High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/57/2012dismissed

Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2016-08-17Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

!,-&./&(01 #"&"&(#.' 2#.'3'

/"!"# 3(4!-!($"1#.'

#'5($#("' ) 6 7 /87/ .#'#(") .2&4!97!"1: $;%!"#: ."1#5#"&"&(#. .!.35<!./&(0113=!(: $$&"&(!, 3(4!- . =&" 1!(4&: $;%!"#: ..#'5($#("' ">

1#"1#."1##5."#.' ,%!,(#?'5!5#.=!9-#!,,?#$"'##"1# 43$0=#("@

-#.# #..#$""1##5."#..(" A 1#"1#."1#43$0=#("'13,$-#.#5."#$&("1#$&0#'"@ 87/

!,-&. /&(01 5#"&"&(#. '##<' "1# &''3!(%# ! ?.&"

=!($!=3':$&.#%"&(0"1#.#'5($#("'"%3("1&'?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%#: .#($#.#$ -9 1&= ?&"1 #

#%" .= B B+ " +> B*A "?!.$'

5#('&(!.9-#(# &"'!($0.!(" %('#C3#("&!,!..#!.'!,(0?&"1&("#.#'" ( B B+ :"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'!55&("#$ !' !3.(#.&(

1!<.!!=.4#%"&('1."D E&(!(0!,.<'15&;&'&(# ?.<#$ "1#.# 35"

B B+

"#. "1# %=5,#"&( "1# 5.4#%": 1&'

'#.;&%#'?#.#.#".#(%1#$:;&$#$&'%1!.0#%#."& &%!"# ((#F3.# ("1# %=5,#"&( :"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'!55&("#$&(!("1#.5.4#%"-9 .#'5($#(" :(!=#,9: #!'/!",347&(<.4#%"&('1."D /7E!

"#.

3.$!9':?1#.#"1#5#"&"&(#.4&(#$( +B B+ !($?.<#$"1#.#!'!

3.(#. 35" B # ?!' .#".#(%1#$: ;&$# $&'%1!.0# %#."& &%!"# ((#F3.# 1#5.4#%"':(!=#,9: !($ /7?#.#=#.0#$&("

1!<.! #!' !(!0#=#(" !.$.#'5($#(" 1#.#&( &( '1."

E3($#."1#3(4!-#.0!(&G!"&( %": B++&('1."D"1# %"

B++E:&("#.=' /#%"&(* + %" B++!."2 %"

B++ $#!,' ?&"1 1!<.!!(0!, !($ #!' .4#%"' &( '1." D E 1#.#!

"#.:"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'!55&("#$!'1!.0#=!(/5#%&!,.!$#&( ?.< %1!.0# %!5!%&"9 &(

: !(0!, ?('1&5: ;&$# ,#""#. $!"#$

+> B*A ((#F3.#> ( "1# $&'%1!.0# %#."& &%!"# .= /7 ((#F3.# :"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'?.(0,9=#("&(#$"1!;#;,3("!.9 .#'&0(#$ .= '#.;&%# ?&"1 #

#%" .= B 1# 5#"&"&(#. 1!$ !55.!%1#$"1##(".!,;#.(=#("($3'".&!,.&-3(!,%3=7!-3.3." :1!($&0!.1:?1&%1:;&$#!?!.$$!"#$>B

* ((#F3.#:1#,$"1!"

"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'.#".#(%1#$ .="1#'!&$5.4#%"1#5#"&"&(#.!""!&(#$ "1#!0# '35#.!((3!"&((A BBB!($?!'.#"&.#$ .="1#'#.;&%#

1#5#"&"&(#.!55.!%1#$"1&'3."&("1#9#!.

&#!

"#.=.# "1!(

9#!.' 1&'.#"&.#=#(":'##<&(0"1#5.#'#(".#,&# 1#5#"&"&(#.

