High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22687/2015allowed

Vinay Kumar Kakkar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-11-29Mr. Justice Darshan Singh23 pages

!"##" "

$ %"

&" '( " # ! '!$)"(&" "

$ %"

&" '( $ %& ' ( " *"+!,&-.+/. "&("01 2&& *$&" ,3 4.++3.%"

*"'5).+/. ""(

*"#-3 (.+/. ""(6

*"!#)/.+/. ""(

*"+ "73 4.+/. ""(6

*"$()".+/. ""(

( ) 8&"")44( & "!))"(

(" "" 2 74 ("

(" ""2 &"&"8& & /4/ 2&&!!4.&" ".2&&(2 /4 2 74"".&9 4) "& !8&!2

"7 2 *"+! ,&-&.+//"7" 2&&&4$7&:"( 6

7 )&! & " 2" 7& " "(" 2 *" + "7 3 4. +/. )&4 *" #- 3 (. +/. ((" 2&4 "( 6 %"

$ ;4" /4(! "(" <! 0&" " =& "(">1. )&& ) & (" !(4 " "( 2 " & ! "( %" $ +7" 4 "4*"#75"0&" "=&5">1.)&&&7 "()& / " &4$7&:"(" &4472&& $

& .&("&/

4 &447&2"( "(&5""/ )&&) "7"(&)#( "! &"("8&! &&"" "

"( &"/ &5"& 29 2"(.)&& 2 7 & " 4 "/ &"2 " 4

7 & "7& & ("" ("!&7&"(&5".)&& &"(""7

8&"4/ "

& "7 &" &&("

&/2)"#7&5" $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41 )&4 &! ;? / ;7" 0;4"41 "" &"7 01 %". )& & ( )" 4 8& &/ 2 )"#7 & 4 " 8& ("

) (( , " ;7" 0;4"41 "7 4" 2 ) (4! &4" ;4"4;7"7)&&) "/%)("! $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41 )

& 2 )"#&!( '(@&4$7&&"(("%&

4(""(42&&(7&% && ))"#7( ;7"0;4"41&"(")2" 7& ( !(""

2 " "/""

& "&"! ( "(" &5"/

""(2 & "(" 6

. &4 $7& ) "4/ & ) 6

0+A1&"("24&!-& )&& 5"/-7"(" /B( &5".&2! $ 2/4;7"0;4"41&( 4

A: "

" "2(&# 48&&)&"# (4( 2 "!&( ( ;7"0;4"41&42 &4 $7& & "(" & ( $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41 & 5" B & ( . & "/ & !(4 &5")"7/"2 &("/ &%"

$ +7" 4 "4*"#75"' 4. 60&" "2" ""=&

' 4>1 + (" & ' 4. & ((! &( $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41 4 2 ! 2 &" " "" ! " 2 ("!"2 " ""( 2 44 (&!"("/ "&' 4' 4 &' 4(""27&=C 4 >"

44) D *+,-../,0.12 @ (" &44 2 (( & $"/. 4 & ( 9 4 ?("( 4 ! +((?5&" 4 & """ !&( 4 ! &+((?& "" !&"&2 " "" !E ' 4 47)&&=!& "" !>" 44) 304563/6+.07310@01'" !&$"/ &44 2 ! & !" ( 4 ! 6 +((?5&" 4 @ +44("!&442!&2 " : !:!" : F4 &") ("/. )&" ((! 2 ! 2& 2 " "" ! &" & 2 " "" ! :A (" ( &44 2

44 2 " "" ! :A (" ( &" & " "" ! ' ""((!"((!2 " " "( &442!4 24" /424 "!)&&$"/E G 4" & ' 4 4 ) & " " " ((! " ((! 2 " " " ( &44 2 ! 4 24"/424 "!)&&$"/ &5"8& +((? & ' 4 "7"7 & ( $ 2 /4 B

" 44 $" " 44)

'6 32.81,0. 1920 /,537./ :+,-../,0.12 ,15 3;936.31/3) . ,1<) 6 5.63/0 63/6+.07310 /,537./ :+,-../,0.12 ,15 3;936.31/3) . ,1<) 6 ,99.107310 0436 04,1 =< 5.63/0 63/6+.07310 304563/6+.07310 ??

