Ayoudhia Prasad Duggal v. Cat Chandigarh And ORS











































































 
 



 

 !"#"$% 

& 


 











  







'% ()'*
* + ()'*
*))




 !

 
!"


#



 
$  
!"


#



% &

'


 
(


!"


#



%) *)), 

*
 

 
# +
  + 



,-"




+
  


.

"
#

/ 


  
#
  

#
0

 1  



+ 
 
2&3)
4- 
567


8

9


+ 

 !
 
  


$"
  







 

 
:&3'
4- 
5&7


8



%
'
 8 #
#



%:

* "

;

0 
#

+
#

+
"


8

<


4

%
)7
* "
*

! 8!

>=


*

 "

  

  

  

 

    

 











































































& & 
# " 
8 ". 




8
 
++ 
#

  

/
8"

+

++8
#



>! +
= 
"+
4 
 
?>=@7
=
## 

+

! =


 ".

*




<


* "

+

 =



>=

3:3A&3:


*

# +
8
 "

 

 

 
+ 

B+   
4 B7



"

!


B
+

 8


4 + 7 
3)3A&3:


 *
B
=
*

 "


 3A3A&3:

B


"


 

*

"


+
#

&')3315
8 <






%
'



8 
++8
#
>=  # 

8+ 

  

632&3:




% :




8!
+
* "





<


 

*



 C

&332&3:

,+ "

  *
D D

9

 +





+
#

'3))E15

 ;


! 8!

+


8 
>=
 


  
 
&A32&3:


.
#

+
#
8!
+
/

+
*


" 

!

9 
% "
 
&23&3:
 

 
:3&3'

" + *

 "
=
 
# 

   


 "

 




+ 

 !
  : B
*

" 

8 #
#




*
# 



/ 
 + 
/ 




% 


:

 

*

+ 


<


# +
A&3:

AA&3:



# +
&32&3:

&&2&3:


" 
*

 

 " 


#

0  
 
 +

8


>=


 

8+ 

 . 




  











































































:

+
! 8!

  
9 + 
#
>=


8
## "





<






 


8# 



+


8


#
8



"

8





"+
 
0 
#


*

 "
! 

+ 
 
' 
9
 
! 

 "

" +
#

/

8
8 ! 

5                

  

                  !          " 

       #        

 

        $      #"  

               

          %    $   
%

#       

  

 
 

 &#'(() *+,         



           "  

   !  



     

   

                      

 

   -     



        .   /0 12(3                   .  "   

 . !        

     4



  5



  

  #   ! 

 #    ! 





   

  !    "       "   



 











































































' !

    "   .  

 



 & 2 & *   

 # 1 2 .                 #

   

  

   " "   

    

      

      



6  

        $        "

         #      "   

                

                 

         

  $  #          "              $ % 

  $

  !    .      

 7 ) 
# "
#

"


;
 

       0
8

 


+ 
+

*! 
   8
# +
 




"


B
 
+  
 " + 
+ 
 


#
 +


;

!


=


#
8

# "  ;
* "
  8
*





!


#
 >! +
$
 



"




+ 
8# 
 
"

+ 

<


4


%
)7

* "


 /
 *
 +



+


 
#
>=
 
0  


"

"+ "
* "
 
+
8# 



*

" +
#
 8

+
#

   
+


8
 + #
   
#



%   5$


8

8


8

>! +


F 6 /
 !

 

"+  
 
8












































































) "  

  E 
"


#



" # "


+ 



 "

 
 
&'&&3:
4- 
57
8+ 



%:

 

8'#   $  "    "

   

 

 9          "      

      

  -!     "      9            "  &:

 




#  

   &:

 



   $"     %        

                  

 "   ;      $

< 

"   $

   



   

  



          "

  

 



   

 =  

     

    

     
A B

 

"


 

 
< +
#


;

 


!


