High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23379/2014disposed of

Jaspal v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Patiala & ORS

2023-12-12Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages

" #$%$&

%'( &(+#,#)$

- -

%,.%/ ------ ('#'#)$(0 1(0,2, 3( 0(,#&#$4 **#+(05 $&2,'0#%/ 0#62$%/5 %'#%/% )'3(0,

------ (,.)$&($', 78 -

9 9 0(,($'

0#3%$'

%#$ 0- #,3%63

%#$5

&:)+%'(

, .('#'#)$(0-

01#.#$ %/ !%&%:5

&&#'#)$%/

-- 2$;%6 0(,.)$&($', )- - )$( 0(,.)$&($'

- - 9 5

" 3#, %$ %../#+%'#)$ *#/(& 2$&(0 9(+'#)$

/#,'#$4 ,%=( %&;)20$(& ,#$( &#(5 :#&( )0&(0

- - "5 .%,,(& +))0&#$%'( ($+3 '3#, )20'-

)0 0(%,)$, =($'#)$(& %../#+%'#)$5 ,%=( %//)?(& =%#$ '%@($ 6)%0& ')&%> #',(/* 3(%0#$4-

../#+%'#)$ %++)0&#$4/> &#,.),(& )*-

('#'#)$(0

%,.%/

*#/(&

#$,'%$'

.('#'#)$

2$&(0

0'#+/(, )$,'#'2'#)$ $&#% #,,2%$+( $%'20( +(0'#)0%0# A2%,3#$4

?%0& -

$$(B20( 5 .%,,(& $&2,'0#%/ 0#62$%/5 %'#%/%

3(0(#$%*'(0 0(*(00(& 7'3( 0#62$%/75 ?3(0(6> .('#'#)$(0 40%$'(&

,- <5 #$,'(%& 0(#$,'%'(=($'-

20'3(0 .0%>(0 =%&( &#0(+'#$4 0(,.)$&($', )-

3(0(#$ 0(#$,'%'( .('#'#)$(0 ?#'3 *2// 6%+@ ?%4(, +)$'#$2#'> ,(0:#+(- - 0#(*/>5 .('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$

%,.%/ 0%#,(& %$ #$&2,'0#%/ &#,.2'( 0(4%0&#$4 '(0=#$%'#)$ 3#, ,(0:#+(, ./(% 3( 3%& ;)#$(& 2$&(0 0(,.)$&($', $)-

3(0(#$

3(0(#$%*'(0 0(*(00(& C0(,.)$&($' %$%4(=($'D - ,(0:%$'

3#, ,(0:#+(, ?(0( '(0=#$%'(&

- - ?#'3)2'

%$> $)'#+(5 #$A2#0> )0 %'

'#=( 3#, '(0=#$%'#)$5 3( '%@#$4 ,%/%0> ,- < .(0 =)$'3- ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ +/%#=(& 3( 3%& ?)0@(&

&%>, )$( >(%0 3#, ;2$#)0 ?)0@#$4-

++)0&#$4/>5 .('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ .0%>(& 0(#$,'%'(=($'

)'3(0 +)$,(A2($'#%/ 6($(*#',- - $ )'3(0 3%$&5 %*)0(,%#& +/%#= .('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ +)$'(,'(& 0(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'

./(% .('#'#)$(0 ?)0@=%$ %..)#$'(& :#&( /(''(0 - +)$'0%+'

6%,#, 3( 0(/#(:(& B(+2'#:( **#+(05 2$#+#.%/ )2$+#/5 (0% %,,#5 :#&( /(''(0 - <- ,%#& /(''(0 &2/> 0(+(#:(& .('#'#)$(0 ?)0@=%$- '

,'%'(& (B'($,#)$ +)$'0%+'

.(0#)& ?)0@=%$5 #'

*#$%$+#%/ 620&($ 2$#+#.%/ +)2$+#/-

++)0&#$4/> .0%>(0

&#,=#,,%/ +/%#= .('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ =%&(-

$ 6%,#, ./(%&#$4, .%0'#(,5 *)//)?#$4 #,,2(, ?(0( *0%=(& /(%0$(& 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

# $ % <- :#&($+( /(& 0(,.(+'#:( .%0'#(, ,2..)0'

'3(#0 +/%#=,- - )$,#&(0#$4 =%'(0#%/(:#&($+( %:%#/%6/( 0(+)0&5 8(%0$(& 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

:#&( #',

?%0& -

$$(B20( 5 0('20$(& *)//)?#$4 *#$&#$4,

% ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ (=./)>(& 2$#+#.%/ )2$+#/5 (0% %,,# - -

6 ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ $)'

.(0=%$($'

(=./)>(( )0 (=./)>(& %4%#$,'

0(42/%0 .),'-

+ 9(0:#+(, ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ ?(0( '(0=#$%'(& :#&( /(''(0 - <- -

%;#$&(0 9#$43 3#, +0),,(B%=#$%'#)$ %&=#''(& +)00(+'

?)0@=%$ +)$'#$2)2,/> ?)0@(& ?#'3 )==#''(( *)20 >(%0, $) ,.(+#*#(& .(0#)& =($'#)$(& %..)#$'=($'

/(''(0 B- ?3#+3

#,,2(& ?)0@=%$-

( ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ ?)0@(& *0)= -

- - 3#, ,(0:#+(, ?(0( '(0=#$%'(& ?#'3)2'

%$> $)'#+(5 +3%04(,3(('

)0 .%>=($'

* (0=#$%'#)$ ,(0:#+(, ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ :#)/%'#)$ .0):#,#)$, ,(+'#)$ <

+'- - 3( 8(%0$(& 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

40%$'(& *)//)?#$4 0(/#(* ('#'#)$(0?)0@=%$ & '

' ! ( !

