#'"(4 0,8!'/,7"!9/:$!"#0"3#7#"%"%'#0 0++3!8,09/:$!"#0"3#0#&7'/#'"& ;;;

     

#"%"%'#09.3.!&!77%'"#/!&!!0/6,'/#0"3#
'/%!'

#/  0&&  1$%#"6  !'/  &#0:%'2  !"  "3#  #4!//%$"%'  #'"0#4$,<4

#3!=%-%"!"%'#'"0#9!'&!93!&%-#/"3#%'&"!'"7#"%"%'!&&!%-%'2"3# 0/#0/!"#/ 4 9.3#0#=63%&$-!%<00#2,-!0%?!"%'

%'&#0:%$#3!&=##'/#$-%'#/

!$"&"3#$!&#!0#%'!'!00.$<7!&&  !"3#0"3# 7#"%"%'#0.!&!0#2,-!0-!&&4
5#<7-6##,'/#0"3#
'/%!' #/0&& 1$%#"6#/%#/%'3!0'#&&'

 0#&#'"7#"%"%'#0.!&!77%'"#/ '$<7!&&%'!"#=!&%&!&!!0/6%'"#0<&0/#0/!"#/)*

 1#0:%$#&    "3#  7#"%"%'#0  3!:%'2  '"  =##'  0#2,-!0%?#/9  3#  %-#/    @ @ )=#0#"3##'"0!-/<%'%&"0!"%:#0%=,'!-93!'/%2!03 #'$3!'/&,$3 .!&/%&7&#/'A A.%"3!/%0#$"%'""3# 0#&7'/#'"1$%#"6""!8#!%'!-/#$%&%''"3#0#70#&#'"!"%'"3# !77-%$!'" 70#&#'"7#"%"%'#0 &##8%'20#2,-!0%?!"%'%'&#0:%$# 
"%&%' 7,070"#/$<7-%!'$#"3#/%0#$"%'&%&&,#/=6"3##'"0!-/<%'%&"0!"%:# 0%=,'!-"3!""3#%<7,2'#/0/#0/!"#/ 4 3!&=##'

44 7!&&#/ -!%<"3#7#"%"%'#000#2,-!0%?!"%'3!&=##'/#$-%'#/=6 $%"%'2"3#--.%'20#!&'&(4

%

#"%"%'#03!/=##'!77%'"#/!&!!0/6'$'"0!$"=!&%& !'/=6.!6$<7!&&%'!"#!77%'"<#'".3%$3%&'"!0%23" =,"'-6!$'$#&&%'

%% 3#7-%$%#&'"3#&,=B#$"0#2,-!0%?!"%'0!<#/=6"3# 1"!"# ,'B!=/'"!77-6""3#
'/%!' #/0&&1$%#"69 .3%$3%&!'!,"'<,&=/6!&"3#&!-!06@20!/#%&'"2%:#' =6"3#1"!"#:"

%%%
'/%!' #/0&&1$%#"69!'&!%&,'/#0%'!'$%!-/%&"0#&&!'/ "3#&,0$#&%'$<#!0#-%<%"#/!'/!$$0/%'2-6=#'#%" 0#2,-!0%?!"%'%'&#0:%$#$!''"=#!$$0/#/""3#7#"%"%'#0 !:%'2 3#!0/ $,'&#-  0 "3# 7!0"%#& !" -#'2"3  !'/ 3!:%'2 7#0,&#/"3#7-#!/%'2&'0#$0/9"3%&,0"%&"3#$'&%/#0#/:%#."3!" "3#  %<7,2'#/  0/#0  /!"#/   ''#>,0#  4  /#$-%'%'2  "  "3# 7#"%"%'#0=#'#%"0#2,-!0%?!"%'%'&#0:%$#9$!''"&,&"!%'
"%&'"%'/%&7,"#"3!":%/#0/#0/!"#/CA

) '#1<"##7!%&3".!&!77%'"#/!& #'%#!-!&&4
57&"'

$<7!&&%'!"#=!&%&'!$$,'"/#!"33#03,&=!'/.3.!&!-& &#0:%'2!&! #','/#0"3#
'/%!' #/0&&1$%#"6!'/3!//%#/%'

3!0'#&&'

 0#4'"%$#/1<"##7!%&3"3!/=##'20!'"#/ =#'#%"0#2,-!0%?!"%' :%/#0/#0/!"#/ ) 4A 9 7!&&#/  =6  "3#  #7,"6  <<%&&%'#04$,<43!%0<!'9 
'/%!'  #/  0&& 1$%#"69%&"0%$"0!'$39!'&!