$ 2 /4

" 5$ ;7"7 "(/ 2"& ;7"7" 9 /4 (4! & "(/ 2"& ;7"7 " " !0/41)& "?(" , " ;7" " + " !H " 01 , " ;7" " + " ! )& ( +*G; 9 4 / " ?(" )

"?("& 7"&4" 012 """ !H" 012 ("!H 012 " ""( H2

44&!" "

20 ,--0035 .1 >,6.+2 /,0386.32 .1 , -0

9202 5.>.535 .10 # =-/?2

92023,/4 0,- 3,/4 /,0386< GG GGG 8 4 01 " "" ! 012 ("!

"! $4

" 01 ("! "! +" ! :

0/1 ("! "! $4B

" +" ! (7 9 4 +*G; :

84 G 24 " /424 "! " 0/1&/ &442 442 """ ! G/424 "! "01"01 ("&2((( 24"(:7( ""7! "!&"&&44 ". &(" &44 2 424 2 "/" & "74 " )& "!&44 "/424&(" "/""2 &(")442 "# " &( "( " 8& %"

$ +7" 4 "4 *"#7 5" ' 4. 6 )""(42 )' 4 6

& 4 & =%"

$+7" 4 "4*"#75"$"/' 4.

>0&" " 2" ""=

' 4>18&' 4! " 6

/%"

3/"!.+7" 4 "("!. / ?" ()" "" 2 2: 01 " )& 4 0??/1. 0???1 0???1 2: 01 $ 6 & -2 +7" 4 "4" *"#+. 0 -2+ 1((424 %"

' 4 &

' 4("/ " 9 4 "2 "' 4 &+((?&" 48&' 4" 44) ("4&442(( (&$"/. 4 & ( 9 4 ?(" ( 4 ! +((?5&" 4& " "" ! & ( 4 ! 6 & " +((? & ((! &" & 2 """ ! "/ & " "" ! ""/ 7" !(4 .&"7"7?("&44 2 "4?24 & ? I & " & ((7 &"

!2" 2477 $& 4 . 5#)" 4. B&" 5#)" 4. ;?:"/! & 4 %(( 7".(7&"9 ?(""/424 44 (&/""/ "&!. """7"

"7)"7E ' 4 4)&&=!& "" !>(""2

44) D '" !&$"/&442!&!" ( +((?5&" 4E $" &!!2" "/7/"2 &("/ ' 4.)&&" 44) D $" " &!!2" &$"/&442 "!2 &47& &" "/ ( &$"/ "/ "&"&& !!2"((2 " "" !. & "" !" "! 2 &

((7 &" ! & " 4 &44 2 "2 ?7&" H "/ "&"&& )"!"!!2" ((&!.&"" &442"!

44) 01 !!2"((2 """ !&442 "!!2"((2 ("!"2 " "H 021 !!2"((2 ("!&442" !!2"((2 " "H 01 & !!2"((2 ("!" " "." &442"!"7 & " & !!2" & ((! "! )&& & )" ("! " " "".H 01 & !!2"((2 " " "!

"".&"" &442"! "7 ( . (" " 27 7/ !!2".)&)")7&7&"" ( & ("/ ((! & " ( ")"4&!.&2 &47& &" "/ & ((! & 47& & "/ 4 & !. 4" !!2" &442" 7"!!2" $" !!2" &$"/(( ( "4 ("/4 2 " 4 )7A" 4 (" &44 2 "! )&& ""7 4"4 ((/) & &"7 4"((!E &4 )"#7 ( $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41.&4$7&)2"2"9 !2 &!)"7

/!! 0+?: 1&"/ & 5" & ( 4

3 4 6 & 2"( "" 0+? : 1 " "4/ "! & "7& &4 $7&&5"7&"7& &(".)&"77"/2

&2"(""&&)4 ("!&" &""7 !&)"" "7&&"74 6"

