← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21752/2016allowed

Yudhanshu Angural v. Baba Farid University Of Health Sciences Faridkot & ANR

2016-12-14Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari20 pages



      

!"#$

%&!

!"#'

   



     

    

  (#  )*(  +++*  !

"# $    

!

%&$    '  !

(&) $ 

 %$) ++,"!-,.,/&, 0   " *  #  

* 

!    

+,-. &  -/ ,/ +,-.

0   -,1+ &!  

 $!&2  $#3 4 '-

 0   & & ! 2

(   *    '       )  !

6  "3!6"'+,-.5 &   

 

 (3 (5$* *&(  7 -+    & /+ 89..-::  

 3 4 ';5 #<+   & -,9<     &    

 & 2 =

$  $  % &  !  (

    &       * 

     &       *      

&  

3 4 '.5>*  9,$,,,?'  

 <$,,,?'

&         &  *    #       *        &*

-/ ,/ +,-.

 & 9<$,,,?'3 4 '95

 &+< ,/ +,-.+9 ,/ +,-.

 * $

& * &   +/ ,/ +,-.

          *$    $   &   

     & 

   * 

    $  $

       >      

 0  @    %  ! ?2    7 ;   8   2

*   & % & ! (

$7$2  & 3&   5$  



"                 7 <   &   -8 ,- -//.3 4  '<5 % &)A  2 &$      &     ) $    &    0

   

      !6"'+,-.$ *  4  '- 0       &$  

(     *  2 A  2 &$ & 

"  $ *  

* & 

+/ ,/ +,-. 



     " ' *  &    && (&&   

-/ ,/ +,-.  #

 &

   "(&&& +/ ,/ +,-.  #   &   #A  2 & 

  



     $*

* 



*,< -, +,-.

 0   & &   

 $

& *  "     &+:

-, +,-.     

   (   &*     &  "  $ *   &  $ * *  &    !

"#

+9 ,/ +,-.3 4 '--5$ *

7 ; 8  2

*   &

 % &! (

 &



&&*   

$   #& 0$$& 

    & 

B     ) &  

  !"

"#

 $$ %&'()

$ % * "+ "!"

"# ,  

 $-$%&'

()  -.  '/       0     1 *  !"

"#   

 $-  %&'  ()  -.    '/"     !"

"#    ""  $$ ( )  234  .  0"  45     "6" 7 '/ "  77 +  $$()  234  $ .  1" *  %++ 57   !"

"# 2 "

 $$%&'(2 ")

.2 76"7

&"8

1 

 $$ ( ) ,  %*     

   ,"  8   9  

  6"   

 

 

2 "8"+  

    *   ) 

  &*     & 

 (    '     * 

&                 )                       % &  *     

        

 &*$



$ 

        $( 

    &     

 C(& C & 2 =

$ &    $  *   *    

   &       -/ ,+ +,-.3 4 '-

 5$*   '

D 

   

"

"6  6

7  :4 ";

 !"#"# $%#"&%#"'() *!+   ,- 

 

,* ./ 

+++

   8<!28%8!%!'%3 := 0=8&2>'%3   ?&33%>8!8%'!'

&2='% 1%'%+   , 

8%0%'1   0 2  6

7 

!

  

    

     3  '4&"5    

   

,  3'4&"5



   

  



 3  '4&'5/     

    

,  



 3'4&'5/  +

,*  

 

 

, 6 

  3  '4&7/    8+,*  0 2  3 '4("/  -,0  3'4((/ // 3'49"

 $   0 

3'49'

  

 

 

, +

+  3 '49(/ 8  <!28%8!  %!'%3 

  %   + *   *      ?&33%>  8!8%'!'     1%'%  +   /  !    !'4%"#%#"'(:

"   '     -8 ,- -//.* 4   



 ( &

 & *

    &  & *  &

  "  2 &A     '

; ,!<0 00= 0,  +0 +  

/%    -,/ 3

 , 0* >

  1

+ =/

=  /8/<'("'?%'%4#/@ //'  "(/"7/'47?3 1   ,*=/    -,  1  

 =     /#%##A%94BBBBBB  #"/"7/4A31      *, *   

*  / =/



 , 1 0 00= 0,  +0 /%/

;   3  1=3            

 % 

,.   +0 +   

0    1

       

 % 

,  ,     1

 ,          

%,   +

,   

 % 

, +    0 

+  1   +0 /:

3  0  ,=0= 

3  ,+    ,   ,0= +0 +    /%/

   -,/8  1  ,

, 0 =/  + .+ %=/.+  0= 0 ,   =  

% 1   +  +      3  1     =      

 

/ 3*   

.  =/+.

   

 

/> 1 0+  .  +*, /:

"     *    % & *   

  & "% & *-9 ,< +,-.$   $  *-, ,.

+,-.

( '--

 &   '

D''/    

  

       0, *  





*

- .. 0 6$     +%   +

/$ 0, *



 +

0=

  / 

 1

.. 6$   1   >  C  .

, */  

        .=

,-    =    0  +  % > 0   0, *,*  .   6  %  

0/        .

