High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23371/2014disposed of

Karampal v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Patiala & ORS

2023-12-12Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages

" #$%$&

%'( &(+#,#)$ -- .%/%01%2

------ ('#'#)$(/ 3(/,4, 5( /(,#&#$6

**#+(/7 $&4,'/#%2 /#84$%27 %'#%2% )'5(/,

------ (,1)$&($',

/(,($'

/#5%$'

%#$ /- #,5%85

%#$7

&9)+%'(

, 1('#'#)$(/-

/- 3#1#$ %2 !%&%97

&&#'#)$%2

-- 4$:%8 /(,1)$&($', )- - )$( /(,1)$&($'

- - - " 5#, %$ %112#+%'#)$ *#2(& 4$&(/ ;(+'#)$ 2#,'#$6 ,%0( %&:)4/$(& ,#$( &#(7 9#&( )/&(/ - - <7 1%,,(& +))/&#$%'( ($+5 '5#, )4/'-

)/ /(%,)$, 0($'#)$(& %112#+%'#)$7 ,%0( %22)>(& 0%#$ '%?($ 8)%/& ')&%= #',(2* 5(%/#$6-

112#+%'#)$ %++)/&#$62= &#,1),(& )*-

- ('#'#)$(/

.%/%01%2 *#2(& #$,'%$'

1('#'#)$ 4$&(/

/'#+2(, )$,'#'4'#)$ $&#% #,,4%$+( $%'4/( +(/'#)/%/# @4%,5#$6

>%/& --

$$(A4/( 7 1%,,(& $&4,'/#%2 /#84$%27 %'#%2%

5(/(#$%*'(/ /(*(//(& B'5( /#84$%2B7 >5(/(8= 1('#'#)$(/ 6/%$'(&

,- 7 7 #$,'(%&

/(#$,'%'(0($'-

4/'5(/ 1/%=(/ 0%&( &#/(+'#$6 /(,1)$&($', /(#$,'%'( 1('#'#)$(/ >#'5 *422 8%+?

>%6(, +)$'#$4#'= ,(/9#+(- - /#(*2=7 1('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$

.%/%01%2 /%#,(& %$ #$&4,'/#%2 &#,14'( /(6%/&#$6 '(/0#$%'#)$ 5#, ,(/9#+(, 12(% 5( 5%& :)#$(& 4$&(/ /(,1)$&($', $)-

5(/(#$

5(/(#$%*'(/ /(*(//(& C/(,1)$&($' %$%6(0($'D <- -"""

2(/?

5#, ,(/9#+(, >(/( '(/0#$%'(& "- - >#'5)4'

%$= $)'#+(7 #$@4#/= )/ %'

'#0( 5#, '(/0#$%'#)$7 5( '%?#$6 ,%2%/= ,- 7 1(/ 0)$'5- ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ +2%#0(& 5( 5%& >)/?(&

&%=, )$( =(%/ 5#, :4$#)/ >)/?#$6-

++)/&#$62=7 1('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ 1/%=(& /(#$,'%'(0($'

)'5(/ +)$,(@4($'#%2 8($(*#',- -

$ )'5(/ 5%$&7 %*)/(,%#& +2%#0 1('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ +)$'(,'(& /(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'

12(% 1('#'#)$(/ >)/?0%$ %11)#$'(& 9#&( 2(''(/ - -"""

+)$'/%+'

8%,#, 5( /(2#(9(& A(+4'#9(

**#+(/7 4$#+#1%2 )4$+#27 (/% %,,#7 9#&( 2(''(/ - - ,%#& 2(''(/ &42= /(+(#9(& 1('#'#)$(/ >)/?0%$- '

,'%'(& (A'($,#)$ +)$'/%+'

1(/#)& >)/?0%$7 #'

*#$%$+#%2 84/&($ 4$#+#1%2 +)4$+#2-

++)/&#$62=7 1/%=(/ &#,0#,,%2 +2%#0 1('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ 0%&(-

$ 8%,#, 12(%&#$6, 1%/'#(,7 *)22)>#$6 #,,4(, >(/( */%0(& 2(%/$(& 8(2)>

# $ % - 9#&($+( 2(& /(,1(+'#9( 1%/'#(, ,411)/'

'5(#/ +2%#0,- - )$,#&(/#$6 0%'(/#%2(9#&($+( %9%#2%82( /(+)/&7 E(%/$(& 8(2)>7 9#&( #',

>%/& --

$$(A4/( 7 /('4/$(& *)22)>#$6 *#$&#$6,

% ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ (012)=(& 4$#+#1%2 )4$+#27 (/% %,,# - -"""-

8 ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ $)'

1(/0%$($'

(012)=(( )/ (012)=(& %6%#$,'

/(642%/ 1),'-

+ ;(/9#+(, ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ >(/( '(/0#$%'(& 9#&( 2(''(/ - - -

& %:#$&(/ ;#$65 5#, +/),,(A%0#$%'#)$ %&0#''(& +)//(+'

>)/?0%$ +)$'#$4)4,2= >)/?(& >#'5 )00#''(( *)4/ =(%/, $) ,1(+#*#(& 1(/#)& 0($'#)$(& %11)#$'0($'

2(''(/ A- >5#+5 #,,4(& >)/?0%$-

( ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ >)/?(& */)0 <- -"""

"- - 5#, ,(/9#+(, >(/( '(/0#$%'(& >#'5)4'

%$= $)'#+(7 +5%/6(,5(('

)/ 1%=0($'

* (/0#$%'#)$ ,(/9#+(, ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ 9#)2%'#)$ 1/)9#,#)$, ,(+'#)$

+'- - 5( E(%/$(& 8(2)> 6/%$'(& *)22)>#$6 /(2#(* ('#'#)$(/>)/?0%$ & !