44) D K "((!2 " ")442( "4 !(""

27!(""

/ "!24!& )& 77 "&"?( "!/4 " " &/7 2 2 "

)&& " "/ &44 2 "! )& G)44.&)/".2(&5"( !4 !4 &" "&(")&&& 44 &" !& $!4"4 . )44 "7A9 "( ! 2 (7&5" !4 ! "&!&4 & "(" )&&& 44&" !& ?? ?? ?? 6 K )4427/&" 2 )&!!

("/2 )4427/?(( 2 E 4 "&&((!2 " ")442( "4 !(""

27!(""

/ "!24!&> )& 77 "&"?( "!/4

" &/7 2 2 "

)&& & "/ 42"!)& 4 6( 4& &4$7&)4427/" 2 )&!!

( "/ 2 )44 2 7/ ?( ( 2 % "/ )" "" 2 7/" 2 & " 4 "7 4 &" "/"((424"! 2 "! " "&!(4 & 5" "!!! 8& "( @ 5" & 7" 4 $ 2 /4;7"0;4"41A, ";7"0;4"41/!! 6)&&&0&4$7&1! 7 "$"(4!

&4" G & 4 ! =)&&" "! " !(""

>. ) 4"4 =8!>. !7 !(""

8& "

"/ ) &) "! & 2"( & " $ 2 /4 ;7" 0;4"41 8& ! & (" 44 & " 7 7" 4 & ( , " ;7" 0;4"41 5 & 7" 4. &4 $7& 2! " & (" G ! 2 ! )& " " & / " 4 $ 2 /4 ;7" , " ;7" " 4 & 5" 607 1&(" ( $ 2/4;7"" &5"6!"( $ 2/4;7"0;4"41 )" " ( $ 2 /4 ;7" )" "

6G44.&""( $ 2/4;7" G 4" ?(4 4 " ("4 &4 $7&> ! (" 9 4 ""(&( $ 2/4;7""! ' 4((424(""

)&)$" G&"!"# 4 !. & 2 ( & =

!""" #!

"$ $ $!

$ "" % " &!'

( )!

$ #!

$ *

" + ,-. -

'$ " !$ $! $

> G &". &4 $7& ) 2"2 7 !(""

0?(1 ( '!"#24 . & !. & 44 & 9 4 " " "" ! G ) "" & 2"( " &447 & %7& " & ) "74 - 7 '" ! " "9 (4 $"24) $& /# . /) &

2"(%" )&)/"#(( 2- 4 ! & " B & &" &. ( & !" ) &)?24)&4$7&G&"!"#4 !.&2"" &&)("!$;0;1)

&2%44 7&2G&2 /424 ( "4/ 9 .&5" &&2"7 4"L$;0;1 8& (" 2! & &4 $7& 4 2 - 7""(7"9 /)&&9 4 " """ !&(5&4"7";7"7 )4 (4!&4".4#&("% ( "" ()44 !(&" $;0;1 244 " &"& ("!+77"/2 &(4! &4$7&& 7"A" 4.&("

!4 !"##""(7&2- 7& "!&("4#4 2

2 &!! 6 2!&"(%"7 &2-&&" 4&2("(""! ' 4 &

' 4.)&&2" " &!!2" &$"/2"!2 &47& "/ !" ##")("!&( $;0;1-

.2 & ! "&7"

$;0;1&2&&2( &7"

, ";7"0;1% "7&&! &4$7& $" & 2 )"74 4 & &4 & 9 4 (4!&9 "9 4 5;0;1.&" ".&2 """" *"/".&5"&(&(" "

" " "" ! & 4/4 $;0;1 % (" & &4 $7&> ! & 4 2 "!/ "! $" 5. ' 4 ("/ & !!2" (( 2 ("! &44 2 " !!2" (( 2

" "$&("!)"