!,'%,!&='"1!"3($#.3,#> A 1!5"#.2:/#%"&(2:2,3=# 3(4!-&;&,/#.;&%#'3,#':&("#..35"&(-#"?##("?'5#,,' '#.;&%# .#($#.#$ 3($#. "1# /"!"# ;#.(=#(" '1!,, -# ".#!"#$ !3"=!"&%!,,9 %($(#$: #F%#5" ?1#( "1# &("#..35"&( &' %!3'#$ -9 .#'&0(!"&(: "#.=&(!"&(.$&'=&''!, .='#.;&%##"% #'5($#("' ">:&("1#?.&""#('"!"#=#(":"<"1#'"!($ "1!""1#?.&"5#"&"&(&'15#,#'',9"&=#-!..#$1#5#"&"&(#..#"&.#$ .= '#.;&%#(A BBB!($.#%#&;#$"1#5#('&(!.9-#(# &"' .=

A ?:!

"#.=.#"1!(

9#!.':1#&'$&'53"&(0"1#5#('&(!.9-#(# &"'1# 5#.&$ '#.;&%#-9"1#5#"&"&(#.&( &(!(0!,.<'15&'("

$#(&#$:-3"&"&''"!"#$"1!"1#1!$;,3("!.&,9"#($#.#$1&'.#'&0(!"&( 1#.#!

"#.:1#?!'!55&("#$&( /7!"/3($#.!0!.( +B B+ !($ ?.<#$"1#.#"&,, B !'!3.(#.!($"1#.#!

"#.(%=5,#"&( 5.4#%"!($!

"#..#%#&;&(0"1#.#".#(%1=#("%=5#('!"&(:1#1!$.#'&0(#$

.="1#'#.;&%#1#'#.;&%#' "1#5#"&"&(#.?&"1"1#

:!'!,,#0#$ -91&=:&'("$#(&#$"&''"!"#$"1!"3,#> A 1!5"#.2:/#%"&(2:

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

"1#?.&"5#"&"&(&# * BB+:"&",#$!'

:?!' &,#$&("1&'3.":%,!&=&(0"1#-#(# &" ?.< %1!.0#'#.;&%#.#($#.#$-9"1#=&( ."1#53.5'# 5#('&(!($ 5#('&(!.9 -#(# &"': ?1#.#&( "1# &;&'&( #(%1 "1&' 3.": ;&$# 43$0=#("$!"#$ A> BBB ((#F3.# :1#,$"1!""1##=5,9##'?1 1!;# .#%#&;#$ "1# .#".#(%1=#(" %=5#('!"&( ?1#( "1#&. ?.< %1!.0# '#.;&%#%!=#"!(#($!.#("#("&",#$"0#""1#?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%#

> %3("#$"?!.$'5#('&(!($5#('&(!.9-#(# &"' 1#/7'

: &,#$!0!&('""1#'!&$43$0=#("?!'$&'=&''#$!'?&"1$.!?(: ;&$#.$#.$!"#$>+

((#F3.# :5!''#$-9"1#(E-,#/35.#=# 3." ($&!:("1#'"!"#=#(" "1#,#!.(#$%3('#, ."1#5#"&"&(#.'

"1!""1#7 &'5#($&(0-# .#"1#&013."1#.# .#:&"?!''"!"#$"1!"

"1#?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%# "1#5#"&"&(#.&( !($ /7&'(""-# %3("#$ .0.!(" 5#('&(!.9-#(# &"' 1!;#1#!.$"1#,#!.(#$%3('#, ."1#5#"&"&(#.:"1#,#!.(#$ /"!"#%3('#,:"1#,#!.(#$%3('#, ..#'5($#("' ">!($1!;#!,' %!.# 3,,90(#"1.301"1# &,# 1#'#.;&%#'%,!&=#$-9"1#5#"&"&(#.&'!'3($#.) /. .4#%"

B B+

+B B+

+> B*A A BBB 1#$&'%1!.0#%#."& &%!"# ((#F3.# .= '1?'"1!"

"1#5#"&"&(#..#'&0(#$ .="1#'!&$5.4#%"(!,"#.(!"&;#!55&("=#("&(

/7.4#%"1#$&'%1!.0#%#."& &%!"# .= /7 ((#F3.# '1?'

