High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3990/2023disposed of

M/S A.M. Auto Diesel And ANR. v. Varinder Nath Mayor Anda Nr.

2026-04-20Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

( ( ( (A;

#" (' #" (' #" (' #" (' ;;:

;;:

;;:(' (': : : :A- E.

- E.

- E. 4% %(!

4% %(!

::D: : : :>

"%"%(!

"%"%(! - .

- .

)(!* !"- .

+ + + + #$%&(%,*8(4#" "$ ) "%"%(! ! '("$ BBBB ,- #&.

,- #&.

+ + + + /0 1 2#1(') !") "%"%(!'%& *3!

!* "%4& 5('"$ (!

"%"3"

"%(! (' !*%#, 4$#&& !6 $# 7 ! &#%* "( #! (* *#" * :F:F: )#

* 71 & #! *%8%&3 3*6 -3!%(%8!.#&#!*$#,2 2$ 71"$ ())("3!%"16#!" * "( "$ ) "%"%(!

( # "( 4(

9 C#=% %! ?9 #%!* #"$ # #1( -&#!*&(*.2# "

#" *# !%& /0 % % '&1 "#"%!6, %! "$ ) !" 4#

, #! 8%4"%(! ) "%"%(! 4#= "( 7 '%& *%!"$ 1 # :5#""$ %!

"#!4 ('"$ 9&#!*&(* <3#"$ * =% %

$() !(; #!* * : %"3#" * #" #1( 3%&*%!

!6 $3 #* ! (#*, #&#!* *$# #6#%!

" "$ ) "% %"%(!

, 2$ %! "$

9&#!*&(* 4&#%= * "$ $ % 7(!#'%* ! 4

%"1<3#"$ * =% *) =%

)(!'#=%!6('%

)(!* * !" (#)) # *# #!*" !* *$% #''%*#8%"(!:>:

::# ?9 !"$ #%** #" , #""$ <3 "('

'& #! *4(3!

&'("$ ) "%"%(!

7 '( "$ & #! *%#&( 3", "$ =#"" 2#

#*@(3! * "( :D:5: '(

?9 !

:D:5:,"$( 36$ ?9#)) # *'($% 4( (

9 C#=%!#"%(!,$(2 8 #6#%!

(! <3 "=#* 71 1& #! *4(3!

&'("$ ) "%"%( (!

,"$ =#"" 2# #*@(3! * *"( F:5:$ #'" ,"$ =#"" 2# &% " *( (!:F:F: !"$#"*#" , ?9 2# ) !", 73 3" # <3 " 2# =#* (! 7 $ $#&' (' "$ ) "%"%(!

4(!*34"%!6"$

9 C#=%!#"%(!,#'" &3!4$ (2 8 , 8 !#'" &3!4$, ?9 2# !("4(

9 C C#=%! *,"$ 71 3&"%!6%!4& ( 3 ('"$ ())("3!%"16#!" * *"( "$ ) "%"%(! 9"

!#!" & 8#!"H%=!%(* )#

*71"$ & #! *%#&(3" # C"#4" *$ 3!

!* 9 * *#" *:>:: * *#" *:>:: * *#" *:>:: * *#" *:>::

$(*$%*8(4#" '( $#3!+$#!!#*8(4# '() "%"%(! #" '(

?9 % ) !" <3

" '( #! #*@(3!= !" 71 4(3!

& '(

)(!* !",4# "#!* #*@(3! *"(:D:

:5:'(4(

C#=%!#"%(!(' ?9 9

:9:9:> %8%&3*6 3!%(%8% %(!9D

::A: * *#" *:D:5: * *#" *:D:5: * *#" *:D:5: * *#" *:D:5:

$*8(

&'("$ (4#" '("$ ) "%"%(!

?9% ) !"'($% 4 (

9 C#=%!#"%(!,$(2 8 #!#))&%4# #"%(! #*@(3!= !" $# 7 ! =(8 * 71 ) )(C1 4(3!

& '( "$ )(!* !" (! ! "$ 6(3 3!*"$#""$ =#%!4(3!

&% !("2 && (!#44(3!"('$%6$' 8 #!*% 3!#7& 7& "( 4(= = ) !" 7 '( "$ 4(3" ! "$ %!"