4)4

#0,&!-"3#!77%'"<#'"-#""#01<"##7!%&3"'! -!&&4
57&"/!"#/CA

.,-/0#:#!-"3!"&,$3!77%'"<#'"!7!0"0< 3!:%'2=##'20!'"#/'!$<7!&&%'!"#20,'/.!&!-&'$'"0!$"=!&%& 0&%><'"3&3#0#%&!$-#!0&"%7,-!"%'%'3#0!77%'"<#'"-#""#0"3!"3#0 &#0:%$#&$,-/=#"#0<%'!"#/!""3##'/"3#$'"0!$"7#0%/.%"3,"!'6 '"%$#!'/.%"3,"!&&%2'%'2!'60#!&'
"%&'""3#$!&#"3#0#&7'/#'" 1$%#"6"3!"1<"##7!%&3"3!/=##'!77%'"#/!2!%'&"!0#2,-!0:!$!'" 7&" 1"0!'2#-69  "3#  20,'/&  !&  0#2!0/&  0#2,-!0%?!"%'  7-%$%#& 0<,-!"#/=6"3#1"!"#:"'"=#%'2!77-%$!=-#""3#
'/%!' #/0&& 1$%#"69!/:#0&#%'!'$%!-7&%"%'"3#%&"0%$" #/0&&1$%#"69!'&!

!'/"3#%'%"%!-!77%'"<#'"=#%'2'!$'"0!$",!-=!&%&3!:#=##'$%"#/'-6 %'"3#$!&#"3#7#"%"%'#0"/#'63%<=#'#%"0#2,-!0%?!"%'=,""3# &!<#:#0620,'/&3!:#'"3#-/2/%'"3#$!&#1<"##7!%&3"9.3 .!&  %/#'"%$!--6 &%",!"#/  !'/  .3  3!/  !-&  =##'  %'%"%!--6 !77%'"#/  ' $'"0!$",!-=!&%& #0-#'2"3&#0:%$#'$'"0!$",!-=!&%&.!&0! 7#0%/C6#!0&9.3#0#!&7#"%"%'#03!&=##'/#'%#/"3#&!<#:#06=#'#%" 0#2,-!0%?!"%'%'"3#-%23"%<7,2'#/0/#0/!"#/ ''#>,0#

4 %'&7%"#3!:%'2&#0:#/0!7#0%/%'#>$#&&6#!0& 3%&,0".,-/3!:#'3#&%"!"%'%'3-/%'2"3!""3#!$"%' "3#0#&7'/#'"1$%#"6%&!0=%"0!06!'/:%-!"%:#0"%$-#&A!'/ '&"%","%'
'/%! 3#%<7,2'#/0/#0/!"#/  9%9"#&"#/'"3#",$3&"'#!%0'#&&!'/#D,!-%"69$!''"&,&"!%'

#"%"%'#0%&#'"%"-#/""3#=#'#%"0#2,-!0%?!"%''"3#20,'/7!0%"6 .%"31<"##7!%&3"

4A4

0"3#0#!&'&0#$0/#/!=:#9%<7,2'#/0/#0/!"#/

4 %&&#"!&%/# #&7'/#'"1$%#"6%&/%0#$"#/"%&&,#0/#0& 0"3.%"3!&0#2!0/&0#2,-!0%?!"%'&#0:%$#&"3#7#"%"%'#0'"3#7&" !0/6@-!&&4
57&"

#"%"%'%&!--.#/%'"3#!0#&!%/"#0<&          

-,$86 3#"3#0&7#!8%'2@0#!&'#/( #&@ 3#"3#0 #70"!=-#( #&@