← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/39383/2021dismissed

Shobha v. State Of Haryana

2024-02-26Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta13 pages



  !  "!

#$%$ &$'$ $ $ $ & $  ( ) *"

+, -  .

*"

+, -  

&/0+0 1     

   $  2%3 #!/

 &

$4! $  (    



  

     &

$4! $ -#    !

"





#$%&& 



' 

()* #+ +,,%%,%+   

 

* "  & - 

.



/# 0



1

 

 +23+  

    4 ' 

  

+3/&&  4'

     %+ ()"  

 

-  1 )

5 5- &  6*-17.

 

-

-

 4 

 -  8 * "  )"          &      .

         

 

     

 Page no.1 out of 13 pages

 "  



-  - &    *-19  - :  8      ;

  & &  <=  9  -

  >;  &  

   * "  9     :   - "   >    *-1&.

 %% ;  +,,%%,%+           

 



"



 

"   

4 -

 4 

  

 

       "

 "    "  

   " 

  ;

:

       " 

    " 

 ,3,%%,%+   <  & * "      "

  "        4 

 $0  ":    

 " 

"1  "

       -

 4 

  ,3,%%,%+     "  :  4 

  "  

 4 

4-

6

7   "    4 :

     "



  

 

 =  =

  "

 4  4

 "

       4  :₹+?,,@" 



  

  

  

    /#    "



 +,,%%,%+    

 "

 

 :



 %/          "

       "

      Page no.2 out of 13 pages

4 " * "   +,,%%,%+  4 #5#A/,   "

 

: -

 4 ;  

    

    "  

    !

   <    & * "  "

 

 "

 A

7    B 

"  

   :    " "

 "



71 (   ++

  3":% 

7& 

  



7-

 

    7!

   C "   *  @



 7*    ;-

56 ((A   "

  "

 





   

  

 %#      

 "

   "  4 

 "

 4 "

-

 

   " 4  



   

 %0 )   4 

   

   "

  " 



4    4   =

   * "

:

 " 





  "

  

-

" 1    

  

1"

  

   4"

 Page no.3 out of 13 pages

4

 4 



"

" : 

 

4        1

:

;- 

 4 

    ;-*A+,,3,  * ,/ ,3,%%,%+ " 

 "

  1 1 

  

       &

 * "  





 %?

()    

       

  

"      *   D@  %2   

4    

 

 4 

      4  6  7    %?+,%,%,  

    *   "   

)"     () 

"   

B



 

 %,,/

1 1    4 

  

"   

  





  "  & 

 /+ :

  ' 

 

    ()      

       

+3/&&

4  



   4   





4 ! 

8  

 &  8:  

 %,   

 

  +$,,     4

 



4 

 

  /% > 





     Page no.4 out of 13 pages

 

    "   

4

:  

"  ' 

 

"

  " 

 "    & 

  "





 

" 

 // >  

 

         

  

 :

/# 0

1    > 

  

/# 0

1 4 

%67

 

  

4  "

   

"

  4

  4   

"   4 

  

      #   

  



 ,3,%%,%+"



 





4 = =

 "

    4 

"

 4    

4 >    

     4              "

      

   

 

    " 

4        4   =







     ;* " 





1   

   4"

 

   

"



4 1 ;-     

  ,3,%%,%+ 

   

)  Page no.5 out of 13 pages

 

    

  

 

:  & 

 "



 

" 

>  

4  

   



/# 0

1      

4    

   

 0 ) 

 4 

4       

   6.



1

 

 +23+"  to provide for termination of certain pregnancies by registered medical practitioners and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Medical Termination of Pregnancy Rules, 2003 E 

F%,,/G

4   

1 +23+

 /# 0

1    



1   

  A  

    

 



       

 

 

 

   !"

 #$% 

&  '  

  (

)

 

 )    )  

     & (

  

' 

& 

(

&       '* 

 

 + , ! ------------ 6  7 

       &   ' 

 ( &      

 

'      '  ( 

 & 

(

.*&   ( '   & (

''*

  ')'  

 (

.*&  /  0* &&    ) 

(

 .*&       1  /  2  1

 '   



&& 3 Page no.6 out of 13 pages

*

  /  0* && 

 

 

  

 &  * &&(

) 

 ' 

 .*& &

'

& & &+    + ------------ 6  7 ,     

 

 

 

   !"