"1!""1#.#!'( .$&'%1!.0#?!';,3("!.9.#'&0(!"&(?&"1#

#%" .=

B 1#5#"&"&(#.1!'1&='#, .#,&#$35("1#43$0=#(" #(".!,($3'".&!,.&-3(!,%3=7!-3.3.":1!($&0!.1:?1&%1'1?' "1!" '&(%# "1# .#".#(%1=#(" %=5#('!"&( ?!' 5!&$ " "1# 5#"&"&(#.: "1#.# .#:1#&'$##=#$"1!;#-##(.#".#(%1#$ .="1#'!&$'#.;&%# ?:"1#5#"&"&(#.%,!&='"1!"1&''#.;&%#5#.&$&( !($

/7'13,$-#%3("#$ ."1#0.!(" 5#('&(!.9-#(# &"'!'"1#'#"?

5.4#%"'=#.0#$&("

(!%%3(" 3(4!-#.0!(&G!"&( %":

B++ %"A B++1#$!"# &.'"$&'%1!.0# .= &'

B B+ !($"1#.#!'( ..#'&0(!"&(&'!55&("=#("&( /7 1#,#!.(#$%3('#, ."1#5#"&"&(#.1!'.#,&#$35(/#%"&( * %" B++:?1&%15.;&$#'"1!"!,,"1#.&01"'!($,&!-&,&"&#'

#F&'"&(0/"!"# 3(4!-&(.#,!"&(" 1!<.!!(0!,.4#%"!($ #!'

.4#%"'1!,,:("1#!55&("#$$!9:-#"1#.&01"'!($,&!-&,&"&#' '3%%#''./"!"#'&('3%15.5."&(:!'=!9-# &F#$1# #!'.4#%"?!'

$# &(#$&(/3-'#%"&(> /#%"&( * %" B++:?1#.#&( /7!($

?#.#%;#.#$&("1#$# &(&"&( #!'.4#%""0#'"'1?"1!"( %=&(0&(" .%# "1#3(4!-#.0!(&G!"&( %": B++:!,,"1#.&01"'

!($,&!-&,&"&#' "1#'!&$5.4#%"?1&%1?#.#5!." #!'.4#%"?#.# 0&;#(""1#'3%%#''./"!"#'?#;#.:"1# !%".#=!&('"1!""1#5#"&"&(#.

?!'.#".#(%1#$ .= 1!<.!!=.4#%"(%=5,#"&( "1#?.<!($ "1#.#!

"#.1#?!'!,'.#".#(%1#$ .= #!'/!",347&(<.4#%"("1# %=5,#"&( "1#'!&$5.4#%"!($"1!""1#.#".#(%1=#("%=5#('!"&(?!' $3,95!&$-9 /7:?1&%1?!'!%%#5"#$-91&=?!9-!%<( B 1#.#".#(%1=#("?!'("$&'53"#$-9"1#5#"&"&(#.!"!(9'"!0#

"#.

!-3" 9#!.!($A=("1'.#".#(%1=#(" .= /7:"1#5#"&"&(#.?!'

!55&("#$ .#'1&(

:!(0!,?('1&5!($"&,,1&'.#"&.#=#("&("1# 9#!. BBB:1#$&$("%,!&="1!"1&'5.#;&3'?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%#&( '13,$!,'-#%3("#$ ."1#53.5'# '#(&.&"9!($"1#.-#(# &"'

"#.

"1#'35#.!((3!"&(&("1#9#!. BBB:"1#5#"&"&(#..#=!&(#$=3= .(#!.,9 =.#"1!(

9#!.' ?: "1# C3#'"&( ?3,$ !.&'# !' " ?1#( ! ?.<#. &' .#".#(%1#$(%=5,#"&( ?.<!($.#%#&;#'.#".#(%1=#("%=5#('!"&(:

+ ?1#"1#.1&''#.;&%#&'"-#%3("#$ ."1#0.!(" 5#('&(!.9-#(# &"'?&"1 ?1= 1# &' #=5,9#$ !

"#. ! 0!5 =.# "1!( (# 9#!. ( .#'1 !55&("=#("@ 1#&;&'&( #(%1 "1&'3."&( %!'#'35.! 1#,$"1!" &("1#'!&$%!'#:"1#?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%#%!(("-#%3("#$ "?!.$'.#03,!.'#.;&%#1#&;&'&( #(%1 "1&'3."&(!%!'#.#,!"&(0 ""1#?.<%1!.0##=5,9## 1!<.!!=.4#%": #!'/!",347&(< .4#%"!($ 1!<.! #!'!(!0#=#(" !.$:"&",#$!'