! ) #

* +

, ! - .

' +

' !, ' /

0 1

, 33* 4 5 66& 7

4'+5 8 , ,

33"

3 ! !

& '

;<= 92), >#7

? ! ,

$ ";333(< 4$ !

! )

! !

, + ! )

)

!, A

A "

$8698=

" !

$ 2

$ ";333(< 4$ !

*3 !

B *C

)

% "- $ %*)0(=($'#)$(& +#0+2=,'%$+(,5 .('#'#)$(0 *#/(& #$,'%$'

.('#'#)$ 6(*)0( '3#, )20'-

- 3%:( 3(%0& /(%0$(& +)2$,(/ 0(,.(+'#:( .%0'#(, 3%:( .(02,(& .%.(06))@ ?#'3 '3(#0 %6/( %,,#,'%$+(-

)$+(&(&/>5 %*)0(,%#&

?%0& -

$$(B20( $)'

#=.24$(& 0(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'-

*'(0 %042#$4 ,)=( '#=(5 /(%0$(& +)2$,(/ .('#'#)$(0 +)$*#$(, 3#, .0%>(0 )$/> ?#'3 0(4%0& ($3%$+(=($'

%?%0&(& 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

,26=#''#$4 %?%0&(& 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

/)?(0 ,#&(-

- $ )'3(0 3%$&5 /(%0$(& 9'%'( +)2$,(/ %..(%0#$4 0(,.)$&($', )- )..),(& .0%>(0 .('#'#)$(0 ($3%$+(=($'

,26=#''#$4 %?%0&(& ;2,'#*#(& %++)0&#$4/>5 .0%>(0

&#,=#,,%/ #$,'%$'

.('#'#)$ =%&(-

- )$76/( 92.0(=( )20'

E'A6 0 E

3(/& 2$&(0 " 9

(

( ! !

), +

# $ !

< !

! F '

;= 9

, !

! ! !

, 4'G ' /

2 , 4 33*5 # '++ 5, :

! ,

! +

, ! !

! 9

$ )

, $

2 +

0 @ '

< 92.0(=( )20'

%,(,

%6):(,'%'(& :#(?

%**#0=(&- '

3(/& 0(#$,'%'(=($'

$)'

02/(5 #'

&(.($&, 2.)$ :%0#)2, +#0+2=,'%$+(,5 /#@( $%'20( ?)0@5 =%$$(0 =('3)& %..)#$'=($'5 /($4'3 ,(0:#+( ('+- $ :#(?

0%'#) ;2&4=($',5 0(*(00(& %6):(5 40%$'

#$,'(%& 0(#$,'%'(=($'

.0).(0 0(=(&>-

<- 3( )$76/(

.(B )20'

./('3)0% +%,(, &#0(+'(&

/#(2 0(#$,'%'(=($'-

(*(0($+( +%$ 6( =%&(

2 A

, @ G 4 33?5 '++ ;7;, '

A = :

G 4 33?5 ; '++ 7;,

@2) ) /

G 4 33?5 # '++ *

%@#$4 $)'( *%+'

.('#'#)$(0 %..)#$'(& ()$ 0(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'

- 3( $)'

0(42/%0 (=./)>((E 3( 4(''#$4 =)$'3/> ,%/%0> ,- 5< E ,(0:#+(, .('#'#)$(0 3%& '(0=#$%'(& :#)/%'#)$ .0):#,#)$, 9(+'#)$ <

'(0=#$%'#)$ '))@ ./%+( %6)2'

>(%0, %4)5 +)2./(& ?#'3 *%+'

0(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'

$)'

/%#& %$> +3%//($4( %*)0(,%#&

?%0& -

$$(B20( %/,) +)$,#&(0#$4 .('#'#)$(0 /#'#4%'#$4 ?#'3 0(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'

,#$+( <E '3(0(*)0(5 %= ).#$#)$ %?%0&(& .('#'#)$(0 /)?(0 ,#&(-

- )$,#&(0#$4 ')'%/#'> +#0+2=,'%$+(,5 => +)$,#&(0(& :#(?5 #$'(0(,'

;2,'#+( ?)2/& 6( =('

#* %?%0&(& .('#'#)$(0 0#62$%/ 6(/)?

($3%$+(& *0)= ,- <5 ,- 5 5 -

(,.)$&($'%$%4(=($'

&#0(+'(& .%>

($3%$+(& %=)2$'

.('#'#)$(0

%*'(0 %&;2,'#$4 ,- <5 5 #* %/0(%&> .%#&5 ?#'3#$ .(0#)& '30(( =)$'3, *0)= &%'( 0(+(#.'.0)&2+'#)$ +(0'#*#(& +).> '3#, )0&(0-

$)$.%>=($'

%*)0(,%#& %=)2$'

.('#'#)$(0 ?#'3#$ ,'#.2/%'(& .(0#)&5 .('#'#)$(0 ,3%// 6( ($'#'/(& +/%#= ,#=./( #$'(0(,'

0%'( F .(0 %$$2= '#// '#=( ,2+3 .%>=($'

$)'

=%&(-

"- 3( #$,'%$'

.('#'#)$ &#,.),(& %*)0(,'%'(& '(0=,-

// .($&#$4 %../#+%'#)$ ,5 #* %$>5 ,3%// ,'%$& +/),(&-

- -

,;@, 3('3(0 ,.(%@#$40(%,)$(&

!(,

) 3('3(0 0(.)0'%6/( !(,

)