High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17718/2020allowed

Rajesh Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-02-10Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar24 pages

$" % "

(# )

* '

% "

$" % "

(# ) ))

"#( !"

$" % "

(# +

$" % "

" "

1- " $- . %"

*#32 # " *! *-"

*#32 "

6 )

))

" % 3 7 (2 *#32 "

" . 2 *#3 7"12 &"'2

" 5/4"

1-2 *##1 *#3 7"12 &"' - %8 '2 *#32 "

"(# 6

7"3 4/ !1"

1 #"# / ! "2 8" ( !41 1 #(1 8'

!! "#" !"##"$!%&%&

!4"

% 4;("

+ ;("

* 9* 3" 1 % &"' 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 "4'

'2 1/

"2 #(1'#< #( # 7"1 /"

#8' ! 1 "

("# '" 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 #(1'/ 1"- 7"1 /"

#8' 3" 1 / 3 ( ;(" % 4;("

9* ! "

1 !!"2 &"' .'

"#"

" '# (" 4

!( /# "#" ##

1"- #(1'#

9*2 # !( /# "#"2

!(1## "(# 6+ , ( "3 2 "(#2 =( "(# 6 "

((" 4" " (( ("> ("'" - %8 '2 1"# 1 "

"(# 6

1 # 8

4# # " !"$'&%!%&%& ) !4"

) !

;(" "!/

% 4;(" 1 "#"

## ?

(# !!"2 &"'2 "4'

'2 1/

"2 #(1'#<#( # (" (1 (/2 2

9* #" 1 %

&"'2 7"1 /"

#8' ! 1 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 #(1'/ 1"- 7"1 /"

#8' 3" 1 % 3 ( ;("<* "

% 4;("<1"-

9*2 !1'

! 1

"#"

" # 1"# *#3 7"12 &"'2 4# " 2

# 1"#'

"13#

# #("! "

# #( " ""'

!# " $- . 1"# "

1 "

("2 !# 1"

# "13# #<"

# #("! "

# #( 2

=/ # 1# !# 1"- #(1'#

9*2 !( /# "#"

!(1## "(# 6+

( "3 2 !

"# ((" 4" " !"$'"'!%&%&

!4" * %"" 3"

9* % &"' 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 "4'

'2 1/

* %""2 #(1'# ""2 % 9"("2 &"'2 "

("# '"

1 "#"

(# ""2 % 9"("2

&"'2 (/<# /

+ * %"" !# "#"

/ 3 @41 ! ." 7"1 /"

#8' !# 1 ;"!

"1 /"# 8" (

! "! )

!"$&()!%&%&

!4" "3" 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 "4'

'2 1/

"3"2 "("#

#8' "#"

(# 1"

##"# ""2 % 9"("2 &"'2 !!"2 &"'2 "!/

#" #

"3"

# ! #( !!"

% 4-

!!# "/1 #( (12

"3" !# 3141 % %1 !! # "/ '"

#( 4 !!"

" # #1

"3" #( # 1"

4 # 11/ ; ## "2 11/ A 1 "#"

(# !!"2 &"'2 "4'

(/ 11# "3" #( ""2 % 9"("2 &"'2

"#"

## )

" '# (" !( /# "#" 1"

1/ 8" (2

"3" 4" / #( 4 !(1## "(# 6+

8" ( ( "3 2 !

"# ((" 4" " !%&&)'!%&%&

!4" "3" 1 3"'

! "#" 1"

!( /#

!(1## ! "3" 4" / #( "(# 6+ "

1/ 8" (

( "3 2 "(# 6+

## "

((" 4" "

6 "!

"#" /"# 8" ( " 5/4"

1-2 1"# *##1 *#3 7"12 &"'2 "!# " " " 1 ( 4" / ! "!

"1 /"#

("! 73"! # 8 (" 8/2 2

/ !!"1 / &"'

#8' 4 "!# /1 11 '"

; 1'

("! ("# 1

1! #3 # # % ("! "

# $ !

% &!'! (#) *!!+ ''!##!

$ %

, "

- .%- !"!+ / + )1

1) )

#32

/ !

## % "11"2 ( "# + )

)2 !!"1 / &"'

#8' "1 !!"2 &"' ; "

#/ % "11"

/# !!"