:!.&'&(03" +++

BB*:$#%&$#$(

>:?1&,#.#,9&(035("1#3,, #(%143$0=#("

"1&'3."&(

: B** /7 :1#,$"1!""1#?.<%1!.0#'#.;&%#&'"-#%3("#$ ."1#0.!("

5#('&(!.9-#(# &"'"!,'%=#'3""1!"&(

:!(!55,&%!"&(

>&(7 * B

A?!' &,#$ ..#;&#?.#%!,, "1#.$#.

$!"#$ A

A:?1#.#-97#""#.'!"#(" 55#!,!.&'&(0!0!&('""1#.$#.

$!"#$ B

A "1#,#!.(#$/&(0,# 3$0#:?1&%1?!'$&'=&''#$-9!

&;&'&( #(%1 "1&'3."(

>:1,$&(0"1!""1#C3#'"&( ,!?

.!&'#$1#.#&(!-;#&'<#5"5#("-#0(#&("&(!55.5.&!"#%!'#'1# 5#"&"&(#.1!'!,'.#,&#$35("1#&;&'&( #(%143$0=#(" "1&'3."&(

+ / 3."1#..#,&!(%#1!'!,'-##(5,!%#$("1#&;&'&(

#(%143$0=#(" "1&'3."&(

:!.&'&(03" +++ BB*:$#%&$#$(

>:?1#.#&(.#,&!(%#?!'5,!%#$("1#!3"1.&"9 5#F3."

! "

/35.#=#3."

("1#"1#.1!($:"1#,#!.(#$%3('#, ..#'5($#("' " >1!'5.$3%#$"1#!3"1.&"9 5#F3."&( %!'# '35.!!($1!'!.03#$"1!""1#'!&$!3"1.&"9&'=&'&("#.5.#"#$1#5#.3'!, "1#'!&$!3"1.&"9&# %!'#'35.!'1?'"1!"&("1#'!&$ %!'#: '#;#.!, ?.&" 5#"&"&(' ?#.# &,#$ 1#.# ?#.# %#."!&( 0.35

5#"&"&(#.': ?1 ?#.# ?.<&(0 !' (0&(##.': ;#.'##.': "#!%1#.': /3- &;&'&(!,,#.<':,#.<': %%3("',#.<':&=#8##5#.'#"%!($"1#.# ?!'"1#.'#" 5#"&"&(#.':?1?#.#?.<%1!.0##=5,9##'!($'=#

"1#= ?#.# .#".#(%1#$ 1# %!'#' "? %!"#0.&#' ?#.# '#5!.!"#,9 $&'%3''#$ ,, "1#=?#.##=5,9##' 1!<.! #!'/!",34.4#%"!($ "1#.5.4#%"':%;#.#$3($#."1# #!'.4#%"1&,#".#!"&(0"1##

#%"

"1# 3(4!- #.0!(&G!"&( %": B++: "1# %!'# "1# ?.< %1!.0# #=5,9##'?!'%('&$#.#$"?!'!,'&( .=#$"1!"!'5#."1#5.;&'&('

/#%"&( * + "1# %" B++: "1# %=5,#"# %=5(#(" ?!'

".!('

#..#$"

(!9 : B +:!($"1# !.$?!'.#(!=#$!'

1!<.! #!'!(!0#=#(" !.$ -3""1#?.<%1!.0##=5,9##'

#!'.4#%":&"?!'-'#.;#$-9"1# 5#F3."!'3($#.) H> 1#.#?#.#&(!,,!-3"A+

?.<%1!.0#$#=5,9##'

?.<&(0("1# #!'.4#%"3" "1#=:!-3" +

1!;# !,.#!$9 !%%#5"#$ .#".#(%1=#(" %=5#('!"&( 3($#. "1# '#"",#=#("!..&;#$-#"?##("1#?.<=#(!($"1#=!(!0#=#(" &("1#%(%&,&!"&(5.%##$&(0'1#,$-9"1##0&(!,7!-3. ==&''&(#.#(".!,:#?#,1&:3($#./#%"&(

($3'".&!,&'53"#' %": B> ,,"1#

3(&(' ?1&%1"1# ?.<%1!.0#$#=5,9##'!.#=#=-#.'?#.#5!."&#'""1#'!&$ %(%&,&!"&(5.%##$&(0' 9.#!'( /#%"&( *A$ ($3'".&!,&'53"#' %":!'#"",#=#("!..&;#$!"&("1#%3.'#

!%(%&,&!"&(5.%##$&(0&'-&($&(0(!,,5#.'('?1?#.#

* #=5,9#$&("1##'"!-,&'1=#(""?1&%1"1#$&'53"#.#,!"#': ?1#"1#."1#9?#.##=5,9#$("1#$!"# "1#$&'53"#.

