← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4542/2019allowed

Arvind Kumar Sarraf v. M/S Haryana Petroleum Products And Another

2025-05-23Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal7 pages



   

     





 !"" #$ %  & '( $!)"" 

           

 *!

 +, *"

-  -.

 -,       !  "     # !

 $  % & 

  

  '%!   "

( )))) -.

 -,/ "

 

#   *+,*+-!

. !"

  

 $

 0 #  1   2

3!  4

/ !  5 /  

""





 6    +1*3  5  7$$  '

#                   "      /

"  

(*""   $ / 5 



" *     !  "  /  "

("



 !

. *!    8

'  #

        & !  "

  (*  

     "  

(*$ " /

# ! /

#  

/ 

#%

5   !

*

. 8$  





 #

"  ! ""

. ,!

 6  9 13$$5

  % "

#

 !5

5

:

$ 

5

 

# 

"  $ /  !

. ;!# 

/  "   "" "

""

 ""

. -!

 6    +1*3$$5

  '

#    "               "    

   !   ""

/

:

$ 



"#  

<

'

#  



*8+,*+*7 

"  "    "  $ !

"   ( =. 

2  

"

(*

     " " "     

/  

 

  

     

    !"

" #$$% & '  ('

 )  *+  $, -./->

 0'1  

 2 3'   +

$

+  /' . 8 $

# !  # !   "

(   

 "

5





!

.  

 *! 

 # "   2  ? ?$  

! "

(*

8



 

   #

(*

  "

/

5

/

   

/  " 

43 '  +'  

 ''5   '  62/7!,$$

$ , @   "  

  

"

/  /

.

#  "

 7 :

""

. -!

#  %

A 5 

(*  

 " "  "   :5

  #

B  C/ " $ 

8   99 :    ' -.

 !!!   

#5   "    : / # 

#

 " 

"      

"  

#>

(

 /"

/

 "   @  

  1" 3! #$ 2 



     !

 "  /

"

 

#

5   5



" 5

 "

 5 %

   



#





@/

/ 

% 

  #

# /

#2

 / 

 '  D 2  

 2   "5  

/ 

5

 2  !

  "



,   / #

#"



"5   5  

 

  "5  9 = / 

# /% !

0'1 ; 1" 3! / 



   

      

           

    

      

      



            

 !          

      

      ! 

     "    

  

     

      #







        !

  

     



#

      $     

       

  

  $  

!      

         

           !        %

  

 !     

   

 



      

   





  

  

    

 

   

      !  



   !    

          

   ; @ & ' ; 1" 3!5

   

# /

5! #$ 2 / " 

  5



5 '   #

#

7



"  

 

- "

 /.

# /  "  " @ " (*"

!"

 "

 

(* 2  ? $  

"  @ " (8! /   

 " 



 "



 "    5       8+*+  

#    

#     *+!77!7,*;;@ " (,

7"



# /

"

 /  A

#

' "  !  /  

    /  

#  "   /

  

*8+*+,!

.  !5 / 

5

 "

 "

 "

.  *!  # 5  @ " (! /   

  "



    5

' /

"  

5  

!   

++;*+,5 "  + :  

# 

(*  # 

"  #   "  /

   /

  .

 

D

  

   "

/

"  5

/   '

(*!5 2  

" 

  "   

@   

(*  "" 

 ""



  

  :       "

       /5  "

  



(*( 

/   !5

     5  

  

 /5    "

  

(*

 .

 

!"  !

 '

#   #      '    /

  "     #!  

!

.  !/



(*!/ "   / #

 # 5   / 

!

(  $"



  (     



  

"

% 



 $"

 



5 5 "

#

#D

# !

   

:2  

  

 

5  #

/



#     "      

 "    

  .

 /  !  

/ " 

  

 ' 

: % #



43 '  +'1" 3 

"  "

(  

 @   

#"

0'1 ; 1" 3!2  #$ 

 

 

"

2   .

   #     

 ' '"     

/ 

( %



  

 



! 

! 



* :   $  

8

  )'      )   :



:

9  ' $,<!

+  *1<-$!

   " 

$"

  

@

 2 " !

9 5

' #

#2  

  #



@ 1  " 4'

: $,,! 

:  -$! $  



5      / " #



 #

#2  !

 # 

 5

 #

#2   :   $  

    =. 

# $ 

 "    #

   #

#2  % # / 

 

  #

#2  5" 



 #    @ 

# " ! $   

#





(*      " "  "          

     :

 $     %   ""

 5   "" 

#   

 %

 "    : ""  :

$  



 "#  

/ 

8 @

5/

 ! 

" 

5 @"#   

""

. -!

 "  /



 "  

(*

   / '   

 , 

#""

13  

"  *8+7*+*7  0-.

 -,1 %  23$3

#  45#67 8 !

4

23$3

5 $#9: 4