High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9475/2011disposed of

Gurdev Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra10 pages

!"#$% & !$%$'%(#$%)

* +,* - -- . +,* - ,,

! " #$%&'%#'(

)*' +# ""' #( (,' " #'#''(

)*'- " #') (

)*'' " *#' '(

)*' + . //// -- ./

0 # ##'1 (# ' +2'#

++*'3 4567 0889:808( *.+# ;' *2 *(0<9.3#'++ '=# *+0<9.>7- ' + # 2'# + +*' 3 4 5?7 0@86:800( *A+# *+0<9. : #++'*+#*''#'#)&+,' '+*' ' 0889:808('*2B' &' ::9A'*( ' ')BB'

&','(' %'B'('&#'B$' "''$"','( +'BB *9@(08A(' 08@+ '

'3"#'B7+ & '

,*'

) #'#+')+ .#

1'& '='#4 +#*& ' + B* (#

B' #'&' *& '*' )B &+#''> 6 # +B #,*( ' 8@08:808( *?5 +#;' *2CBB*( ' #'*2+ # '( # 1BB 1# &# +& # ' + '* + +*'3 '7#' ,*'*' 45. . ' B ( # B* ' & # '

+*' =1# ' )1 & # " ' )B & *#&#'+,'(' (+#'# )& ' '

&1# .+ #" '1# * 9@( 08A ' 08@( #B ' * '

'> #'+( # ' )& '+*' *A+# *+0<9.3 4 5?7+'*2 B' &' 09@@'*(#+#'

-*--- , -, - . #B' *B+# * (#'#&

+*''B'B2'# ' ' '# * )

C#'

5 +# *+0<9.(' #B$1'#;'

*23C& '7B(09A63#'++ '=#B+ 09A67#')+BB1 #' *..5+'5 +#

*+0<9.(#B' *''*2 +' )'*& ' (B +#

& *B'53'7+5*307+*.8( ) 1#+*&4'* #'+ 1)(* #'#

*'(;' *2C&&1'* #'

)&(' ) B6+#B+09A61##

B* 3 '7( +'BB 'B & 1# # #'+ 4'*

) #+( * #' # '*2 '# '# B''B ' # ' &' '( ' *B # '

)3 '7(' (# #'*2'&'

+' B*D )' *& ' ** (+B'1 (' D)'

? +#& #B' *B+# ( #'BB ''&+*& '#' #*& ' 5 .#1## )&B'B (' #'+# '*2+#,*B' (*' (# #'*2 * #+( , B'*#

! !

#$% A #B' *B'

' + :&(#''

# B (" ' ,*+ .#''

) # #& 1 C&& #C#'&'# +C#+"( ,'(& #B :98<:88?(' (:@80:88A2B ( B+1' ( # 'B

* +" ',*#

* # +') + .( # # && A:?? '

6889:88?(' (&& 0@@8A ' 868?:88A#' " '

,*+ .#''

) #,')& # 'BB* (:886(1#*#1''B4 # ,*

) +*' 09:? ' ::.:88?( # )& + ,'( '& + ' C&&* 2B ( # )&,'( '&+ E')B &

B 'B'

&1# .:?0:88A(' (:08@:88A(# + " ' ,*+ .#'+(#' )& +*' *.+# *+0<9.('*2 #'

B' +# B* 3 '7 @ #''

'#+*' *.+# *+ 0<9.(#'++* ** ('B 1## 1##'

#,*1## B' +68 ' (1*'BB + 'B #' #;' *2CBB*(0900:808#,*+'BB '++* *B # 1#' #;' *2 CBB*(' (#B''** B & # # )&

+* #'&(# )&(1 & * ,*# ,*(' ('** B +*' *A+# *+0<9.1' ) A<: ' 0@86:800(' () :6A: ' 688A:800( 1# '*21' *B' &'

'# *+09@@'* +B' ' A6.'*+B' ('*' #)'** < ' B ( & #' # B' * # +*'3 '7(' #')&('#4 + #C& ' 5 '

.(+ B* )F B' (#'& ' *& '* ' )B & + # '' '** '* 1# # B + "'B'+ '

'(' (& *+*'BB +# B'

#'&' *& '* )B &+" '1# ,*+

.')BB'

"','('&#'B$(' %'B'(' "''$"','(

#B' * '

