High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21772/2016dismissed

M/S Dhillon Roadways v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd & ANR

2016-10-20Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary11 pages

#$%& %'%( )( ($% * +,-) ./.01/ ) +,-) ./ . %$$ ( %23&'( %2 4"3&'(5 46($5

%($'$(( $% 777

# $

$8&%$* 5%$' ( 5 %'%(

)9($ :); 4($ $*($ $%& $%!*- "($9 %9 2%&62 !

$% %!% (%6( %% (% '%(( <& 2'$(% $&9 '% &6(!($

$6( %9

%'$% (%$$"$%!('(

%$8($ &'( &%($%(!"$%(( $ 6%$( = ($

(9$ $%!> ?(

($9$!(<$ '$ $ @ ?(

$'$(( %9&<9(($ (<

?$'$(( $%%$6$4$ $*9 ($ A ?

$8&%$ *@; %$6( =((''%6($

6$% %$' ( 9'

% 4$% 6( 6&9$ ( '$% ($ $% $ 4$% 6( ! ( <$ 69'

$($ <"> ?

$%$ ($%5($'$(( $%%$6$4$ ($%$*9

($ B

$8&%$*?; %9($%$' (5 %$6( = ( ( &'

($%$ ( 6&9$ ((($$% $(5<&( ( ($%(

** ($9$4$%" "5$ B

5($'$(( $%&'

%$ ( 6&9$ (66% "54 $$*9 ($ B

$8&%$ * ;5($%$' ( 9(($ ($< ($'$(( ($% & "4$% " ($ 6&9$ ($%$ ($%5($'$(( $%%$6$4$ ($%$*9 ($

$8&%$ *A; %9 ($ %$' ( !$%$<" = ($ 6&9$ (!$%$ %$6($ (<$&'

$ (%&=$*9 5 ( ($%(

$%$' ( 2$ ($'$(( %9($ $ ( %$'%$$ ((4$ %4$% 6( '%$*C& 6( 6&9$ ('$%($ !(($%=

()6( 9< $%9

!( $8((%$$!%2 " ($%

$6$ ($'$(( $%((($9 % "(&($ < $% !$%$&$ $(($%(%&=$*9 ($ A B

$8&%$* ;2 ($9 ( =4$ $8($ < 4 (" % ($%

" $ &'( B

+!$4$%5 ($ 699& 6( ! ( $ ( ( ($ '$(( $%$%$ ($%54 $$*9 ($ A B

5($'$(( $%&'

$ ($''

6( ($ ?:

$8&%$*>; ($6$%( 6($ ($

$8&%$*B; & "&$ <"($(($% '%(&(%("5 & $%($+%"

%%=$<" 6(5

:$%$

($%%$ $%%$ ( D($6(

,; (!"5($'$(( %969'

$($

($'%$* %$C&($ 6 ( 5 <&( ! 62$ !$ ( %$6$4$ $*9 ($ > B

$8&%$* ;

%9 =(%$=% =%$E$6( (($ &% = ($6 6 $4 &( <" ($ & " 6 ((&($ 699(($$ % ($ %$ F(9$$( =GH$'$(( %9 $ A

<$ %$(6&%(6

= =($ $*9 % $% ($ > B

$8&%$* ;5!6! '$ 4 $% $% ($ @ A

*>* :

$8&%$* ; %$6( =($%$' (( $6 $%$'%$$ (( '$(( $%5 $ !( !$$2 %9($ ($ %$6$'( 6$%( $ 6'"

($% $%5!( '$% $8( $!$$2<"' ='$2 =% $%

($%

% = ''%(& (" $% =(($'$(( $%5 66% 6$ !( ! '&%& 6$ ($ % $%5 ($ '$(( $% &<9(($ %$'%$$ (( ($ A A

$8&%$* ;(($%$' (%

($ '

$ 66% "5 3$ =$% : (%6( $

;5 %($%

$= 5 %'%( 5$!$ 5

% $ ''%(& ("

$% = ( ($ '$(( $% %9 A A

5 4 $ % $% ($

$8&%$* @;%$E$6($ (%$'%$$ (( !(&( 6& ($'