/ 1 ( !!"

!!"1 / /# ""

7"12 % !!"1 /

&83"2 8 8/ ("# 11 '"

)

* # - 1'

+ ,

) 11 =/ 8 8/ #"8 1 *//"3# ("(# ! #1/'

112 ! !(1' ("! 1# 2 1# 3+4!

$!5

# (#) $

#2 4" "

# 8" ( 118# +

#"# 11 !(1' 1'

3/ ( ; "/"#2 "" !'

!# 1"

)

!!"2 &"'2 ##"# !(1'

/2 / ("!

# 8"-/ 8 8/

)2 2 !!"1 /

/2 ( *#!"3 " 4

8/ #" & "!# 8"-/ '1

/ 11'

#" 2 '"

)2 A 1 8"-/ 4

& """# "#

"#"

# 4! "'

4 ( "# !(1' 8"-/

8 # 8"-

8# # # ""

7"12 % 9"("2 &"' ! 12

+ +

7"12 % 9"("2 &"'2 "!# !!"2 &"'2 11 %""

9* &"'2 11 !(1'< 8"-/ !! #" 4

8/2 2 !!"1 /

/2 ' # "A # '

1 # #

/ 8# /3

( "

# <# ! !!"1 /2

1# "

( "8"##< "3# 8"/

: +

3 ## 4! '

( 8"/ "/"#2 #"#

# /"# (" # ! "! 11 " ( # '2

!(1' 8 8/ ("# /"/# 1 2 8'

!( /# "#"2 !(1' 8"-/ 8 8/ 8 / 1#2 ! #( 2 #(1'! "

"(" ." "/ 3" "/# 1 "( " #3# %2 (("(" -

1 ((141 ("! ("! 7" ( >.> %"3

12 ??

"!# =" (8"

""#

*"1

1 ) ?

((141 ("! 7" ( >.> %"32 !("/ ( 8 *((#= >*> "

*((#= >*> #!" ( 313# 1/ # ! " #

1 ""

"13 4 !'

1 ("/ >B41'

%"3> ! 1"

1 ??

"""# ( %"1 6

*((#= >*> !- 1"

( 3"#

1 &# ("! 811

#8' / ! ("! 7" ( >>

#8' %"3

12 ??, "

"2 >

1 ??,>2

"!# =" (8"

*"1 ) ?

1 +

1 ("3## '

" 1 ((141 "3 ""(#/ '

" 12

" !!#1'

4" !!! " 12 # "(1#

1 ((141 "3 !("/ ( 8 *((#= >*> " *((#= >*> #1# ( (" /" "1 %2 ("1 % 9 1 % ( *2 * 1"- # !

#/ >"1 %>2 1 ( ;("

% 4;("

# (1

#/ >("1 %>

B/ "

"3" &3'

$ 1 "3" # ! !

#/ &83"2 !'

12 // 3"'

!1 "2 ((141 1'

#8'2 2 !!"1 /

B ! ("! 7" ( >> !!"> %"3

12 ??

"2 >

1 ??

1 " "/

*"1 ) ?

1 ((1# "3 !("/ ( 8 *((#= >*> "2

(1 ( "1 %2 ("1 % 9 1 % * %""2 *2 * 2 % 4;(" 1"- # !

#/ >"1 %> % "

"3" # !

#/ >("1 %>

12 // 12 ((1# !!"> !( D#

2 " >%"3> ## ! ("! 7" ( >> !!"> %"3 &83"2 1 "! # 4

1 *"/ ! #3# "

1- " $- . 1"# "

12 # " *! *-"

1"# 1 "

6 )

))

" % 3 7 (2 1"# 1 "

8 #"#

"!"1'2 ## "

4 " 8 8/ 11 !(1' ("! 42 ( #(1'<#( !(1' 8/ 8/ 11 !" 2

%#1'2 ## ## 3 3"'

8"-/ ;("2 % 4;(" * %""

/ 1#

#(1'# !!"1 8/2 "

( =# *"#/ ("2 1# !# 8"- ( =/ !!"1 / ("

((141

1 ("2 #

8"-

" ! 4

8/ "#

" !# #( "#" # 3 # " #( #<#(1'# !(1' 8"-2 4 "#"2 "4'

!!"1 / 4" /

/2 " #

#1 ; (# " " !/ !( /# "#" #( <#(1'! '

-# =" #"- 4 8" !2

# # # ( 41 " 8/ !(1 "3#

"/"# /

; " (# 1!#

#"- =" "!1 '!