" (' @3 "%4 , 4# % #*@(3! * * "( F:

:5: '( 4(

?9 #!* =#%!%!6 8%* !4 (' ' "$ ) "% %"%(!

:9:59:D !* )G#3

::A:

*#" * *#" * *#" * *#" *:F :F :F :F::::F: : : :

$(*$%*84&'()

&$@3!'( ) "%"%(!

?9% ) !"'($% 4

9 C#=%!#"%(!$(2 8 )(C14(3 3!

)(!* !"$# )& #* *"$#""$ 4#

=#17 "#G !3)#'" &3!4$ %!4 =#% %!4(3!

&$# !("4(= ) !"#!*4

9 C#=%!#"%(!('"$ 2%"!

$#& &&7 4(!

!*34" *#'" &3!4$44(*%!6&1"$ '% '%& 7 )3"3)#'" ::

:9:F9:F

::A:

$(*$%*84&'()

&$@3!'( ) "%"%(!

%& "#G !3)#6#%! (C1 C14(3!

&$# "#" *#"7#"$#""$ = =#%! 4(3!

& % #)) #%!6 %! # ) (!#& 4#

7 '( "$ (!

7& 3!@#7 E #1 1#!# %6 6$(3"#!*# 34$$ $#&&!("7 # #7& "(4(

?"(*#1""

"$% )(C C1 4(3!

& '( )(!* !" % $ 7 71 *% 4" * "( '%& #! #))&%4#"%(! #*@( (3!= !" ) 4%'1%!6"$ !#= ('"$ 4# ) (!#&%!2$%4$"$ =#%!4(3 3!

% #) #)) #%!6"(*#17 '( "$ (!

7& 3!

3!@#7E#1#!#%6$(3"44(*%!

%!6&1 '%& 7 )3"3)#"AA:

:9:F9:F

::A:

$(*$%*84&'()

&$@3!'( ) "%"%(!

%& "#G ! 3) #6#%! #" AA A: ( #))&%4#"%(! '( #*@(3!= = !" $# 7 ! =(8 * (! 7 $#&' (' "$ )(!* !" (2 8 # 4()1 (' * "#%&

& (' #*@( (3!= !"('"$ (!

7& 3!@#7E# #1#!#%6$(3"%! 9:D> :F $# 7 ! )&#4 * (! 4(* * )(C1 4(3!

& $# "#" * #" 7# "$#" "$ = =#%! 4(3!

&% #)) #%!6%!"$ #%*4# "(*# #1(2 8 ,"$ !#= ('"$ #*8(4#"

" %! #'( #%*4# % *%'' !"*)(C1 4(3!

&% *% 4" *"()&#4 (! 4(* *"$ H%= =!%(* "( $(2"$#""$ =#%!4(3!

&% #& ((! ('"$ 4(3!

& #)) #%!

!6%! 4# 44(*%!6&1"$ '%& 7 )3"3)#"

#"D::

:9:F9:F

::A:

$ (*$%*84&'() "%"%(!

&$@3!'(

%& "#G ! 3) #6#%! #" D:: %"$ #!1 #))&%4#"%(! #*@( (3!= !" $# 7 ! =(8 * !( #!1 H H%=!% (* $# 7 ! )&#4 * (! 4 4(*

"$ !(! $# #)) # * (! 7 $#&' ( )(!* !" * )%" ) 4%'%4 *% 4"% "%(!

6%8 !71"$ 4(3""("$ )(C14(3!

!8% 2('"$ 4(!*34"(')(C14(3 3!

#)) ) #%!6(!7 $#&'('"$ )(!* !","$ $% 4(3"'%!* "$#"!(6(3!*% =#* (3" "( 6 6#!" '3"$ #*@(3!= !" "( "$

)(!* !" '( 4(

? 8 ! ("$ 2% ? 2$( % #6 * #7( 7(3" 5 1 # $# 4(= '(= &$% $%, % #)) ) #%!6%!"$ A*"%= "(*#1'($%

C#=%!#"%(!#!*$% =#%!4(3 3!

$# '#%& *"(#)) ##6#%!8 !("$ 2%

!(@3 "%'%#7& 6(3!*$# 7 !"#G !

