High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22803/2015dismissed

Vimla Devi And ANR v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ORS

2016-11-29Mr. Justice Surya Kant,Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia11 pages

!""#$%$&'()

' *+, - ,-. *+, - ,- ++

! " # ! " # ! $ % ! & ! " ' ! " -. / 0 1 ()* "+,--./0 -01/2 -01.." -/)2 ! ! !3' " 4 56 "! )-/7-//- -8))-//- ' '

! 1 7 " 9

!3' ! ).81"$ 56 $ -./0-//0 (-* :" ' !3' $ " ! !3' '5# ! $% 56 $$ ; '6: $ " ! -08()* " ' $ ! 0" ( "$ *

! )8.<'! ! !' 65 % 56

56 " '6% =' ! 6

56 > :5 '

! ' !3' 6! 56 5 ?! ! (0* 9 !'

" '

' $ 56 > :5 '

' ! ! 6 !' !3' '

" $ $ @ ! 6 $ '! ! !'5 % 56 $ "

! -08()*" ' $ " ( " $ * ! )8.<

6 5# ! $ ! !3' " '

5 5 !6 $ !3' 5 "'6 6 5 ! > ' '

@ 6")/ )- 6 " $ ' " $ '"" "!' % !6 '! " 5 '' ! '65 " "' "

! "!

!! !'

$ % "! "A'

$'5 5 5 '

@ 6 ! > "' ' " ! ! "

! '

'!! "'6! '5# !?

!3' 5 " '$'% 6'! , 6

#' ! ('

*$ 56

@' !5 )) -/)-$ " $ " 6 "

$ $ % " 6 5 @ $

"6 "

! '5 " $ '! @ 3' "$ "! ' ! "

@ ' !' "! (' 6 "' *6 " 6 % 6 ! '6 " !3' !

! 5 6 ! 6 (1* 9 !'

(* " ! 6 ' 5 " ' @ ! ! 6#'! : $!3' ' " ! -08()* $ ! 0//?

" ' 6' $ 6 ! " !3'

' ' $' "'

' 6 '

" 6 ! 9 !'

6 '

! " > :5 '

' (* "

#$ %& % ' % () *+$$+*+ $#

)) ,-

& (* .

+ / + + 0+ % 1 23

41 (2* +

' '"' ! '5 3' $ $ 5 5 '

" '

@ 6 ! B (7* =$ 6! "!5 % $56$!'$ @ ! ! 6 $ '

! --7 " ' C

! $ " "

5' % 6

! ' @ !' '!"6! " +'6 "' @ ! @ 6#'! D 5 6

+%%7)+ 89)+ -1-

!4 (* 5 ,-

, E (<* "$!' ' 6 ' 56 $" ' '" 5 "" 6 ? ! ! ! #'! , $ ! F "?

' " $ " "! "! 5 "'

' $'" ! 6" 6 ! " ? " ' '

' 5 ! 6 #'"6 ! ' ' 6 @ !!' ! $!

! ' $ 5 >' $ 6 " '""! '' " " 6 " (.* = 3'6 " 6$ ! '5 " ! " 5'5 6 !

! >$ $ !!' ! #'"6 6 5' ! "! "' 6$! " !

5 ' '

"! D

5 3 + : + 3 %;

$ 7) $ :7+ 5+*+

<) 2 --

4-!E 6 $ " !3' ! ' !!

5 !"0

#231"4" 0%&!5"602&7!5 !!5"% 8"0"1$"9"60 &!"7!5$8 % : %60 &!"7! 3"0%&%$8$1 014%$!2 !"7:5: %;$6$1 &! 92!5$% 0$65!%D "6= %. 7 2= ;

+ 21

>63 7>

3 < #+ +". ,-

,!E (8* = + +3 < +

53:

97 --11

4 '

5 '

" 6

! ' $ 5 ()/* " ! !3' ! ! > :5 '

' (*2% +:+ 5% -,4

!4&( *+ +"

7%.