4 #1 " !/ " !(1 "3# (" / !

!(1 !# " /

#"-

#( <#(1'! !/ 12

/! "

; 1"32 (# ( !(1 "3# / !# #3# 12

# =(1

8 8 4 (-/ / (" 1"

!(1'

/ 4 !

#( < #(1'! "

'" ; ## ("!1 ((" #3"1'

# #( <#(1'! ; "3"2 "# (""

11 !(1' 48 8 8/ ("! 42 11 "3" #("! !!2 4 ( 4# '

! ## "! (1'

#(# "2 "3" 11# > " > 4 -(/

+ +

; (# )

1# ! "3" 8"-/

/ # !! <" 1"

## +

-/ 11 ( ( "3"

/ ""

42 "(1/ ! 1# ! / #" 118 !

/ 1 2 !! <" 1"

## +

#"8 !13 1/ "2 8" ( ! #!#

)

3/ "#"# " &83"2

1# # 8" ( -/ "11 #!1 "#"

)

("'/ "

#" 118 "

((1 11 (#/ #" ; ## 1!

"3" 1"#'

# 4"4#

/ ' # ##

(#/ 8" (2 ( "(" !

11# (" #("!2 /"/

8"-/

/ 3"'

1/ !

; "# /

" #3 "3" 48 8 8/2 #!" ""'

(#/ "# 2 1"# *#3 7"12 &"'2 # #( 8/ ## "A " & "1'

(

1 ??

31 %"3 7"1

"2 >

:> & "

1 ??

((1 !!"1 / &# !!"2 2

/2 1 E1#

/ /3"#

1 ??,

& (" " 1 ' "!# ""/ !2

1 ??

((1'

& ( (" #(1'! 1'

1!# ("# '"

" ! " #(# ( 41 " "!1 #!"2 8/ !(1 4 /

/ &

!(1 !# / ( #3# 1 " '

/"1 "#" #( <#(1'! (#2

1# "# /! B"# *#3 7"1 " " !# 8"-

" "

#3"'

"! ('1 "

A 31 (

# 4/ (# !!"1 / & " ("!1 ((" !(# ""/! "

("# '" ; ("/ "3"2 " 5/4"

1-2 1"# *##1 *#3 7"12 &"'2 11 ((#

1 ??, !

1 ??

!# ! &3'

$ 1 "3" & ("! 1# "# " ("

/ !("/

9*2 !!"1 / !("/

#8'2 &# 4

& &#

/ /3"#

1 ??

E1# !!"1 / 1'

7"1 /"

#8' /3"#

1 ??,

& " 1'

&# 4 "# ( "

#/! % ("! " " "3" #(

/ !!"1 / /

"#" (- ""

8"-

" "

("!1 ((" !(#2 (" " #

# "/ !!"1 /2 " ( ! #/ # 3 =2 #"'

##"2 " 2 ("1!"'

3"'

1/1'

!( /# "#"

"4'

#( <#(1'!<"(" (/

# " %#1'2 "

=! #!"3 =" "412 "1 " "4""

* 2 !'

# " 1"'

1 ((141 #" 131 8 8/ ("! * 1"#'

(# 2

1 ??

"13 4 # ((1# 4

1 ??,2 // !1 "2 1#

((1

/ "/ ! ""'

# ! 1'

" #

; ( !11'

1 ??, E1# %

/2 2 8"-/

9* !

1 ??

1 1# !(" ((141 1'

!!"

* /2 '"

("! #3## 4

8/ "!# (" ("!2 4/ "1

#2 2 !!" %/1'2

1 ## ( % 4;("

>"1 %> "

("! ( 1'

)) !(""'

( 3141 ( "

$ 1 ;("

8 (" >9 1 %> " )

("! ( ) !(""'

( E " "2

1 ?

12 #1/

! # "" !2 ("3## ( * * 2 5 "

* #"2 % 4;("2 * ! "

!B#/"

* 1# 11# ("! 5 "

%1 %/"( "2 %'(2 1"-2 %" " 1"- !( "

(""2 (" 8'

>6> " #"

1"# ( * % 4;("

" /41 4/ (

1 ??