""

 

! *
#

"

" # "
"++  
#

  
 


=


 8!  
" 
,+ "

"

 "


"  
#


*

 
## 
=


 ".
* 

# "


* "
 
" +



 
< + 
/
 !



 
< + 
A&3:

&32&3:

8

;

 



 
+  
#





A&3:
 &32&3:

" !
* "


- 
5:
"" !
B











































































6 8 !
 
 



5# 
 5 


# +
#  .  
* "
 "


* 
# "


!


>   #

>! +


 
!


#
  
  
>  
# !


; 


 ;
#
>=14 7
8# "

 
&&&3: 
!


+

+


" 

- 
5



 
"!


; 


 ;
#



#
# - 

  
  #
 8

+


 "

+

+


!
#

 ;

;
#



#
"
  
9 + 


#
 5 "+5G . 


8


 ;

 4 7

+ 


5 ;#                  

        2 92+,

3 ;93 8 ++2-2++>-

;'?

<-

;5< 

 9   8   #     #       !

       %     $   

       #""% $  9       8         

        

    !



 

 



 292+, #

  ?

   #   "

"

      $ 

     



 

  "

  

    

  -   7 2  

*! 
 

" 

 "




* - "
*


;-  ;
 !



 

  
* " *
 !
"
+



#
;$
H  


 ;



# "

 
 C


  
9 +  
,!

""  =


* "




%
)


"




/ 
 +





* 


* 
-  
*

 !



 













































































E

 4 7


# +
+ 
# + 
+
 
8
0  



* 
!

8
8
"

8
+ 
8"


#
+ - ++   

"
9 + 
8

>=
G8
" 

"

 "

"  

* "


 
 
8
8 


=





 
#
  4 7
*
"


8



#

 + 
; #
! 
  ;

8


"
#

 


.
""


8

 

#

;8
0  ;


 *
" 
 !
* 


+ 
#



#
 
  5"+5G . 
9

5# 
8

=


* "
"

" 






*


1
"! 
 
>! +
>  
;"

8
+ ;
#




 8



* 
;


!

8;

%

  


- "



#
"


- 8  
 +
.* 
#
*  
 
* 
8




 8

+
 




 



 
#

#

 #
  
" 0"

#*
8

  
#
;+ 
-  !18   ! ; 3 B

! *
#

+  
" 
 

*

  "
" 
#


 

B
"+

 8

*


* 
 
"


"++  
#
   
 
 . 

""

  

!

 


 +
# 

 
*
 !

  

"+ 


"" 
 





#
 1G .  
8

;

 

A&3:

&32&3:
"


8"+

 

"

 + #



#
. 
 8

+
"

+
* 
8





!
+ 



#



!


 +
# 

 
" 


 ;

" 
  



#











































































A



!

# "#

  
# +


#

=

  


  
 4 7

/


 
" 

""

* 

"


#


= 
 

8  
 "


+ 

8 
 


    !

# $ %$

&" ! '(()'*+,,(

* "
 
 



 
"




"


# 
  %$

- .

/ +,,'0
""+'1
*   

#

>! +

# 




5

 
"

 #

 +



=


*

 "


>! +
*



8

"    
8   




-  " 


 







#
 #

*

8 !
5    

             !      

  ((> 

  3 2  

           3     "

  3 2  





    #

"    



 

   

$     8 &  '     



          ! 

7  
/   

 
*


+ 



8




+ 

 !
 






% &

'


 "



#
#
 8

+
#
   
+
#



+ 



 

 +

<




&3:
*  
 
+ # +

 
#
"++ "

 
#

 
$# 

 
*


" 

+

 

"" 
  

!!
+ +" +

# 
* "
*
0 


!


=













































































2 "



 
 8 "
#

-  
 !


 



 
8# 
8  
  


 
< +
 #

 *


 "

0 +

+ 




#

8

 "! 



8
"  
 +  


 
#


"

2
/ 3 4

 ./ ./  92+2+* &

& 5 * / 6 7 *! &

6 7 *!