'3-'#C3#(",9(!=(!0!.!(#!($/30!.7"$2 !"&( 1!<.!;."9!($.' / > B+ ) B+ 77 >> /:&"?!'1#,$-9"1&'3.""1!"&"&'("#;#((#%#''!.9:&( .$#."-&($"1#?.<=#(""1#'#"",#=#("!..&;#$!"-# .# "1#%(%&,&!".:"'1?"1!""1#9-#,(0#$""1#3(&(?1&%1 "< 5!." &( "1# %(%&,&!"&( 5.%##$&(0': '&(%# "1# 5,&%9 3($#.,9&(0 /#%"&( * "1# %" &' " 0&;# !( #F"#($#$ 5#.!"&("'3%1/#"",#=#("'("1#&('"!("%!'#:!,,"1#

3(&('?1&%1.#5.#'#("#$"1#?.<=#(("1#?.<%1!.0#$ #'"!-,&'1=#("?#.#5!."&#'""1#%(%&,&!"&(5.%##$&(0'1# '#"",#=#("?&,,"1#.# .#-&($!,,"1#?.<%1!.0#$#=5,9##'I (;&#? !%""1!""1#?.<%1!.0##=5,9##'1!$#("#.#$ &(" ! '#"",#=#(" #

#%"#$ -#"?##( "1#= !($ "1# =!(!0#=#(" &( "1# %(%&,&!"&(5.%##$&(0':&"?!'1#,$"1!""1#9!.#("#("&",#$"!(9.&01"' !5!." .="1'# ,?&(0 .="1#!

.#'!&$'#"",#=#(" ("1&'?!9:'&(%#"1#5#"&"&(#.1!$!%%#5"#$"1#.#".#(%1=#(" %=5#('!"&( !" "1#"&=# .#"&.#=#(" .= #!'/!",347&(<.4#%":

"1#.# .#:(?1#%!(("%=5,!&("1!"1#?!'?.(0,9.#".#(%1#$!($"1!" 1&''#.;&%#'&( #!'/!",34.4#%"7&(<'13,$-#%3("#$&(

?1#.# 1#?!'!55&("#$!

"#.!0!5 (#9#!.!($"1.##=("1'.#;#.:"1#.# &'!(&(.$&(!"#$#,!9 =.#"1!(

9#!.'&( &,&(0"1#5.#'#("?.&"

5#"&"&( (;&#? "1#!3"1.&"9 "1#(6-,#/35.#=#3." ($&!

&( %!'#'35.!:!= "1#;&#?"1!""1#%!'# 5#"&"&(#.&''C3!.#,9%;#.#$-9"1#'!&$!3"1.&"9!($'&(%#"1#5#"&"&(#. 1!$!%%#5"#$"1#.#".#(%1=#("%=5#('!"&(:?1&%11#1!$!,.#!$9.#%#&;#$ ?!9-!%<&("1#9#!. :"1#5#"&"&(#.&'("#("&",#$"!(9"1#.-#(# &"

B ('#C3#(",9:"1#'#.;&%#'.#($#.#$-9"1#5#"&"&(#.&( 1!<.!!=.4#%"

!($ #!' /!",34 7&(< .4#%" %!((" -# %3("#$ . "1# 53.5'#

%=53"&(0 "1# ,#(0"1 '#.;&%# !($ %('#C3#(",9 &F&(0 "1# 5#('&(

%%.$&(0,9:"1#5.#'#("?.&"5#"&"&(&'$&'=&''#$ 87/

+ '4<' 1#"1#.'5#!<&(0.#!'(#$ ) #'

1#"1#.#5."!-,# ) #'