$%$ <"( > +$ 6$5 <" !" ($ '%$$ ( !%( '$(( & $% %(6 $ ($ ((&( 5($'$(( %9&=(& 6$ !%( ($ (&%$ 6$%(%% %C& =($ %$ $*9 % $% ($ > B

$8&%$* ;%$E$6( =(($ %($%$ F ( 9$$( =GH5 ($% $% ($

$8&%$* @;5%$E$6( (%$'%$$ (( = (($ $*9 % $%&%($%'%"$%<$$

9 $(&$!%( ($ (&%$ 9 9& %$6( =($%$' (( 6 $%($< ($ $% ($'$(( $%5 ($

! ==%& * :;

($ '

$ %$ <" ($ '$(( $% 4$ $($% <$$

6&$ % =<$$ %$(&% $ ($9$I :;

$< ($'$(( %96& (4$<$$ = %$ % ($9'

$%$ ((( ('$($%$C&%$ 6$%( 6($ %$=(%( > ?5$($6 = ($ $%5 4$! ($ 6(((($%$' (($9$ 4$ $ ( $%$(($%!

6$ & $ &=($8($

($9$ A B

*@* :;

$%$' (6

(<$'$%9(($ (%$E$6(($6 9 '$(( %9(&6<$ ($ (=$5 4$! ($ 6((( (($ $%!'$ $ B

! 9(($ '$%$* 9 ($ B

$8&%$ * ; $ '$(( $% &<9(($ ( 6$%( 6($ ($

($ ($%9 ( $%I :4;

$%$' (4$! $'!$% %$ 8( 6$%( ($%9

( $%5<$6&$ ($9 %(&( ($" $% $%%$ 8$ ($6 &$%$C&% =6$%( 6($& ($6(

($ $% ($ @ B ? @ )$% $ 6& $ %($'$(( $%6 ($ $ ((($6 ($ $%! > ? ($ $% !$%$( <$'$ $

@ ?5 <&( ($ %$' ( '$ $ ($ 9$ 4$%" <$ ($ "5 ($% ''%89($ "$=(9 ( 6$($'$(( %9 %$ "&<9(($ (6$%( 6($ %$=(%( ($

'%%(($'$ = ($ $%5 (($ $%! 9(($ <"($%$' (5($%$ %$5 %$E$6( ( < !

$= %<(%%" 4$ ($%!$5 ($ %$' ( $% $%%$ 8$ ($6 ( &<9 6$%( 6($

%$=(%( (% '%($% $ $%5($%$ %$5($"4$4('!$%(%$ ($ 6 ( 5!6!9$%$ " %9 (" 9 %(&( 5($ + ,< $+=&%( 6&(( >?

:; ?5(( $

9$ ($!%('$(( ! $66$'( =($ ( ($ %$' ( (( ($" %=( " %$ 8$ ($ 6 &$

&<9 6$%( 6($ %$=(%( & $%($6(

? $ 4$(&=( &

"6 $%$ ($&<9 9 $ <"

$% $ 6& $ %($'$(( ( "&<( 6$ ($9$

( ( '&($ ((($%$!'%$*%$C&($6 (

*?* ''

6 ((&<9(6$%( 6($ %$=(%( (($(9$ &<9

($< 9(($ "5($'$(( %9 (&<9((6$%( 6($

%$=(%( (($(9$ &<9 (< > ?5%($%( &<9(($ ($9$ A B

5 $'($($ 6((('$ = ($ < !@ ?&=($($ $%6& (<$'$ $ @ ?

!$%$'$ $ ($%''%89($ "$=(9 (5<&(($9$<"($

$ (=4$ "%=((($'$(( $%(6 9((( ($&<9

%$=(%( 6$%( 6($& 4$<$$ $%$ <"($%$' ( $%$9=(<$4%&%$ %'$ =($ $%( ($%(=$<"($ %$' ('$%& ($9'&= $ % $% ($

$8&%$ * @;'$ '&%& 6$(($ %$6( (6&%(4 $% $% ($ @ A

$8&%$* ;'$ A

'$(( $%5 ! (( ($ 3$ =$% : (%6( $

;5 %($%

$= 5 %'%( 5$!$ 5 $ (!(

($'

$ %$ <"($'$(( $%<$ %$9%<%$4("5($%$ ('% 9'&= $ % $%%$%$*'% &6$ <$ !*

! ! " # $%

$ #& # '

# !

() * + ,%-, %,%

,. /

, 0 !