.&&"/ 2&)"&" "A( %4!" "" ( & (7( ""&"(".&5" 4 7" 4 7 &) & ! &4$7&$"/)&&)!("" &2! !!2" &"/ 8& (" ((4 " "! " & '7& G "! +.

#7 & 5" " & !2 A ( ( )& "( & " 4 $;0;1A,;0;1 6%&27 ((4& "!.)&&+? ": M"! &" "/4 & & 2- 4 2 & (" 4 72 &4$7&&!4 8& !!#"7"7 &4 $7& !(4 & $& /# . $& 427 $7& $& " <4 &/ 4" 2 ("! ;? / ;7" 0;1 )&

447&"9 " "&("! ;? /;7"G ) 422"(" &4$7&>2-H("@ !" ##"> 2- & "( & 5" &" "(/ 2-8&!&2 4 "!" 44) &4 $7& : % & ! & $& G & "7". /# . $& 427 $7& $& 2!&$&&4 " <4 &/ 4" 2 ("! $7& ) # ;? / ;7"0;1 )& 44 & ( &5" "9 " " & ("! 6

;? / ;7" 8&" " ? ("!4 2"2 ( $ 2/4;7" & 5" 0;1 & 2" )&& &" ( " 7 & / " " 9 ( "! !(""

/ $& ")7 2"& B4 , " ;7" &4 $7& 0;1 2 ("! (" "" 2 :

(7 7"

4) %$+*5")&")4/, " ;4"4 5"&. ;7" ) + " ! & &

" & 2 ("! $ 2 /4

44 & ;7" 0;1 A+& 7 & ( $ 2 ( ("!9 M "&".&"" /4 ;7" ) ( ;? / 0;41 8& ! 7" " 7/ &" $& &4 $7& &) ;? / ;7" % &/ 2 & 7" 4 2! !

2- (" "( $;0;41 $" 6 6 " " 8&! $&"! !! +!:GGG: 6A : $7&)4 6"7"72/ 2- & " 4 $& /# ( & &$;2 && ("!4 8 & "/ $ 2

44 & /4;7""2" "9 9 4 "7 4"2

8& .& $; 0;41 $&

44 & ?(" ? " " 427 $7& ) ("!&( ;? /;7" ("! & ( 0;1&&((4!;4"4 $; 0;41 ;7"7 "7 4" $& 427 $7& 247 ")7 2 7 ")7 2"& % ( " " " 9 ( + ("

"!G8G*&4"8&" ".& "" ( 6. & ("! " & ( % " ! ( 7 ")7 & 2 7/ 4 2 (" 2"& $& /# / 4" +! :A6: ) (( )&&4"4 ! , " ;7" &D&("! 2-&(("/4

6 "&" &" " 42 &7/"!E8& ("!&( ! " " 4 " (("/ 44 $; 0;41 8& .&!("!2" & & 2 & ! 2 2 $& " <4 "&4 +" ! & -)("! %9 4 44 "&( &( $;0;41 % " ! 0;1 (" 2 4) & %$+*5"&9 4 247 2 &) & *&4G( &&&7/& 7"4$"6 &"7 ;? /;7"0;1 24) $& &4 $& " <4 "7 4" $ 2 $7& $A& 427 /4;7"0;1%("!) $7&. /# ! & 2 & ( " " <4 & -

9 " ( 7( ""7! 8& . & )"7& 44&?(" ? " ;? / ;7" "7 4"2 "&("! ;? / 0;41&")( ;7"0;1+("/7"4 4 )& ?" $ 2/4;7"$& "<4 "! " $A& (4, "&!M "&".&&4" 3$&"! 2 &"7 "" 4:

G( K7" $7& " & & & 7/ & &"7 ;? / " $& &4 ;7"0;1 $7& & " %)/".&)"#7"7 4"2 )"#7 $ 2 /4 7" 0;4"41. $ (" )&" $& " <4. $& /# ;7"0;41& $&427$7&""7 4"$ 2 5" $& "! /4;7"8& .&"44 $7& ) &47 & ;? / ;7" 0;1 & "7 4"4 & ( ("! ! 2 " 2 " &! $; 0;41 & +44&2/

