← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22734/2015disposed of

Ajay Kumar v. The Postgraduate Institute Of Medical Education & Research & ORS

2015-11-19Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages



      "#$ $%&'&()* +",-./"0 $#&#&($0 2$0'.'

'#0"3."#$('#&#.#$  $3&%"4 3.%"#&( $'$"0%5"(3#5$0'

$'6(3$(#'

 7 85&'5$9 $#&#&($0 2$0'.'

'#0"3."#$('#&#.#$  $3&%"4 3.%"#&( $'$"0%5"(3#5$0'

$'6(3$(#'

 :  ;'$ $(%$"#$0&(< $#&#&($0 2$0'.'

'#0"3."#$('#&#.#$  $3&%"4 3.%"#&( $'$"0%5"(3#5$0'

$'6(3$(#'

 

  

      

0$'$(#)1 0 "5.4=5"0/"1>3?%"#$ 0#5$6$#&#&($0'

&( '7 ! 0 -&035"0>3?%"#$ 0#5$6$#&#&($0 &( :  ! 0/&#5"(+&>3?%"#$ 00$'6(3$(#'(# 02&'5"4<<"0@"4>3?%"#$ 00$'6(3$(#( AAA 

 ! "##$%&"'#()*+,"-./ "%5 #5$6$#&#&($0'5"'%5"44$(<$3#5$ &0'#0$'6(3$(#B'

3$%&'&(0$+$%#&(<#5$&08&3'"'8$&(<((10$'6('&?$ $3&'/&'' 7 8.#"44@#5$#5$0#@@0&#6$#&#&('  5$ &0'#0$'6(3$(#&($"%5 #5$6$#&#&('>&(?&#$3#$(3$0' 0

11 0.((&(<"%"

$#$0&"&(&#'60$/&'$'(#5$#$0/'"(3%(3&#&('/$(#&($3&( #5$(#&%$&(?&#&(<#$(3$0'  $@&44 &0'#4,3$"4@&#5 7  5$6$#&#&($0B'8&3@"'(#%('&3$0$3"'5$@"'5$43#8$ &($4&<&84$&(?&$@ %4".'$ 3! #5$>@5&%50$"3'"'.(3$0)1 



    

             

 

       

    

   



 

   

     

        



 ! "!  "# "$    

  

    %

   

       &'

  

 %   

!

  "

  !#"  $  %&  '

 '

('

  (

 ( '  )'

  (   !

  "    )

5$%$0#& &%"#$0$4&$3.6(8,#5$6$#&#&($00$"3'"'.(3$0)1      *$$  

     $+ % "*#%  !

*+ 

,**-.+  / 

 ,*++             % 

    ,   %   +

 --.                                      

  

!/01--234-56.&7,$ 3                     ) 7 5$#$0/'C'5& #D5"'(#8$$(3$ &($3@$?$0>%4".'$:

#5$&'"'.(3$0)1 0   1  2  38  

    

  3****       

  %



       



        !  

  709    *  "0   )  4".'$:&(3&%"#$'#5"#'$0?&%$'@.438$0$E.&0$3 0"#4$"'# #@'5& #'("/$4,80$"9 "'#"(34.(%5>& >(#/0$5$$4&<&8&4&#,60?&3$3 &(%4".'$ 3!0$E.&0$'$F6$0&$(%$ '$0?&(<(#4$''#5"(

6$0'('6$0 '5& # ?$( "''./&(< #5"# #5$0$ "0$(4,#@ '5& #'>&# @.43  0$E.&0$ $F6$0&$(%$ '$0?&(<"0.(3

6$0'('5$%$0#& &%"#$&''.$3&( "?.0 #5&'6$#&#&($0'#&6.4"#$'5&'$F6$0&$(%$#8$4&/&#$3#'$0?&(<(4,

6$0'(' : 5$0$+$%#&( #5$8&3'.8/&##$38,#5$6$#&#&($0&( 7 >&'>#5$0$ 0$>.65$43  ! "##3#("'#()*+,"-./ * 5$  8&3  '.8/&##$3  8,  #5$  6$#&#&($0'  &(  #5&'  6$#&#&(  @"' 0$+$%#$3(#5$<0.(3#5"##5$, "&4$3#'.8/&#"("

&3"?&#"'0$E.&0$38, %4".'$@5&%50$"3'"'.(3$0)1 

2 



  1 1 

  2  2&

   

    0:(  

   

!/01--234-56.&7,$ 4   

  

  "       "     

 "      " ""      0:( 

 

  )&+

 (() 5$0$+$%#&(&'(#+.'#& &$35$"

&3"?&#@"'(##8$ &4$3 "4(<@&#5#5$#$(3$04".'$&#'$4 3$'(#0$E.&0$#5$6$#&#&($0# &4$ #5$"

&3"?&#"4(<@&#5#5$#$(3$0 5$0$#5$0$'6(3$(#'0$E.&0$3" 3%./$(##8$'.8/&##$3"4(<@&#5#5$#$(3$0&#'6$%& &%"44,60?&3$3 0 #5$'"/$&(#5$ 0&('#"(%$#5$%5$%94&'# 0'.8/&''&( #$(3$0'