%1 23 1 4

* *

, #

# 13"

$ 6$ #

6 ,7 2.

# 6 !,+ # #

$ ! # 6

! " # $ %

, * #

# ! , 666 666

# 8, ,%

5#" '

* 9 : ", ! +;"< =1 , >/ %

/ +;" ! # !

" # %

5$ ,=9;1 1;<

97<? @ +<+(7+ 12

@A62

, + # !

# !

* * 6

# ,'! $

#' # " # # ! !

, '

6 ,4

: ;?@B5

: @;?

$ % & @:>;

5(<$$

%$'$($ "$ <"($'$8&%(((6 6$

( ($ $%'%6$ $

(4 ($ & 9$ ( %=( ($''

6 ( $$89 =($ 6'$ E& 6 %$4$! ($9(($% !% (%6(5(!$ <"

($'$8&%( ' :&'%;((($$9'

"$%($<$( E& =$(!% 6 (%6( ($6&%(, ($% $%$ 6$ &69(($%& <$ 9 9 $ &%( & %9

" $8$%6$ E& 6 %$(% ( &

$= ("%%<(%% $ ($'%( ($$9'

"$%''%$ ((!$

& $%* + # !

# # B $ # $ C

, '

" C B

$" #6 B

*B*

# # ,4 $'$8&%(

' :&'%;!(%$=% (($6'$ E& 6 %$4$! (%6(& 9(($%5 ($% 5 (6$ (( ($(($&(%($%$%$C&%$ (<$6 6$ $ =%$($% ((& $ ($% 6( ('$ (E& 6 %$4$!&

$(6 <$ $9 (%($ (<$ 6&5%<(%%"5& %$ < $%9&$ (((&(%"'!$%$ %$ (<$%4( %$6% $ ($%$ %$$8(%6($ & $%* $6'$ E& 6 %$4$! (%6(& 9(($%!

&%($%$89 $ <"(&%(

!!"!

#$ %&% %'& ())*+ , -5

"% .% #% &% !/'012 (1"3# + 4'&15 %'

!$, #&11 %' #1 (

+*,-<$ $$4$% ($% $6 (!6 !$ $$ (%$ $% % &25&4 % "66 # (%'& + /' $ , #%

%' #1( +9, ($ $= '(

($&<E$6(!&99$ &' ($%69'%$$ 4$%$4$!

'% 6'

$ !''

6< $(($'%6$ %E& 6 %$4$!

$ ( $ ($

! =!% :'A'% A* ;

F A %9 ($ <4$ $6 5 ($

! = '% 6'

$ $9$%=$ :;

($<6%$C&%$9$ ( %(6 $ @ % $ 6(

<"($(($5 *%<(%% $ $$ 6$ &<( 6$ ($$%(<$( %'

"$$6( %$9$ < $(($ E& 6 %$4$!

"(($$8($ (((($(($9&(6(4 "

% 6$% < $%$ (!96

% "& ($%% '&%'$ ($(($6(!( ($<& %$ < $5 (!& <$ $=(9($((2$ (6 $%( ($ (

'%%($I :<;

8( 4 &$ $%$ (%$ "!( '&%4$! ($$8$6&(4$ 6&%(% "4$ "% $(

*A* '

" ('%6$$86$'( %(%2 = !

&66( $8$6&(4$'%4$ (<$%<(%%"%& %$ < $ 34$% 9$ (6(

%9("!(6$%( $ ("( %

%9&6!% = (%6(<" 4( =($ $%5

($6%6&9( 6$5($ ($% $%$ 6$<"&%(4$%" 9($ I :6;

($ 9(($% %9& ( = 6 ( ($ 6&9$ ( !% =6 (%6(5=%$($% ((& $%$C&%$ (<$6 6$ $ (($(($&(%($&

$($6(

($ $% =&(%(" & (<$9 6& 9&$ ( ((&(%"'!$%5 ($% $%$ 6$<"&%( (!%% ($ I : ;

$%( '%$6 ( %C& 6( %($ $%4$ (<$ !