((1 1 ; / 2 ! ##

: ?

##"# !!"2 &"'2 *##1 %""'2 ("!2 73"! &"'2 # 73"! "## / !1 " " (

/ !!"2 &"' " #"2 ("3## ( *<* 11# ;("

1 ( 1"- 11# % 4;(" " "2 !!"2 &"'2 # ! ##

"!/ ""2 % 9"("2 &"'2 11 %""

9* %2 !1 " ( 1"- :

*<*

# /# % 4;(" ;(" "(31' / !1 " -(/

1 ??

11 ((1412

1 ? " !# 1"

( % 4;("

* " /41 % "("/1'2 73"!2 3 !#/ #

12 ((1412 A # ( 1"-

% 4;(" %/1'2 1"- "!# (" #"

/"'

("! ( % 4;("F 2 " !(1 1- 1"'

((1 !# ("

"/"# 8 8/ " 1 ((141 !2 #( !3 4 " 8 4/ # 1/ 4- '"

) 9 ( !1#1'2 (("

#(# #1/

8 8/ !(1' 8"-/ " 13 1 #"# . # 1"

)

##"# !13 !# 1"

8 8/ "# (" #(# ""2 (("(" " 1 /

( (1 /3" !

#(#1' 4/ #2 (("

!/ (

8 1 A 31 ""'

" 12

((1 "#/ !2

1# " ("2 !'

# ( ;("

# 3 =

1 ((" (

# "

; !'

# !( /# "#" #( !(11'

4" "1 " # 4 1 !(1'

4 # #( < #(1'!

1"# *#3 7"1 // =" " 4 # !1"

#( <#(1'!2

41 =(1 4 (" 1"

!(1'

1# "

#( <#(1'! " ; #!# ??

% 4;("

/2 ,,

4 #

#( <#(1'!

%!1"1'2

;("2 +

#( <#(1'!

* %""2 )

#( #<#(1'# !!"1 / ; "(1 1# 8" (2

# (" ! "

#(# ( 41 " 8/ !(1

3/ "3# "" ( *"#/ !2 (" ="

#"- "!1 '!

-/ !!"1 3 1 !(1

(1# ""# E " "2 =(1#

82 4"// !(1'

#8' #"- # ;("2 % 4;(" * %""

/2 '!

-/ !!"1 3 1 "!1# ; !(1 #"# / !# #3# 12 !4 ( !

#(1"'

("#/ / !2 8# "" ( !(1' #("! 1/ " / !

8/ " "

8 (" =" 4 '!2 1 1 ( 41 1"/

; 811 1# '

#!"3 ! '

#4 "'

("(1 "41 ""2 3 2 =" #"- 41 E " "2

1 ??

1# >B41'

%"3>2 3 #

((1 ( ;("2 % 4;(" * %""

/2 # ! # "

1 (1 ( "

/! E"1'2

1 2 !!4"

"3 141 "3 '

(12 "

# % &"'2 ( 4/ "#"# #

# !(1

13/ (" "3 !/"/ "/ "3 ; 1'

( !!4"

"3 '

(12 % "

# %#1'2

1 2 !!4"

"3 !'

#( # "3 !('2 "

4#'

#3# 12 "("# "

11'

411'

8# "

"11# % 73"!2 ! (1 "(" "

11 "'

3"'

% &"' "#1'2

1 2 !!4"

"3 !'

#( # "3 "1 73"! "

!('2 2 "

4#'

#3# 12 "("# "

2 11'

411'

8# "

"11# "1 73"! E " 1'2

1 2 !!4"

"3 !'

#( # "3 '

% 73"!2 "1 "/D2 ! 4#'

"11# 73"! "

("3 4#'

!!4"

"3 11 #( # "3 "1 "

% 73"! "

"/D "

4#'

"""#

1 =(

; 1"# *#3 7"1

((1 ("1'

""2 "'

("2 4/ ("

/ ("!2

#( #<#(1'# !!"1

/2 2

#8'2

# (" ! (" "2 8#!2 4 "# 8 8/ (" #(# ! ("! E " "2 !!"1 / #!#1'

4#'

"(" ("

"/ ! #3# !13 4" % ("! "

# (11'

"/ # 1'

#("!1 ; "" # !('2 "

4#'

#3# 1

1 ""2

12 "!# =/2 # ! " "

; "

" ## "

((1! 8"# #

12 # 1# 1

"(" %/1'2

(11'

("3# 73"! !(1' !'