'#"#$3C"44#5$3%./$(#'$(%4'$3@&#5#5$#$(3$0 0/'5.438$(./8$0$3 "(3'&<($3D 5$3%./$(#'&(#5&'%5$%94&'#3$'(#&(%4.3$#5$'"&3 "

&3"?&# .0#5$0%4".'$ @5&%5@$5"?$"40$"3,'$#.#"4'0$E.&0$'C#5$ 60$1E."4& &%"#&(3%./$(#'#8$'.8/&##$3"4(<@&#5#5$#$(3$0 0/D 5$'"&3"

&3"?&##8$ &4$36.0'."(##%4".'$@"'(#($ #5$'$ 3%./$(#'5$0$+$%#&( #5$#$(3$0(#5&'8"'&'>#5$0$ 0$>&'(#@$44

.(3$3  05"(+&'.8/&##$3#5"#%4".'$0$E.&0$3#5$"

&3"?&##8$

&4$3"4(<@&#5#5$#$(3$0(#5&'0$<"035$64"%$3%('&3$0"84$$/65"'&' (#5$@03'C(#5$3"#$  &44&(< #5&'#$(3$0D&(%4".'$5$'$@03'

3(#E."4& ,0'#&6.4"#$#5$#&/$@5$(#5$"

&3"?&#&'#8$ &4$35$, E."4& ,#5$%(3&#&( $4&<&8&4&#,("/$4,#$(3$0$0'>@53(#5"?$"(, 4&%$('$ "'&/&4"0#0"3$ 0/0$'6(3$(#((#5$3"#$  &44&(< #5$ #$(3$0  0&#6$#&#&( :  &'>#5$0$ 0$>"44@$3 5$  &0'#  0$'6(3$(#  &'  3&0$%#$3  #  %('&3$0  #5$  6$#&#&($0B'  8&3>  & >  &# #5$0@&'$'"#&'

&$'"44#5$#5$0#$0/'"(3%(3&#&('

 ! "##$%4"'#()*+,"-./  5$#$(3$0'.8/&##$38,#5$6$#&#&($0&(#5&'6$#&#&(@"' 0$+$%#$3(#5$<0.(3#5"##5$6$#&#&($05"3 "&4$3#%/64,@&#5#5$

44@&(<#$0/'&(#5$>@5&%50$"3"'.(3$0)1  





  6          

              

    

           

       &'

 +    "

      0 

          &'

 ;   ;     

$'

                       )  5$6$#&#&($0'.8/&##$3#@$(?$46$'5$/"'#$0$(?$46$ @"'"3/&##$34,'$"4$3 5$$(?$46$%(#"&(&(<#5$60&%$8&3@"'(# '$"4$3  "4#5.<5  #5$  /"'#$0  $(?$46$  @"'  '$"4$3   5$  %4".'$  &'  (# /"(3"#0,5&'&'%4$"0 0/#5$.'$ @03C/",D&(#5$'$(#$(%$$ 0$6$"#$34,"'9$3#5$0$'6(3$(#'@5$#5$0"(,60$+.3&%$ "(,("#.0$@"'

0%.435"?$8$$(%".'$3#"(, #5$0$'6(3$(#'&(%4.3&(<#5$60&?"#$ 0$'6(3$(#'("%%.(# #5&'"44$<$34"6'$5$0$@"'("('@$05&' %4".'$&'"4'(#.("/8&<..' #&'6''&84$#%('#0.$#5$'$%(3 '$(#$(%$#/$"(#5"##5$/"'#$0$(?$46$5"3#8$'$"4$3"(3#5$0&<5#

#5$0$'6(3$(#'#3&'E."4& ,"8&3&'(4,@5$(#5$/"'#$0$(?$46$&'(# '$"4$3 (#5$%&0%./'#"(%$'>#5$0$+$%#&( #5$6$#&#&($0B'#$(3$0&( #5&'%"'$@"'"08&#0"0, 5&'@0&#6$#&#&(  !&'> #5$0$ 0$>"44@$3 $'6(3$(#('5"44%('&3$0#5$6$#&#&($0'8&3"4(< @&#5#5$8&3' #5$#5$0#$(3$0$0'

7 #@"'/"3$%4$"08,.003$03"#$3  #5"##5$"@"03 #5$@09&( "?.0 0$'6(3$(#(@.438$'.8+$%###5$03$0'&( #5&'@0&#6$#&#&(%%03&(<4,>& >#5$8&3'.8/&##$38,0$'6(3$(#(&'

#5$0@&'$(##5$/'#%/6$#&#&?$>#5$@0903$0&''.$3#0$'6(3$(# ('5"44'#"(3@&#530"@(  5$@0&#6$#&#&('"0$>"%%03&(<4,>3&'6'$3   52'1

,/2-672+'0./2,+ +82-1+ 2-6772-1.

016+ )9))#()* 4.%9, 5$#5$0#8$0$ $00$3# $60#$0G$';