High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16458/2018disposed of

Subhash Makkar v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2018-07-24Mr. Justice Amit Rawal3 pages

!" "#$%$&' (

!" "#$%$&' ( )*+, %,- .. / "!$!$&"/ 0% )! !" /1 & &2!,"/% "%3&2"&!% -'4 5-)6)6- -'4 5-)6)6- -'4 5-)6)6- -'4 5-)6)6- /"%"&!' -/5."%,), /7 829# !"8

/!,"3"!$!$&"/ 6)6-8:5;

6)6-8:5;

6)6-8:5; ,"3"!$!$&"/8<,$%!," !,"/ &2%"&$/#$!$="&8 $>"2 & 33>$# !$& *&2"/ )"#!$& !," - $&!"& &#" &2 "> /" /"&!% &2)"&$/$!$="&%#!8(?

/%,/!@!,"#!4A+"

/"!," - $&!"& &#" /$+*& > ," /$+*& > 9$2" $!% /2"/ 2 !"2 B( 3 %%"2 !," /2"/ "9$#!$& C $&%! /"%3&2"&!% D ( ,"/"$& CC/$"9"2 C $&%! !," % $2 /2"/8 !," <$ " !," 3"!$!$&"/ $>"2 !," 33" > <,$#, < % >><"2 +1 !," 33">> !" /$+*& > 9$2" $!% /2"/ 2 !"2E &>1!!,""F!"&!!, !/"%3&2"&!(,"/"$&<*>2 ! ."# /" !,"3"!$!$&"/ &23/9$2",$7 2 &2$&# %"/"%3&2"&! ( ,"/"$& 2 &! 3/9$2" !," 2 !,"& ," <*>2 3 1 EG 3"/ 7&!, %/"&! !"/ ," /$&C >" /&"2 #*&%"> / !," 3"!$!$&"/ &2 3"/*%$&C+!,!,"/2"/% !,"/$+*& > &233">> !"/$+*& >8 7 !,"#&%$2"/"23$&$&!, !+!,!,"/2"/%3 %%"2+1!,"/$+*& > &2

33">> !"/$+*& > /"3 !"&!>1$>>"C >," $/%!/2"/3 %%"2+1!," /$+*& >$%& & 33>$# !$& $>"2*&2"/)"#!$& !,"#!+1<,$#, $!, %2$/"#!"2/"%3&2"&!% D(,"/"$&!9 # !"!,",*%" !," 3"!$!$&"/!$%&""2>"%%!7"&!$&!, !!,"/$+*& >#&%!$!*!"2*&2"/ )"#!$&( !,"#!# &&>12"#$2"!," 33>$# !$& $>"2*&2"/)"#!$&

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

/"8%,"< %&! & CC/$"9"23"/%&!7 $&! $&!," 33" >$&<,$#,!,"33">> !"/$+*& >, %2$/"#!"2/"%3&2"&!% D(,"/"$&$"!,"%&% !,"3"!$!$&"/8!3 17 $&!"& &#" & 9$"< !," /"% $28 +!, !," /2"/% /" ,"/"+1 %"! %$2" &2!,"7 !!"/$%/"7 &2"2+ #.!!,"- $&!"& &#"/$+*& >! 2"#$2" !," 33>$# !$& <$!, /"C /2 ! < /2 7 $&!"& &#" ! !," 3"!$!$&"/8$& ##/2 &#"<$!,> < &23"/7$%%$&$% >%C/ &!"2!!," 3"!$!$&"/ ! $>" & 33/3/$ !" 33>$# !$& +"

/" !," $%!/$#! - C$%!/ !"8$&# %","2"%$/"%!,""9$#!$& ,$%%&%8&!,"C/*&2

E !, ! !,"1 /" &! 3/9$2$&C ,$7 3/3"/ 7 $&!"& &#" $!, !,"%" +%"/9 !$&%8!,"3/"%"&!3"!$!$&$%,"/"+12$%3%"2 /!$"% /" 2$/"#!"2 ! 33" / +"

/" !," - $&!"& &#" /$+*& >&B :6)6-;

:6)6-;

:6)6-; (

(

( ,"!,"/%3" .$&CG/" %&"2 '

"%G ,"!,"/"3/! +>" '

"%G