: --1

4& (* >*) % ) + + 7 $ + % 5%)7++7+ 6:+?--1

4& ( * + 26 %%+% 3$ 41

- ' 6 ' '

! ' 5 " ! " !3' " '! 5 ! '5 3' "! = 5 ?' " " ' "!3' 65 !' 6! !3' 6 $ #'"6 '

@ 6 " ())* 6

5%)7+ 2+ +$?

>+ :

%2 ;

% 4

- (*! ! !3' " "@ " "$ 5' ! $ " 6 ' $ '

" 6 ! % $ '5 3'

% ! " 6

$ $$% 56 '

' ;

& 6)+6+:+#+ +3 < +

1-4 ()-* ' 6 $ !3' $ "'

"' ''!%$ '!!3'

" )16 " 6 #$ %& %' % ()*+$@! ('

* 5 "" ()0* ! 5 ' '

56 > :5 '

' >A 3$ % * '+% :7+ +

= $ 3$ +

1!6 $ "$ ?

! (

)

' #

- (

* ()1* 9 ' @ "!" ! (* " $ ! ! 5 ()2* =65 "! '

! 1 7" 9 !3' ! ).81$ ' )-/7-//- -8))-//-=

"" $$ 6 -//0 ! "

$,228$ -./0-//0 ()7* 6 ! !3' ! 6 6!!

!3' '5 " $ !

56 ! 6 " " ! '

! )." ).81 !$!$ 6 $ " ' 56 !G' /</)-/)0 "

! '""' ! "!

$ 6$ --/8-/)2 ()<*

" $ $$ 56 '5# !?!3'

! '$' 6 6 6 56

$6"+ ,.212"-//1 +,)-<<8"-//1 $

$ )./0-/)) " 9

'" 9$ " 6$ 56 > :5 '

' )-/<-/)0D @! ('

*E " ! + ! ('

* 6 $ !3' !' '

" '! $ $ " ! -08" ' ().*

6 ! ! !3' " 5 ? ! " '

' 6 -/)2 D$ ! " -))/-/)2E " 6 ()8* A 5 "! !6F

! ? $!3' ! 6 ! !3' " 5' " ! " '

' ('

* (-/* " $ !!'

" !6 '! !5 !'

! '$ 5 $ ! 6 5 6 '' ! 5 " ' "

! "!

> 65 56 !3' " 6 " $ $

! '$ 5

(-)* '

@ ")-6 3' !3' $! '! $ ! 5 ! % (--* !!

% $ "' !!

3' !3' " (-0* 6 !!' ! $!?

: % " ! !6 $ "$ ?

/ $0

* *

3 4 #

- (

* (-1* = 6 5 " % 6! " !3'

' '

"'!' & 5 ! ' " '" = $" "! 5 ! 6 $ " ' !3' !

5 " $+ % '! $ $ "' % " !

! ! !3' $"'6 '! $ "' ' ! ! 5 5 '

" 6 (-2* ! '

56 !'

" ! 6 '5 = #$ %& %' % ()*+$@ ! ('

* $ "'

" "! $ !3'

$ "' ! 6"$ $!3' $ "'

5 H 5 " ' ! 6I $' ;

'5!

' : " !3' , '! 5' ! $ $ 6!3' " ' '5! ' (-7* = .

+ / @ ! ('

* "! '

! 1" 9 !3' ! ).81$ '5 -)/<-//7 !3' $ 6 ! + ,-0.07(+* " -//7 !

! ! > ' $

)./)-//. > :5 '

3' !3' ''

6 "

! ' 5 )/6 : 6 56 > :5 '

' <2 " " ' $!

' ! ! ' ! :!' (-<* + 6 $ $ "' : ! ! '

$ "! !6 ! "!3' ! 5 !" 565 *

" ! $ ! $ !!'

" 6 ! $ ! 6 " 5 ?

(-.* = " 5 !' $ $

5 5 5 5 65 !! 6

-204 . &!

276" ()

-27$3512: 1$

276"