 #$%  &   ' 

(

'  

 

&  '  

 (   ') (    )

&' &  & 

  (

 



()  &

- 

*



)    



 

-  



&  + 4 5* & 



' 

 '     & 



  !

 ( ') (    )

&' &  & 

  (

 



()  &

- 

*

 + ! 

'  (

  ' 

 ''*

)  ) ( 

  !

 ( ') (    )

&' &  & 

  (

 



()  &

- 

*

 + 3  4  

 4 

"

 

/

    "

  "

  

 4    



9"

 

# 

  "

 

 4  

0 

 

       )            

  

  "

    

   

 

  "

  $ )  

   

  





 %,,/

             

         4       



    

   





 

  %,    

  +$,,    4 

  

 1       Page no.7 out of 13 pages



>& 

  

%67



 "

  " 

 "

  "   

4

: 

"  ' 

 

 "   

& 

 "





 

" 

 2 

%67

   A   &   '  &

' ) &  ' 

(

) 

&  

)  & 

+6 +, )  4 >& 

 

 

    

"      

1  4  : 11.

As the meaning of "Termination of pregnancy" would reveal, it is the procedure to terminate a pregnancy by using either medical or surgical methods, and not the culmination of the procedure. A "procedure" generally refers to a series of steps or actions taken to accomplish a particular task or achieve a specific result. In the context of "termination of pregnancy," the term "procedure" refers to the medical or surgical steps undertaken to end the pregnancy intentionally. In the case of abortion, the specific procedure can vary and may involve either a medical abortion using medication or a surgical abortion, each with its own set of steps and considerations. Overall, a procedure is a systematic and organized set of actions designed to achieve a particular goal. Page no.8 out of 13 pages

+% )     

 4   

     

    

 "

  4 = =  4 ,3,%%,%+ 4  "

 4 4  6  7

" 

4    

 

 !

  <  &* "   +,,%%,%+"

  

"    "

  "

 





   

  

 

  +,,%%,%+"

  " 

"

=

 

   4       

"

  4 

 4 

1  "

  " 



 4  1



 



       

    

 

 4 "   4 

4     

 4     

  4    4 '



    



 4    " 



 ,3":     '&  

  4 "     =

"     

1 

    

  "

       "

 



%67

1  Page no.9 out of 13 pages

+/+  >  

 

     

         



   !"

 #$% &    '()**+)   

4   



 

'  



"

   4 



  :

   :

4 4 

5-     :  

 " 

 4    



1     4       1   ()  "      -



   " 

  



5-      : 



 

 +/% )

 

H

   "  4

&   

4  

 

 

 4 

 

 

  " 

 



  " 

      





 



 +//



  

      4

    

   

    

    

  4

     " :4

&   



 ,

 -. /    

4



  Page no.10 out of 13 pages

+#+ > 



   

      

0  

.     !"

 #$-12 3)4*!

5+6)$

+5+45+6*/)     

 

"  

 " 4       - &  

 "



1:

 



       

 

1:



"      "



 

1:

)"  



&   

  1 "    +#% & 

     4 

  "   

    "   



1:

 +0+ > 

     7   8

9 7  7 

7. -:

;71;/ 1-<7;/7:

=2#%  &    '

(56*55)  

  " 



-4

   1  

  "  

    +#": 

   



  4  

"  

5-4

    : "

   4   

   4 





+#":4    

       4  

 "



   

₹#,,,@    

₹0,,@"  :4      Page no.11 out of 13 pages

+0% )" 

 

 

   -

&   :

 



/

1   A "+ 

7



' 

)''

*

     +  

'&  (   !

8 

&  ) + 



 '&  (  +  & &

   &

  )  *   9  4,

(

  ') ( * )    

&

 ,%%,+  

(   )   & 

  ' 



  & & 

) '  +6 +0/  "

   

 

  

7  

,

-. /$ -4

       



  4 

+#":    

 

 )"    

   -

&                "

 

 

 



/6%7"   4 1    %,,%    4   

 

      

 15.4      

 

    4 

  

   4 



 )    4

   

     



    

 Page no.12 out of 13 pages

+?

 

  

 

 

  



&  

   4

' 

()

' 

     -   "

+, -   7&

$4! $8    #!&    @ :

A I@*

   4A I@*

Page no.13 out of 13 pages