!71

)(!* !"'(!(!9#)) ##!4 ('"$ $ =#%!4(3!

& #"$ "$ 2%"!

$# 7 !

!$##

%!4 =(!%!6! 34$4%4 43= "#!4 ,*(!("* =%"'%""('3 "$ 6#!

!" #!1 ())("3!%"1 "( "$ )(!* !

!" "( 4(

C#=%! ?9 34$ $ "$ ()) )("3!%"16%8 !% " #" *# (2 2"(4(= 3)(!;:F:'( =#%!

%!%!6 ) "% %"%(! 8%* !4

:9:F9:F

::A:I /A0 66 6% 8 *71"$ (* *#" *:F:F F:,"$ ) !" 8% %(!) "%"

"%(! 4#= "( 7 '%& * )%" !("%4 , !( (! $# 4 4$( ! "( #)) # (! 7 $#&' ('

/D0 $ $#8 $ #* & #! * 4(3!

& '( "$ ) "%"%(!

#!* 6( (! "$(36$"$ )#) 7((G /0 $( (36$)%=#9'#4% ,"$ #)) # "

"(7 !(@3 "%'% * # (!(!"$ ) )#" ('"$ ) "%"%(!

'(!("#8#%&%!6"$ () ))("3!%"16#!" *"(4(

9 C#= =%!

)(!* !"( ?9,$(2 8 ,G )%!6%!=% %!*"$ % "#!"%#&%6$"

#!*# #& ( "(#''(*"$ = '' 4"%8 ())("3!%"1"(* ' !*"

"$ %4# %!"$ 8%4"%(!) "%"%(!

!,%" 2(3&*7 %!"$ %!"

"('@3 "%4 ,%!4# "$ 1 # #''(* *#!("$ ())("3!%"1 1"(

?9 %* %","$ %=)36! * *(* *#" *:F:F:,2$ 71

())("3!%"1 "(

?9 2# "

#" * # , % &%G &1 "( 4# #3

"#!"%#&) @3 3*%4 "("$ %6$"

('"$ ) "%"%(!

$ '( ,#*()"%!

!6# )#6=#"%4#))( (#4$#"$ "$#!* ' #"%!6"$ %6 6$"

(!$1) 9" 4$!%4#&6(3!* (* *#" *:F:

:F:)#

*71"$ & #! * %#&(3"% $ 71 "# %* $ ) "%"%(!

9" !#!

# #''(* *(! '' 4"%8 ( ())("3!%"1"(4(

?9 %! "$ 8%4"%(! ) "%"%(! ) ' * #" "$ %!

"# #!4 (' "$ 9&#!*&( $(2 8 "$ #= = $#&&7 37@ 4""()#1= !"('

'4( "- .('

,::,:::9"(7 ) )#%* 71"$ ) "%"%(!

"("$ 9&#!

!*&(* (!(7 '( "$ *#" '%C C * 7 '( "$ & #!

!"(!"(&& />0 # #! *4(3!

&'("$ ) "%"%(!

$# )(%!" *(3""$#""$ ! C"* *#" ('$ #%!67 '( "$ & #! *%#&(3"% '%C *'(:>::>! 34$8% 2 2(' "$ =#"" , "$ & #! * %#& (3" % <3 "

* "( !("%'1 "$ )#"% #7(3" !"(* #!

!*'%C#*#" '(#)) ##!4 ('

)(!* !"(7 %!6 ?9'( $%

9 C#=%!#"%( (! ! 4# "$ , ) "%"%(!

'#%& "( * )( %" "$ 4( "- .

,::,:::92 2%"$%!"%= 7 '( "$ & #! *% %#&(3","$ #= 7 4(8 * *# # # ('#!*

8 !3 #!*"$ ())("3!%"1#'

''(* *8%* "$% (* 7 " #" * *# %& /50 $ ) !" ) "%"%(! % #&&(2 * * %! "$ #7(8 " = !* *%!6 #))&%4#"%(!- .,%'

'#!1, $#&&#& ( "#!**% )( *( (' + . + . + . + . )%& )%& )%& )%&:

:,: ,: ,: ,:> "%G - - - - ?$ ?$ $ "$ ) #G%!6 # (! *

$ "$ )("#7&

(