High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21834/2016allowed

Inder Harpreet Singh And Others v. District Magistrate & ORS

2017-11-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath8 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#,- - - -. - . - . - . - '/#,!,0,##"%'12!'/"2#,& #"%"%'#,& 3& 2# %&",%$"4!1%&",!"#.&"!"#

%$#.!"%!5!!'/"2#,& #&0'/#'"& 4( 4( 4( 4(6 74 884 6 74 884 6 74 884 6 74 884 ,#&#'"( 4&'90!* 2!'"./)$!"#. ,"2#0#"%"%'#,& 4,!9,!)829,!'!. .9':!+ 4,,:9'"",%./)$!"#. ,,#&0'/#'" 884 . 884 . 884 . 884 . 2# 0#"%"%'#,& 2!)# $2!55#'1#/ "2# ,/#, /!"#/ - 0!&&#/ +; "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"#. !"%!5! /%,#$"%'1 "2#* " )!$!"# 9&#

.",##" .!

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

/!"#/ #C#$9"#/%' !)9, 0#"%"%'#,& D %',#&0#$" 29&#%'E9#&"%'+9""2#&!%/$%)%5&9%"2!&'"+##'09,&9#/+;,#&0'/#'" !&%"@!&/%&*%&&#/ ,''0,&#$9"%''A -2#2!& 9,"2#, &9+*%""#/ "2!" "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# @95/ 2!)# "2# :9,%&/%$"%' " #'"#,"!%' "2# !005%$!"

%' 9'/#, #$"%' "2# $" !'/ %' "#,*& "2# $"%' 5!' @2%$2 2!& +##' 0,#&$,%+#/ +; 95# "2# 9':!+ 4!%'"#'!'$# !'/ #5 !,#'"& !'/ #'%, %"%<#' 95#&. = &2,">"2#95#&6?'"% %#/' F% ,#&0'/#'" @!&"2#@'#, "%& 9,"2#,&9+*%""#/"2!""2# %&",%$"4!1%&",!"#@95/2!)#"2#:9,%&/%$"%' " #)%$" !' 9'!9"2,%<#/ $$90!'" ,* "2# 0,0#,"; "2# &#'%, $%"%<#'G0!,#'" !

"#, $'

%,*%'1 "2# "%"5# "2# &#'%, $%"%<#' +; "2# 9+

%)%&%'!54!1%&",!"#!'/"2#'!

"#,1%)%'1&2@$!9&#'"%$#"!0#,&'%' 9'!9"2,%<#/ 0&&#&&%' @95/ 0!&& !' !00,0,%!"# ,/#, " %& !5& &9+*%""#/ "2!" ' &9$2 0,$#/9,# 2!& +##' 55@#/. "2#,# ,#. "2# %*091'#/,/#,%&0!"#'"5;%55#1!5!'/@%"29":9,%&/%$"%' ' "2# "2#, 2!'/. 5#!,'#/ $9'&#5 , "2# ,#&0'/#'"& 2!& &9+*%""#/"2!""2#0#"%"%'#,&2!/1""2#0,0#,";%'/%&09"#",!'& #,,#/%' "2#%, !)9, *!5!

%/#5; ' "2#,@%&# ,#&0'/#'" %& "2# @'#, "2#0,0#,";%'/%&09"#"%&!5&&9+*%""#/"2!",#&0'/#'" %& 5/@%/@#/5!/;.@22!&'"+##'5B#/!

"#,+;2#,$2%5/,#'."2#,# ,#. &2# 2!/ " %5# !005%$!"%' 9'/#, #$"%' "2# $" @2%$2 2!& ,%12"5; +##'!55@#/+;"2# %&",%$"4!1%&",!"# 2!)# 2#!,/ 5#!,'#/ $9'&#5 , "2# 0!,"%#& !'/ 0#,9&#/ "2# ,#$,/ 2# E9#&"%' %')5)#/ %' "2%& 0#"%"%' %& !& " @2#"2#, "2#

%&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# @95/ 2!)# "2# :9,%&/%$"%' " #'"#,"!%' !' !005%$!"%'

9'/#,#$"%' "2#$"@2#'"2#0#"%"%'#,&!,#!/*%""#/5;"2#@'#,& "2#0,0#,";%'/%&09"#!'/!,#'"%'9'!9"2,%<#/0&&#&&%'H &0#,"2#&$2#*# "2#$".#$"%' "2#$"0,)%/#& "2!""2#"!"#)#,'*#'"&2!550,#&$,%+#!$*0,#2#'&%)#!$"%'05!' 0,)%/%'10,"#$"%' 5% #!'