""- "&! 5" & " )"#7 " &! " !$;0;418& !2""7 " &! 8& +' ! $& "! )442("("2 &"("7

")& $7&. $; 0;41 2 &! M "&". $& 3$&"! ! 2 " K7" $7& &/ 4 2 2/ $& 3 "! ("! 0A&1 $ ("7 $7&.$;0;41 ;7"0;1)& ( & 7" 4 +&" " /!! $; 0;41 ! 2 $%" A A

: 3$G ! "74

. $%" A A

: 3$G ' & 2-

$ A A

42 $&&4$7& 3$G 6

/ )&& 44 & & " & ("!AB"74 7%$+* ! 2 4(4 5" " " & %"

3/"!(&(" 77 "" &"7. 2 /4 & 2/ " . &

" ! " &47 & "" &"78& "" ! 2)&")

"!7!

" 8& ! $& "! $7& ) 4 & 7" 4 $ 2 /4;7" ??

6 $& ##"

: %&&(" $& ##" ) ("/ " 4 . & 2 4 & (( , " " "

& !!2" &44 2 ;7" "! 2 & 47& "&"("! "/ &" & ) 7/ ("! &( $;0;1 &( $;0;1- &

.2 &! "&7"

2 % 44 $;0;1&2+ & & (" & 7" 4 & &/ 2 2G&2 "7"$;0;12 &2&)4 /424 "4/ " & 7"

,;0;1 )&& 9 ( % "" (" " 4 2 G ! 2 2 "7 4"L !&"&!!2" &"/ $;0;1 $& &4 &/ 2 4 FA': ((?:+ $7& ) 2"2 " 4:

& 2/ " 4 0"/ 2 $;0;1 ()&"&)1.))&& 7 !(""

( $;0;1 &/ 2 / 8& ! 2 & 7" 4 & 4 $& &4 $7& ""&! $;0;1 ($"6 &) $" +"74 & ! $;0;1 ! 2 ( (4! &4" &) /424

" G! 2!&"&$&427 "7 4"L $& $7&&7("!$;0;1&" 7&

##" 8& ""7 4" ! ?(4 / & "9 &

" "(" 8&" ". ! 2 4 &! $&427$7&"9 " 2"!/ "!$"! 2&) &(("("(4("("/ ' 4: &" 42 G4&"&&! $& &4$7&.$;0;1$"&)"74 2 4 $" )& / & " 4$&&4$7&&2&) 4 2 &47 9 4 (4! &&9 "&9 4 5;0;1. &" ". 2 " " "" ! & 5" 4 & (&(" " """" ! (" 5" " 4 $. &" ". & 2- " / & ((4 ! #4 2"&

! 2 "!/ "! $" 2 &)(("("(4 G "&" & $& &4 $7& &-&2"" "2"2 &5" 5 " ("/ 021 " 4 . & 2 (""2 & !!2" (( 2 ("! &44 2 " !!2" ((2 " "$!

("! ) "

% 2! " &! 7 )&! & &/ 2! 2 "("/

"&" "(" 6 )&& " 7 (7 )& "

8&" ". &" (4$"! 2&)"74 8&5"& 4"(4 72"77&4 $7&( &2"27&!77&!" & "7& ( 8& "(" "(4 ! &. & "4 & 5" 8& / ! )&&" & 4 & 2 "! & "(" 8& !(" 2 & " &4 & & 2"( &4 $7& & 5" ) 4474. & & 9 & "(" 4 ) 4 " &") & !7& 2 4 )& -2 *"+!,&-(("7 "&(""7 2"" / 2 "/ 4) & /4/7 " 4. 2"( " %"7 &"7& !"4(4& 4&&4 $7&>"

&5")4474 2 &)&( && *". %"

% & 2 & 7:& & 5" &" 7& '7&G "!+ &(&(&/2(4 ""+? ": 44/4 8&7:&"4 :(#7

&" ".) 422"&( &"4/& &"" "448&" !4 44)