, *        .           0, * 

 

,- 0% +

/

   1        0,     .   -,  = +   1

,

  +

/:

&

$ 

&      

*                      *   >    

  

 >& *   " * 

  &

*     '

;3>%>=4>'>%2%'>@!33< '/

   0  0   .



*

   + = / #/

  ..

*6$ <#"'(

*;

:/ A/   .    ,  1

  +    

= * 1, 111/, // 



, +

= * .* 0   /A""%</ ?/

 ,+

..

 D+6$ E#"'( +*,+ ,*

0

= *1, 111/, // / &/

 



 ,+

..

 D+ = ,    . 

  

= *1,  111/, // /

- (/

 + 

1 

 

 * 0=

     .  

= *  1, /  

  +.

* 01  

 

, ++ *  /:

 ( +:3 5 -, ,.

+,-.

3 4 '85*

&  *

>     & & $*    '

;0    + 0 ,    =

 %8 0*

,  . +  +.   * .  

 

/ 8>1 

+ , .   

 

  = +  -, 1   

+ + * .

* /:

"   ( (-+*     * 

 &  ':,

 $*   '

D + "

   $ D $D$ F$ $ % 

 7 

  : :$'&:

.   

  $$        /;.  2        

('



" 77) 

    % +% +BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

 %  0      /BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB    =

0%1

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %=

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB       -,  ,    BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1    , 0   

  .;



   

 

 3'4&":

#/ % +% +BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

  % + * = =

0%1 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB % = BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB -,/

$ 0   BBBBBBBBBBBBBB  BBBBBBBBBBBBB  0   :

0$$  *

* * &  $*   

 **   

*    &.

 E &( % 

"+  ? 

/;  $$()  4  -.  '/  "+  ?  0  " "  2# !"

"# $$()4 .6 " ?/;"!"

"# $$( )4- ' 7 ;

* ?/;4 "67!"

"#.

,7   $$ ()4 .& ?2"

6    .

/; $$$()4 ' "

"+ 

?4

/;   4 "67>6"9& "74 ""+.

"+





()4  "   &' 7 ;

* A 3 5  ' ;9/D

8      % 

"+     /;.( $$)3' !-//<3;5 ("<+93F5 35     

     .  

 ,

0        .=

   . . / 8  >  =1  . .

 +

  3 

  1

1 .   / '/"+

  0   "  2#  !"

"#.  $$  ()  ',  -$  B $$()4 (98)(@)   D

8   

 > =1 

1

 =,> , ,

,*  + ..

   +

+



,

1 > 

    +0=

+/ D

8  ..=  =1G.

 

  

8    0, * +

    ,

  0 . .

, $   $G+  

   +

  ,+    , 

 

0=  . . 3 = 0   1/0 D

8      6 "  /;" !"

"#. $$( )',  B $$( )4-

(98)(@)> =1    ,   .=     +

 

    +  

  ,    0 1

/ =1 G.

,* D

8  

=, 

1 

  $$,*  



  0  D

8  /

3  1   .=

    + ,   ++ $   '449 =  1

 = ,  *+.

 1 /+   ,+ ,*       G     .1

     ##(      

  

/: 0  "#  ""77 +   

6"

6 0"

1 .( ) - . 4(           > 

* & 

   

   

    & 

&** 

0  

& $ 

&>     *  $*   &

 G *     4(     7   6 #>6""* "7 7"

. $$-()', .* 

   



-<.(     *    &    (       *   *      

   

*     "

H** & #  !*

&$*   0&

&  4(   7%"

 6" 



1 2$3+,,<5- ((-:+$*     &  >

  &* &

&  * * $  *   * &&   *     "   ' H9/    3 3 1         . .

.+

* .. 

, => / 1

> 1   . .

.+

* .. , 

 ,   . .

/    .   1     +   +

     *  ,*  +> 0    >  + 3  

   =>   

. .

3      + .   +

      *    > 0  1   =* + . 

 0 , 

/ 0    .    ,   .   +  *+ . 

..

      .

  +  G+  / 1 =

,=3  

0 0     3 * 

 + ,  /   ..

 3  .

   +     .

    

*  G+     1

      0  

*I#G+  3

  +    =  ,   ..

    

  1 

   ,     .

 0  

*I#G+  3    1     + G  +0/1=3 +> 

G  ..

      .

     ,- + *

 3   +  

    ..

 3         .

    0   

*  I# G+  3  1   

*     

     + .  /    +   1       .



,.+  => . .

 .+

* .. 3

 0  1   *

1 => 0   . .

      / - 0+   

         0        

  ,

 /H 0&

& $ &(  0   "!"

"#

", 

.

$( )', -    ( * $       :< <I  & #      >   4&      &&& > & & #::I "&  & * )  0*  

&    $  

* &   * 4& &* 

0* & &  *     "    ' H4/ + .

 *+.  

 =, 1

 ,   /  . 3  . *1   .. /    1 ..= ,*   

'

+"7=

"6

.>1



 ;  =

C(

)  $D/ .0. ( J 0+ 3    , =  

1   H(/     = 

  .  ..+ 0    .   