/0,0#,"; &#'%,$%"%<#'&#$"%' $" 0,)%/#& "2# 0@#, "2# "!"# )#,'*#'" " *!B# 95#& $$,/%'15;."2#95#&@#,#*!/#+;"2#"!"# 9':!+%'@2%$295# "2#95#&/#!5&@%"2"2#!$"%'05!'!'/,#!/!&9'/#,( I$"%' 5!' , "2# 0,"#$"%' 5% # !'/ 0,0#,"; &#'%,$%"%<#'&'!$"%'05!'

,0,"#$"%' 5% #!'/0,0#,"; &#'%, $%"%<#'& &2!55 +# '"% %#/ +; "2# "!"# )#,'*#'" @%"2%' ! 0#,%/ &%C *'"2&

,*"2#/!"# 09+5%$!"%' "2#&#,95#&%' "2#

%$%!5 !<#""# !'/ %" *!; +# ,#)%&#/

,*"%*#""%*#J 2#!$"%'05!'@!&!$$,/%'15;'"% %#/' F!'/%"%& 0,)%/#/"2#,#%'"2!"%"@!&$*#%' ,$# ,*"2#/!"# %"&%&&9!'$#2# 0,$#/9,# ,#)%$"%' ,*0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5+9%5/%'1 &#'%,$%"%<#'%& 0,)%/#/ %' !$"%' 05!' +#&%/#& #)%$"%' ,/#,

,* 0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5 +9%5/%'1 &#'%, $%"%<#'G0!,#'"& !'/ #'

,$#*#'" ,/#,& 2# #'"%,# !$"%' 05!' 0#,"!%'%'1 " "2# #)%$"%' ,* 0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5 +9%5/%'1 "2# &#'%, $%"%<#'G0!,#'"& %& ,#0,/9$#/ !& 9'/#,( I,$#/9,# , #)%$"%' ,* 0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5 +9%5/%'1 #'%,%"%<#'&G0!,#'"(

K%L *05!%'"&,#$#%)#/K!&0#,0,)%&%'& "2# 4!%'"#'!'$# !,#'"& !'/ #'%, %"%<#'& $". -L ,#1!,/%'1 5% # !'/ 0,0#,"; #'%, %"%<#'& +; /%

#,#'"

#0!,"*#'"G1#'$%#&%#$%!5&#$9,%";. 9+

%)%&%'!5 4!1%&",!"#. 5%$#

#0!,"*#'". &G$%!5 ,B#,. #505%'# ,#'%,%"%<#'&!'/ %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"#2%*&#5 M&2!55+# ,@!,/#/" %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# "2# $'$#,'#/ /%&",%$" 9,"2#,!$"%' K%%L 2#

%&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# &2!55 %**#/%!"#5;

,@!,/ &9$2 $*05!%'"&G!005%$!"%'&""2#$'$#,'#/ 9+

%)%&%'!5 4!1%&",!"#&

)#,% %$!"%' "2# "%"5# "2# 0,0#,"; !'/ !$"& "2# $!&# "2,912 ,#)#'9# /#0!,"*#'"G$'$#,'#/ #2&%5/!,& @%"2%' F/!;& ,*"2#/!"# ,#$#%0" &9$2 $*05!%'"G!005%$!"%' K%%%L 2# 9+ %)%&%'!5 4!1%&",!"#& &2!55 &9+*%" %"& ,#0," "

%&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# %'!5,/#,&@%"2%' /!;&

,* /!"# ,#$#%0" $*05!%'"G!005%$!"%' K%)L "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# %& 0%'%' "2!"!';&',/!912"#,,5#1!52#,% !

F &#'%, $%"%<#'&G0!,#'"& !,# %' 9'!9"2,%<#/$$90!"%' !';0,0#,"; !& /# %'#/ %' "2# 4!%'"#'!'$# !'/ #5 !,#'"& !'/ #'%, %"%<#'& $". -. !'/ "2!" "2#; &295/ +# #)%$"#/. "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# &2!55 %&&9#%'"2#*!''#,2#,#%'!

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

%C#/ ' "2#9"#,/,, !" &*#

"2#, $'&0%$99& 0!," "2# 09+5%$ 0,#*%&#&!'/%'&9$2"2#,*!''#,!& *!; +# 0,#&$,%+#/. @2#,#90' "2# '"%$# &2!55 +# /##*#/ " 2!)# +##' /95; 1%)#'G&#,)#/ " !55 0#,&'& $'$#,'#/ )%$"%' ,/#, ,* 0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5 +9%5/%'1 #'%,%"%<#'&G!,#'"&( K%L % . !

"#, $'&%/#,%'1 "2# $!9&#. % !';.&2@'+;!';0#,&'&%' 09,&9!'$#""2#'"%$#!'/!'; #)%/#'$#2#G&2#*!;0,/9$#%' &900," "2# &!*# !'/ !