8&" 7& & (" 9 . &" ) ""( ?&7 2) & 5" & "(" " ?7 ( 4 "4/

4 "7 & ( )&"&2"")7"7L&( &"("2 " & & 44)7!&"2 7("/ 8&"4/?" "!& 7:&

44) DNND "7&(" ( &2"")7"7L&44( &"("2 " & & 44)7!&"2 7("/

0 (" O I & ( 1 47)& & 9 4 &" & !(4 )&& )44 2 ( )& & '74 "/ M !!".&7"&E8&&"2 &5"&442( & %+'8'B " 4 4 & 5 JJ+ O I " 5JOI 8& ! (4 2 4" $ & & &" & ( 42()44!&%+'8'BE 8& 7:&44 " 4 & !" ". & !" / & &/ "& ) !/ & ( . 2"(&-#7 &" 42 "# "("

& 2& & ()" & 2 2 & 2 &) 2 & "( "7& " "7 ! "!"")&( )&& ()" &" && *""

"&"4 "("5".)&&/4/(4 7/" !(4! ( 24 " " / 7"4 " & " !4 44&2- ")&&& " ( 8&" )"&?" &)"#?(44 ((" &" &)/" &7& 2 7 7 " 4 & " ! &" $" "! ' 4" 4 "!& "7 4" ((!+("' 4 .(" 42((&$"/ 4 &(&9 4 "&(&4$7&@"(

2"""" &&!2 !( "! (!"#"(&49 4 """ !&( & (2 && *".%"

&")7&4)& )2 &"(4 ()"'" !4 2!&!" ("/ " ' 4 +((? 5 8&

' 4 (""2 ((!2 ( .)&&& 6' 4("/ " 24 (")"/424&5")&&' 4("/. &4 $7&!(""&!7 " &

' 4. &&((!" "2"( ! &/2(24. 2 & &)

' 4.& 422"2 8&" )!(4("&2&2"( &4$7& . &" ".&/"2!!!2" &$"/;/ "& 6 ' 4. &4 $7& 4 ! 4 24 ) /424

"!)&&$"/"! 4' 4 8&" ".)& "" ( )"7 & 24 27 /424. " "( "4' 4 42&8&")&"4 9 24 " : 24 "7 " ( " 2 "" )"7 2 & 5" )& &4 $7&> 24 &2- 72 && *".%"

"74 &7"/&(42 """!! 44 2 "&& *"7/&!&4"4)&"("!&"" 5 &2&?( /)44"&5" *"/".( 44 &/2""(7 (&4$7&)( ;7"0;4"41& & & ( %+'8'B " #) )&&" & )" !4" 4$ 2/4;7"0;4"41&5"! & &7 &# &)&&&!!")&& &44!7&

7<#7 "! 74.&"

&4$7&&5") 2 " " / &7 8& !(" & & *".%"

&(("7"&5" 7(7 " 2"477 &4$7&&4(&!!7"44744 &5" !# &! ("! !!2" & " )& " )" 4"7 "&((":2#8& 22" & "&"( "& ?(&4$7&4"("7"&5" 8& .&" 49 &4$7&% "&. &)44' 48"""

8&"4 7&&)&4/2 &)"! ("&2 +2"&!<4 ! 4 D/! $ "

" " "" ! ! $ "

"" " "" E 8& .G&/&9 &&2"("" &4 $7& 0+?: 12 4"74474."2""

4 27 (" (44 "

" 7" 2 &" /")&&&5" 4

"")& ""7& )"& &&7&""" ()"8&9 47"A" 401! 4 44+ "&"".G4 4/ & 5" & "(" & $ 3/"! 4 )& &

" &4 $7&:"( & 2 2"2 " ! ("!!(4 &5"G&2#&"(" &4 42"//?(42 &?(4 &""

9 4 .2&&)"("44)(" " @ ( A

!4 0 .1

2 /

0 3

"2 /