"""# ( 41 " #( '

"/D<#("! "1 73"!

1 (11'

(- #( '

#("! "1 73"!

( " !/

1 ??

#2 8#!2 % ## !# #

1 4"/ ("

/"1 " 1 4/

: E " "2 " # !" 1"# "

1 "("/ /"1 " 1 4/

("# "3 (1 " 1 ('

; !13

1 ??

((1'

("1'

("2 "3" ""2

14"'

- " " /"1 " 1 ; 2

1 ??

31 " ("2 " # =" #"- " "

/"3"

# 1 3"'

31#' ; #!# "

4 " ("! 8 8/ 11 ("! 42 4! (" #(# 3 "!# (" ! ("!

#8'2 4/ !!"1 /2 1# ""

/ #

/ 3"'

#/! % ("! " . # ## 4" % ("! "

#8' !('

"(" 4/ " #("!1 '2 4/ 8/ ("! % ("! " (11'

# 1'

"/#

#8' !('2 %2 1# #"# #"-/ !/ % :

$ 1 *2 ?

"2 > * ?

4! " # 4/ #3# " % ("! " (# % :

* ?

!## ("

# '

1 " '

G#"-/ 1# ((# !!4"

/1 * "' ; 4 % ("! " 1!1'

1# !!"2 4/ "

#8'2

1 " #"-/ !/ % :

* ?

#2 ""2

1# ((# "!

/1 * "' . # ((! " "

!4"

%""'

/1 * "'

# 1'

/" # 11/ "82 ! 1/

((141

1 # #"8

8 8/2 1 8 8/ "! !"/# 18"

131 B/11'2 " '

3"1((/ " 48 8 8/2 '

131 ("

( " '

1!1'

/ " # 4 "/ 8 8/ "'

# 11 !(1' ("! 4 8 8/ 4/ 1 (2 A #( / "

#(1'/ !(1' !!"1 /2 1'1 1

/2 2 # " * 1"-

#8'2 8 -# - !!"1 3 1 "# ('

;("

% 4;("2

"#1'

=(# 4# 4 3 1 -/ 3 1

#8'2

8 11/

" " # " ! " =" "" 11 1 4 ("(1 "/

% ("! "

1# / % "1"

"#" #( <#(1'! !( /# 6 )

))

"" 141 # "/ 8'

/" #

* "/"# "3" / "("#2 #!#

11# ("!1'

/ 8/ 1"

+ +

; # ! !

(# >""> 4

/ 1/ 4- '"

E " "2 "#"

## +

:2 "4'

*##1 !!"2 &"'2 """#< (# 1'

* 1"-

9* 4 %4"

%/ "3"

+2 8"-/

#8' "1

9* H! /"2 41 "3" 4

8/ "# !!

; %4"

## "!

(" ! #("!2 A """/

" 41 "/ ! #(

8/ # ! 1'

" # "#" /"11'

"" ("2 #( 2 3"'

1!# ("# # "

##F ; ## "2 1!

"3" 1# "#

/ 11 (#/ #" 4" " 8" (2 " "11 ((1 (#/2 ("! " (" " 1# 2 "4'

1# 1"11'

" !

#8' 4 !

"(" ;

32 " =(1 " !/ "#" 11/ '

4/ 3"

## ##1'

# 4 # /2 "4'

/ #(1# =" A 11'

4" ((1 !# "1 ." 1 #/2 !'

# 4 # 18 ("# "3 4

# /"1 ("(1 "1/ #( 2 "("2 &83"2 " # #!

4 "#

#/!

"" ("# # # 11'

"# ( ( 1"

43 1'2 " # ("!2 % &"'2 #( /2 #(1'/ "

"("/ !(1' 8"-/ 8/ 8/2 41 18 /" # !" 8" ( "#/1'

118# / # 11 !( /# ("#/ #/ !11 ((1 11 # 1# 1/ 1 "#" " 11 "#"

*+ ,

-"&%&%" .

/0**1 (-/<"# H

("41 H