' !

( !

! ) #

* +

, ! - .

' +

' !, ' &

/ 0

, 22* 3 4 556 7

3'+4 8 , ,

22"

2 ! !

;<= 91), >#7

? ! ,

$ ";222(< 3$ !

! $ )

! !

, + ! )

)

!, A

A "

$8598=

" !

$ 1

$ ";222(< 3$ !

*2 !

B *C

)

% <- $ %*)/(0($'#)$(& +#/+40,'%$+(,7 1('#'#)$(/ *#2(& #$,'%$'

1('#'#)$ 8(*)/( '5#, )4/'-

"- 5%9( 5(%/& 2(%/$(& +)4$,(2 /(,1(+'#9( 1%/'#(, 5%9( 1(/4,(& 1%1(/8))?

>#'5 '5(#/ %82( %,,#,'%$+(- - )$+(&(&2=7 %*)/(,%#&

>%/& --

$$(A4/( $)'

#0146$(& /(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'- -

*'(/ %/64#$6 ,)0( '#0(7 2(%/$(& +)4$,(2 1('#'#)$(/ +)$*#$(, 5#, 1/%=(/ )$2= >#'5 /(6%/& ($5%$+(0($'

%>%/&(& 8(2)> ,480#''#$6 %>%/&(&

8(2)> 2)>(/ ,#&(-

$ )'5(/ 5%$&7 2(%/$(& ;'%'( +)4$,(2 %11(%/#$6 /(,1)$&($', )- )11),(& 1/%=(/ 1('#'#)$(/ ($5%$+(0($'

,480#''#$6 %>%/&(& :4,'#*#(& %++)/&#$62=7 1/%=(/

&#,0#,,%2 #$,'%$'

1('#'#)$ 0%&(-

- )$B82( ;41/(0( )4/'

E'A5 / E

;

5(2& 4$&(/ " 9

(

( ! !

), +

# $ !

< !

! F '

;= 9

, !

! ! !

, 3'G ' &

1 , 3 22*4 # '++ 4, :

! ,

! +

, ! !

! 9

- $ )

, $

1 +

/ @ '

;41/(0( )4/'

%,(, %8)9(,'%'(& 9#(> %**#/0(&- '

5(2& /(#$,'%'(0($'

$)'

/42(7 #'

&(1($&, 41)$ 9%/#)4, +#/+40,'%$+(,7 2#?( $%'4/( >)/?7 0%$$(/ 0('5)& %11)#$'0($'7 2($6'5 ,(/9#+( ('+- $ 9#(> /%'#) :4&60($',7 /(*(//(& %8)9(7 6/%$'

#$,'(%& /(#$,'%'(0($'

1/)1(/ /(0(&=-

- 5( )$B82(

1(A )4/'

12('5)/% +%,(, &#/(+'(&

2#(4 /(#$,'%'(0($'-

(*(/($+( +%$ 8( 0%&(

1 A

, @ G 3 22?4 '++ ;7;, '

A = :

G 3 22?4 ; '++ 7;,

@1) ) &

G 3 22?4 # '++ * -

%?#$6 $)'( *%+'

1('#'#)$(/ %11)#$'(& 2(/?

/(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'

<- -"""

5( $)'

/(642%/ (012)=((F 5( 6(''#$6 0)$'52= ,%2%/= ,- 7 F ,(/9#+(, 1('#'#)$(/ 5%& '(/0#$%'(& 9#)2%'#)$ 1/)9#,#)$, ;(+'#)$

'(/0#$%'#)$ '))?

12%+( %8)4'

=(%/, %6)7 +)412(& >#'5 *%+'

/(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'

$)'

2%#& %$= +5%22($6( %*)/(,%#&

>%/& --

$$(A4/( %2,) +)$,#&(/#$6 1('#'#)$(/ 2#'#6%'#$6 >#'5 /(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'

,#$+( F '5(/(*)/(7 %0 )1#$#)$ %>%/&(& 1('#'#)$(/ 2)>(/ ,#&(- - )$,#&(/#$6 ')'%2#'= +#/+40,'%$+(,7 0= +)$,#&(/(& 9#(>7 #$'(/(,'

:4,'#+( >)42& 8( 0('

#* %>%/&(& 1('#'#)$(/ 8(2)> ($5%$+(& */)0 ,- 7 ,- 7 7 -

(,1)$&($'%$%6(0($'

&#/(+'(& 1%=

($5%$+(& %0)4$'

1('#'#)$(/

%*'(/ %&:4,'#$6 ,- 7 7 #* %2/(%&= 1%#&7 >#'5#$ 1(/#)& '5/(( 0)$'5, */)0 &%'( /(+(#1'1/)&4+'#)$ +(/'#*#(& +)1= '5#, )/&(/-

$)$1%=0($'

%*)/(,%#& %0)4$'

1('#'#)$(/ >#'5#$ ,'#142%'(& 1(/#)&7 1('#'#)$(/ ,5%22 8( ($'#'2(& +2%#0 ,#012( #$'(/(,'

/%'( G 1(/ %$$40 '#22 '#0( ,4+5 1%=0($'

$)'

0%&(-

<- 5( #$,'%$'

1('#'#)$ &#,1),(& %*)/(,'%'(& '(/0,- "-

1($&#$6 %112#+%'#)$ ,7 #* %$=7 ,5%22 ,'%$& +2),(&-

,:?, 5('5(/ ,1(%?#$6/(%,)$(&

!(,

) 5('5(/ /(1)/'%82( !(,

)