"#, 1%)%'1 2%*G2#, ! ,#!&'!+5# 00,"9'%"; +#%'12#!,/."2#

%&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# %& &!"%& %#/ "2!" "2# 0,0#,";G0,#*%&#& !,# %'9'!9"2,%<#/$$90!"%'."2#

%&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# , "2#,

%$#, /955; !9"2,%<#/ *!; *!B# !' ,/#, #)%$"%'. ,#!&'&"+# ,#$,/#/ "2#,#%'. /%,#$"%'1 "2!" 0,0#,";G,#&%/#'"%!5 +9%5/%'1 &2!55+#)!$!"#/.'&9$2/!"#. '"5!"#,"2!' F/!;& ,*"2# /!"# ,#$#%0" &9$2,/#,.!&

- *!;+#&0#$% %#/%'"2!",/#,. +; !55 0#,&'& @2 *!; +# %' $$90!"%'"2#,# .!'/$!9&#! $0; "2#,/#,"+#!

%C#/ '"2#9"#,/,,&*#"2#, $'&0%$99& 0!," "2# 09+5%$ 0,#*%&#&M K%%L 2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# *!; !5&!&&$%!"#&G359'"!,; ,1!'%<!"%'&G&$%!5 @,B#,& @,B%'1 , "2# @#5 &#'%, $%"%<#'&

,$#*#'" ,/#, "%&0,)%/#/%'"2#!$"%'05!'"2!"% !$*05!%'"%&,#$#%)#/ +; "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"# "2#' 2# @95/ %**#/%!"#5; ,@!,/ "2# &!%/ $*05!%'"""2#$'$#,'#/9+ %)%&%'!54!1%&",!"# ,)#,% %$!"%' "%"5#!'/!

"#,,#$#%)%'1"2#,#0,"2!&" ,*!'0%'%'"2!"!';&', /!912"#, , 5#1!5 2#%, ! &#'%, $%"%<#'&G0!,#'"& !,# %' 9'!9"2,%<#/ $$90!"%' !';0,0#,";!'//#&#,)#&"+##)%$"#/2#,#! "#,.2#@95/ %&&9# '"%$# %' @,%"%'1 " "2# &!%/ 0#,&'&. @2 !,# %' 9'!9"2,%<#/ $$90!"%'"&2@$!9&#!&"@2;"2#;@95/'"+##)%$"#/!'/%'"2# '"%$# 2# @95/ &0#$% ; "2# 1,9'/& ' @2%$2 "2# ,/#, #)%$"%' %& 0,0&#/ " +# *!/# !'/ "2#,#!

"#, 0!&&#/ "2# ,/#, #)%$"%' !& 0#, 0,$#/9,#0,#&$,%+#/%'5!9&# "2#$"%'5!'K90,!L '"2#0,#&#'"$!&#.,#&0'/#'" 2!&2#,&#5 !/*%""#/%'"2# @,%""#'&"!"#*#'""2!""2#0,0#,";%'/%&09"#2!&!5,#!/;+##'",!'& #,,#/+; 2#, )%/# 3!&%B! /!"#/ %' !)9, 2#, &'& '/#,

!,0,##" %'12 K0#"%"%'#, L !'/ 9B2+%, %'12 K0#"%"%'#, L. "2#,# ,#.&2#%&'""2#@'#, "2#0,0#,";%'E9#&"%',#1!,/%'1@2%$2 &2#2!/ %5#/!005%$!"%' ,#)%$"%''"2#1,9'/"2!""2#0#"%"%'#,&!,#%' 9'!9"2,%<#/ $$90!"%' "2912 "2#; !,# %' !9"2,%<#/ $$90!"%' +#%'1 @'#,&4,#)#,.

"2#&9%" %5#/+;2#,"$2!55#'1#"2#&!%/",!'& #,/##/ /!"#/ 2!&!5&+##'/%&*%&&#/ ,''0,&#$9"%'!'/2!&'" +##',#&",#/!&'"2%'12!&+##'&2@'""2#9,"!+9"%"&,#&",!"%'. "2#,# ,#."2#!005%$!"%'9'/#,#$"%' %5#/+;,#&0'/#'" !1!%'&" "2# 0#"%"%'#,& @!& 0!"#'"5; %55#1!5 !'/ 9'&9&"!%'!+5# !'/ "2# %&",%$" 4!1%&",!"#2!/':9,%&/%$"%'"#'"#,"!%'"2#&!%/!005%$!"%'%'"2#!+&#'$# "%"5# ,#&0'/#'" )#, "2# 29&# %' E9#&"%' , "2# 09,0&# 0!&&%'1!',/#, #)%$"%'!1!%'&""2#0#"%"%'#,& ' )%#@ "2# !

,#&!%/ +&#,)!"%'. "2# 0,#&#'" 0#"%"%' %& !55@#/!'/"2#%*091'#/,/#,%&2#,#+;&#"!&%/# K884 L K884 L K884 L K884 L )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#,- - - -. - . - . - . - 2#"2#,&0#!B%'1G,#!&'#/ #&G 2#"2#,,#0,"!+5# #&G