' 9 ;' '*B&#'*#'*21' #')& *#' +# B* +#'(# # ,*'*2#'* ''*2+ B* (+ #*& '* #' +#&(#'* #'*2*' ' +# *+0<9. # B* + #')&('*#*69.:' *..5+# *+ 0<9.(''

B*'B '0(!'1$234%35!(6 5 ! 3#'7$%347!$"5 5$% (6!!5#5%-(35$% &$234(3$2) 08 #2+B'11#*#2 +&B' ' 'B'1 #C(1##(&+#' &

# )&' # )' 5 )B ** ( ## )*' *.6+# *+0<9.( )1#+ *&4'* #'+(#B'4' B('## +# ' &' '(' *)B *' *69.:+# *+ 0<9.

!"#$%#

&"!%%'"(

! "#

$% % &'()*&)

&'()+

/ .

. - 0 .0

00 +#'1#')+&B' 2+B'1# '++&')(# )+'& B &+5*307*B'3'7(

3''7' 37(+*.8+# *+0<9.( )1#+*& 4'* #'+( '# # '

' )& '& B '+ +&'2 (#'* ' '+'*()5'5)( '2 (' B &'

*+##&*'

#')4'* )('(*.8+# *+0<9.

1)( *)+#')( #1'$+# )&

*.6+# *+0<9.(#&' '*B *69.:+ # *+0<9.( *& 4*B ( &'B #1'$+ ''

&') ' # )B ' # )&B'B ( # # ' ) *& ++*)( ' D # *& B'*(+' (#' )(*&*& BB *2'B !$( )$ *&+ -*+

-*+

$!34!6 $% 3$96 5:%#4!5%623!34 '915 5$% 6##! #9; 3406!%#($'% 02$!3473535$%! 5 !<(3#/6%#/34 '915 5$% 6##! #9;3406!%#-363($'% 05 6((73#

0: ) + # * '+'* # '

)& )5'5) ' 2 ( # 'B #( # '$ '# *B'3 '7('*' #' )( *.8+# *+0<9.( +#''

#'+(# )+*.6+# *+0<9.( *&#

++B'B (# # )+*69.:+# *+ 0<9.*&4*B 2B5*& B'*(+' (# )+ *.8+# *+0<9.( #'

' )&( ''BB )'(#'*2 * ('*'&B'*# +#++#

)'*& ' 5 )B ** (1#*&'' #'1

('*5 . 06 # &' '+#B '$ ( #+'*&#' #) B ''

&3 45:D:7 #

)&' .#+(1##1'$+#'

&( # # ) + * .6 + # * + 0<9.( &'$ '

B*'B# )' '+ *69.:+# *+0<9. 2B(#++*+5*& B'*(+' ( #'*2 '# 1# #' &' '# *.8+# *+0<9.('# '&B)'*

&% '

() *'

+! ,%& - * '(

! !) '+ .% /%

( ! - ! -3 3- ,%& ! !

!3 ,%&

-! - %

0% *(- (

(

! /.& !

)

(

!! /.&%

% 1 $

+ *# 5

"#""

$ $% &'() *#+,

( !

! (

(

!! /.&% -#-"

!"#$ "#"#!"#%

!"#$

#&'% $##!!"#$

#&'%

() *

!%,

"#"#!"#%

!"#$

-#-. -

!"#$-

## #&'% "#"#!"#%

!"#$

-/ -

.* ()-

/ 0

/ /

!"#$

## #&'%

!%(#) !"#$

#&'%2 0@ C2B (#' &'

' &) *' #C( *'BB 1# # * +#'1 '& *'& ' :A8?:800( #C( 1#+*& 4'* #'+B'B (1##')4'* ''

#*'

# ) * 3 '7( ' &'

# GB

4 C( *& 4 B' #'1##'1' # *+0<9.(*'& *B '**+ * +' * (' D' & *& ' #C(# # +''1'

# *+0<9.(#* 2

345 1(#&6

#)&&

"1'1#)&&1 / 1

0< 2B(1##''B4 B' #')4'*

##'# ''1' ' &+# *+0<9. C2B (#'1' &'

#CBB*** ( '* #+*'3 '7(&'

#&&+*00+# *+ 0<9. # ' '1' * 1# : &# +& ' # *& '(' & #( +#1# *5 .( + # CBB* ** ( #' # '

*& ' *& ')'B'B *& B' # B' 5B ** 09 +'** B =-- .> =,,> ) #B#

434! 76?5%:@!6 $%# @$

434!!7$!3690 @$