($ &%$((($6 (%6(%($6'6("

($%$&%6$(&66$ &

"$8$6&($($!%2I

:$;

($(($%( (%&9$ ( ($6(%$ < "5 % "

'&< 6 ($%$( !% = 6 (%6(5 $%$ = ($% $%$ 6$<"&%(4$%"%$(%6(4$ 6$ '$% 6

9 & 9$ ( %=( ( 6%%" <& $ !( ($ 34$% 9$ ( $%$ %$5 &%( <$ %$ ($% $% = ($ $% % 6 (%6(& 9(($%5 $8$%6$ '!$% E& 6 %$4$!5 & '$(($

! =C&$( :;

$($%($'%6$ '($ % $6 9 $<"

($&(%("9 $% ($ $ ( 4&%9$ $I %!$($%($'%6$ '($ % $6 9 $ %<(%%" %%(

(( ($ 6&%( 6 " J($ $6 &6 (( %$' < $ &(%(" 6( %$ < 66% 6$!(%$ ( !6&

4$%$6$ JI

$($% ($ '&< 6 ($%$(

$6($ ($

!$%(($<4$C&$( %$ $=(4$5($ ($%$ & <$ ($% $%$ 6$& $%%(6 $ H ' ($ &( ($$% $%'%( (% $%($ $6

(6 6$ $%'%6$! !" 6%9 (%"% $ ($6 (%%"5 6 (%6( <$$ !% $

* * $'($($ $ 6$ 6$ $%'%6$$%&C&$( (&6 =($ $= (" '%'%$("

$6( =($4 (" ($ $%'%6$!& 4$%$ 9&6($69'$($ ( &(%(" $6 $ (6 6$ $%'%6$5( (4 ($

& 9$ ( %=( ($''$

( %6& ($6(

($%$' (<$($%9$ & %$ < $(!%% ( "

($% $%$ 6$ %9(&%($4 -$ 6 ($+= &%(!5 ((4$!5'$% $6( "E&( $ $(( = $($ % $% '$ <" ($ $ .& =$ 9 = ($ !%( '$(( H B $ 6( 6%6&9( 6$ >?

:; ?5

' :&'%;5%$ $ &' <"($'$(( $%5%$ ( =&<

%9($ 6( ($'%$$ (6$5<$6&$ ((6$5(($%$ ((9$5 ($6 6$% $ &(%($!$%$ (& = "6$%( 6($&65($ 6 ( %$=% =&<9 6$%( 6($ %$=(%( !%$ 8$ %

< $% ( % '$6 6 < $%5!$%$ ($ ( ( 6$5 & '&($ "5($ $=(%( &(%(" ($+%"

(($( =% !4$%"9&6& =&66$%( 6($ 9$! <( $ <"($ '$(( $% %95 <&( ($% ($5 &<9(($ ($ 9$ !( ($ %$' ( ($%&<9(( =($*($ $%&656$ ($'$((

(<$(%$($ ('%!(' :&'%;%$4$%5C&$( 6(%$ 4 4$ (6$5!6%$C&%$$4 $ 6$( $$ $( 9$ ( $%$(((6&%( ((6(6&%( ''$ & $%($ $8(%% %"!%(E&% 6( 5&6C&$( 6(6

(<$ $6 $ <"

(6&%(&56( ($%$' ( %$E$6( =($($ $% '$(( %9 %($%$ F (9$$( =GH6

(<$ (<$

$= %%<(%%"$ ( "

$= ("%'$%4$%(" ($

* * 9'&= $ $*9 % $% ($ > B

$8&%$* ; ($!$

%$ $ % $% ($

$8&%$ * @; %$E$6( = ($ %$'%$$ (( ($'$(( $%= (($ $*9 % $% A $(( 566% "5 9$ ( + 6(<$% 5

(7 /+

$($%'$2 =%$ 0$ $($% $'%(< $ 0$