  

..  G+ 

  +   .

 .

/ +    3

+ *.

      1 =  

    ,   3     +  =    ,

    

 *+. 

*/

 =*1>1 

   

/  0     .

    *+. *  

  

3  0

     0

.=

//////H/ '"/       .    3     

0  1         1

+ 3 , 

.

,  

1   

* +.

   , 

1 G+  1  1



*

0 /H

    ) & 4 (  4

'

+"  .'/" "!"

"# 8 7 6"

6 .

+7

8 7 

. (-)-$*      

  

$&      &  **

* #)        -8 ,- -//.*  * * 

   )     *  B (     0      $            C

  (*  &64 !  $0 $=

0

& 

   > &   "&* 

&*   $* *  

  & & $*     3 4 '85 && &&



  

&         '   

    &&  0 

& $* ) B &      $ 

 &  *  &   ) &*     

&  (&      ) &              $&    $  &     0A6 ( )$* 

  &       * 

  *         '

* 4& '

*4&* 

 "

   </ :I& #!

2

& * ;,I* > &   &    4( * $  &

     *      4  (   

      

> &</ :I& #*  %       

4&$#   





$# *$  *

*    *  *  

B&    & 

 4& 0*  *   >    & 



  0% * "+ "A6 ( )$>  4( **  &       2

   0*



  *   

 *&# && (

 2 6   *      " &

 &  .,I & # &4&&$* *        & 

>  *   > $ 

 &* $* *) & 



 0*$ 

& $

    $  *&*  ") & '/   0  A6 ( ) * ** * 0 

4& )  *  B >  ' 4& '  6  $ $  $*     & &  

 ") &2  ( *  

    *           $  #    *            4  (           "  $  

  &   

    &     *&$     * 0  **

*  *  #     $#

    &  

&    * $  &   * &

*  -/ ,/ +,-.  "4

 

&      

*

 

   

& 

 " &  '

D&  & 6" '/

   .  *.= ,-    + = 

 

+  0, *  

,*  . / #/

  =.  

 

0 

+   

+ 

.%   01 .  .* +

..

 +



0  = 

+'4/"4/#"'(#"/"4/#"'(/  

 1 1

 . 

 

0  3 

 1

,      

    -

 

   +  1

 , 

    / A/=   +  ,* 

 

03 

         .               

= *8 >   0 . , 8 > 

, =  +     

  

0  +  '(/"4/#"'(   #"/"4/#"'(/ D 0 .    ,*  3

 1

, 

 +

*/    1 

1 0 %  +   



 

  

0     +   =  C   > 0   0, *!

'/6'" 

 = 0/ #/  '"I'    6>      =    

     *  3 + *38 0*

$ / A/'"I# 6>  = $ 0, * . -,=/  / ?/    '"I'3  '"I#  .

 +       -,3   

$G+.  0=   . / &/ / (/ / 9/  = 0* / 7/.*8 > 

+/ 4/+   

 1 .

'"I'

'"I#G+  /:

0  

&  $ *  &$* *      

-/ ,/ +,-.   0 &   &(&&*

-/ ,/ +,-. 7 ;.$*  #    )% &  -, ,.

+,-.   $*  

   0 

& $    #    



*  

 &+< ,/ +,-.+9 ,/ +,-.

0      & &

&    *  *  G

 $

 -       &  $*#* &  

&

&    " 

$$&#  *  &  ** 

 &$

 #

    &   $ 

      $&  &   )         $  *  *         &(&&  0&

& $ 4(   "+

%"" "

?," 1 

%&'

 $       

  

&' &     "     '

;A"/  A     

       0    .   +*    

 

%   

  .

   

 .

  .0  +

   .

+  

3 

   +   3 

 

,=+       %  

      +*

 0   ... +.

    

 3 */ 4444444 A7/ +

0  

   + 0 +



 .

  , 0 ,  3



=*     3        .

  .     =



           

0  

*  

  ++  0    =    + 0.*3 1      ...        

   +   G.  , 0 ,  1   +

 $  

 

G ,*   3 8 

.

  0  0 +

 *.     +/    G31

 =,    1 =   

      + +

1 0  3  +

,   .   *   3   

1

 

   .  = =    /1  ,

, +  

 . / 3     1   8  .  0    1   +  

   , ,   

  3 >    

3  

,    *   1  ,*    J 0/ *  3  0   .

, 1 

 +  

3  

, ,  .

  



, ,+      



*

 *     

 +

3   +.

 3/    

3     

 

         1   1        ... *. 0



.

 

     ,+     /: "**

* "

7%  ?4

.?

770 "6777 + 8 "7'

  &"  

     ( )       "  4  (        *   

&< # &

  $*   

*4  7 <'



  & + #  & *  



 &  &$  $

  

   $*    &

&   $

 '

   ' <, ,/ +,-.

0* &$



&

 $



  1++*2 ( '0

  =

K   .> 0%  !

L

K  ., !

L